Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Social Media should be banned for under 16s

164 replies

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 10:00

Off the back of Esther Gheys campaigning about phone use and social media,
I was thinking how bonkers it is that we (as a society) haven't put in stricter controls over social media / internet use for kids yet.

It's as if the technology has developed too quickly, and parents have been left scrabbling around trying to control whatever they can, in what is essentially a completely unregulated cyber world.

I realise that some people are anti nanny-state, but imagine if CBBC started showing snuff films or porn in the middle of some teen drama. When mental health problems in children are soaring, and there is some evidence to show a link to phone / social media use, it seems totally nuts that regulation isn't being enforced at a higher level.

I see grown adults lose all perspective just from being on twitter, how on earth do we think kids can handle it better?

What benefit is it for children under 16 to be on social media? So they can do some tik-tok dance craze? If you want to do a dance just do it in your front room with your mates. To post posey-influencer style images at 13/14? For whose benefit?

I've heard people argue that its unrealistic to think that it can be changed now. Why? My kids are still young so maybe i dont understand.

OP posts:
usernother · 05/02/2024 13:19

I agree, and the problem is parental. I know of 8 year old who have phones with internet access who use TikTok and instagram. I can't believe that parents don't check what their children access online, including social media. If parents were held legally responsible for allowing their children to access to social media and prosecuted for it, it would be a start. Lots of bullying in schools would disappear.

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 13:11

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 13:03

You can check on apps being dowloaded etc, what about internet searches? Can't you just delete your internet history??

You can restrict safari to your approved sites only.
You can take safari off altogether.
You can make sure any googling is done in a family room if it’s needed for homework or to look something up.
You can allow google / safari but only for 5 mins if a teen thinks they might want to quickly look something up on the bus.
so many options rather than allow or don’t allow!

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 13:10

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 05/02/2024 13:03

This chat has actually reminded me of my Nana spending a Wednesday evening at the community centre for a few weeks on a course about “that Internet thing” when we first got a computer.

I was never allowed anything that she didn’t know how to work.

I think a lot of children being more tech savvy than parents is a massive part of the issue.

100% correct! 🤣 Love the Nana memory. So relatable.

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 13:08

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 13:00

@asterel but you can't really just decide to ban a useful piece of technology because some people can misuse it.
I mean people use cars to deliberately run people over.
We just need....I don't know... something more to understand why so many teens end up going on social media sites..What are they looking for? What are they hoping to achieve? Basically what makes them want to do it?
What is missing from their lives?

They arnt missing anythjng! They want to be involved socially and have a very strong desire to be accepted! As it always has been!
We all (mostly) have a strong desire to be accepted. That stems from our very survival. As early humans, if we weren’t accepted into a tribe, we wouldn’t survive. We must fit in at all costs. Very few humans don’t have that inate desire. If lots of us didn’t, the human race wouldn’t not have made it this far- it’s our ability to join and connect in so many complex ways that makes us the most successful race.
Teens feel this extremely keenly as they transition from child to adult.
Social media feeds into this like piece of a jigsaw. It can create great joy and on the flip side great sadness for teens.
They are not missing anything- just human!

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 05/02/2024 13:03

This chat has actually reminded me of my Nana spending a Wednesday evening at the community centre for a few weeks on a course about “that Internet thing” when we first got a computer.

I was never allowed anything that she didn’t know how to work.

I think a lot of children being more tech savvy than parents is a massive part of the issue.

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 13:03

You can check on apps being dowloaded etc, what about internet searches? Can't you just delete your internet history??

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 13:00

@asterel but you can't really just decide to ban a useful piece of technology because some people can misuse it.
I mean people use cars to deliberately run people over.
We just need....I don't know... something more to understand why so many teens end up going on social media sites..What are they looking for? What are they hoping to achieve? Basically what makes them want to do it?
What is missing from their lives?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2024 12:59

Ihadittoo · 05/02/2024 10:27

Probably is correct but how would you enforce it?

This is the question I always ask myself

The only thing I'd add is that IF it was outlawed, it might make refusal easier when faced with the inevitable whining and "everyone else has it"

egowise · 05/02/2024 12:59

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 12:17

The thing is all the parental controls are there for you to use! Your child can have 20 mins of Instagram on their phone to catch up with mates posts etc for example before it the app turns off.
You can approve every app or not approve.
Your child / teen doesn’t need a laptop in their room with unmonitored safari. If you actually bother to learn the tech (which every parent should!)
then there are so many things you can use, and no, if you know what you are doing, and are around keeping an eye on your teen, it’s not that easy for them just to ‘get around it’
Of course, they can and will see things on other kids phones- can’t get around that one but that’s not where the main damage is done IMO.
It’s being on their own, in their room with unfiltered devices for hours that’s the problem.
And yes, I do have multiple teen children before anyone asks!

Exactly, i have just set up a pc with microsoft safety centre. Youtube even blocks comments up to a certain age.
I get alerts for every download and requests for those that cost, and no access to anything below the age range set. 4 separate profiles, one for each person.
I get a weekly report with all websites accessed, time spent on each individual app/ browser.
You have to set it up for google too, but we had that for phones already.

The tech is there, it just needs to be used.

JasperTheDoll · 05/02/2024 12:58

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 05/02/2024 12:56

Is this thread about social media?

Because having a smartphone for buses/homework/internet isn't the issue

It's the SM

It is but a few posters seem to think that taking away smart phones or any devices that connect to the internet is the answer to everything.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 05/02/2024 12:57

I also think one thing that should happen more is that parents should be less arsey with other parents who do things differently. I know a couple of people who “gave in” on TikTok in particular because not only were they getting grief from their child, but their own friends were critical. So they felt like they were getting it ‘wrong’

I faced this a bit with boundaries and curfews with my DD2. She didn’t have the same freedoms as her friends, in fact at one point she didn’t even have the same freedom as her twin sister. For good reason though. She wasn’t mature enough for it, she had a health condition that made certain things dangerous and it was for her safety.

But Jesus Christ you’d have thought I was locking her in the cupboard under the stairs for 23 hours a day according to some other parents! I was also told several times I obviously thought they were shit parents for being more relaxed - even though I was more relaxed with DS and DD1!!

Kids are all different so if someone parents different to you it’s not a slight against you. It’s just that their kid is different to yours!!

InAnotherLifetimeMaybe · 05/02/2024 12:56

Is this thread about social media?

Because having a smartphone for buses/homework/internet isn't the issue

It's the SM

asterel · 05/02/2024 12:54

If we can’t go back because the bus companies will be inconvenienced and it’s more faff to do homework in writing, aren’t we just saying that people’s well-being and kids’ lives are less valuable than commercial and corporate convenience?

Technology ought to do things to serve us - our lives shouldn’t be just fodder for whatever’s easiest for capitalism. Is being able to buy a bus ticket easily online worth your kid ending up with depression and stress, for example? Why are we just accepting that we should just prioritise technology that isn’t actually very good for us?

MargaretThursday · 05/02/2024 12:54

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 05/02/2024 12:34

There's a huge difference between more restrictions and a complete ban.

As I've said, my uni age children have said with the things are now they think I should be stricter on my younger children than I was with them (and most other parents felt I was uber strict as it was).

That still doesn't mean that only introducing things at an age where so many teens feel invincible and know it all is a wise idea.

I agree here. It's very common for university students to look back and know it all. Especially how to parent younger siblings stricter. 🤣

That's not saying that it wouldn't have been an issue for them at the time, or they're right.

I think they're wrong. because if you banned it for under 16s, then the kids getting the phone for the first time will be in the all-knowing, parents are wrong 16-18yos. That's the age you want to be relaxing a little, letting them have a bit of their own privacy etc. They're not going to accept you checking their phone and they'll know all about the evils and don't need telling, thank you.

For mine they all got it at an age it was perfectly normal to check the phone regularly. So they accepted it. And so it just continued.
At 16yo my dd had her own job and would have bought her own phone if she hadn't already got one. I very much doubt she'd have accepted me saying I needed to check it in that case.

JasperTheDoll · 05/02/2024 12:52

Exactly. Many schools ask pupils to use them in lessons for two factor authentication when logging onto school devices etc or to take photos in practical subjects such as art. Almost all homework is online now too.

Megifer · 05/02/2024 12:50

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 12:14

@Oblomov23 I used that title because thats what Esther Ghey is suggesting. If you read my posts youll see that Im suggesting theres many ways to tackle the problem.

But as long as your kids are alright then theres not a problem, right?

I was also a bit of a "I'm alright Jack poster". I'll clumsily try to explain why - everything nowadays seems to be someone else's issue to manage e.g. one that gets me currently is this instant jump to "talk to someone" if you're having a bit of a shit time mentally, or that video with the two blokes at a footy game and the chatty one has killed themselves at the end and the message is almost a guilt trippy "if only the other guy had talked to him more.......". I really hate that video as you can tell.

It's almost like the first line should be to saddle someone else with the task of helping you when surely the best, long term and sustainable help would be to seek help or try to sort it yourself first?

Thats how I view this. The information is out there, kids will access it if they want regardless whether they download a vpn, an app that can subvert blockers, sneak a look on a pals phone at a sleepover or kids view it in school on others phones (am slightly amused at the "phones are banned at dc school" posts, yea, theyre banned at my dc school too allegedly).

Passing the responsibility off on to someone or something isnt a long term solution because when they can access it they are thrown into that world for the first time completely unprepared. As parents we need to try and drum it into them that they don't want to do these things, but in a way its not taboo so if they do and need help they dont feel ashamed to talk, help them build resilience to these things so if they do accidentally see a pro-whatever site they can hopefully shrug it off, monitor what we can and deal with situations with the kids input where possible so they can handle it better mentally in the future.

(That is really shittily explained I know)

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 12:48

@JasperTheDoll that's the thing - a smart phone is so much more than "social media". I do so much on my - including using it as my "bus ticket".
There is a lot I literally wouldn't be able to do in life without it. Any online forms. Ordering and paying for things. Applying for things. Information from the school. Getting the Uber to and from school.
Yes I could do some of those things before - but doing it online is so so so much quicker and easier.
You can't ban smart phones for teens . As said - some need it for their bus ticket and to access apps for homework - unless we all (as a society) went back to old methods. But we've gone to far in that now.

LuciferRising · 05/02/2024 12:48

I'm convinced AI would be able to help here - we can't employ enough people to police the Web for it forever changes but AI could. Somehow. It would be a massive undertaken. International cooperation etc. Male violence is another thing that needs to be tackled and the access to violent porn. Or religious extremism.

But children do not access only from smartphones. There are numerous ways to connect to the Web, via different device types and different networks. As a starting point, education of the parent is needed. People need to understand what they can currently do to control what their child accesses.

RosePetals86 · 05/02/2024 12:48

I agree I think under 16s should be banned from social media. I don’t think social media is healthy for many adults let alone children. It’s a distorted reality and tbh if it disappeared tomorrow I think we’d be better off as a society. (And before anyone chirps up that mumsnet is social media, I’m talking about the likes of Facebook, Instagram, TikTok etc)

Oblomov23 · 05/02/2024 12:48

@YetMoreNewBeginnings posts sense. I too am finding most of Ds1's uni friends are thriving, loving it, are studying hard, at the gym, out with friends, less reliant on drink, sm usage, etc. They are clean living, aware of what they are eating, and aware of sm and the effects on their MH, and some take breaks from sm if required. Good for them!

asterel · 05/02/2024 12:47

Isn’t that something which the bus company ought to address? There must be ways that other people without smartphones can use the bus. Do you think we should be expected to buy expensive tech for kids that might not be good for them just for the convenience of a private bus company?

JasperTheDoll · 05/02/2024 12:43

asterel · 05/02/2024 12:23

I’d favour just denormalising it in the first instance - schools saying pupils can only bring brick and not smartphones to school, more of making it okay for kids not to have them. I recently went round a mixture of state and independent schools to look at with DD. All the kids at the state comps had (expensive!) smartphones, and the schools also made a big deal about setting them homework online, using apps and so on.

The independent schools all had an anti-smartphone/social media culture, and when you asked the kids who took you round on tours they said that phones aren’t a big deal and it’s quite normal for kids in the school not to have a smartphone or social media before at least year 9. So it obviously can be done. And it’s very telling that expensive independent schools are trying to denormalise smartphones. State schools and parents could easily follow suit and just try to stop normalising the idea amongst parents that every kid must have a smartphone at ten or 11 or they’ll be somehow “left out” or socially inadequate.

(If anything, it’s starting to look like the reverse. Too much time online hampers kids’ lives, social and academic skills and life choices, and will set them back in life, whereas parents and schools who restrict it will end up better adjusted.)

If only brick phones are allowed then how do those pupils who travel by bus manage? Most if not all services to our local high schools are cash free and pupils have to pay online and show their weekly/monthly ticket via the app?

Oblomov23 · 05/02/2024 12:42

Plus, from another angle, are you happy with the school your dc attend? I have been very happy with our school. Ds2 is still there. Their pastoral care is good, they spend time in tutor, assemblies, PHSE etc, talking about all sorts of topics: phones, the internet, self esteem, bullying, and just treating each other nicely. Most decent schools do.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 05/02/2024 12:34

asterel · 05/02/2024 12:31

@YetMoreNewBeginnings

I teach 18-22 age students, and by that age they are universally telling me they wish they had had more restrictions on their internet and social media / phone use during their teenage years. Many are already doing “digital detoxes” and so on at that age and telling me not to let my kids have phones! Social media seems to be a generalised bad experience for them even when they’ve only had it for a few years.

So it can’t be that there are loads of wonderful positives to it that outweigh the bad stuff, or why do my students already by 18 think that it’s been a uniformly negative experience for them? Doesn’t that suggest that they’d have been better off having less of it, if any? So maybe we adults need to step up and step in.

Edited

There's a huge difference between more restrictions and a complete ban.

As I've said, my uni age children have said with the things are now they think I should be stricter on my younger children than I was with them (and most other parents felt I was uber strict as it was).

That still doesn't mean that only introducing things at an age where so many teens feel invincible and know it all is a wise idea.

gamerchick · 05/02/2024 12:33

You can't shut the gates OP. An age limit won't make any difference, kids have always lied to get past age restrictions since age restrictions existed.

It's up to the parents. I detest this arse wiping crap that goes on now. It's one of the reasons kids are getting well into their 20s not being able to adult.

I personally havent let my youngest have SM and he's nearly 17. He's SN and I know it could do more harm than good. Thankfully he's not that interested. I can't shield him forever, it's a digital age whether you like it or not.