Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Social Media should be banned for under 16s

164 replies

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 10:00

Off the back of Esther Gheys campaigning about phone use and social media,
I was thinking how bonkers it is that we (as a society) haven't put in stricter controls over social media / internet use for kids yet.

It's as if the technology has developed too quickly, and parents have been left scrabbling around trying to control whatever they can, in what is essentially a completely unregulated cyber world.

I realise that some people are anti nanny-state, but imagine if CBBC started showing snuff films or porn in the middle of some teen drama. When mental health problems in children are soaring, and there is some evidence to show a link to phone / social media use, it seems totally nuts that regulation isn't being enforced at a higher level.

I see grown adults lose all perspective just from being on twitter, how on earth do we think kids can handle it better?

What benefit is it for children under 16 to be on social media? So they can do some tik-tok dance craze? If you want to do a dance just do it in your front room with your mates. To post posey-influencer style images at 13/14? For whose benefit?

I've heard people argue that its unrealistic to think that it can be changed now. Why? My kids are still young so maybe i dont understand.

OP posts:
QuickDraining · 05/02/2024 16:52

They should ban parks and park benches. As kids might sit down and talk to one another, about topics that we don't personally find comfortable.

They should ban pubs, because I've heard some pretty terrible conversations in the pub.

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 15:40

DecoratingDiva · 05/02/2024 14:50

It’s not a terrible idea but how would you actually do it.?

Our government can pass all the laws it likes but what power do they actually have over companies and users based all over the world.

And even if you get past that how do you actually make it work? They can ban facebook for all of us but banning facebook just for the u16s only is a lot more complex.

Many Adults would need a serious life re evaluation if FB was banned outright for everyone. It’s far more than just posting a few photos for Aunty Vi in Australia these days!
Peoples jobs, and lives are operated using it!
You can’t put any bans or restrictions on other countries putting stuff on the internet. This country (nor any country) has that power over everyone else.
Government could put an outright ban on some sites but others exactly would spring up within days to fill the gap. There is no answer currently to this problem except parental knowledge and supervision. Parents not bowing to peer and child pressure to have the latest phone and app younger and younger because their child is pestering that everyone has it.
As I said upthread- the controls are there USE THEM! Learn the tech. Get wise and knowledgable about what’s out there / new apps / new threats and how to control it on your child’s devices.
If most parents did this, the problem would be so so much less. It’s very frustrating when you have got all the restrictions in place and your kid hangs out with Johnny on the bus who’s parents haven’t put any restrictions on and he’s watching you tube and googling whatever he likes in front of your child.

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 15:32

pleasepleasepleasebequiet · 05/02/2024 14:04

I can't believe how naive some people on here are by saying it's as simple as parents monitoring it.

In my job I've come across vulnerable kids who have been taken advantage of in respect of county lines, along with youngsters being groomed and bullied etc.

The results of some of these situations are devastating and dangerous.

Their parents have done pretty much everything to stop it, but teenagers can generally find a way to get on social media without their parents knowledge!

If a child / family is at the stage of being groomed / county lines then banning social media for under 16’s won’t stop that at all. Like cutting off a branch when you need to up root the tree.

MargaretThursday · 05/02/2024 14:53

pleasepleasepleasebequiet · 05/02/2024 14:04

I can't believe how naive some people on here are by saying it's as simple as parents monitoring it.

In my job I've come across vulnerable kids who have been taken advantage of in respect of county lines, along with youngsters being groomed and bullied etc.

The results of some of these situations are devastating and dangerous.

Their parents have done pretty much everything to stop it, but teenagers can generally find a way to get on social media without their parents knowledge!

I don't think anyone is saying it's as simple as parents monitoring it.

However as you also say:
teenagers can generally find a way to get on social media without their parents knowledge
So they will if they're banned. And I'm certain that if they are being groomed, or county lines, one of the big things the groomers will do is give them a wonderful mobile phone (to hide from the parents) and that will be so tempting for a child whose parent doesn't let them. They groomers aren't really going to care that giving a mobile phone to a child is illegal are they?
When the child then becomes uncomfortable at what the groomer is asking, they have absolutely no one they can go to because they know they shouldn't have the phone. So the situation for that would be worse.

What I'm saying is that it is far better for them to be allowed and given the tools to use it.

(Edited to remove a random word at the bottom! )

DecoratingDiva · 05/02/2024 14:50

It’s not a terrible idea but how would you actually do it.?

Our government can pass all the laws it likes but what power do they actually have over companies and users based all over the world.

And even if you get past that how do you actually make it work? They can ban facebook for all of us but banning facebook just for the u16s only is a lot more complex.

Dollyparton3 · 05/02/2024 14:45

Half of my husband's family no longer speak because of one teen family member's social media addiction and the fallout.

She was totally unregulated as a young teen, bought followers, posted lewd content and had open public profiles.

Her mum played dumb whenever people raised concerns, and used it as ammo for her parental alienation agenda against her dad. The Teen concerned grew up with colossal levels of entitlement and manipulation and she placed her "influencer" greed above all of her most pivotal family relationships.

She never made it as an influencer by the way.

janicegarvey · 05/02/2024 14:29

I agree with this as I think social media and smartphones in general are damaging for kids

but not sure how they'd enforce it

OriginalUsername2 · 05/02/2024 14:21

asterel · 05/02/2024 12:31

@YetMoreNewBeginnings

I teach 18-22 age students, and by that age they are universally telling me they wish they had had more restrictions on their internet and social media / phone use during their teenage years. Many are already doing “digital detoxes” and so on at that age and telling me not to let my kids have phones! Social media seems to be a generalised bad experience for them even when they’ve only had it for a few years.

So it can’t be that there are loads of wonderful positives to it that outweigh the bad stuff, or why do my students already by 18 think that it’s been a uniformly negative experience for them? Doesn’t that suggest that they’d have been better off having less of it, if any? So maybe we adults need to step up and step in.

Edited

It’s seems to be this age that are making all the “millennials are messing up their kids by letting them watch YouTube” videos. We should probably listen to them, they’ve been through it fresh.

pleasepleasepleasebequiet · 05/02/2024 14:04

I can't believe how naive some people on here are by saying it's as simple as parents monitoring it.

In my job I've come across vulnerable kids who have been taken advantage of in respect of county lines, along with youngsters being groomed and bullied etc.

The results of some of these situations are devastating and dangerous.

Their parents have done pretty much everything to stop it, but teenagers can generally find a way to get on social media without their parents knowledge!

Anononony · 05/02/2024 14:04

A ban until 16 wouldn't stop addiction from that point on. Social media wasn't much of a thing until I was a similar age and certainly Facebook didn't really pick up until I was 18+, I'm still addicted to my phone.

I don't know how we stop it, I need to lower my phone usage yet rely on it for business as well as personal use, and a lot within the same apps so just having a work device and a personal one wouldn't work.

My 10yo is a gamer and has a small YT channel, and is otherwise not on or seemingly very aware of other social platforms. We do limit his gaming and especially his consumption of YT videos, but again he uses his pc for productive things like creating (games, videos, graphics for thumbnails etc), so I'm hesitant to limit his general device usage because I can see that being how he earns a living if he continues as he is with wanting to create and code

It's very difficult to balance, but I am grateful that for now the worst social media he is exposed to is YT comments (which I get notification of via email, so is monitored)

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 13:57

@LuciferRising yes - come offline is all very well - but don't ban it because for some people it's very important to them.
It seriously is down to the parents to get their children offline and/or only accessing suitable things.

sagalooshoe · 05/02/2024 13:55

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 13:45

Meanwhile back in the real world..

Why is it so impossible?

Mumsnet, facebook and fortnite manage to have a reporting system to block irresponsible or dangerous/offensive users. Why can't other social media platforms?

Why can't they ban pornhub or certain users of onlyfans?
They can but it would take effort and they just don't want to as they enjoy the money it makes 💰💰💰

clarepetal · 05/02/2024 13:55

Ihadittoo · 05/02/2024 10:27

Probably is correct but how would you enforce it?

Sadly, this. Would love to, though.

LuciferRising · 05/02/2024 13:54

Put more activities out in the real world and make sure teens can access them - and they won't always need to seek out an online life

But online is now another 'realm' and it is integrated in almost everything we do. And children have far more things to do that in the past, but these things are not accessible at their fingertips. Perhaps parents need to put money where their mouths are. Come offline.

TinyTear · 05/02/2024 13:54

lljkk · 05/02/2024 10:42

My < 16 DS is very keen on PGo. We were out for almost 3 hours yesterday for Community Day. I only started playing 6 weeks ago, way to hang out and get my own dopamine fix.

DS only really got into PG when someone added him to the local groupChat so he could do the extras & social parts of the Game, call up people for Raids. His boss (DS has a regular job) is on the GroupChat & I have known the boss since before DS was born. Many ppl on there are age 30+.

But oh dear, the GroupChat is SM & OP says all SM for <16s is bad, woe alas calamity nuts catastrophise predators clutch the pearls, can't possibly be a good thing.... Besides, talking to people in person is never toxic, bullying, irrational, violent, horrible experience. Didn't happen before digital SM were invented.

As a 50ish woman who plays PoGo and I am on a number of group chats I agree.

There is this 16 year old kid in my group we keep on the straight and narrow :-D and also many of us bring kids to raids...

Re Social Media - it's a sad situation Brianna's mum blames social media for the killers attitudes but doesn't get that probably social media made her child believe they could change sex and dress inappropriately for school

LuciferRising · 05/02/2024 13:50

Meanwhile back in the real world

But AI could be a solution. AI can analyse and correlate astronomical amounts of data sets. Organisations already use it to understand their networks, the traffic, security events - and this is old AI packaged up for commercial use.

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 13:49

@WhiteLily1 exactly - teens turn to social media because it interests them.
But sometimes it's because what interests them just doesn't exist out in the real world.
Put more activities out in the real world and make sure teens can access them - and they won't always need to seek out an online life.

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 13:45

sagalooshoe · 05/02/2024 13:34

They should just ban and completely erradicate porn,violence and anything that's a safeguarding risk on the internet full stop.
If anyone's caught streaming it/uploading it/sharing it whether they are an organisation or a person the IP address gets immediately deleted, like zipo/gone, they can try another IP address but zip/gone too. Ban their access to the internet.
If roblox gets taken offline due to a few idiots trying to open up an S&M bar in there then I'm sure as hell that the people making money out of ROblox would do more to erradicate it to begin with.
Same with any game/app/website.

If people want to be sleazy and violent they can join an underground club and get the hell out of our faces.

If a kid sends a dickpic from their phone then they are banned from Inst - simple. We have AI now - surely it can take much to intercept and spot these things - they all look pretty much the same! 😄

Meanwhile back in the real world..

WhiteLily1 · 05/02/2024 13:43

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 13:20

@WhiteLily1 what I meant is what are they missing in their lives? Something must be to make them turn to social media.
The education system (at least in England) is full of making teens like robotic clones (school uniforms, teaching methods, what they have to study etc). They don't have much time for hobbies because of the high level of school work. Part-time jobs have become almost non existent for under 16s due to red tape. There is often no where to go (no youth clubs) - no where to simply hang out and discover who they are and what's they enjoy.
They are bored and full of energy which in turn becomes frustration - and their only escape is through social media.
Which sucks basically.

I don’t disagree with what you are saying, but social media isn’t a last resort - a form of entertainment of the lowest value. Many teens love what it offers- yes there are problems, but many teens have a great time socialising on there and getting involved. It needs to be more closely regulated in my opinion but why I’m saying is social media fits a teenagers need to fit in. It literally caters to that need and then some!
Even if there were hobbies and jobs galore - teens would still be heavy users of social media!
They arnt using it to plug a gap! It’s literally how they live and socialise day to day. Like telling you to give up your phone entirely because ‘what are you missing’ A smart phone is integral to our lives now- everything is on it! It’s no different for teens.

LuciferRising · 05/02/2024 13:41

You can check on apps being dowloaded etc, what about internet searches? Can't you just delete your internet history??

Phones can be set up so that all apps require permission to be downloaded.

For internet history - put all traffic that goes through your home router through an application which records the history. It can also block sites. They cannot access this application from their phone. You can do this for any device which goes through your home router.

If needed, eg if they access 4G - there are other controls you can use.

StarlightLady · 05/02/2024 13:38

This has come about over an extremely delicate, tragic and heartbreaking situation.

But if we are talking about legislation here, how on earth would it be enforced?

thecatsthecats · 05/02/2024 13:38

Halfmanhalfcake · 05/02/2024 11:23

This is really interesting, why do you think they reject it so much?

They don't so much as reject it as ignore it - for example, I say "I want to review how we're using social media to meet the Children's Code", and someone will say:

  • yep, great idea (but not be interested)
  • no, we're doing everything right already (defensive managers usually)
  • I really want this (concerned front end staff)

Then something happens that was entirely in scope of my predicted issues.

There's a bit of an obsession with what the auditors recommended three years ago - but they missed significant areas of the legislation and entirely lack the practical know-how I bring.

sagalooshoe · 05/02/2024 13:34

They should just ban and completely erradicate porn,violence and anything that's a safeguarding risk on the internet full stop.
If anyone's caught streaming it/uploading it/sharing it whether they are an organisation or a person the IP address gets immediately deleted, like zipo/gone, they can try another IP address but zip/gone too. Ban their access to the internet.
If roblox gets taken offline due to a few idiots trying to open up an S&M bar in there then I'm sure as hell that the people making money out of ROblox would do more to erradicate it to begin with.
Same with any game/app/website.

If people want to be sleazy and violent they can join an underground club and get the hell out of our faces.

If a kid sends a dickpic from their phone then they are banned from Inst - simple. We have AI now - surely it can take much to intercept and spot these things - they all look pretty much the same! 😄

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 13:20

@WhiteLily1 what I meant is what are they missing in their lives? Something must be to make them turn to social media.
The education system (at least in England) is full of making teens like robotic clones (school uniforms, teaching methods, what they have to study etc). They don't have much time for hobbies because of the high level of school work. Part-time jobs have become almost non existent for under 16s due to red tape. There is often no where to go (no youth clubs) - no where to simply hang out and discover who they are and what's they enjoy.
They are bored and full of energy which in turn becomes frustration - and their only escape is through social media.
Which sucks basically.

Speedweed · 05/02/2024 13:20

I think in years to come we'll be looked at as a backwards era in terms of understanding the effect of all this stuff on the brain, and the resulting effects on dopamine rewards, attention spans and overall brain development.

I agree it should be legislated against far more strongly but it probably won't happen until there is a generation or two who have been made very ill and - crucially - where the cost of that illness has a cost impact on society. For example, tobacco was available for a few hundred years, the health research in the twentieth century appeared, but it was only when those health impacts could be quantified as a cost, and an avoidable drain on the public purse through the NHS, was anything done to start seriously legislating to dissuade smoking.

Swipe left for the next trending thread