Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be pissed off she lied and took a flight without telling us!

215 replies

Authorinwaiting · 05/02/2024 09:52

Daughter is 21. She was in a relationship up until Christmas but met someone else and dumped boyfriend.

She has moved home now and living here full time. She was supposed to be taking time on her own to get her head straight.

This weekend she made a big deal about going to her friends house to stay for the weekend. She made up a whole itinerary and off she went.

Now for perspective she has not been in contact with this friend for ages and fell out as far as I knew. So I was kinda glad she was picking up with her girlfriends again.

Normally she would text loads when she's away both with me and her brothers. We heard nothing except when she messaged yesterday to say she needed a lift home from the bus stop.

I was really suspicious. She was talking in the car after I picked her up
About this fella she met before Christmas and how he invited her to an engagement party with him. He lives in Manchester. We are in NI.

She's gone to uni this morning and left her rubbish out of her pocket on the table. There are two stage coach tickets for Manchester there. So she lied. She's not taking time out on her own and she was in Manchester!

I fell so let down and disappointed. I haven't told anyone because I don't want them
To think ill of her but am I being overbearing as a mum? I mean how do I approach this?

OP posts:
HoppingPavlova · 05/02/2024 10:53

At that age they need to make their own mistakes. That’s how they learn. You are trying to control her so she can’t make mistakes. That means she’s only going to make them further down the line, so you are merely kicking the can down the road as they say. Just let her fuck up and learn from it.

Smartiepants79 · 05/02/2024 10:52

Don’t subsidise her. She can find her own fun money for trips to Manchester. It’s entirely reasonable for you to refuse to fund it.
But you need to let her be with who she chooses and spend her time as she wants. If the lack of money means she can’t do those things then she’ll have to think again. But unless she’s doing something illegal or actually dangerous then you’ve got to let her get on with it. She’s supposed to be a grown up!

FuckingHellAdele · 05/02/2024 10:51

Stop 'disappointing' all over her.

Be firm in your boundaries- this is what we will pay for, this is what we won't. This is what we expect around the house. Etc

Then let her get on with it- deeply unsuitable men, poor decision making and all. It's par for the course sometimes, and most of us come out the other side unscathed.
Don't give her any reason not to be able to come and tell you the important stuff.

LauderSyme · 05/02/2024 10:50

In these circumstances I would tell my adult dd that if she makes a habit of lying to my face, we cannot have a mutually respectful adult relationship.

I would also ask her why she lied so that I could reflect on whether I need to change any of my own less than healthy behaviours.

Heronwatcher · 05/02/2024 10:49

Authorinwaiting · 05/02/2024 10:40

Wow. Ok this is why I thought I'd ask mums net.

I know why she lied.

She was in a relationship with a lad who she went to school with. They insisted on living together this year despite both sets of parents saying it wasn't a great idea.

She decided a couple months in that they were incompatible for all the reasons both sets of parents pointed out. (No judgement from me here. I'd paid the rent for the year already so told her to come home
No problem. She wouldn't because we live in the country and it's a pain getting to Belfast for Uni.

At this point she met someone else and ran both relationships concurrently. I did say I felt that was really poor behaviour but it was her life and she had to make the decisions.

After Christmas she decided to dump the live in boyfriend and move home. Allowing him to stay in their student accommodation they shared.

We were happy to have her here it's her home after all. She's a student so there is no financial implications for her living here either. No problem.

However I asked her to consider giving herself a chance to get over the relationship before diving head first into another one.

She told me the Manchester lad ( from belfast but in uni at Manchester) was away back and she would spend the time getting her head straight.

I'm disappointed. I can see her diving into another relationship head first full on. She had a part time job up until two weeks ago. Working in a shop in town. She's given it up. Because she wanted the extra time to study.

Was it because she wants to spend weekends in Manchester? Am I going to be asked to subsidise her now she has no job?

Im not a mum who tells her what's to do. But I felt her running two lads side by side was wrong. So we argued about that.

That's why she lied about the weekend.

So she knew you might not approve and chose not to tell you, so you know what the answer is.

If she wants to dive into the new relationship then you have to let her, and be there to support her if/ when it goes wrong. Trying to stop her by arguing, lecturing or just keeping really close ties on her will just make her more determined to keep stuff from you.

As for running 2 boys at once, she’s early 20s, she’s not married, you’ve told her you didn’t approve and it sounds like she’s moved on anyway, so you have to too.

I know it’s difficult but start to think about how you’d react if an adult friend was doing something you didn’t approve of and approach it in the same way- whilst modelling the behaviour you do think is good so she has a strong example to follow.

Prawncow · 05/02/2024 10:48

Am I going to be asked to subsidise her now she has no job?

That’s a valid concern. You can make it clear that she needs to support herself.

But I felt her running two lads side by side was wrong. So we argued about that.

That’s none of your business. You don’t have to approve of it but she’s an adult. All your arguing has done is make her lie to you.

WandaWonder · 05/02/2024 10:47

Do you track her periods as well, for her sake step back

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 05/02/2024 10:45

Ah typical response. Drip feed some stuff that mentions key buzzwords to get sympathy like slut shaming your daughter and then "Oh but I'll have to support her"

lifeispainauchocolat · 05/02/2024 10:43

It all seems very intense.

Why are you going through her rubbish and her stuff?

PiggieWig · 05/02/2024 10:42

Disappointed she felt she had to lie is one thing, but she can make her own decisions on who to spend her weekend with.

Are you disappointed she went? If this guy is the reason she ended her relationship it seems a stretch to think she’ll be spending some time alone to get her head straight.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 05/02/2024 10:42

Are you controlling and overbearing (I'm guessing yes)?

She lied because she knew you wouldn't react well... and possibly wouldn't have even let her go. Despite her being an adult who can do what she wants.

Something about "she's back home to get her head straight" screams "we have forced her to come back" to me

dimllaishebiaith · 05/02/2024 10:41

You went through her rubbish to see if you could find out what she had been up to?

No wonder she lied

She's a grown adult. Yes you are overbearing and if I were you I would do precisely nothing, because there is nothing to do here.

My mum was like you, she knows nothing about my life now. That's the route you risk taking.

I also find it highly convenient that she left the tickets "on the table" when she had gone out. Were they actually on the table or did you go looking?

barfotoliv · 05/02/2024 10:41

You sound a bit like my mother when I was that age. When I was at uni I once went to Edinburgh without her knowing, she found out and totally over-reacted. Even as an older adult in my 30s she always wanted to know my every move. She is a lovely, caring mother but I did find it suffocating, and it was a factor in my eventual move abroad. Your daughter is a fully grown woman and doesn't need to check-in with you. Give her some space is my advice.

Authorinwaiting · 05/02/2024 10:40

Wow. Ok this is why I thought I'd ask mums net.

I know why she lied.

She was in a relationship with a lad who she went to school with. They insisted on living together this year despite both sets of parents saying it wasn't a great idea.

She decided a couple months in that they were incompatible for all the reasons both sets of parents pointed out. (No judgement from me here. I'd paid the rent for the year already so told her to come home
No problem. She wouldn't because we live in the country and it's a pain getting to Belfast for Uni.

At this point she met someone else and ran both relationships concurrently. I did say I felt that was really poor behaviour but it was her life and she had to make the decisions.

After Christmas she decided to dump the live in boyfriend and move home. Allowing him to stay in their student accommodation they shared.

We were happy to have her here it's her home after all. She's a student so there is no financial implications for her living here either. No problem.

However I asked her to consider giving herself a chance to get over the relationship before diving head first into another one.

She told me the Manchester lad ( from belfast but in uni at Manchester) was away back and she would spend the time getting her head straight.

I'm disappointed. I can see her diving into another relationship head first full on. She had a part time job up until two weeks ago. Working in a shop in town. She's given it up. Because she wanted the extra time to study.

Was it because she wants to spend weekends in Manchester? Am I going to be asked to subsidise her now she has no job?

Im not a mum who tells her what's to do. But I felt her running two lads side by side was wrong. So we argued about that.

That's why she lied about the weekend.

OP posts:
susiedaisy1912 · 05/02/2024 10:36

Heronwatcher · 05/02/2024 10:29

Everyone is entitled to a private life and she’s an adult.

Maybe she felt embarrassed to be moving on, maybe she knew you wouldn’t approve. Maybe she just wanted to go off everyone’s radar, and see how it went without having to answer questions etc?

Honestly I would do nothing, just keep lines of communication open and non-judgmental and she’ll likely tell you anyway.

This

Heronwatcher · 05/02/2024 10:33

I think that there’s a danger of catastrophising the safety angle a bit too- at that age I was just out of uni (or maybe in the last year) and honestly sometimes didn’t speak to my parents from one week to the next- no mobile phones and I was busy having fun! I also then went travelling for lengthy periods. My parents had no idea who I was with, though I would obviously tell friends etc and TBH was pretty sensible. Something nasty could happen anywhere/ anytime, so I wouldn’t use that as a justification to go overboard.

SkulkHollow · 05/02/2024 10:32

She's 21. You don't approach it, other than to reflect on why she felt the need to lie to you.

I'm guessing you are extremely judgemental about her relationships and she didn't want the hassle of having to justify herself to you.

paintingvenice · 05/02/2024 10:30

You sorted through her rubbish? 🤪 can’t imagine why she doesn’t tell you what she’s up to!!!

Haydenn · 05/02/2024 10:29

What would your response have been if she said she was going to see a guy? I’m in my 40s and I know my own mother would be appalled to know I was going for a weekend away with a chap. Maybe she just didn’t want to have to deal with the inevitable lecture?

Heronwatcher · 05/02/2024 10:29

Everyone is entitled to a private life and she’s an adult.

Maybe she felt embarrassed to be moving on, maybe she knew you wouldn’t approve. Maybe she just wanted to go off everyone’s radar, and see how it went without having to answer questions etc?

Honestly I would do nothing, just keep lines of communication open and non-judgmental and she’ll likely tell you anyway.

lifeispainauchocolat · 05/02/2024 10:28

Hankunamatata · 05/02/2024 10:22

I'm bemused why she felt the need to lie

Given the way OP has reacted, isn't it obvious?

lifeispainauchocolat · 05/02/2024 10:27

I'm not surprised she lied given how you've reacted!

She's a grown adult - it's not your business.

shepherdsangeldelight · 05/02/2024 10:25

Hankunamatata · 05/02/2024 10:22

I'm bemused why she felt the need to lie

Because she knew that her mum would feel let down and disappointed? Correctly, as it turns out.

Hankunamatata · 05/02/2024 10:24

Just re read
'she was supposed to spending time'

Have you been judegmental about her dumping bf and now she feels she can't tell you

Hankunamatata · 05/02/2024 10:22

I'm bemused why she felt the need to lie