Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be pissed off she lied and took a flight without telling us!

215 replies

Authorinwaiting · 05/02/2024 09:52

Daughter is 21. She was in a relationship up until Christmas but met someone else and dumped boyfriend.

She has moved home now and living here full time. She was supposed to be taking time on her own to get her head straight.

This weekend she made a big deal about going to her friends house to stay for the weekend. She made up a whole itinerary and off she went.

Now for perspective she has not been in contact with this friend for ages and fell out as far as I knew. So I was kinda glad she was picking up with her girlfriends again.

Normally she would text loads when she's away both with me and her brothers. We heard nothing except when she messaged yesterday to say she needed a lift home from the bus stop.

I was really suspicious. She was talking in the car after I picked her up
About this fella she met before Christmas and how he invited her to an engagement party with him. He lives in Manchester. We are in NI.

She's gone to uni this morning and left her rubbish out of her pocket on the table. There are two stage coach tickets for Manchester there. So she lied. She's not taking time out on her own and she was in Manchester!

I fell so let down and disappointed. I haven't told anyone because I don't want them
To think ill of her but am I being overbearing as a mum? I mean how do I approach this?

OP posts:
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 05/02/2024 14:18

Is she embarrassed that there's clearly an over lap of men and would you tell her off for cheating?

LondonLass91 · 05/02/2024 14:16

SpringleDingle · 05/02/2024 13:48

God you sound more overbearing than my mum and she complains that at 46 I don't tell her anything. I don't tell her anything because she was judgy and controlling in my teens and early adulthood and the grief wasn't worth it. It's a habit for me to lie to her about anything that she might even remotely disapprove of. My partner is planning to move in and I haven't told mum... I might do before he actually lives here, or maybe after or possibly I'll get my sister to tell her because she won't be hurt by my mum's shitty comment (honestly there's always a shitty comment).

Your DD lied to you because YOU are unreasonable and controlling. She will likely always lie to you unless you nip this in the bud now and stop being a cow.

What a horrible message to someone who was asking for help.

OP, I would also be upset, and she clearly didn't tell you because you would not have been happy that your daughter has left the country to meet a (pretty much) stranger. And to be upset is a normal reaction. Ignore posters who say otherwise, they clearly don't have 21 year old daughters.

Moveoverdarlin · 05/02/2024 14:16

Chill out. She’s 21. If she was married with children and shagging two blokes at the same time, it’s inappropriate. At university at the age of 21, it’s not that bad. Leave her to it.

I would say ‘look I found the Manchester tickets so I know you lied. I’m not cross, do what you want. However, from a safety point of view I would like to know what city and country you are in. If there was an accident and someone asked if you were in Manchester this weekend, I would have told them you weren’t, that makes me look like a shit parent and you look like a little child that tells lies. But we are not those things so let’s move on.’

ABwithAnItch · 05/02/2024 14:14

Authorinwaiting · 05/02/2024 10:40

Wow. Ok this is why I thought I'd ask mums net.

I know why she lied.

She was in a relationship with a lad who she went to school with. They insisted on living together this year despite both sets of parents saying it wasn't a great idea.

She decided a couple months in that they were incompatible for all the reasons both sets of parents pointed out. (No judgement from me here. I'd paid the rent for the year already so told her to come home
No problem. She wouldn't because we live in the country and it's a pain getting to Belfast for Uni.

At this point she met someone else and ran both relationships concurrently. I did say I felt that was really poor behaviour but it was her life and she had to make the decisions.

After Christmas she decided to dump the live in boyfriend and move home. Allowing him to stay in their student accommodation they shared.

We were happy to have her here it's her home after all. She's a student so there is no financial implications for her living here either. No problem.

However I asked her to consider giving herself a chance to get over the relationship before diving head first into another one.

She told me the Manchester lad ( from belfast but in uni at Manchester) was away back and she would spend the time getting her head straight.

I'm disappointed. I can see her diving into another relationship head first full on. She had a part time job up until two weeks ago. Working in a shop in town. She's given it up. Because she wanted the extra time to study.

Was it because she wants to spend weekends in Manchester? Am I going to be asked to subsidise her now she has no job?

Im not a mum who tells her what's to do. But I felt her running two lads side by side was wrong. So we argued about that.

That's why she lied about the weekend.

‘I don’t tell her what to do’ No you may not but you sound horribly judgemental. ‘get your head right’ don’t go out with two guys at once. it’s poor behaviour’ etc. No wonder she lied. I never told my mother anything and still don’t. I don’t need someone telling me how disappointed they are.

Toooldforthis36 · 05/02/2024 14:12

You were way too involved in a 21 year olds personal life. No wonder she keeps secrets from you.

Bluenotgreen · 05/02/2024 14:10

Honestly OP I have DC her age and there is no way I would comment or get involved. Fear of your “disappointment” is probably why she didn’t tell you.

However, I do think she needs a job and I wouldn’t be bankrolling her given all the money you already wasted on rent.

momonpurpose · 05/02/2024 14:10

Tempnamechng · 05/02/2024 09:56

I think I would be concerned that your dd thought she had to lie. As an adult she should have just been comfortable enough to say where she was going, from a personal safety aspect as much as anything.

I think this is very true. She is an adult and if you don't treat her as one you will damage your relationship with her. It's common curiosity to tell your family you are leaving town yes. But your daughter hid this from you for a reason.

Cas112 · 05/02/2024 14:04

skybluekitty · 05/02/2024 10:00

I think I'd be more bothered that there was something so wrong in our relationship that my adult daughter felt the need to lie to me about her whereabouts...

Other than that, it's none of your business where she goes - she's a grown up.

This 100%

Paperandpen123 · 05/02/2024 14:04

I’m sorry OP you sound really over bearing and no wonder she lied. She’s 21 and she doesn’t owe you any details of her life, it’s a privilege to be part of your kids lives once they have grown up.

rainbowsparkle28 · 05/02/2024 13:59

I think your feelings are mis-directed I would be more concerned that she didn't feel able to tell you truth tbh, and safety wise I would be worried if there wasn't anyone who had a general sense of where she was / keeping in touch just in case anything happened but I would say that in any situation. But aside from that she is 21 she is allowed to make her own decisions, I would not be angry 🤷🏼‍♀️

shepherdsangeldelight · 05/02/2024 13:56

Jk8 · 05/02/2024 13:49

@shepherdsangeldelight

Or brothers or father ect. All of whom would have to be called in an emergency before best mate 10 contacts down on her phone list who she spoke to a few days ago...

Not sure of your point? If someone is calling mother/brother/father etc in an emergency, then presumably the caller will tell the mother/brother/father where the incident happened.

The safety issue around not telling anyone where you are is that if you vanish (because you were murdered and dumped in the canal) no one knows where you were. If you're hit by a car and people start going through your contacts on your phone, then it doesn't really matter if they knew where you were or not at the time of the accident as they'll soon find out.

Mermaidsarereal · 05/02/2024 13:53

I'd be upset at her lying but at the end of the day she is an adult. Is there a reason she would lie? Maybe she's worried about telling you something about the bloke she met (might be a lot older than her?)

She is your daughter and no matter how old she is you are bound to worry.

Jk8 · 05/02/2024 13:49

@shepherdsangeldelight

Or brothers or father ect. All of whom would have to be called in an emergency before best mate 10 contacts down on her phone list who she spoke to a few days ago...

SpringleDingle · 05/02/2024 13:48

God you sound more overbearing than my mum and she complains that at 46 I don't tell her anything. I don't tell her anything because she was judgy and controlling in my teens and early adulthood and the grief wasn't worth it. It's a habit for me to lie to her about anything that she might even remotely disapprove of. My partner is planning to move in and I haven't told mum... I might do before he actually lives here, or maybe after or possibly I'll get my sister to tell her because she won't be hurt by my mum's shitty comment (honestly there's always a shitty comment).

Your DD lied to you because YOU are unreasonable and controlling. She will likely always lie to you unless you nip this in the bud now and stop being a cow.

shepherdsangeldelight · 05/02/2024 13:46

Jk8 · 05/02/2024 13:43

I get that shes 21 & people are saying she's an adult but she left the country without telling anyone!!!!!!!!!!!! I'd be absolutely raging about the stupidity of it before the supposed to be taking time to herself stuff!

What if shes been date raped/murdered/hit by a a car

We don't know that she didn't tell anyone. She quite probably told some friends (maybe the one that she pretended she was meeting).
We only know that she didn't tell her mum.

Jk8 · 05/02/2024 13:43

I get that shes 21 & people are saying she's an adult but she left the country without telling anyone!!!!!!!!!!!! I'd be absolutely raging about the stupidity of it before the supposed to be taking time to herself stuff!

What if shes been date raped/murdered/hit by a a car

MumblesParty · 05/02/2024 13:43

I don’t blame you for feeling as you do OP. It sounds as if your daughter has clearly chosen to please herself, make her own decisions, ignore anyone’s reservations - and you have been supportive and financially helpful with her various choices. I imagine the to’ing and fro’ing with house and boyfriends has been quite stressful all round. You paid rent for a year despite expressing reservations about her decision to live with her boyfriend, and then she cheated on him and then came home. I expect you spent time with her, talking about having a break from boyfriends, getting her head straight etc.

She knows that heading off to Manchester went against all the things she’d said, and would worry you, for all the reasons above. So she lied because she was embarrassed to be disregarding all her sensible plans, and because she didn’t want to see your surprise/disappointment.

We’ve all been there with friends - friend has horrible boyfriend who cheats on them, we spend hours, days, weeks consoling friend, supporting them, cheering them up - then friend goes back to nasty boyfriend. It’s a disappointing feeling, despite it being none of our business what our friends do.

I would probably speak to your daughter and say that whilst it’s none of your business who she spends time with, you feel that from a safety perspective it would be sensible for her to tell you if she’s travelling far, especially with someone she doesn’t know well.

Sasqwatch · 05/02/2024 13:41

Tempnamechng · 05/02/2024 09:56

I think I would be concerned that your dd thought she had to lie. As an adult she should have just been comfortable enough to say where she was going, from a personal safety aspect as much as anything.

This

Poor girl.

The fact that you consider that there is a possibility that someone would ’think ill of her’ says it all OP 🙄

HollyKnight · 05/02/2024 13:33

At this point - her being 21 years old - your parenting job is over. You no longer get to chastise or discipline her. Her life decisions are on her. Just be her mum. Be there for her when she fucks up and needs a hug.

ItsADoggieDogWorld · 05/02/2024 13:33

Ghuunvg · 05/02/2024 12:47

I wouldn't be subsidising a 21 year old who quit her job and cheated on her boyfriend while I paid her rent.

Absolutely. I for one would be asking her to work to pay back the rent on the flat she left.
Yes you can live your life, and make your own mistakes. But they are for you to pay, not your parents. She's 21, not a child.

shepherdsangeldelight · 05/02/2024 13:14

user1471538283 · 05/02/2024 12:45

What would worry me was if something had happened to her you would have thought she was with her friends and she wasn't. I would just mention to her that she doesn't need to lie but you would like to just know her vague plans just in case.

But then I am over protective.

Adult children do not need to tell their parents "vague plans".
Until recently this DD was at university. I doubt she gave her mum a running commentary of who she was out with every night.

CormorantStrikesBack · 05/02/2024 13:01

shepherdsangeldelight · 05/02/2024 12:44

There's ways of saying things.
Telling an adult child what they should do (as you would a 7 year old) is inappropriate.
Being openly disapproving and judgemental of your adult child's choices is also inappropriate.

Voicing an opinion to your DC, whilst making it clear that you recognise that it's their own choice and you will love and support them regardless of what decision they make is an appropriate way to have a conversation.

This. And the fact that OP's dd doesn't feel she can talk to her suggests that the dd thinks there's an issue. I do sympathise, I have a 22yo so it's hard. For me I don't offer advice/an opinion unless I'm asked. The way I see it at 22yo I had my own house and lived on my own so my parents had no idea what I was up to.

RowanMayfair · 05/02/2024 12:56

Authorinwaiting · 05/02/2024 11:14

Ok. So just ignore it then?

I won't mention it. I am disappointed she lied but I get that I've not handled the relationship stuff well so I'll get over myself.

Thanks for all your advice. Appreciate it.

She's 21. She's going to make poor decisions. She needs to be able to talk about her decisions with you (especially when they go wrong) without you constantly being disappointed' in her.

skysmumm · 05/02/2024 12:52

FuckingHellAdele · 05/02/2024 10:51

Stop 'disappointing' all over her.

Be firm in your boundaries- this is what we will pay for, this is what we won't. This is what we expect around the house. Etc

Then let her get on with it- deeply unsuitable men, poor decision making and all. It's par for the course sometimes, and most of us come out the other side unscathed.
Don't give her any reason not to be able to come and tell you the important stuff.

Absolutely agree with this!

I was that daughter. I was a total shit to boys. It calmed down though once I'd properly matured. No amount of lectures would have swayed my decision making process.

Bournetilly · 05/02/2024 12:50

She’s 21 and it sounds as though you are trying to control her. There’s a reason she had to lie. I’ve been there myself when I was 20, had to pretend I wasn’t on holiday when I was because my mum wanted to control how I spent my money/ what on (I wasn’t even living at home I was at uni). Obviously I would rather have told the truth but it would just cause arguments.