Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be pissed off she lied and took a flight without telling us!

215 replies

Authorinwaiting · 05/02/2024 09:52

Daughter is 21. She was in a relationship up until Christmas but met someone else and dumped boyfriend.

She has moved home now and living here full time. She was supposed to be taking time on her own to get her head straight.

This weekend she made a big deal about going to her friends house to stay for the weekend. She made up a whole itinerary and off she went.

Now for perspective she has not been in contact with this friend for ages and fell out as far as I knew. So I was kinda glad she was picking up with her girlfriends again.

Normally she would text loads when she's away both with me and her brothers. We heard nothing except when she messaged yesterday to say she needed a lift home from the bus stop.

I was really suspicious. She was talking in the car after I picked her up
About this fella she met before Christmas and how he invited her to an engagement party with him. He lives in Manchester. We are in NI.

She's gone to uni this morning and left her rubbish out of her pocket on the table. There are two stage coach tickets for Manchester there. So she lied. She's not taking time out on her own and she was in Manchester!

I fell so let down and disappointed. I haven't told anyone because I don't want them
To think ill of her but am I being overbearing as a mum? I mean how do I approach this?

OP posts:
AIstolemylunch · 05/02/2024 19:04

she's 21, get a grip.

Jk8 · 05/02/2024 19:03

@LenaLamont She didn't leave the UK would be the alternative

Jk8 · 05/02/2024 19:02

LenaLamont · 05/02/2024 17:48

She lied because you are wearing your big Judgy-pants about her relationships, keep saying how "disappointed" you are and how you don't want people "to think ill of her."

Back off. She's 21, her relationships are none of your business. Stop sticking your oar in.

As for @Jk8 - she didn't leave the country, ffs. She went from Belfast to Manchester for the weekend, not some ashram in Goa. No visas required.

She went from NI to England- thats hardly down the road & if leaving the city you live in a courtesy mention to the family you live with is the bare minimum even if its just for safety

DangerousAlchemy · 05/02/2024 18:48

RachTheAlpaca · 05/02/2024 17:21

Strict parents raise sneaky kids.
She's an adult and obviously she felt that she had to lie to you, to be blunt if you're not careful you'll end up not knowing anything about her life or being involved at all. I'm speaking from my experience

yeah @RachTheAlpaca totally agree! My parents were strict and I never told them anything about my life at Uni. I even moved out aged 21 to move south to be nearer my boyfriend while they were away on holiday 🤣 Rather than talking to them about it as I knew they wouldn't approve. Shame really as now I miss them but we were never that close & they both died a few years ago. My DD is almost 20 & she doesn't tell me everything but that's fine & normal. We have a good, trusting relationship tho.

LonginesPrime · 05/02/2024 18:06

if she was being deliberately deceptive - would she have left the tickets anywhere for you to see, or would she have got rid of any evidence? So either she doesn’t feel like it’s a big deal or she wants you to know and perhaps this is the catalyst for a conversation

or...did OP wait until DD was out of the house at Uni and go searching for clues because she suspected DD had lied?

Shopper727 · 05/02/2024 17:57

I have a 22 yo, you do have to let them live their lives though. I wouldn’t accept lying but my son doesn’t see the need to lie to me if he’s going to do something or go somewhere he’ll say, he knows I’ll say something if I feel it’s not a good idea but he’s pretty good on the whole. The 18 yo is a whole different story!!! It’s hard being a parent to this age group but I’d tell her you didn’t appreciate her lying to you and that it’s not acceptable. Forge a more open relationship where she can tell you about her life good and bad!

Holliegee · 05/02/2024 17:52

I’ll be honest and my intention isn’t to be hurtful - if you look for problems you will find them.
Years ago I too would be like you and although I know you feel
it is from a caring maternal protective action - it isn’t !!! It’s controlling and verging on obsessive.

Shes an adult she has to make her own choices, rightly or wrongly and I suspect from your outlook she may have made some mistakes and you’re keen to help her get past them -BUT you have to let her spread her wings and fly and make her own path.

From
another angle, if she was being deliberately deceptive - would she have left the tickets anywhere for you to see, or would she have got rid of any evidence? So either she doesn’t feel like it’s a big deal or she wants you to know and perhaps this is the catalyst for a conversation you could have which would begin (in my life) like this - I know you said you were going to xyz house this weekend, but I came across these bus tickets, did you end up in Manchester somehow?? (Laugh giggle) and if you were going there I wish you’d have said because you know I worry about you - you will always be my daughter !! …… and see where it goes

LenaLamont · 05/02/2024 17:48

She lied because you are wearing your big Judgy-pants about her relationships, keep saying how "disappointed" you are and how you don't want people "to think ill of her."

Back off. She's 21, her relationships are none of your business. Stop sticking your oar in.

As for @Jk8 - she didn't leave the country, ffs. She went from Belfast to Manchester for the weekend, not some ashram in Goa. No visas required.

UtopiaPlanitia · 05/02/2024 17:47

Another NI person here 👋 I think your daughter’s being self-centred and she’s lying about her plans so she can do what she wants. She doesn’t want to hear what you think, even if your advice is good or useful - it happens a lot with kids that age, they want to avoid what they see as the drama/imposition of having to deal with other people’s feelings. They get caught up in their own lives and forget to think about other people, and they sometimes see family as a hindrance. It’s part of growing up and part of the process of separating from your family to live as an adult. Some young people handle it more sensibly than others. And a 21 year old Uni student living at home isn’t quite as independent as they would always like to be and may find that restrictive and annoying.

I wouldn’t like to be lied to like this either, I can understand why you’re upset and worried; if, god forbid, something had happened to her while she was in England (illness, an accident, a mugging, missing her transport home) it would have made it difficult for you to help her. I would talk to her (calmly) about why she lied and explain why you’re worried about her. If she understands your reasoning, it might help her to see that being sensible means sharing some types of information if only for practical reasons.

Bladwdoda · 05/02/2024 17:44

Op this sounds so tough, you can see her doing things that aren’t right for her or others and you want to help her. That’s totally reasonable.

However she is an adult now and I think sometimes overstepping into an adult child’s life, even a young adult, doesn’t usually end well. It sounds like she didn’t take your advice anyhow, so rather than argue with her or expect her to give you details I’d leave her to it. Have general chats with her, ask how she is and comment if she asks for your advice. But don’t try to “parent” by picking her up on things she is doing wrong.

Although, the side of her being an adult that also needs to come is the responsibly. No you don’t have to bank roll her if she doesn’t have a job. She can be paying her own way. She can’t live in your home acting like a child and expect to be treated like an adult. Also no she can’t have lifts from you at the drop of a hat. I assume she is in that stage of young adulthood where she wants all the independence but is not yet taking all the responsibility that comes with adulthood. I think that’s partly normal.

Anyhow you have my sympathies. Must be a hard age to “parent”.

thebestinterest · 05/02/2024 17:41

Yes, you ARE being over bearing!!!

When I met my now DH, I was 24 and although I didn’t live with my parents, I did tell a lie by saying I was going to visit college friends ( 😬). What I had actually done was boarded a flight to America to meet up with him for a long weekend.

She probably didn’t tell you because she didn’t want to be judged and talked at. That’s why I lied, anyways.

porridgeisbae · 05/02/2024 17:36

@Authorinwaiting I think it's quite rare/unlikely for most women that age to say 'Im going to take some time to myself before I start a new relationship' for a substantial amount of time. I mean, they don't deliberately do it for six months or something. And that's not someone you can make someone else do, if that's what you've tried to do.

She's met someone she's interested in so she's seeing him. That's normal.

Her past behaviour of cheating on someone is obviously not ok but that's in the past now.

LikeagoddamnVampire · 05/02/2024 17:29

Tempnamechng · 05/02/2024 09:56

I think I would be concerned that your dd thought she had to lie. As an adult she should have just been comfortable enough to say where she was going, from a personal safety aspect as much as anything.

Yes this. Its not really any of your business who she sees/shags/visits but you've obviously been over protective so now she feels she can't tell you the truth now.

That's sad and that is what you need to work on.

Victoriancat · 05/02/2024 17:23

She's 21 for goodness sake, she didn't tell you cos you're like this 😂

Noseybookworm · 05/02/2024 17:23

She's a 21 year old woman and presumably doesn't need your permission to go and see a boyfriend for the weekend. It does say a lot about your relationship that she didn't feel able to tell you her plans. Are you worried that she dumped the boyfriend because she met this new bloke? I'm struggling to see what she's done that's so wrong, apart from lying about where she went.

RachTheAlpaca · 05/02/2024 17:21

Strict parents raise sneaky kids.
She's an adult and obviously she felt that she had to lie to you, to be blunt if you're not careful you'll end up not knowing anything about her life or being involved at all. I'm speaking from my experience

LonginesPrime · 05/02/2024 17:21

She's gone to uni this morning and left her rubbish out of her pocket on the table. There are two stage coach tickets for Manchester there. So she lied.

Why would she go to all the trouble to make up a fake itinerary of her trip to conceal the whole thing, but then leave the evidence on the table for you to find?

That makes no sense.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 05/02/2024 17:14

MandyMotherOfBrian · 05/02/2024 16:40

We disagree often, about a lot of different things. We talk. I can't answer what I would do exactly in this situation as it hasn't arisen, and I very much doubt it would tbh. But that's not my point. My point is how have you got to the point where your daughter doesn't feel, not only that she can talk to you, but specifically that she has to lie to you. You have to examine your own behaviour and approach to understand how you've both got to that position. And do something about it.

Sorry quoting myself, but in an attempt to answer helpfully as per your response, adding to my comment......

I haven't told anyone because I don't want them To think ill of her

This is part of your problem - why on earth would you tell anyone anyway? If you have said this on here then I can only imagine it's because you normally would be telling others about your DD. There's no way on earth I would ever share my DDs personal business with anyone else in the first place. Maybe your DD has learnt that you do, hence the lying. And you are clearly judgemental of her - you need to repair this and try to get to a point where she doesn't feel like she has to lie even when her choices might not be entirely sensible.

Bluenotgreen · 05/02/2024 16:53

Authorinwaiting · 05/02/2024 16:30

@MandyMotherOfBrian could you tell me what you do when they tell you you something you feel is not the right thing. I know she would be devastated to find she had been two timed. I don't see how she could do it ? So we argued yes because I've brought them all up to be kind.

How would you handle this situation? What do you say when your girls tell you something you disagree with?

Mine are 23 and 26.

I would say something lighthearted like “You cheating scumbag” so they knew I didn’t approve, but wasn’t taking it on as a serious issue that I should involve myself with. This is how the convo would probably go:

DC: mum, I had a bit of an overlap between Bill and Ben.
Me: Ewww! I hope you were being careful.
DC: of course. I feel a bit bad about it but it’s done now, right.
Me: Discustin. What shall we do for dinner?

We all have our different ways of parenting, and I don’t expect everyone to agree with my ways, but your choice has led to DD not confiding in you. Overall, that’s the bigger risk.

SunflowerSeeds123 · 05/02/2024 16:51

I can see why she's not being honest with her mum.

The money thing, yes discuss it with her. Whom she has relationships with, no, back off.

As long as she's safe and alive, all good.

Toooldforthis36 · 05/02/2024 16:43

lifeispainauchocolat · 05/02/2024 16:40

How would you handle this situation? What do you say when your girls tell you something you disagree with?

You don't need to say anything. She's an adult, not a toddler who needs to be told off or corrected.

This. I have a 21 yr old and a 19yr old. I don’t expect to be privy to every detail of their private life. Adults, even your children, are entitled to make their own choices. I’d argue at this age it’s equally important they make their own mistakes and learn to deal with the consequences of them - pick your battles.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 05/02/2024 16:40

Authorinwaiting · 05/02/2024 16:30

@MandyMotherOfBrian could you tell me what you do when they tell you you something you feel is not the right thing. I know she would be devastated to find she had been two timed. I don't see how she could do it ? So we argued yes because I've brought them all up to be kind.

How would you handle this situation? What do you say when your girls tell you something you disagree with?

We disagree often, about a lot of different things. We talk. I can't answer what I would do exactly in this situation as it hasn't arisen, and I very much doubt it would tbh. But that's not my point. My point is how have you got to the point where your daughter doesn't feel, not only that she can talk to you, but specifically that she has to lie to you. You have to examine your own behaviour and approach to understand how you've both got to that position. And do something about it.

lifeispainauchocolat · 05/02/2024 16:40

How would you handle this situation? What do you say when your girls tell you something you disagree with?

You don't need to say anything. She's an adult, not a toddler who needs to be told off or corrected.

Isitautumnyet23 · 05/02/2024 16:38

At 21 I had a mortgage and was a few years off having kids/marriage. I would text my Mum when free around work (probably a few times a week/phone at the weekend). I would be worried about a 21 year old texting all weekend when she should be busy with friends. I also dont think you need to know any of her plans at all apart from her giving you a rough idea of when she will be back (which day) if she’s living at home and you all have meals together etc. She needs to live her own life.

mayorofcasterbridge · 05/02/2024 16:36

Emptyspiral · 05/02/2024 15:56

The DD's decisions have a financial and now emotional impact on the OP. If she wants to be an adult then act like one. That means mummy isn't paying for your apartment you abandoned because you cheated. An apartment the parents said was not a good idea but still tried to support and are still paying for! it is clear the DD here consistently makes poor decisions and lies and expects OP to clean up her mess. You are not wrong OP. I would have a frank discussion with her that you may not agree with her choices but lying is not tolerated. She could have been hurt and who would have known where she was. It is irresponsible and disgusting behavior for an "adult" No one would allow this behavior from their partner let alone their child.

I agree with this.

Do not be funding her going to and from Manchester, and if she needs money she will have to get another job. I would be angry about that.

You've already been burned with the cost of accommodation for her. As for the two-timing, well it's done, and it doesn't reflect on you. Young people make mistakes, it's one of the ways they learn.

The secrecy part would annoy me but I can see that she felt that you would disapprove, which you would have. The safety aspect would concern me.

If she wants to be treated like an adult, then she has to behave like one.