Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To answer my friend honestly about her partner

364 replies

Whatdoyouthink65 · 05/02/2024 09:11

Context: My best friend from school and I have fairly infrequent contact now, but are both still available when one or other needs something ( like an opinion or a venting row about something). We don’t see each other much for geographical, familial commitment and conflicting work schedules. My friend has one child from a previous relationship which ended with acrimonious divorce and complex nasty custody battle.
When she met that person I did not like him, told her so nicely ( when she asked for my honest opinion- not unsolicited) and it changed our relationship for a long time. When she got divorced she actually confessed that my concerns about him had been entirely valid and she wished she had listened. I never hold this against her because we’ve all been guilty of being ‘rose tinted’ about partners at some point. After the divorce our relationship returned to how its was pre mariage.

She has a new partner of approximately one year. They appear very happy together and have moved in together- she plans to have another child ( his first bio) soon. He has fully accepted her daughter and has stepped into the ‘ dad’ role fully.

We arranged for us to all meet up recently and she wanted my honest opinion about him. I’m really torn about being honest with her again and potentially ruining our relationship or not acting on my gut and telling her a blasé “ yea he’s nice” answer.

I don’t have issues with everyone at all; in fact I can think of very few other people I don’t like. On the surface there is nothing to dislike about him. He’s polite and as above seemingly makes her feel good/ happy. I just didn’t warm to him initially and always trust my gut , but gave him benefit of doubt ( maybes he’s nervous etc).

However, my toddler took herself to the toilet in our house, then shouted for me when she needed her bum wiping ( as is normal for ourhouse) he got up at the same time as me and I assumed he was going to check on his step daughter who was playing alone in our house at that point. He wasn’t; he opened the toilet door and went to wipe my toddlers bum. Thankfully I was only a step behind him, slid myself between him and her and closed the door, saying that I would do it. My toddler looked terrified at someone she just met an hour earlier being in the bathroom with her ( she’s fairly shy and had barely spoken to him).
it made me REALLY uncomfortable, but I tried to think maybe he was just trying to be helpful although it couldn’t shake being uncomfortable.

later the same day me, my partner, my friend and the new boyfriend went for dinner with their 1 child, our toddler and our 8m old. During dinner our toddler asked her dad to pass some crayons, and the boyfriend seemingly misheard and said “ oh you need the toilet , I’ll take you, come on”. Before I even had chance to interject my partner had immediately said no and passed her the crayons she had actually asked for.

the boyfriend also undermined us several times ( for health reasons we don’t allow our toddler commercial desserts because we can’t measure the sugar in them) their daughter was having a dessert and we had said our toddler could have fruit ( she’s normally very happy with this), she had a bit of envy and asked why she couldn’t have chocolate brownies too and I explained it, she accepted it and then immediately after, the boyfriend said “ don’t listen to mummy uncle will buy you a brownie”. Again we stopped this, but there was a few incidents throughout the day of this nature.

I have real concerns as to his safety around small girls although I have nothing more than my opinion/ feelings to present to my friend.

my friend has text asking “ what do you think?”
would it be unreasonable based on the described incident above to answer her honestly saying that I have some concerns or should I give a safe answer of “ yeah he seems nice”.

OP posts:
greenfingers22 · 05/02/2024 17:06

This is spot on the right way to approach the situation, and speaking to her mother about it was a great idea. Well done for doing the right thing OP :)

dearymcdearface · 05/02/2024 17:06

She needs time to process it. It’s a huge accusation. Well done!

Whatdoyouthink65 · 05/02/2024 17:03

Just as an update to everyone. Thank you all for confirming my own thoughts and solidifying them for me.
Unfortunately seeing her in person is not a viable option, and especially without small children around. Even with kids it would likely be months and months before we saw her. So I have video called her.

i started with,
“ I know you’re not going to like what I have to say, but I have always been honest before so I’m going to be honest now.
my feelings about him are irrelevant, but his behaviours towards my DD made us all very uncomfortable. As a grown man, he should know that it’s wholly inappropriate in any circumstance short of me being dead in the living room for him to approach her on the toilet. For him to try again to take her to the toilet whilst both of her parents were there is beyond comprehension of any reasonable person.
His repeated undermining of us as parents and over familiarity with DD was a huge concern for us and I’m very concerned about your relationship with him.

i know you’re clearly very damaged by your dickhead ex husband and perhaps feel like he is helping you heal emotionally but his constant attentiveness to your every whim could be seen as a grooming tactic to get to your DD. I know you have told me he takes her to dance lessons and picks her up from nursery 1 day a week for you. I think you need to seriously and objectively review this because we felt so uncomfortable with his behaviour that we won’t be allowing him near either of our children again. I’m not asking you to chose between us, but in the interest of honesty we won’t be attending any parties etc where he will be present if the children are invited. I understand it will affect our friendship, but I feel morally compelled to be honest for you DD sake.

she took it as expected, defending and explaining everything away.

I told her there is nothing she could say or do that would make me change my mind about our children and that I would absolutely be there for her no matter what she choses ( because at least that way I can monitor from afar).

i have also contacted her mother who is involved in their life on a day to day basis ( whom i am still in Christmas card level contact with) and raised my concerns. She said she couldn’t put her finger on what was amiss but didn’t like him either.

my friend is currently not speaking to me and says I’ve put her in an impossible position but at least I have done all I can for now.

OP posts:
Ohnoooooooo · 05/02/2024 17:02

This is not even borderline - I would sit her down face to face and tell her why you felt I comfortable and let her draw her on conclusions / easier then telling her you don’t like him

WeeOrcadian · 05/02/2024 16:49

Nooooooo

Not even once - twice he tried to be in the loo with your child

Hell would freeze over first

0MammaBear0 · 05/02/2024 16:49

This is concerning... What if he got into a relationship with your friend BECAUSE she has a small daughter? You need to tell her your concerns and advice her to be vigilant with her little girl...

Testina · 05/02/2024 16:37

“However I’m not sure how I could live with myself if in 10 years it turned out he had been inappropriate with her daughter and I’d ignored my concerns to keep the ‘peace’.

I think you need to stop using language like that and use language like “sexually assaulted”.

Your friend does not sound like she is going to keep her daughter safe.

I would tell her outright that you found that behave worrying. I know you’ve said you’ll speak to her - I’m posting because I think it’s worth saying, don’t soften the blow. Use the right language. Or you set her up to deny it. Be upfront - it is not normal or acceptance for a grown man to go into the bathroom after a toddler. And contact the NSPCC for advice.

We have been through this in our family. If you think you’re OTT, starting googling the % of crime types in the UK, and see just how common sexual assault is.

RokaandRoll · 05/02/2024 16:36

And if your friend doesn't take you seriously, I would contact child protection services about this. It really is very alarming.

martinisforeveryone · 05/02/2024 16:36

I think when posters were more forgiving of the brownie comment it was because it was unclear about the sugar and diet at first. I took it as being from a healthy diet point of view rather than because of medical necessity.

Either way it’s not for a stranger to over rule, or anyone really, but this wasn’t a one off naughty treat, as we later learned.

Itslegitimatesalvage · 05/02/2024 16:36

He could just be an idiot who thinks he is being helpful and has zero boundaries, and maybe your friend told him to make an effort with your kid and make a good impression etc. But really… a man just pushing in like that and opening the door to a toddler on the toilet, a toddler he doesn’t know, to wipe her? No. That’s a huge level of naivety which I don’t believe anyone has so he is a creepy weirdo who may have nefarious intent and I’m glad you’re going to tell your friend.

Whenwillitgetwarm · 05/02/2024 16:30

You’ve got to say something. I know PP have said the Brownie thing doesn’t bother them, but I disagree. By undermining you, and playing good cop, points to grooming to me. The next thing will be ‘here, have this brownie, and don’t tell mummy, it will be our little secret’. Scary stuff.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2024 16:27

I have never ever come across a man who would offer to take another person's child to the toilet

Neither have I, at least not in a social setting - not even if asked

And I can totally seee why, when even perfectly innocent things can be misconstrued, so for this guy to actively push to take them seems deeply odd

Rewis · 05/02/2024 16:27

The best case scenario is that he's helpful but doesnt understand boundaries. The worst case scenario is...Well the worst case scenario. Bur are either of these great?

I'd meet your friend and stick to the facts. How he repeatedly crossed boundaries. Don't accused him of anything. Of she defends him. You can say that it might be true but she asked for honest opinion. The "he seemed nice" is meant for guys that are a bit meh hut nothing really wrong with them.

wronginalltherightways · 05/02/2024 16:26

I'm glad you're going to say something.
It's important to go with your instincts, and your DH had the same instinct as you.
It may well destroy the friendship, but that will be on her not you, and hopefully, at least some of your conversation will at least have her looking harder at him.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 05/02/2024 16:22

Tbry24 · 05/02/2024 15:33

I’d tell friend that you don’t know him well enough to have an opinion.

Does he come from a large family? I personally do and wiping kids bums, feeding them, changing them, buying them treats is all complete standard especially if one of the parents has a younger baby as well. I would do that for any child because of my upbringing as all adults or teens look after the wee ones, that’s how I was brought up.

It’s possible he comes from the exact same large family set up which means everything he tried to help with would be normal every day things he does in his family. I’d give him the benefit of the doubt until I at least knew that about him and saw how he was with his step child.

So if one of your friends was dating someone with a young child and it was first time you met them, you’d rush to go and wipe their bum alone in the toilet with them, even though you don’t know them, and the parent was fully there and not busy?! Okayyyyy

Not saying I’d never help a friend’s kid in the loo if the parents were busy but I’d always ask first and I wouldn’t if they were a stranger that I had just met that day!

AxolotlEars · 05/02/2024 16:22

Say something. She asked. You can tell her. It may not result in the course of action you would choose as ideal. She didn't recognise what you saw in her first husband but she has subsequently been able to recognise it. In this situation she may have nagging doubts but being gas-lit by this man. Trust yourself in what you are uncomfortable with

BeReadySoon · 05/02/2024 16:21

OP, perhaps she's asking for your opinion because her gut is telling her something is off but she's too entrenched to be able to identify what is wrong. If she's constantly being undermined then she'll no longer trust her instincts or her opinions. She knows though that you were right before and she trusts you. Please don't let her down. Be gentle, and also specific with examples too. Get her to question the behaviour too. And leave the door open for your friendship. Women who are coercively controlled can take a very long time to get themselves out.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 05/02/2024 16:17

Fucking hell.

Major red flags and massive concern for her daughter :( you have to say something, could you forgive yourself if you didn’t, and something comes out? Then it’s for her to see what to do. At the very least she should be checking he’s not on the sex register etc if he’s around her child.

MrsCarson · 05/02/2024 16:13

I'm glad you are going to say something to her, but I would start by reminding her that last time I gave an honest opinion it didn't go well and affected your relationship and you were right about him. so it's her choice if she wants to know. If she doesn't then tell her that you, the kids and Dh won't be around him any more.

Lovelyjubbbly · 05/02/2024 16:13

Red flags OP

TTCSoManyQuestions88 · 05/02/2024 16:11

Given there is an innocent child involved, I would absolutely have to say it. That kind of behaviour is very strange and she needs to hear it. There is a chance she has doubts already but hearing it from you will validate those doubts. Unfortunately she will likely ignore you and even break off the friendship but you are morally bound to say something. It will play on your mind forever.

Regardless of how tense the conversation goes, at the end make sure to make it clear your are her friend and will be on the other end of the phone when she needs it...be the bigger person, she's clearly very damaged.

NarnianQueen · 05/02/2024 16:08

As pp have said, this might well end your friendship, so I'd go gently if you can and just plant the seeds in her head. Wheen you tell her it made you feel uncomfortable that he a) tried to take your child to the toilet, twice and b) undermined you on the sugar thing, I'd say "I know he's probably in parent mode because he's so used to your dc, but doesn't he realises how dodgy that seems? Dh even made a JOKE about him being a nonce, because you know how those are like, classic signs... I'd hate for him to get a reputation of her doesn't realise HOW WEIRD it is to do those things..."

FofB · 05/02/2024 16:07

Ultimately OP, what you say may make her fall out with you- however, it may also let her see that these kind of behaviours are...weird. As others have said, grooming Mum to get to a child is something that happens.

If you've said something, then she notices it herself (e.g he tries to get child alone at bath/toilet time) it might help her to connect the dots. I am a massive believer in trusting your gut. A difficult situation for you OP, good luck.

NotQuiteNorma · 05/02/2024 16:04

Allofaflutter · 05/02/2024 15:34

The child is probably being abused right now. The friendship is the least of your worries surely?

You know it's posts like this that make me wish forums were not anonymous. People wouldn't be so brave if they had to back up claims like this with some actual evidence.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2024 16:02

My mind is made up. I’m going to have to speak to her and just say that although he clearly makes her very happy - he makes me and my kids and my DH very uncomfortable and that we won’t be spending time with him with our children around in future

Good decision, OP, and when inevitably she asks what he's done you could make it more about the actual incidents than him as a person if that makes sense

Effectively they're the same thing of course, but there's a chance it might help you get get it across without too much of a fall out - unless she's determined to stick by him no matter what, and then you may need to reassess