Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What happens when u don’t have a “village” to raise children

288 replies

WhatsMyUsername89 · 05/02/2024 08:31

I appreciate I’m going to sound like a moany old witch, but I just need an area to vent.

we have DD - 2yo, both sets of grandparents live 8-10 min drive away.

I work 3 days a week, however have compressed 4 days worth of work into these hours. So work 11hr days 8:30-7:30.

the other 2 days in the week I have DD!

Last week DD had Hand Foot & Mouth so I had to take days off work, I agreed this with DH because I earn considerably less the financial hit of me taking time off is less than if he did.

I’ve been booked into having a very painful wisdom tooth removed today (last minute appointment) but I have to work. I had so much time off last week I feel cheeky saying I need MORE time off for this.
But I can’t change it to the days I don’t work???? Because I can’t take my 2 year old.

we have no help from family at all, despite both sets of grandparents (neither work) always saying “we will help out always” but funnily when we ask they always have a reason why they can’t.

DH works long hours & is the main earner, we have found with the way things are going in terms of cost of living we can’t afford him taking time off.

so I just feel so stuck, I hear of friends saying “oh my mum/dad/sibling had my child so I can get nails done” and I feel so envious, I can’t even get any support for getting to a doctors/dentist appointment. (I’m very happy for my friends that they are surrounded by helpful - but I feel jealous)

How on earth do you get anything done when you have NO help.

also even if I had this bloody tooth out I’m going to be in pain for days while looking after a toddler and trying to work.

i feel so fed up, but also feel like such a little cow moaning about something that is SUCH a blessing. I’m blessed to have a job, have a beautiful Daughter, a loving husband & access to healthcare.

About I’m frustrated :(

OP posts:
BaffledOnceAgain · 05/02/2024 10:01

I hear you. Occasionally, my DM would agree to help, but then, for example, I got ready to go to the breast clinic and she rang to let me know that she'd decided to go out with a friend for lunch instead so I strapped both DS, under 3, into the double buggy, packed some snacks and took them with me. Everyone in the waiting room thought it was hilarious when ds1 asked loudly, "So is your poorly boob okay now, Mummy?" while I wanted the ground to swallow me up! When my DH sadly died, DM arrived in the early days to find me in tears at the door. She said, "Oh dear! I'll come back another time." All I needed was a hug and 10 minutes of not being in sole charge of a 5 and 3 year old. I have since moved away, made my own village and find I'm less annoyed with her for not helping now that she actually isn't close enough to do so.

WhatsMyUsername89 · 05/02/2024 10:01

Love51 · 05/02/2024 09:46

Which children have you been a village for OP?
Loads of parents say they want a village for their children but never contributed anything to others. Not all, but plenty.

i think this situation I am in motivates me to help others. We are around many people who do have their own village, so don’t really need us.

However have family members who live 2hrs away who we have had their children for so they can have a night off.

we also dog sit for many friends, however appreciate they may not want to reciprocate by looking after a toddler!!! - but wouldn’t want anyone to feel stuck.

OP posts:
Wasbedeudetetdas · 05/02/2024 10:00

ZekeZeke · 05/02/2024 09:57

Do your parents/PIL have smart phones?
I'm a bit devious but I would set up a group and call it grandparents emergency group.

When you have an emergency, message the group with the information. And see if this changes anything? Do it as a once off.
If neither respond then distance yourself.

Also bear in mind not before long they will be the ones needing help. You will have a list of your requests for help yo look back on before making your decision to help.

So manipulate them then?
There were interesting replies on a post the other day when it seemed like older parents were contacting their adult child with false emergencies.

cardibach · 05/02/2024 09:58

safetyfreak · 05/02/2024 08:45

Sounds very similar to me.

Funny enough, both set of grandparents had help from their parents when they had young children but are not willing, to return the favour to their own grandkids.

A selfish generation.

The whole generation? Really?
And yet stats show grandparents do lots of care...

chatenoire · 05/02/2024 09:58

You kind of get on with life? One grandmother lives 8+ hrs away and the other one lives across an ocean. No other relatives around..

ZekeZeke · 05/02/2024 09:57

Do your parents/PIL have smart phones?
I'm a bit devious but I would set up a group and call it grandparents emergency group.

When you have an emergency, message the group with the information. And see if this changes anything? Do it as a once off.
If neither respond then distance yourself.

Also bear in mind not before long they will be the ones needing help. You will have a list of your requests for help yo look back on before making your decision to help.

WhatsMyUsername89 · 05/02/2024 09:55

TheYearOfSmallThings · 05/02/2024 09:07

I don’t think anyone SHOULD help me, me having a child is entirely my responsibility.

Your husband. Your child's father. That is the person who should be taking a share of responsibility here. That is the problem here.

I wholeheartedly disagree with this. My child’s father is absolutely NOT the issue.

He works very hard, long hours. He works a trade so can’t work from home. He will always offer to not work when DD is unwell and off from nursery, but financially it does not make sense.

Since having our child, our mortgage has more or less doubled, all other bills increased, add on nursery fees and to add I’ve dropped hours.

our income has decreased but our outgoings have sky rocketed.

My husband’s responsibility is to provide financial support so we can keep our home, eat & put our child in clothes.

He could take annual leave; which he does, however he as a human being needs to be able to take annual leave for his own mental health and having a break as well as supporting me.

OP posts:
Sususudio · 05/02/2024 09:53

I second babysitting networks. I had one with other immigrants whose families were thousands of miles away.

My own mum had no help with her DC because she was one of 8 and her mum was too busy!

Butterdishy · 05/02/2024 09:51

Love51 · 05/02/2024 09:46

Which children have you been a village for OP?
Loads of parents say they want a village for their children but never contributed anything to others. Not all, but plenty.

This. It has to be reciprocal. I've made a concerted effort this year as my own kids have got older to actively offer help/babysitting/pick ups and it's paid off. Of course some people will take the piss, but most repay the favour.

MargaretThursday · 05/02/2024 09:50

My parents are over 200 miles away and my IL about half that. They couldn't baby sit unless they happened to be staying.

What I did miss was the easy "oh I'm going to be running late, can you grab the children, please" which people with local grandparents had. And I'm sure my dm if she'd lived 10 minutes away would have more than happily picked them up for tea one day a week.

But what you do is you network. You baby sit, they return the favour. I had a number of parents for whom we all could say to each other"I've got an appointment, can you take dc for an hour or so". The main thing was that we had an agreement that we said no, if we didn't want to. We always said that the answer "no," needed no explanation, and it could be simply that we didn't want to that day. And I never was stuck. But you have to put in at the beginning to get things going, because people don't want to find that you always take, never give. And there were times where one person did a lot of taking, but it was never resented, because we knew that was their current situation, and they would give when they could.

To me that's far more what "takes a village" is about that grandparents doing it. If it was grandparents, then the expression would be "takes a family, surely?"

Thereisnoname · 05/02/2024 09:47

Don't compare to other people who get help just work around it.
Grandparent lives around the corner and rarely offers help.
It is frustrating but I've learnt to get on without it plus its their loss that Grandchildren are not particularly close to them due to it.

Love51 · 05/02/2024 09:46

Which children have you been a village for OP?
Loads of parents say they want a village for their children but never contributed anything to others. Not all, but plenty.

A1ia · 05/02/2024 09:45

I can absolutely empathise. We are in a similar situation.

Locally, we have one set of grandparents - approx 15 minute drive from us. One works full time, the other is retired.
Prior to retirement, the fact they worked full time was always the reason they couldn't really help. At best, they might babysit for one evening every 6 weeks or so (only once our child hit age 2/3 - prior to that I recall only 2 evenings they watched him).
Since one of them retired, I thought there would be more involvement. For a very brief period there was and I was very grateful - my son had to be off school for a full week and the retired grandparent thankfully had him. We gave them a box of chocolates, a bottle of wine and flowers in thanks. However, with the exception of that one incident, they have offered help even less than before. They've babysat our child only once in the last two months. I've been ill myself, as has my husband, and we thought an offer might come to let us both rest to recover but it didn't. I even asked if they could have him one night; I was told they'd think about it and then nothing was ever said again lol.

I suspect some people are just like that.
I try hard not to compare to my colleagues who have grandparents who watch the children regularly during the week when they work or overnight once a week etc. I realise we will never be in that position ourselves.

Could you try to organise the dental appointment for the a Friday (assuming your partner has weekends off)? If your partner could take the day off, you would also have them around for the days following it to help with the child/ren.

I have ended up using childcare when not at work in the past - either nursery/preschool when my son was little (costing upwards of £50 for the day) so that I could attend medical appointments etc without him. Now, I try to do the same but with kids club things - thankfully a more reasonable £15-20 a day, as he is 5.

Emmacb82 · 05/02/2024 09:44

I think probably the most frustrating thing for you is that you have potential help only a few minutes away but that help is not forthcoming.
We have 2 children and one on the way. Husbands parents are both deceased and mine are 3 hours drive away. So we have to do everything between us. He works mon-fri and I work nights and weekends. Often I stay awake after nights to look after my youngest and will be doing the same after Mat leave with the baby. It’s a hard slog, we never get a break or to do anything together without children being involved. But on the other hand I’m glad I don’t have to rely on anyone else and I’m there for the children 100%. Makes us proud that we do it all on our own.

erikbloodaxe · 05/02/2024 09:43

A village as in 'It takes a village' isn't about family helping out it's all the people who have positive interactions on a regular basis with your child.

BingoMarieHeeler · 05/02/2024 09:42

You just get on with it (as you are finding), and the key is to not focus on your lack of village - that way bitterness lies!

MollyRover · 05/02/2024 09:42

Paid childcare is our only village. We had some help from MIL with DC1 but she's had some health issues so we feel uncomfortable with childcare now, which she is very angry about so she has pretty much abandoned DC1 completely. Very sad for their relationship but the reaction has confirmed our worries really, obviously would be nice if she would visit but she's decided that she doesn't want to be a GM anymore if she can't do whatever she wants, even if it puts DC1 at risk. No help or relationship at all with DC2 who she's only even met a handful of times in the last 2 years despite being 15 minutes away but we're used to it now. My family are overseas so they only have a FaceTime relationship. They've never helped or offered to help even when visiting.

This mum help stuff wouldn't work because everyone we know works too. I have helped out a few times with others DC but it's more play dates etc at this stage, not realistic or reliable as a regular solution. We're lucky to both have flexibility and support at work so that makes a big difference, medical appointments or ad hoc illnesses aren't a problem so we can tag team and make up hours. It is very lonely though, we had a pretty traumatic experience last year which made it more apparent how isolated we are. I know it will improve when DC2 starts school and at least the parenting is equally shared with DH.

Whatafustercluck · 05/02/2024 09:40

You make life changes that better support family life. Your dd should be entitled to free hours at nursery? Alternatively, you could source a childminder which will be cheaper.

Depending on what you do for work, you could look at changing jobs, even if it means retraining. It sounds like you and your husband spend a huge amount of time working to sustain your lifestyle so perhaps make some changes to provide a better balance?

I am fortunate. My family live close by so for emergencies they're really great. But we don't routinely rely on them. Our working patterns (both of us) have changed over the years to better accommodate family life. I've been the main earner since having children, but we've both worked flexibily. I never put my career on hold, but as I work in the public sector, it's much more family friendly. My choices have always been based on the balance between finance and time with the kids.

The single biggest thing that makes the biggest difference is both parents pitching in as required, whatever their respective earnings. There have been times when the kids have been ill when I've looked after them, and times when it made more sense for dh to do it.

FriendlyNeighbourhoodAccountant · 05/02/2024 09:37

ColleenDonaghy · 05/02/2024 09:27

We have no family nearby, it's fine. Your DH needs to pull his weight. If he's employed then he takes annual leave to cover your dental appointment and half the sick days that fall on your working days. If he's self employed then he organises his diary around your dental appointment that day.

How many women do you know whose jobs are far too important for them to care for their sick child? It's always men who couldn't possibly take the time but actually I bet 99% of them could make it work if they tried, they just can't be arsed.

We have two small DC, no nearby family and two FT (albeit flexible) jobs. It's fine because we're both in it together.

I agree with this.
Often people say it's not worth their husband taking the time off because he's the higher earner. How many women would have earnings just as high if they weren't sacrificing time early in their career in the same way as some men do.

Not everyone has a village, it's unfortunate your parents/in laws aren't more helpful but you've taken this all on as your responsibility and it isn't. Your daughter has two parents. He needs to have stepped up at some point and taken some time off.

AlltheFs · 05/02/2024 09:36

We use annual leave, what’s wrong with that?!

I get paid time off for medical appointments but for everything else we book holiday. DH and I equally take leave.

We have absolutely zero help and haven’t had a night out since she was born (she’s 4). That doesn’t bother us. We sometimes take an afternoon off together for a lunch date while she is at nursery.

DH’s dad is dead, his mother lives abroad and my parents are elderly and not local. We don’t have anyone to ask, but we knew that when we had DD.

PinkPink1 · 05/02/2024 09:35

When I return from mat leave I'll be working 5 days a week. All the grandparents are young and work. I feel guilty knowing my DD will be at nursery :( why can't your DH take some leave to look after his dd whilst you have your wisdom tooth out?

Mylovelygreendress · 05/02/2024 09:35

I have DGC and I will give you my perspective. Neither my parents nor in-laws helped us with childcare so I was determined to help my DC when the time came .
I help my DDs a lot and I am sure they appreciate it and I only very occasionally feel put upon . I have friends however who are willing to help but feel that the requests/ demands are endless . It starts off with occasional then becomes every weekend / school holiday . Saying no causes arguments and huffs.
An example is one friend whose DIL sends her a list of dates every month that she is needed ! If she says no for whatever reason there is a row.
Could you make it clear that requests will only be last resort and very occasional ?
It’s sad that grandparents don’t want involved ( and every grandparent I know does some childcare) but also remember we do have our own lives !

Wasbedeudetetdas · 05/02/2024 09:35

safetyfreak · 05/02/2024 08:45

Sounds very similar to me.

Funny enough, both set of grandparents had help from their parents when they had young children but are not willing, to return the favour to their own grandkids.

A selfish generation.

I think you are generalising here.
My mum (and lots of her friends) had very little help from family when we were growing up - partly because they didn't live nearby and partly for other reasons I I won't go into. They all had to 'muddle through' too.
Also quite a few of the parents of working age people may also still be working, and therefore have less time to spare to look after grandchildren.
I had very little help when DC was little, though I had a really good friend who was a childminder and helped us out sometimes, for example when I ended up with Hand Food and Mouth followed by a three week sick bug, which landed me in hospital! I helped her in other ways though, it wasn't just all one way, and wouldn't ever have asked her to mind DC for me to get nails done or anything like that!
As others have said OP, it is hard at that age, but you really do have to attempt to make your own village - offering to give and receive help.
I hope the dental stuff goes ok, been there, done that, and it does make you feel quite emotional (well it did for me).

cheapskatemum · 05/02/2024 09:34

Needmorelego · 05/02/2024 08:38

You hire a babysitter.
You make friends with other parents and help each other out.
You make friends with your neighbours and help each other out.
That's "a village".

I was in your situation when DCs were small, OP and did as @Needmorelego has suggested. Particularly making friends with other parents (I attended all the "mother & baby/toddler groups" I could with DCs on my days off. Many parents were in the same position and we'd swap favours regularly.

Futb0l · 05/02/2024 09:33

We just have to pay people. It is what is. We don't have gp close by and my siblings are juggling their own kids and jobs.

We chose a childminder over nurseries/ the asc because her set up was much more flexible - she's rarely at capacity and doesnt mind us swapping or adding days.

You also really have to get past what your husband earns etc & share the burden. It really isn't fair to you or your employer if you aren't.