Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What happens when u don’t have a “village” to raise children

288 replies

WhatsMyUsername89 · 05/02/2024 08:31

I appreciate I’m going to sound like a moany old witch, but I just need an area to vent.

we have DD - 2yo, both sets of grandparents live 8-10 min drive away.

I work 3 days a week, however have compressed 4 days worth of work into these hours. So work 11hr days 8:30-7:30.

the other 2 days in the week I have DD!

Last week DD had Hand Foot & Mouth so I had to take days off work, I agreed this with DH because I earn considerably less the financial hit of me taking time off is less than if he did.

I’ve been booked into having a very painful wisdom tooth removed today (last minute appointment) but I have to work. I had so much time off last week I feel cheeky saying I need MORE time off for this.
But I can’t change it to the days I don’t work???? Because I can’t take my 2 year old.

we have no help from family at all, despite both sets of grandparents (neither work) always saying “we will help out always” but funnily when we ask they always have a reason why they can’t.

DH works long hours & is the main earner, we have found with the way things are going in terms of cost of living we can’t afford him taking time off.

so I just feel so stuck, I hear of friends saying “oh my mum/dad/sibling had my child so I can get nails done” and I feel so envious, I can’t even get any support for getting to a doctors/dentist appointment. (I’m very happy for my friends that they are surrounded by helpful - but I feel jealous)

How on earth do you get anything done when you have NO help.

also even if I had this bloody tooth out I’m going to be in pain for days while looking after a toddler and trying to work.

i feel so fed up, but also feel like such a little cow moaning about something that is SUCH a blessing. I’m blessed to have a job, have a beautiful Daughter, a loving husband & access to healthcare.

About I’m frustrated :(

OP posts:
Mylovelygreendress · 05/02/2024 11:58

@Overthebow i was responding to the poster who claimed we are a “ selfish generation”

Hobbitfeet32 · 05/02/2024 11:54

I would ask the grandparents in this situation.
Other options are pay for extra nursery session or a babysitter, husband takes time off, ask a friend. If you don’t have any friends that can help then now is the time to start building that village so you can ask favours and reciprocate. It doesn’t happen overnight and takes work but is definitely worth it in the long run.

anotherside · 05/02/2024 11:54

The fertility rate across the EU has dropped from 2.37 in 1970 to just 1.6 today.

In the UK it’s 1.56 - among native born UK women it’s about 1.49 compared to 2.0 for foreign born women in the UK. Basically the population of Europe is going to shrink massively without continued high net immigration in the coming decades. Shrinking economy or huge net migration is the choice facing politicians, so the vast majority will choose the latter.

Mariposistaaa · 05/02/2024 11:39

'Village' does not have to mean family.
Do you not have friends who would help out occasionally in an emergency - at least minding your child while you go to the dentist?
Pay a teenager to act as a babysitter - we do this with our neighbour's daughter and she is a lovely girl who we have got to know really well.

My mum and I found that when we were nursing my gran in the last stages of life, we had to build our own village as family weren't interested. But we had one. It was just not people who shared our DNA.

Bubblybits · 05/02/2024 11:33

We live in a different country to both sets of grandparents and all other family. We made a good group of friends, offer favours and ask for them when we need them. We went round and met our new neighbours - two of which are unsuitable to ask for help with the kids but one was happy to take a spare key for us and be put on the list to collect the kids from nursery in an emergency. We offered the same to her too. We take equal time out of work if we can’t ask friends, and very occasionally pay for a sitter (though they are so expensive that we probably only do this 1-2 times a year). The village doesn’t just “appear”, you’ve got to work for it and give as well as receive.

Overthebow · 05/02/2024 11:31

Mylovelygreendress · 05/02/2024 11:01

Selfish generation ? Bit of a sweeping statement! I am in my 60s , worked for nearly 40 years and help to look after my DGC but is it selfish to say - actually no , I want to go out with friends, go to the gym or simply sit on my backside and read a book ?

But you do help with your grandchildren? What lots of us who don’t have grandparents who want to help is that we’d love some back up for health appointments, maybe to babysit occasionally and to have a good relationship and take grandchildren out sometimes. We don’t mean regular childcare in the week, I’d be grateful for one day or evening a month. My parents and inlaws are mid 60s and don’t work. Like many of their generation they retired in their 50s with decent pensions. If they had wanted to stay close to us and help occasionally they could have done. We’re now putting a lot into our pensions and savings in the hope that we can retire early enough to help our DC, it won’t be as young as they did as pensions nowadays are a lot worse than they had, but we’re doing our best.

EllieQ · 05/02/2024 11:28

WhatsMyUsername89 · 05/02/2024 09:55

I wholeheartedly disagree with this. My child’s father is absolutely NOT the issue.

He works very hard, long hours. He works a trade so can’t work from home. He will always offer to not work when DD is unwell and off from nursery, but financially it does not make sense.

Since having our child, our mortgage has more or less doubled, all other bills increased, add on nursery fees and to add I’ve dropped hours.

our income has decreased but our outgoings have sky rocketed.

My husband’s responsibility is to provide financial support so we can keep our home, eat & put our child in clothes.

He could take annual leave; which he does, however he as a human being needs to be able to take annual leave for his own mental health and having a break as well as supporting me.

Are you saying that he’ll take annual leave to have a ‘mental health day’ but wouldn’t use his annual leave to look after an ill child? Plus he can’t take unpaid leave to look after an ill child as he’s the higher earner, meaning you have to take the time off instead? It’s a bit confusing from your posts.

I also wonder if you are able to take a days leave for a ‘mental health day’ where you can relax and have zero responsibility for childcare (cynically, I suspect not).

We have no family nearby so I do have sympathy with you. We managed it by accepting that we’d have to use annual leave / flexitime for doctor or dentist appointments while DD was in childcare or at school. We also both chose to work in flexible jobs to make things easier, though this has meant lower income (public sector jobs).

We rarely go out as we can’t get a babysitter. Other parents we know have family support so don’t need reciprocal babysitting - I don’t like to ask if we can’t repay them in some way. DD’s best friends mum had helped out a couple of times (taking DD to school when we had to leave early to attend a funeral), but again I felt awkward to ask.

Jewnicorn · 05/02/2024 11:25

I hear you, it’s rough! Both mine and husband’s parents live in our home country and we don’t get to see them nearly enough so, while they’d happily watch our kids for us to go out, when we see them I want to spend time with them! I can’t really leave with friends as one of mine has complex health issues and it gets really frustrating at times feeling like the pressure is all on me (I’m self employed and juggle the baby whole WFH as DH needs to work long hours). Of course in an emergency we’d work something out but time off parenting for frivolous (or even non Frivolous things) just isn’t going to happen.
it will get easier though, I promise. My youngest is just a toddler but my older kids are all at school full time so I’m gradually feeling the strain ease somewhat. Once littlest goes to pre school I may even manage a couple of hours a week!

MollyRover · 05/02/2024 11:22

LaMarschallin · 05/02/2024 11:01

What's going to happen when your DC has their own children? You and your DH will probably still be working - presumably you'll drop everything then to babysit for them?
Grandparents generally aren't retired and itching to leap up and rush to look after their grandchildren (much as they'd like to). People between 40 and 60 - the demographic of most grandparents of young children are still working.
Will you be ready whenever DD has a child to stop your job and be ready to babysit for her children? And expect her to do the same for her grandchildren?
I wouldn't want my DDs to spend a large part of their lives waiting to babysit.

It's something I've thought a lot about. I'd love to be able to help my children. I'd hate for them to be in the situation that we're in. My parents and MIL were in receipt of pensions long before my children were born, we certainly won't be in that situation before we're 70 if we carry on as we are. I'm maxing out mortgage and pension payments so that I'll be in the most flexible position possible as regards finances, hopefully being able to work less hours so can be available to help early as much as I can. Downsizing to help with house deposits and staying close by is something I also consider. Long maternity leaves and SAHParenting are not a reality in my world so being able to provide support that I didn't have would be a privilege.

@cardibach I do think that generations have a shared experience so in many cases are shaped similarly by the world they live in at the time. There is a reason we talk about generational demographics, it's not for nothing. Of course I see many GPs at the school gates but they tend to be younger than my parents generation.

thesugarbumfairy · 05/02/2024 11:18

You manage OP, and honestly it gets easier the older they get (I mean I say that but I'm still running around after teenagers!)
We have never lived near family, so have always had to manage.
I have a network of friends that will help in an emergency. Years ago when they were in nursery - one of the nursery workers was so lovely she agreed to have my eldest if I went into labour with my youngest (which she did). When my dad was dying 5 months later, the nursery fit my eldest in every day (I think he was 3 days a week then) so I could travel with DC2 and stay with my dad until the end. I did childcare swaps with another friend when DC1 started school, so neither of us had to pay for wraparound every day.
It has meant that H and I never got away together. In fact the first and only time we ever went for an overnighter was when DC1 was 10 - he was on a school trip, and DC2 was on a sleepover.
There is no point though in being envious of what other people can do. It is what it is.

LaMarschallin · 05/02/2024 11:18

Mylovelygreendress · 05/02/2024 11:01

Selfish generation ? Bit of a sweeping statement! I am in my 60s , worked for nearly 40 years and help to look after my DGC but is it selfish to say - actually no , I want to go out with friends, go to the gym or simply sit on my backside and read a book ?

Hopefully the next generation will be lovely and unselfish and give up working and having their own plans so they can be available to provide child care (even after they too have done all the terribly hard work of bringing up their own children - I mean: the other 2 days in the week I have DD! Yikes! Cruel and unusual punishment indeed, looking after your child, it seems.)
So I hope your pension plans are good, Op, so you can give up work when your DD gets pregnant.

LaMarschallin · 05/02/2024 11:01

What's going to happen when your DC has their own children? You and your DH will probably still be working - presumably you'll drop everything then to babysit for them?
Grandparents generally aren't retired and itching to leap up and rush to look after their grandchildren (much as they'd like to). People between 40 and 60 - the demographic of most grandparents of young children are still working.
Will you be ready whenever DD has a child to stop your job and be ready to babysit for her children? And expect her to do the same for her grandchildren?
I wouldn't want my DDs to spend a large part of their lives waiting to babysit.

Mylovelygreendress · 05/02/2024 11:01

safetyfreak · 05/02/2024 08:45

Sounds very similar to me.

Funny enough, both set of grandparents had help from their parents when they had young children but are not willing, to return the favour to their own grandkids.

A selfish generation.

Selfish generation ? Bit of a sweeping statement! I am in my 60s , worked for nearly 40 years and help to look after my DGC but is it selfish to say - actually no , I want to go out with friends, go to the gym or simply sit on my backside and read a book ?

RosePetals86 · 05/02/2024 11:00

I sympathise OP. It’s hard work but you’ll get people telling you you’re entitled for wanting GPs to help out and show some interest “they’ve done their time”. I guess you either take more time off or your partner does or you ask them for help and hope this time they can?

Overthebow · 05/02/2024 10:56

We’re in the same position, although all our daily are hours away so would never be able to help out. It’s hard, I’m sad about it and have ranted about it a lot (my parents and inlaws moved away so wasn’t our choice to live far away), but we’ve built our lives around this.

You need to share taking days off for DC illness and other things with your DH. I know you say it’s more expensive, but it’s not fair on your work and they may end up giving you less flexibility because of it. We equally share the time off, whoever has the quietest day at work takes the time off and we switch the next day. We pay for extra nursery days if needed, pay for extra annual leave and pay for baby sitters and also share babysitting with some friends who have no nearby family either, and have friends who will take our DC in an emergency. It’s all more expensive but we knew we didn’t have family to help so made sure we could afford it all before having Dc as we knew it would be miserable with no help at all. It does suck though seeing friends get tonnes of help.

LameBorzoi · 05/02/2024 10:52

No answers, but I hear you. It's not just about this one dental appointment. I think as a society we've kind of reached a sorry state of affairs where kids are seen as such a burden by grandparents.

cardibach · 05/02/2024 10:51

@MollyRover that sounds hideous, and it’s no wonder you are upset about it.
It’s not the generation, though. It’s those individuals. I hate generational generalisations of any sort (and of any generation), they are nonsense and deeply unfair.

user1471554720 · 05/02/2024 10:50

We were the same gp living local but there was such a big deal about helping and talking incessantly about arrangements timings, that it was easier not to ask. You wouldn't ask them to kerp dcs for a hour unless it was booked miles in advance and you had a good reason.We have 2 dcs, 2 years apart and work fulltime.

I had a fulltime childminder, who minded lots of kids in her house. She was open 8am to 6pm, would take them if they had a cold (pre covid days).

I worked up a day a month (civil service) and used this for any appointments. I kept dcs in the minder for 5 days a week even if I was off work and needed e.g haircuts etc. If people could afford it, I would rrcommend working 4 days and putting them in childcare for 5, when yoi have no help completely.

I took 2 weeks unpaid leave when the minder closed up in the summer. I still had my annual leave to use for emergencies. Dh and I would go out separately every few months. We always had dcs in eves so no date nights.

Paying for every bit of childcare, eg. Dentist, hair, chin waxing etc, was galling, especially as others got go help so they could go to pop concerts and unnecessary things.

We are closer for it even though it was exhausting. They are teens now so still a lot of input. I work a hybrid office role so I can fit in collections easier.

My mother was 60 when I had dcs. She is 70 now and helps my sibling in their business one day a week. I think that they just don't like dealing with small dcs.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 05/02/2024 10:47

Octavia64 · 05/02/2024 08:36

I didn't have a village because my dad had cancer on and off for most of my kids early years and my mum was his carer.

The in laws didn't do much.

You need to build your own village. Find some mums near you - through NCT groups or toddler groups. Helps to have someone you can share the experience with. We also joined a babysitting circle so we got the odd night out and someone to cover emergencies.

This
sorry Op, it won’t change how youfeel that you’re being”let down “ by parents, but in reality so many mums (and dads) are in this situation.

both sets of parents lived hundreds of miles for us, as did siblings. It results in as,e thing, though admittedly it is then easier to “understand”. I made mistake once of asking my parents to take kids for a week whilst I attend3d a course overseas and my husband was also travelling with work. Course was paid for, travel booked based on them saying yes. With week to go they pulled out. I was furious as it cost my company £1000s . Didn’t make me look good. Never agian asked them to do support me with childcare.

instead I involved myself with mums and toddlers, pta or any other organisation that I could get to know local mums and make friendships . In rare emergencies i then had the “village” network to fall back on.

im retired now, and on my own. I do same thing now, join lots of things, cultivate friendships, put myself out to help others, so, that if the needs arise, I can call in favours to help me. That’s how the village thing works. Youhave to make the effort first.

MollyRover · 05/02/2024 10:46

@cardibach maybe there is but I know one of my grandparents in particular helped my parents enormously. I honestly thought of them as more of a parent to me. My own parents help one of my siblings out regularly but would rather play at being a grandparent with mine and other siblings children. They've both been retired for 15 years or more, since their mid 50s and are very fit and healthy.

My MIL has never worked and sees my eldest DC as their own personal toy to show off to their friends and was neglecting basic needs while completely ignoring youngest DCs existence. Making plans and arrangements behind our backs and undermining us deliberately. All contact was withdrawn when we wanted to make changes due to their ongoing health issues, there was a "last straw" situation. I suspect a touch of (low level) dementia (hoarding, poor judgment) but it could just be stubbornness. We're worried about them but at the same time just don't have the bandwidth to deal with their anger and coldness, not when it's being taken out on our child. It's awful because when DC1 was just born I remember thinking how lovely it was that someone else loved them just as much and in the same way as we did. That's really what the "village" means to me. Now it just seems so transactional because DC1 was completely dropped and DC2 is of no consequence at all because of just being too much for MIL- not because we want her to look after them, but just because she couldn't iykwim.

Totally hijacking the thread, sorry OP. Bit tired and emotional today.

kittensinthekitchen · 05/02/2024 10:44

WhatsMyUsername89 · 05/02/2024 10:03

When did I say annual leave was just for fun?
I didn’t. I said my husband takes annual leave to support me and DD. However he also needs time to rest, otherwise he’ll be run down and eventually reach a burnout.

Oh come on, he's not gonna 'burnout' because he takes a couple of hours off for you to go to the dentist.

What do you do about routine appointments/checkups?

Candleabra · 05/02/2024 10:41

I agreed this with DH because I earn considerably less the financial hit of me taking time off is less than if he did

Re: time off with kids - you need to be equal partners on this. He needs to do his share regardless of the finances now. If you always have to take time off then his career will continue as normal and yours will be fucked after a few years. Then the gap will widen further. Agree with all the comments about reciprocal favours re: babysitting etc - but the child’s father must do an equal share too.

quisensoucie · 05/02/2024 10:38

A 'village' is far more than just the grandparents
Just shows what a daft phrase that is

Caspianberg · 05/02/2024 10:35

We have no help. Ds has to just come with us a lot.

I took him to last dental appointment, dentist was fine and said it’s normal and many babies or small children attend. Just took iPad with me, and hygienist said they could split appointment over 2 mornings if needed, but in the end Ds sat ok for 30 ish minutes.

we have kindergarten now but it’s only mornings and term time only.

No family. We have a few neighbours or friends I could leave in emergency, but I couldn’t leave him with them when he’s ill for example or longer than 2hrs.

Princessfluffy · 05/02/2024 10:34

Also regardless of being the higher earner DH needs to cover half of the days taken when your dd is sick.