Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What happens when u don’t have a “village” to raise children

288 replies

WhatsMyUsername89 · 05/02/2024 08:31

I appreciate I’m going to sound like a moany old witch, but I just need an area to vent.

we have DD - 2yo, both sets of grandparents live 8-10 min drive away.

I work 3 days a week, however have compressed 4 days worth of work into these hours. So work 11hr days 8:30-7:30.

the other 2 days in the week I have DD!

Last week DD had Hand Foot & Mouth so I had to take days off work, I agreed this with DH because I earn considerably less the financial hit of me taking time off is less than if he did.

I’ve been booked into having a very painful wisdom tooth removed today (last minute appointment) but I have to work. I had so much time off last week I feel cheeky saying I need MORE time off for this.
But I can’t change it to the days I don’t work???? Because I can’t take my 2 year old.

we have no help from family at all, despite both sets of grandparents (neither work) always saying “we will help out always” but funnily when we ask they always have a reason why they can’t.

DH works long hours & is the main earner, we have found with the way things are going in terms of cost of living we can’t afford him taking time off.

so I just feel so stuck, I hear of friends saying “oh my mum/dad/sibling had my child so I can get nails done” and I feel so envious, I can’t even get any support for getting to a doctors/dentist appointment. (I’m very happy for my friends that they are surrounded by helpful - but I feel jealous)

How on earth do you get anything done when you have NO help.

also even if I had this bloody tooth out I’m going to be in pain for days while looking after a toddler and trying to work.

i feel so fed up, but also feel like such a little cow moaning about something that is SUCH a blessing. I’m blessed to have a job, have a beautiful Daughter, a loving husband & access to healthcare.

About I’m frustrated :(

OP posts:
Overthebow · 05/02/2024 16:57

Fupoffyagrasshole · 05/02/2024 12:49

my mum would fly over from a different Country to help me any time i need it!! I couldn't cope without her sometimes!!

when my daughter fractured her foot when she was 2 my mum got on a flight and was with me a few days later and stayed with her while we went back to work!

She will be here in advance of my elective c section for my second child and looking after us for a month!

My MIL on the other hand can't even remember my daughters name and couldn't give a shit about spending time with her / helping out! thats fine too her choice

But we spend very little time with her and none of her kids are going to look after her when she's older as they've all distanced themselves from her!

MY parents on the other hand - i will do everything to help them / look after them when older as we are all super close!

I don't know how people cope in emergencies without help tbh!!

nursery is only 8 -6

That’s amazing of your mum, mine wouldn’t even come to ours when my DC was born when my DH had gone back to work as she conveniently booked a holiday for that time, and not one that was booked in advance of my being pregnant.

VelvetShrimp · 05/02/2024 16:52

In my case there are no family to watch the kids. Not ever. They are too far away, and most of them wouldn't be interested anyway. It means that I have to do every single thing (I do have a few local friends who would help in a dire emergency but I'm saving that for if and when something unavoidable happens!).

It is utterly, utterly hard and exhausting. The reward is the children, of course, their personalities and their love. It is so hard though.

I look at friends with grandparents on tap and I have felt bitterly aggrieved that my life is a stream of survival and difficulty in comparison. But life isn't fair. We don't get to be treated equally. We have to keep going.

cadburyegg · 05/02/2024 16:39

I'm afraid I agree that your dh needs to take annual leave to look after dd if you cannot. The village needs to start at home. If your husband can't or is unwilling to look after your dd for a couple of days then you can hardly expect anyone else to.

I don't have a partner, but I do have a village. I have my mum, mum friends, and paid childcare. it's taken me years to form a support network, and I had less of one when my dc1 was a toddler. They are 8 & 5 now.

My "village" and I do very occasional childcare swaps and school runs for each other as one offs. I wouldn't look after a friend's toddler whilst they went in for an operation unless there wasn't a partner around. That's what the partner needs to be doing.

RosieAway · 05/02/2024 16:31

Not to “compete” but I literally have no one. Mum died years ago, my family is in another country. The ex is abusive so less than helpful. I was sick recently while looking after my sick little one / like really sick, we both were in A&E. I do have friends but it’s not really the sort of stuff you can ask for help with. And I have in the past, and it hasn’t been forthcoming for various reasons but mostly due to them being busy too.
So I don’t know! My teeth are literally falling out of my head because I just cannot get to the dentist, and other issues around health and just life planning don’t get a look in at all. Let me know if you find the answer

spriots · 05/02/2024 16:31

CharlotteBog · 05/02/2024 16:27

Child falls off their bike outside your house, a passing driver stops to help and knocks on your door to ask for help.
The 'village' concept works if that person answers the door.
It's not just the people you know, it's the whole community considering the children around them; helping to provide a safe environment.

Agree. To give an example from today - doorbell went, I answered (because I am a normal person) and it was the postie saying that next door had left their keys in the front door. We are in London, that just isn't safe. I took keys in, texted my neighbour, it's all good.

But if I hadn't, they would very likely have been burgled. Worth answering the door, I think

ToothFairy2023 · 05/02/2024 16:29

I paid for childcare and worked part time. I would suggest reducing your hours so your just doing normal days and less tired and make cut backs in other areas.

I had two 13 months apart and my parents lived a 10 min drive away but never helped as my sister pawned my niece off on them every hour of the day that they couldn’t manage anymore than looking after my niece and when she wasn’t there they had a ‘’day off’. It’s not ideal and hard work but you just cope and get by. I had to take my baby in a pram to a 6 week anti natal check and a dental appointment etc etc. Yet my sister got her one daughter looked after if she was doing house work, going to the hairdressers, needed to talk to her partner etc etc.

You are being overly dramatic with your tooth it hurts at the time and you have to be careful what you eat but it doesn’t hurt for days.

CharlotteBog · 05/02/2024 16:27

MollyRover · 05/02/2024 16:17

Neighbours or school parents have phone numbers. What has answering the door got to do with it??

Child falls off their bike outside your house, a passing driver stops to help and knocks on your door to ask for help.
The 'village' concept works if that person answers the door.
It's not just the people you know, it's the whole community considering the children around them; helping to provide a safe environment.

Butterdishy · 05/02/2024 16:26

MollyRover · 05/02/2024 15:58

You know what's actually ironic? I have much younger siblings so actually (along with my older siblings) provided my own parents with plenty of free childcare. Was cooking dinner for the whole (large) family most of the week from my early teens too.

Lol same. Now said younger sibling (also full grown adult) is regularly used the reason they're far too busy for us.

LaMarschallin · 05/02/2024 16:26

Cathy31 · 05/02/2024 16:05

@LaMarschallin not sure why you're so heated about my mum and I. Yes, you're right, she doesn't value the relationship. You're wrong, however, about her being proud of her grandchildren. She barely knows them. You're also wrong about me valuing her for free childcare. It hurts me a lot that my children won't have the relationship I had with my grandmother, and that my mum hasn't been there for me during some extreme difficulties including my life threatening illness. I'm perfectly happy paying for my childcare. You're also wrong about her being fine without me, since she like most people has needs beyond money. She's very openly angry if I don't ring or visit often enough. She has social and relational needs which she expects me to meet. I have the same needs, but she won't or can't meet them for me.

I replied to the OP with what was intended as an empathetic response. Maybe, rather than describe me and my mum to me, when you know neither of us, you could try to do the same.

Not heated or even that interested, just got a bit too much time on my hands like a lot of posters here.
I'm sorry for both of you. Hope things improve and your life threatening illness either improves or doesn't come back (whichever is appropriate).

user1471523870 · 05/02/2024 16:24

We both work full time and no family in this country. But for the last 5 year we managed reasonably well. You will probably need to be a bit more organized and have a different mindset, but it is absolutely doable. We split responsibilities, that included also emergency childcare. In your case, if you took time off when your little one was poorly and you couldn't easily book it again for your medical need, your other half should have stepped in.

The only person I rely on for going to have my nails done, as per your example, is my husband. And I stay with my son when he needs/wants to go out too.
I admit it gest a little more complicated if both of us want to go out together, but in a way this is easier to organize via a baby sitter....

OutsideLookingOut · 05/02/2024 16:18

Sususudio · 05/02/2024 15:47

I am from one of those regions. They also live with their in laws, brothers in laws, sisters in laws, sometimes entire families under one roof. That's what a collective society means. But do Briitsh people really want to live like that?

I find it quite odd when the collective society is romanticised for its childcare when what it often means is you will be changing your MIL's diapers, as my mum had to do.

Got to be honest, a lot of the time women are not treated so well either. You entire value is in birthing/bringing up children. No thanks.

Noicant · 05/02/2024 16:18

School, do things that need to be done on weekends, no babysitting options for us, I’m a trailing spouse so I gave up work. It’s not easy at all but one day they will be older and it will get much easier. But yeah it’s not easy. I would never want to do regular childcare for my DC tbh (burnt out already) but would always be available for short notice lending a hand.

MollyRover · 05/02/2024 16:17

CharlotteBog · 05/02/2024 16:13

The problem is in much of the West. People here have all bought into an overly individualistic society where people are self centred, keep themselves to themselves

Very many people on MN don't answer their door unless they are expecting someone. The 'village' isn't going to work with that sort of attitude.

Neighbours or school parents have phone numbers. What has answering the door got to do with it??

EmilyTjP · 05/02/2024 16:17

TTCnewbies · 05/02/2024 13:32

We are year 2024 op. Your child is not YOUR responsibility. The village starts at home. If you won't allow your DH to take time off to support a medical emergency then what do you expect?

Your options are simple:

  1. babysitter
  2. DH takes time off
  3. ask the grandparents
  4. take your daughter with you (this has happened plenty of times in these settings, take a ipad or phone with tv on for little one and the nurse keeps an eye, they are in the same room)

Number 4 least ideal but you don't seem to want your DH to take time off?!

This.

I haven’t read the full thread but i find it baffling people post this stuff berating grandparents and society for not helping but make excuses for the husband to have no active input at all!
Most companies offer sick pay/parental leave, why can’t he access those for emergencies?

CharlotteBog · 05/02/2024 16:13

The problem is in much of the West. People here have all bought into an overly individualistic society where people are self centred, keep themselves to themselves

Very many people on MN don't answer their door unless they are expecting someone. The 'village' isn't going to work with that sort of attitude.

FeelingSoOverwhelmed · 05/02/2024 16:11

It's hard - I think what's hard about your situation is that you seem to have written off your DH being able to do any more than he is. Which makes it more of a challenge. Whilst I appreciate it's difficult, the main and obvious solution is that your DH takes on more of the load. Taking annual leave for yourself/your mental health isn't a luxury many parents have tbh.

I don't have any grandparent help - in fact I am the help! I care for my terminally ill dad once a week and work 4 days a week. I do get school holidays off as I'm a teacher so that helps but it is an inflexible job the rest of the time. We just split things regardless and offer proactive solutions to employers eg working time back, or booking apps at the beginning or end of the day.

As others have done, I befriended lots of other parents to be able to call upon for favours and return the favour. I host a lot of playdates in the school holidays!

MollyRover · 05/02/2024 16:10

Cathy31 · 05/02/2024 16:05

@LaMarschallin not sure why you're so heated about my mum and I. Yes, you're right, she doesn't value the relationship. You're wrong, however, about her being proud of her grandchildren. She barely knows them. You're also wrong about me valuing her for free childcare. It hurts me a lot that my children won't have the relationship I had with my grandmother, and that my mum hasn't been there for me during some extreme difficulties including my life threatening illness. I'm perfectly happy paying for my childcare. You're also wrong about her being fine without me, since she like most people has needs beyond money. She's very openly angry if I don't ring or visit often enough. She has social and relational needs which she expects me to meet. I have the same needs, but she won't or can't meet them for me.

I replied to the OP with what was intended as an empathetic response. Maybe, rather than describe me and my mum to me, when you know neither of us, you could try to do the same.

All sounds very familiar, couldn't agree with you more 👏

Cathy31 · 05/02/2024 16:05

@LaMarschallin not sure why you're so heated about my mum and I. Yes, you're right, she doesn't value the relationship. You're wrong, however, about her being proud of her grandchildren. She barely knows them. You're also wrong about me valuing her for free childcare. It hurts me a lot that my children won't have the relationship I had with my grandmother, and that my mum hasn't been there for me during some extreme difficulties including my life threatening illness. I'm perfectly happy paying for my childcare. You're also wrong about her being fine without me, since she like most people has needs beyond money. She's very openly angry if I don't ring or visit often enough. She has social and relational needs which she expects me to meet. I have the same needs, but she won't or can't meet them for me.

I replied to the OP with what was intended as an empathetic response. Maybe, rather than describe me and my mum to me, when you know neither of us, you could try to do the same.

MollyRover · 05/02/2024 15:58

You know what's actually ironic? I have much younger siblings so actually (along with my older siblings) provided my own parents with plenty of free childcare. Was cooking dinner for the whole (large) family most of the week from my early teens too.

Sususudio · 05/02/2024 15:47

CottonC · 05/02/2024 15:34

@WhatsMyUsername89 I agree we should have a village raising children (and most of the world actually does; in much of the continents of Africa and Asia plus other countries e.g. in Central and Eastern Europe and Latin America this is the norm).

The problem is in much of the West. People here have all bought into an overly individualistic society where people are self centred, keep themselves to themselves and proritise careers and status above family, plus there are so many broken families so the support of the family unit is all fractured.

There's also the whole narrative in the West of how burdensome children are which is utterly ridiculous and ironic considering this is one of the richest parts of the world so if people can make it work, they can.

It's an opportunity OP to also self reflect and see that you're probably also part of the problem, e.g. before you had kids had you ever thought of and acted on being a 'village' for other people or were you yourself consumed with your own career, desires, boyfriend etc?

I am from one of those regions. They also live with their in laws, brothers in laws, sisters in laws, sometimes entire families under one roof. That's what a collective society means. But do Briitsh people really want to live like that?

I find it quite odd when the collective society is romanticised for its childcare when what it often means is you will be changing your MIL's diapers, as my mum had to do.

CottonC · 05/02/2024 15:34

@WhatsMyUsername89 I agree we should have a village raising children (and most of the world actually does; in much of the continents of Africa and Asia plus other countries e.g. in Central and Eastern Europe and Latin America this is the norm).

The problem is in much of the West. People here have all bought into an overly individualistic society where people are self centred, keep themselves to themselves and proritise careers and status above family, plus there are so many broken families so the support of the family unit is all fractured.

There's also the whole narrative in the West of how burdensome children are which is utterly ridiculous and ironic considering this is one of the richest parts of the world so if people can make it work, they can.

It's an opportunity OP to also self reflect and see that you're probably also part of the problem, e.g. before you had kids had you ever thought of and acted on being a 'village' for other people or were you yourself consumed with your own career, desires, boyfriend etc?

OneTC · 05/02/2024 15:27

If you can't afford your husband to have a day out then you presumably can't afford to be seriously ill from your tooth going nuclear.

Get the tooth sorted, worry about the lost hours later

CharlotteBog · 05/02/2024 15:21

I've always understood the "takes a village" saying differently- that raising a child takes a functioning and supportive society. Nothing to do with free childcare.

Same. The 'village' is someone spotting a kid out cycling the wrong way down the road and letting their parents know, or someone posting in the village FB that their child has lost their coat and lots of people saying they'll have a look, or neighbours rallying around at short notice to help with lifts.
It's not a long term childcare arrangement with grandparents.

MrsTingly · 05/02/2024 15:17

I've always understood the "takes a village" saying differently- that raising a child takes a functioning and supportive society. Nothing to do with free childcare.

FWIW I think not having people on hand to help is pretty common these days and perhaps that is why OP is getting a rough ride. It is hard and it's a question of muddling through. I think something like emergency dentistry should really be a good enough reason for your partner to take time off. Having nails done, obviously not.

Octavia64 · 05/02/2024 15:10

Ok so I got interested in this and went down a bit of a rabbit hole.

There is research on this, there's a paper from 2011 which says that 26% of families with kids 14 and under used grandparent care in the previous week, but I suspect that families with early teens don't use grandparents much.

It also says that for children under 2, 44% are regularly cared for by a grandparent and 28% sometimes leaving 28% who are never cared for.

So about a quarter of under 2's were never cared for by grandparents in 2011. I don't know how that will have changed in the intervening years.