Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies

584 replies

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 07:36

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies whilst apparently separating fighting bully pups.

Longer jail sentences, minimum of 5 years for owners of dogs that kill people for not controlling them.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
Mumof2NDers · 05/02/2024 19:25

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 18:42

Yep thats what all owners of these sorts of dog say, until they are not.

What do you think the Staff Bull Terrier was originally breed for?

They were originally bred for bull baiting then dog fighting. A couple of centuries of correct breeding has changed the breed. The kennel club recommends them as one of the best dogs for families.

HeartShapedBox · 05/02/2024 19:24

SomeCatFromJapan · 05/02/2024 17:25

It's a shame for the woman who died and her poor wee grandson, but from the dogs perspective they were protecting their babies.

This is utter victim-blaming. Male dogs don't have protective instincts towards their own puppies yet it was happy to join in mauling the woman to death. Normal dogs don't behave like this.

It would be victim blaming if I said it was the woman's own fault for listening to the idiot owner and attempting to separate puppies with a broom in front of their parents, but I didn't.

Male dogs might not be protective towards their pups but the female is, and if she goes to attack then it's no big surprise that he might join in, especially if they're bonded together.

It's an absolute tragedy, and the only one to blame is the idiot owner who sounds like he shouldn't own a goldfish never mind big, strong dogs with a predisposition to aggression.

Mrsjayy · 05/02/2024 19:21

@ejsmith99 I don't think any poster on this thread has blamed the woman.

BoobyDazzler · 05/02/2024 19:13

ejsmith99 · 05/02/2024 19:12

Oh according to the bully sympathisers, it's all her fault for using a broom. Provocation, abuse, any dog could turn!

Bollocks. No normal breed of dog produces puppies that fight so viciously with littermates that they need splitting up. Any creature wants their genes to have the best chance of going forward, fighting your siblings will reduce the likelihood.

No normal breed of dog will kill a human just for holding a broom. If they were really, really traumatised they might snap then stop when you back off. Not keep going back for more, not multiple bites all over the body. Not even when they were feeling their most maternally protective, and if the pups were mobile enough to fight that would likely be over

Which dogs are most likely to do this? Ones selectively bred to fight. The end of the predatory cycle. Bite, shake, kill, dismember. Combined with "gameness" and a high pain threshold. Look all over the world and areas with levels of pitbulls have high levels of maulings. So let's breed them even bigger and stronger to make the perfect family pet. Call them Luna and put a rose crown on them. Become hysterical when society says they aren't happy with your crap choices and wants evidence that you are trying to be responsible. When in doubt blame chihuahuas, despite the painfully obvious fact that one good kick and they go flying, no-one dies.

The lengths some will go to blame victims. And absolutely every selfish decision these people make reduces the freedom and quality of life of all the responsible people.

Have you read the thread?

ejsmith99 · 05/02/2024 19:12

Oh according to the bully sympathisers, it's all her fault for using a broom. Provocation, abuse, any dog could turn!

Bollocks. No normal breed of dog produces puppies that fight so viciously with littermates that they need splitting up. Any creature wants their genes to have the best chance of going forward, fighting your siblings will reduce the likelihood.

No normal breed of dog will kill a human just for holding a broom. If they were really, really traumatised they might snap then stop when you back off. Not keep going back for more, not multiple bites all over the body. Not even when they were feeling their most maternally protective, and if the pups were mobile enough to fight that would likely be over

Which dogs are most likely to do this? Ones selectively bred to fight. The end of the predatory cycle. Bite, shake, kill, dismember. Combined with "gameness" and a high pain threshold. Look all over the world and areas with levels of pitbulls have high levels of maulings. So let's breed them even bigger and stronger to make the perfect family pet. Call them Luna and put a rose crown on them. Become hysterical when society says they aren't happy with your crap choices and wants evidence that you are trying to be responsible. When in doubt blame chihuahuas, despite the painfully obvious fact that one good kick and they go flying, no-one dies.

The lengths some will go to blame victims. And absolutely every selfish decision these people make reduces the freedom and quality of life of all the responsible people.

BoobyDazzler · 05/02/2024 19:00

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 18:42

Yep thats what all owners of these sorts of dog say, until they are not.

What do you think the Staff Bull Terrier was originally breed for?

Staffs are bloody wonderful dogs and generally pose non risk to anyone beyond possibly getting knocked over with exuberance when they’re puppies. They might look similar but they’re very different dogs.

Swizzlersandtwizzlers · 05/02/2024 18:59

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 18:42

Yep thats what all owners of these sorts of dog say, until they are not.

What do you think the Staff Bull Terrier was originally breed for?

exactly, it’s the same old story. They always claim their dog has never attacked anyone after it mains or kills someone.

sure, some Staffies might be better natured than some cats but animals are massively unpredictable. And if a staffy snaps and attacks someone and if a cat snaps and does the same the consequences will be much different. Most teens and adults and even some primary school kids could overpower or at least fight off the latter, not so much the staffy.

The potential for danger including death is much greater with a staffy.

Once when I lived in London I saw a staffy in bus with some teens and decided I’d just wait for the next one. My issue is so many people bringing dogs in close proximity to others in crowded places and they’re asking for trouble.

Years later I actually was getting off a bus in and there was a man with a staffy. I didn’t even notice it initially so I didn’t do my usual which is to give them a wide berth. But it must have taken a dislike to me for whatever reason or was maybe just overwhelmed at all the people trooping off the bus but either way it lunged at me. Luckily I noticed just in time and side stepped it, at the same time the owner had saw what was happening and pulled it back so together we kept it away from me.

I wonder if that had been a young teenage girl or a drugged up young man or very frail old man ( all of whom I’ve seen with staffies) trying to hold it back what would the outcome have been?

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 18:42

Mumof2NDers · 05/02/2024 18:35

We have a Staffy and I can honestly say our cat is more dangerous!

Yep thats what all owners of these sorts of dog say, until they are not.

What do you think the Staff Bull Terrier was originally breed for?

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 05/02/2024 18:40

oakleaffy · 05/02/2024 18:22

ABSOLUTELY agree with this.
Ear cropping is absolutely barbaric.

It is done illegally in UK where it has caused dogs terrible pain.

It's utterly pointless.

They say ''It stops them getting torn in fights'' ..In Dobes, it's done to make them look more intimidating.

Some Pits have the ears almost amputated close to the head, like two ugly stumpy horns.

It should be illegal to import ear cropped dogs.

Pit and XL owners say ''But wot about neutering..that's worse''

Poor things. It's brutal and looks like it has been done blindfolded, with a knife and fork.

However, I don't agree that enforcing ear-cropping legislation should have been focused on INSTEAD of XL specific controls.

How would that have done anything to protect the public from attacks (like the muzzle, lead, insurance registration intends to) and prevented continuation of the 'type' (like the neutering and ban on sales/rehoming)?

I don't think this is an either/or situation.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 05/02/2024 18:39

Pallando · 05/02/2024 17:43

I think that instead of the "XL bully ban" they should have cracked down on ear dripping. It's been banned in the UK for almost 20 years!

I would say that every single breeder who cuts their puppies ear is a shit breeder (and is unlikely to have breed for placid temperament) and everyone who buys a cropped puppy is either ignorant or wants their dog to look "hard". Neither are likely to be good owners. I think if all illegally cropped dogs had been seized and destroyed it would have helped (it's a shame for the dogs, as it's not their fault what happened to them, but humans are more important).

I would also like to see the import of cropped puppies banned - it must be traumatic to have their ears cut, taken away from their mother and then taken on a very long journey from somewhere where cropping is legal to the UK at such a young age!

The Kept Animals Bill, which included banning the importation of dogs with cropped ears, got rejected in Parliament.

Mumof2NDers · 05/02/2024 18:35

Densol57 · 05/02/2024 07:48

Absolutely disgraceful. Ive lost count of arguments Ive had with owners of staffs who call their dogs the "nanny breed" and also these manufactured monster XL dogs. They are dangerous weapons and lethal in almost everyones hands.

We have a Staffy and I can honestly say our cat is more dangerous!

Pallando · 05/02/2024 18:33

@oakleaffy the number of people who don't recognize what breed our Dobie is because his ears don't stand up is shockingly high! You still see quite a lot of cropped Dobies around - one even won the local dog show a couple of years back...

There's a massive Cane Corso near us with cropped ears. Never seen him (or possibly her) do anything other than walk nicely on the lead but I always leave a lot of space if we have to pass. They probably think I'm worried about my dog being reactive to theirs, but I don't trust any dog with cropped ears - I know some might be legitimately rescued by good people, but that's probably the minority.

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 18:24

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2024 16:16

Like everything else and it is a huge failing with so much in the UK, there is little enforcement of the law

Ain't that the truth jasflowers Sad

I know, i was listening to R4 on the criminal gangs who put their shoplifters into squats, despite it being a crim offence, the Police take no action, the owners of these properties have to go through the civil courts, despite the shoplifters often being tagged, this takes years.

Link to XL bullies? Criminal gangs will use these dogs to threaten and intimidate, dog fights alongside illegal gambling.

the Police seem pretty useless in so many cases, i don't know if its lack of numbers, incompetence/corruption or paper work but something has clearly gone very wrong, they seem a reactive force.

oakleaffy · 05/02/2024 18:22

Pallando · 05/02/2024 17:43

I think that instead of the "XL bully ban" they should have cracked down on ear dripping. It's been banned in the UK for almost 20 years!

I would say that every single breeder who cuts their puppies ear is a shit breeder (and is unlikely to have breed for placid temperament) and everyone who buys a cropped puppy is either ignorant or wants their dog to look "hard". Neither are likely to be good owners. I think if all illegally cropped dogs had been seized and destroyed it would have helped (it's a shame for the dogs, as it's not their fault what happened to them, but humans are more important).

I would also like to see the import of cropped puppies banned - it must be traumatic to have their ears cut, taken away from their mother and then taken on a very long journey from somewhere where cropping is legal to the UK at such a young age!

ABSOLUTELY agree with this.
Ear cropping is absolutely barbaric.

It is done illegally in UK where it has caused dogs terrible pain.

It's utterly pointless.

They say ''It stops them getting torn in fights'' ..In Dobes, it's done to make them look more intimidating.

Some Pits have the ears almost amputated close to the head, like two ugly stumpy horns.

It should be illegal to import ear cropped dogs.

Pit and XL owners say ''But wot about neutering..that's worse''

MatchingBedding · 05/02/2024 18:16

This whole case is bloody awful. I expect this prick thought he was a great owner. The bloody arrogance of him! I will guarantee he thought he could control his dogs and had “trained” them to obedience. Well here is the result, the scum bag.
There’s a stupid meat head at the bottom of our village that enjoyed intimidating owners and smaller dogs until his monster ripped a jack Russel to shreds. The dog was seized and destroyed. The poor JRs owners are still traumatised. The meathead had already let his monster impregnate his girl monster… so another litter of aggressive pups was sent out into the world. I doubt any of them will be registered but to be honest what good does registering/neutering/chipping do if they bite your face off in your living room?

RubyEarWax · 05/02/2024 17:51

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

Pallando · 05/02/2024 17:43

I think that instead of the "XL bully ban" they should have cracked down on ear dripping. It's been banned in the UK for almost 20 years!

I would say that every single breeder who cuts their puppies ear is a shit breeder (and is unlikely to have breed for placid temperament) and everyone who buys a cropped puppy is either ignorant or wants their dog to look "hard". Neither are likely to be good owners. I think if all illegally cropped dogs had been seized and destroyed it would have helped (it's a shame for the dogs, as it's not their fault what happened to them, but humans are more important).

I would also like to see the import of cropped puppies banned - it must be traumatic to have their ears cut, taken away from their mother and then taken on a very long journey from somewhere where cropping is legal to the UK at such a young age!

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 05/02/2024 17:38

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

They've been lining the Cane Corso up for a while. The ones with more cash have Corsos and other large mastiff breeds (genuine breeds so cost more).

There will always be another 'It' breed for these morons. So there should be more done to develop and enforce proactive legislation as well as reactive. Unfortunately, proactive legislation is much harder and more expensive than reactive.

RubyEarWax · 05/02/2024 17:35

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

ThursdayTomorrow · 05/02/2024 17:32

We are in a climate emergency.
Regardless of their danger to humans, no one should be getting a dog as a pet - they are a luxury the planet cannot afford. Assistance and working dogs are, of course, an exception.

RubyEarWax · 05/02/2024 17:30

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

OhmygodDont · 05/02/2024 17:30

Normal dogs tend to bite once as a fuck off

This was a mauling also dogs don’t have people feelings. Yes a mother dog will protect her offspring but again a growl and a fuck off bite if you ignore.

Not a full on assault. Dad dogs are mainly not near pups because they can’t be trusted. All they care about is getting the fuck from the female again puppies get in the way of that.

LakieLady · 05/02/2024 17:29

@SicParvisMagna , my DB lives in Jaywick, three streets away from the house where this happened.

I agree with every word of your post. It is, without exception, the most deprived and depressing place it has ever been my misfortune to visit. I grew up on the roughest council estate in Croydon in the 60s/70s, so my bar is set pretty low!

SomeCatFromJapan · 05/02/2024 17:25

It's a shame for the woman who died and her poor wee grandson, but from the dogs perspective they were protecting their babies.

This is utter victim-blaming. Male dogs don't have protective instincts towards their own puppies yet it was happy to join in mauling the woman to death. Normal dogs don't behave like this.

HeartShapedBox · 05/02/2024 17:21

Schnauzersaremyheros · 05/02/2024 08:02

This poor woman was advised to use a broom to separate the puppies - with the parent dogs in the same room!

WTAF?! Of course the parent dogs were going to react to a perceived threat towards their pups 😡

Exactly what I thought.

It's a shame for the woman who died and her poor wee grandson, but from the dogs perspective they were protecting their babies.

Swipe left for the next trending thread