Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies

584 replies

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 07:36

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies whilst apparently separating fighting bully pups.

Longer jail sentences, minimum of 5 years for owners of dogs that kill people for not controlling them.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
Emotionalsupportviper · 07/02/2024 16:05

FancyJapflack · 07/02/2024 13:39

I was surprised to see a post by a well known dog trainer saying she was moved to tears by the video the owner of the dogs made, where he called for the breed to be eradicated.

”He’s a broken man” 🙄

Boo fucking hoo. He chose to own a large breed known to be violent. He chose to BREED from them. I have no sympathy at all.

Of course he is moved to tears - he's going to have the book thrown at him (I hope) and the cowardly bar-steward doesn't want to go to jail.

If that dog-trainer can't see past the crocodile tears she must be an idiot.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/02/2024 16:03

Sounds like your 8 yr old Springer was possibly very poorly 'socialised' at the critical young age where dogs learn not to be afraid of people and things.

That sounds highly likely @oakleaffy - she was kept in a stable on a piss-stained mattress, and she reeked to high heaven. When we were taking her home in the car she vomited what must have been an entire pound of green-coloured bacon (which smelled rotten, but that could have been the vomit) in a solid lump ie slices not separated.

We suspected that the dogs (she was there with another half grown pup) weren't fed very often and when they were just had rotten food - possibly from skips outside shops - chucked in with them and they had to grab what they could. Both Mr Viper and I wished we could have afforded her sister, too, but she hates our cocker bitch who has been nothing but lovely with her, so could well have been even worse with a sibling.

oakleaffy · 07/02/2024 15:29

OrlandointheWilderness · 07/02/2024 15:18

😂 @VeterinaryCareAssistant I didn't - my phone did! Pure typo, it attempted to write staffing and I corrected it and didn't notice it had capitalised!

That told YOU off for daring to capitalise a word. 😂
Pit apologist alert 🚨
“ He just wants to play!
Bbbut butt Chihuahuas!
It’s how you raise ‘em
You SNEEZED!
You farted
you MOVED!”

With zero acknowledgment of a dog’s innate drives.

To either herd, chase, or fight.

OrlandointheWilderness · 07/02/2024 15:18

😂 @VeterinaryCareAssistant I didn't - my phone did! Pure typo, it attempted to write staffing and I corrected it and didn't notice it had capitalised!

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 07/02/2024 15:14

OrlandointheWilderness · 07/02/2024 13:33

@oakleaffy sounds like you are exactly the right sort of owner for your dog.
I had a lurcher once - 3/4 grey and 1/4 STAFFY. He was bought by my then partner as my birthday present off the roughest house in bransholme estate in Hull. He was well socialised and trained, but by nature was the nerviest dog out. He had a long and full life with us and we loved him dearly, but we all know in the wrong hands he would've bitten. We knew when to leave him to it and give him space, and how to interact with him. He was never allowed near children. He was a happy dog when understood!

Why did you capitalise the word 'Staffy'?

FancyJapflack · 07/02/2024 13:39

I was surprised to see a post by a well known dog trainer saying she was moved to tears by the video the owner of the dogs made, where he called for the breed to be eradicated.

”He’s a broken man” 🙄

Boo fucking hoo. He chose to own a large breed known to be violent. He chose to BREED from them. I have no sympathy at all.

FancyJapflack · 07/02/2024 13:36

Sturnidae · 05/02/2024 22:15

Re those commenting on the people around hearing screaming and doing nowt: you've clearly never been to Jaywick. If you have any sense, you keep yourself to yourself and hope for the best. People living there don't trust the police at all. There has been outreach work done over the years, but Jaywick residents are let down time and time again by everybody in any semblance of power.

Yep. Jaywick is EXACTLY the sort of place you’d expect to be full of people like the bloke who owned these dogs.

FancyJapflack · 07/02/2024 13:34

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 07/02/2024 13:27

I think those "what to do in the event of an attack" things vastly underrate the speed of attacks, the strength, power and stability (centre of gravity wise, not psychologically) of the dogs and the human flight/flight/freeze instinct.

Edited

Absolutely. If one of those dogs set its sights on you, you have no chance. “Offer your leg and choke it by it’s collar” - ffs 🙄

OrlandointheWilderness · 07/02/2024 13:33

@oakleaffy sounds like you are exactly the right sort of owner for your dog.
I had a lurcher once - 3/4 grey and 1/4 STAFFY. He was bought by my then partner as my birthday present off the roughest house in bransholme estate in Hull. He was well socialised and trained, but by nature was the nerviest dog out. He had a long and full life with us and we loved him dearly, but we all know in the wrong hands he would've bitten. We knew when to leave him to it and give him space, and how to interact with him. He was never allowed near children. He was a happy dog when understood!

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 07/02/2024 13:27

I think those "what to do in the event of an attack" things vastly underrate the speed of attacks, the strength, power and stability (centre of gravity wise, not psychologically) of the dogs and the human flight/flight/freeze instinct.

oakleaffy · 07/02/2024 13:09

@Emotionalsupportviper Sounds like your 8 yr old Springer was possibly very poorly 'socialised' at the critical young age where dogs learn not to be afraid of people and things.

A Dog rescue said dogs who have been rescued from hoarder situations where a dog has spent it's crucial early weeks in a bare room are very fearful, as they just haven't experienced stuff and learned by a comforting older dog or human that there is nothing to worry about.

A Whippet in Australia was like this.. terrified of everything..detested women.
He had spent almost 18 months in a shed. {I followed his story over the internet}

A vet suggested euthanasia as he was so fearful and unhappy, but he was reunited with an older female Whippet from the same 'hoarder' situation, and he now lives alongside her.

Still fearful of people, but he isn't aggressive, and lives a much happier life alongside the Whippet ..it's thought she could even have been his mother.

The Daily Mail have come up with this as a 'Defence' against dog attacks.....

Not sure how much use it will be though as attacks happen fast and clear thought can go out of the window by this point.

''Cutting off the airway'' seems to be what Pit owners do in USA. Again, needs clear thought and a suitable noose like device to put around the dog's neck..easier said than done.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13055513/How-defend-XL-Bully-attack-dangerous-dog-expert-advice-banned-breed.html

How to defend yourself in XL Bully attack: Dangerous dog expert

The ban on American XL Bully dogs came into force on February 1, with owners facing criminal proceedings unless their pet is registered as exempt. 

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13055513/How-defend-XL-Bully-attack-dangerous-dog-expert-advice-banned-breed.html

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/02/2024 11:34

Frequency · 06/02/2024 20:26

They shouldn't need muzzling in the house. A responsible dog owner would ensure they were never in a position where they felt they needed to attack a stranger or child.

I've lived with a fear-aggressive dog. He came to the rescue I worked for and was deemed unsuitable for re-homing due to aggression so he stayed with me for 15 years. In all that time the only person he ever bit was me and that was my own stupid fault. I left chocolate on the counter and needed to get it off him quickly. There were a million and one ways I could have managed the situation safely but I over-reacted and reacted without thought. Luckily, he was 15 at the time and only had a few teeth left.

Do you know what I never, ever did while he was with me? I never left him alone with a child and an elderly family member. If we had guests and I needed to leave the room the dog came with me. If I needed to go away for the night the dog either came with me or went to kennels experienced in canine aggression.

I would never have left him alone with someone who didn't either know him and his triggers inside out or was qualified in canine behaviour.

We constantly worked on his triggers and his confidence, unfortunately, he had so many triggers it took around 2 years for me to feel he would have been safe to rehome to the right family by which time we were all bonded with him.

Ditto the dog I have now. He is a large breed and stupidly friendly but he's not left alone for even short periods with people who don't know him well or have the confidence and experience to properly manage him.

We have a fear aggressive dog (springer spaniel). We don't know what happened to her before we got her as a 5-month (approx) pup, but 8 years later she is still terrified of almost everything.

Indoors we behave as you did with your dog.

Keep her out of the way if workmen are in the house; NEVER leave her unattended with visitors of any age: NEVER let children approach her, even to give her a biscuit.

It's a PITA but if she bit someone intentionally, even once, we couldn't keep her, and with the family she is lovely, loving dog (though it took about two years for her to relax with us - she is particularly frightened of women, which is unusual, I think - and would often growl at my DD and myself. We decided to risk it and she's worth it - but it took a long time and I wouldn't trust her with anyone else.)

Swizzlersandtwizzlers · 07/02/2024 01:39

This country is lawless. His illegally owned dangerous dog killed a baby and he was only jailed for 18 weeks back in 2014 and now he’s a dog breeder?!!

He should have been given 10 years minimum and been banned from owning or working with dogs for life. Outrageous that this man is breeding dogs.

He clearly has no remorse and is potentially contributing to the death of more children at the hands of XL bully. I don’t know why clearly unhinged irresponsible people are allowed to carry on in this way and the law only intervenes after a fatality.

I’m not a fan of prison for non-violent crime, but prison sentencing guidelines need to be reviewed urgently in this country for things like manslaughter, murder, assault etc.

oakleaffy · 06/02/2024 22:57

Emotionalsupportviper · 06/02/2024 20:10

I don't doubt the living conditions exacerbated things, but the dogs themselves are dangerous.

I'll bet they only got walked once in a blue moon as well - and a bored, under-exercised dog of this type is even more dangerous.

The small house definitely wouldn't have made those XL pits be aggressive.. BUT what would have been a massive issue was eight dogs that are incredibly strong not getting enough exercise.

They are almost certainly dangerous with other dogs, and the owner likely wasn't keen on walking much.
He is seen having the 'adults' running around off leash in the videos, but even my friend with their nine small sighthounds has a routine for them all, for their exercise.

She takes out the 'oldies' separately to the youngsters, and because they are ''easy'' she can take out four at once. They don't pull, and walk on slack leads in one hand, leaving the other hand free for poo-bag picking.

Reactive XL Bully types would be a different thing entirely, just by size alone.

I bet those huge dogs got hardly any time out outside that tiny house.

wetotter · 06/02/2024 22:13

I am not sure that the figures on the numbers are likely to be accurate, as there isn't a good way of counting

What is clear however is the number of pet dogs shot up since the start of the pandemic. And it seemed as if every other family got a doodlepoo or a cocker spaniel, but at the same time a different type of owner got an XL bully

I read somewhere that there had been more applications for exemptions for XLs than anticipated - over 4,000

justaboutdonenow · 06/02/2024 21:21

@Frequency it's not fear aggro these dogs are showing though, it's a prey driven behaviour pattern that's been selectively bred for.

As an addendum to my PP about exemption numbers- what isn't taken into account is that that 40,000 will include bull breed mixes, mastiff mixes, & various established breeds not recognised by the KC such as American bulldogs, alapahas, corsi, presa canario etc.

justaboutdonenow · 06/02/2024 20:58

Emotionalsupportviper · 06/02/2024 19:34

According to this report 40,000 of these dogs have been granted exemptions. That means that 40,000 have owners who are responsible enough to register their dogs, and ensure that they are tattooed, microchipped, neutered and walked only on leash and with a muzzle.

40,000

And how many are there out there with owners like this self-serving, arrogant, ignorant twat?

Edit for spelling. Again.

Edited

The estimates seem to be between 50-100k American bullies in the UK & I've not delved into the veracity of those figures.

That's a lot of dogs for a breed that's only really been in the UK for a few years.

All the beautiful breeds of dogs in the world (silken windhounds, mudi, Icelandic sheepdogs) that aren't recognised by our Kennel Club that could have been imported & we end up with these antisocial, ugly, useless things.

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 06/02/2024 20:31

Frequency · 06/02/2024 20:26

They shouldn't need muzzling in the house. A responsible dog owner would ensure they were never in a position where they felt they needed to attack a stranger or child.

I've lived with a fear-aggressive dog. He came to the rescue I worked for and was deemed unsuitable for re-homing due to aggression so he stayed with me for 15 years. In all that time the only person he ever bit was me and that was my own stupid fault. I left chocolate on the counter and needed to get it off him quickly. There were a million and one ways I could have managed the situation safely but I over-reacted and reacted without thought. Luckily, he was 15 at the time and only had a few teeth left.

Do you know what I never, ever did while he was with me? I never left him alone with a child and an elderly family member. If we had guests and I needed to leave the room the dog came with me. If I needed to go away for the night the dog either came with me or went to kennels experienced in canine aggression.

I would never have left him alone with someone who didn't either know him and his triggers inside out or was qualified in canine behaviour.

We constantly worked on his triggers and his confidence, unfortunately, he had so many triggers it took around 2 years for me to feel he would have been safe to rehome to the right family by which time we were all bonded with him.

Ditto the dog I have now. He is a large breed and stupidly friendly but he's not left alone for even short periods with people who don't know him well or have the confidence and experience to properly manage him.

That's great and all but doesn't really have anything to do with XL's when they have form for escaping from gardens, bursting through fences or escaping out of windows and attacking people to death (Ian Price).

RubyEarWax · 06/02/2024 20:29

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

Frequency · 06/02/2024 20:26

They shouldn't need muzzling in the house. A responsible dog owner would ensure they were never in a position where they felt they needed to attack a stranger or child.

I've lived with a fear-aggressive dog. He came to the rescue I worked for and was deemed unsuitable for re-homing due to aggression so he stayed with me for 15 years. In all that time the only person he ever bit was me and that was my own stupid fault. I left chocolate on the counter and needed to get it off him quickly. There were a million and one ways I could have managed the situation safely but I over-reacted and reacted without thought. Luckily, he was 15 at the time and only had a few teeth left.

Do you know what I never, ever did while he was with me? I never left him alone with a child and an elderly family member. If we had guests and I needed to leave the room the dog came with me. If I needed to go away for the night the dog either came with me or went to kennels experienced in canine aggression.

I would never have left him alone with someone who didn't either know him and his triggers inside out or was qualified in canine behaviour.

We constantly worked on his triggers and his confidence, unfortunately, he had so many triggers it took around 2 years for me to feel he would have been safe to rehome to the right family by which time we were all bonded with him.

Ditto the dog I have now. He is a large breed and stupidly friendly but he's not left alone for even short periods with people who don't know him well or have the confidence and experience to properly manage him.

SomeCatFromJapan · 06/02/2024 20:17

That Jack Russell puppy video is a world apart from the XL bully ones, it really emphasises the temperament differences, and JRs are feisty little buggers.

Emotionalsupportviper · 06/02/2024 20:10

I don't doubt the living conditions exacerbated things, but the dogs themselves are dangerous.

I'll bet they only got walked once in a blue moon as well - and a bored, under-exercised dog of this type is even more dangerous.

Abracadabra12345 · 06/02/2024 19:59

The family of the owner say it's not the dogs but their living conditions. They were housed in a small chalet.

The grandmother came to look after her son while the father was in London making a music video.

Emotionalsupportviper · 06/02/2024 19:47

Fizbosshoes · 06/02/2024 19:41

While those conditions show the owners are at least following the law, I'm still not overly confident.
a) how and who is policing the muzzle on/walk on a leash rule? Even if you called the police they are not going to arrive instantly
b) most attacks happen in private homes, where none of the guidelines apply.

Too right!

I was shocked at he figure of 40,000 - I dread to think how many more are out there, unrecorded, unidentifiable if they attack anyone - and as you say, no dog wears a muzzle at home and even the "good" ones are unreliable.

oakleaffy · 06/02/2024 19:47

And surprise surprise......another XL Shitbull attack on innocent people.

These things are a blight on society, alongside their crappy owners and apologists

''Don't Bully our Bullies'' ...no, Don't let your vile choice of mutt ruin lives of people who want no part of your nasty aggressive dog type.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13052339/XL-Bully-attack-mother-children-Battersea-park.html

Horror as unmuzzled XL Bully 'launched unprovoked attack on mother'

The dog attacked the women and her children, aged one and two, as they entered the playground at Latchmere Recreation Ground, south London on Friday, February 2.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13052339/XL-Bully-attack-mother-children-Battersea-park.html

Swipe left for the next trending thread