Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies

584 replies

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 07:36

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies whilst apparently separating fighting bully pups.

Longer jail sentences, minimum of 5 years for owners of dogs that kill people for not controlling them.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
PaulCostinRIP · 05/02/2024 09:11

According to one family member the puppies were playing and getting rough and the son told the grandmother to separate them using a broom and that's when both of the adult dogs intervened and attacked her.

So whilst there are mitigating factors for the dogs to believe they were protecting the puppies the fact is that the son was utterly clueless in the raising of the puppies and not being able to control the adult dogs under these circumstances.

The dogs that attacked are also victims as they should not have been in the care of someone who has poor knowledge of dog behaviour.

I wonder what will happen to the puppies.

Velvian · 05/02/2024 09:06

I think this is a man problem too. I wonder how many women and children live with XL Bullies and other aggressive/inappropriate dogs against their wishes.

I think coercion and control are commonplace in families. It is also very common on threads here to see that men are actively blocking women from keeping their children safe.

WhollyGlorious · 05/02/2024 09:03

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 05/02/2024 08:47

All dogs that a toddler could not beat in a fight should be put in grave. No exceptions.

This.

And I say that as an owner of reportedly one of the most aggressive breeds of dog - a dachshund.

Despite ranking high in biting statistics, it ranks extremely low in death statistics (and in a recent ish case where a dachshund was involved in the death of a dog walker, the dachshund was eventually released to the owners and not found to be at fault).

My sole criteria for choosing a breed was that I must be able to overpower it if required.

They’re animals, you can’t possibly rationalise with them. If they perceive a threat there is a risk they will respond to neutralise the threat in the most effective way they are able - no matter how trained they are, most average dog owners can’t train out a fear response.

whitewallsoutside · 05/02/2024 09:02

I agree OP. If you knowingly keep dangerous and out of control dogs and they hurt or kill someone, you should face a significant prison sentence.

Without wanting to comment on the specifics of the case (no one yet knows what happened) I don't understand why anyone would want to keep a pet which was aggressive and capable of killing, let alone why you'd do that if there were kids in the house.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 09:01

This is why the "ban" is insufficient: most of these attacks happen either in people's homes or when these dogs escape from someone's property, when they would not be muzzled even if the owner was following the rules. The law should be that all of them are seized and put to sleep. If they are dangerous enough to ban then they are not suitable to keep as pets at all.

QueenBean22 · 05/02/2024 09:00

Daffodil18 · 05/02/2024 08:53

Yes I do think jail would be reasonable seeing as the breed is now banned. However I’m a little stuck in this case. The young boys mother and grandmother have now passed away. Where will he go if his father goes to jail. Such as shame for the poor boy.

The aunt who was in the story?

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 08:56

soupfiend · 05/02/2024 08:49

The poster is blaming the owner (quite rightly) not the victim. Read the post

I did, the pp said the woman tried to separate the fighting puppies and they turned on her, as any dog would do.

DyslexicPoster · 05/02/2024 08:56

The owner is probably still defending himself and seeing himself as the victim in all of this. The owners have exposed their child to deep trauma.

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 08:54

unexpectediteminthebraggingarea · 05/02/2024 08:50

I'd apply the same rule to cars too. All killing machines

I see your point but nobody actually needs an XL bully. Cars are needed to get around and there are millions of them.

I understand if you cause death y dangerous driving or under the influence there are jail terms.

Although that's not the point of this thread you could make a thread about that ?

OP posts:
Daffodil18 · 05/02/2024 08:53

Yes I do think jail would be reasonable seeing as the breed is now banned. However I’m a little stuck in this case. The young boys mother and grandmother have now passed away. Where will he go if his father goes to jail. Such as shame for the poor boy.

unexpectediteminthebraggingarea · 05/02/2024 08:50

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 08:46

It's interesting that none of the 8% who voted that a minimum 5 year jail term for owners of dogs that kill haven't said why. Or is it the thread police types with their 'we had a thread already, why do another', even though the question is different 🤔

Anyone who voted against minimum jail term care to offer a why these idiots who have a weapon that can kill don't deserve to have a jail term and minimum at that?

I'd apply the same rule to cars too. All killing machines

soupfiend · 05/02/2024 08:49

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 08:47

Rubbish, talk about blaming the victim & puppies is a very broad term, newly born or 6 months old?

"Normal" dogs rarely turn on adults, whatever the situation & if they do, can be pulled off.
The Police had to shoot these dogs on sight, an Armed Response team sent to a dog attck....

The poster is blaming the owner (quite rightly) not the victim. Read the post

unexpectediteminthebraggingarea · 05/02/2024 08:48

mambojambodothetango · 05/02/2024 08:02

Indeed. Those of you saying you won't understand why anyone would want them or why they haven't obeyed the law... it's an act of defiance against an 'authority' they can't even name, in the same way a lot of things are these days. They know it's wrong, they know they're dangerous, that's the appeal. To make them look hard etc.

I also know a couple of people on FB (more friends of friends) who don't fit the hard stereotype but just seem to believe that they are the world's best dog owners and owning an XL that hasn't killed anyone yet is their proof Hmm

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 08:47

pizzaHeart · 05/02/2024 08:42

This^
I totally support the ban but who does this to puppies? Any parent dog would react in these circumstances. How on earth the owner could advise her this???

Rubbish, talk about blaming the victim & puppies is a very broad term, newly born or 6 months old?

"Normal" dogs rarely turn on adults, whatever the situation & if they do, can be pulled off.
The Police had to shoot these dogs on sight, an Armed Response team sent to a dog attck....

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 05/02/2024 08:47

All dogs that a toddler could not beat in a fight should be put in grave. No exceptions.

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 08:46

It's interesting that none of the 8% who voted that a minimum 5 year jail term for owners of dogs that kill haven't said why. Or is it the thread police types with their 'we had a thread already, why do another', even though the question is different 🤔

Anyone who voted against minimum jail term care to offer a why these idiots who have a weapon that can kill don't deserve to have a jail term and minimum at that?

OP posts:
Ginmonkeyagain · 05/02/2024 08:46

Why the fuck did she buy a Doberman as a house pet? That's like getting a off road SUV as a city run around.

RubyEarWax · 05/02/2024 08:42

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

pizzaHeart · 05/02/2024 08:42

Schnauzersaremyheros · 05/02/2024 08:02

This poor woman was advised to use a broom to separate the puppies - with the parent dogs in the same room!

WTAF?! Of course the parent dogs were going to react to a perceived threat towards their pups 😡

This^
I totally support the ban but who does this to puppies? Any parent dog would react in these circumstances. How on earth the owner could advise her this???

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 08:40

Alwaysalwayscold · 05/02/2024 07:57

I was asking if a 5 year minimum jail term for owners of dogs that kill people is unreasonable.

You don't have to read the thread of it doesn't interest you. There are hundreds of alternative threads and multiple threads on similar issues, just scroll on by.

OP posts:
soupfiend · 05/02/2024 08:38

SidekickSylvia · 05/02/2024 08:07

Is everyone reporting un-muzzled XL Bullies if you see them? I haven't seen one for a few months, but a neighbour reported (to 101) seeing two unleashed and not muzzled while walking her dog in a remote area last week. They asked for a lot of details and said they'd send someone immediately, so it would seem to be taken seriously.

I realise this wouldn't have made any difference in this poor lady's situation, and that most attacks are in the home, but do please report if you feel it's safe to do so. It just astonishes me that anyone would think it reasonable to keep one as a pet.

I honestly dont know how that would work, by the time you get through to 101 and then go through all the questions the person will be back home more than likely, presumably you dont know where the walker lives or their name etc?

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 08:36

No requirement under the XL Bully legislation to muzzle in the home & these dogs breed before the law came into force.

The exemption rules are sterilisation, muzzling in public & insurance, all these dogs, inc the puppies were in the house.

Of course he may not have had the paper work but that wouldn't have prevented this.

DoggusDomesticus · 05/02/2024 08:36

PaulCostinRIP · 05/02/2024 08:28

The young boy in the house who managed to flee and yell for help, has already suffered the loss of his mother when she died and it was him who Esther (his grandmother) was visiting as they were close after the boy had lived with her for a time after her daughters death.

So now he is without his mother and his grandmother and his father probably faces jail.

I thought the photographs of the dogs owner (the father of the young boy) were a parody but it turns out they are actually serious. What an absolute 🤡

Blimey, he looks intelligent and reasonable, doesn't he?
The ban and/or sentencing for owning banned breeds, and owning a dog that attacks and kills need to be increased and enforced. Unbelievable that this is still happening.
Idiots like this one are not going to cooperate with the mere notion that his dogs are "not allowed"

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/02/2024 08:36

A 68 year old woman was told to separate fighting dogs with a broom handle? Christ on a bike!

I am increasingly coming round to the idea of seriously restricing anyone's ability to keep animals.

soupfiend · 05/02/2024 08:35

KeeeeeepDancing · 05/02/2024 07:59

From the times- who on earth hears screaming and doesn't do anything about it?

Xyz , 38, who lives in a property behind the address where the attack occurred, said she had been in the garden at the time. “It was all quiet and then we heard dogs barking, and then we heard someone screaming,” she said. “It seemed like the screaming of a child. That went on for about ten minutes. We went back in after a while because it sounded horrific.”

Areas like that always describe themselves as a 'very close knit community' as well

Did I read somewhere the poor child lost his mother 2 years ago? Now his grandmother?