Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies

584 replies

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 07:36

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies whilst apparently separating fighting bully pups.

Longer jail sentences, minimum of 5 years for owners of dogs that kill people for not controlling them.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
Devilshands · 05/02/2024 11:30

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 11:04

Yes and you could pull it back couldn't you, as i have not read of a Vet mauled by Golden Retriever.

Talk about missing the point.

And even if they did, they’re not so powerful that even an average person couldn’t pull one off. XL bully? Average person stands no chance.

SweetBirdsong · 05/02/2024 11:28

@DrunkenElephant

@SweetBirdsong I am a huge dog lover, and I completely agree with you.

Thank you. I think most dogs are lovely - and any badly behaved ones are usually badly behaved because of the owner. But these XL bully dogs are absolutely ridiculous! They should not be around in society or peoples homes at ALL.

.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 11:26

PaulCostinRIP · 05/02/2024 10:34

@Mrsjayy the understanding that I have is that Esther the victim was grandmother to an 11 year old boy who was in the house when the dogs attacked. His mother was Esther's daughter and she has passed away. The boy had a close bond with his grandmother as he lived with her for awhile after his mother died.

He now lives with his father who is the owner of the dogs.

The aunt of the boy who is also the daughter of the victim is the one speaking in the media.

Let's hope then that children's services remove the boy because clearly his so-called father is not fit to be caring for a child. Poor boy, to have lost his mum, probably lived in terror with those dogs (the fact the boy's father gave instructions to the grandmother who was killed telling her to hit them with a broom when they fight each other shows that he knew they were vicious and aggressive already), and now has witnessed his grandmother being mauled and had to listen to her screams as she was ripped to pieces.

This man should be sent to prison for a very long time.

DrunkenElephant · 05/02/2024 11:21

@SweetBirdsong I am a huge dog lover, and I completely agree with you.

HoneyButterPopcorn · 05/02/2024 11:21

My sister had farm dogs. They were dogs but substitute children or ‘cuddly wuddly ikkle babies’. They were well trained (neighbouring farm had sheep so they had to be well trained - farmers would shoot any dogs worrying their livestock).

they were all beautifully behaved and friendly dogs. Never had any problems with their behaviour even when they were old/sick.

DS adored them but we never left him alone (when he was little) and it was drilled into him that you never went up to a dog you didn’t know and certainly didn’t try to pat/cuddle/pick one up.

Some people just don’t train their dogs and see £££££ in breeding. I knew one man who was breeding these XL dogs and was charging tens of thousands per pup. I thought he was making it up but apparently not. He was a dog breeder so I suppose you can charge more for pedigrees (are they pedigrees or like these new candles labradoodles or jackapoo types)?

SweetBirdsong · 05/02/2024 11:19

I am literally horrified by this. There have been many tragic cases of dogs mauling to death/killing toddlers and babies, especially over the past 25 years or so. But these fucking beasts are killing ADULTS. Grown women, and grown MEN. Imagine being so savagely attacked by a DOG that you die. NO dog like this should be bred.

Police need to seize all XL bullies, and they need to be euthanized. Every. Single. One. Anyone who thinks they should be kept as 'pets' needs locking up frankly. And people need to stop this 'aww but he's just a soft old bear and I demand we keep him' trope. They all need seizing and putting to sleep. And no more should exist.

ENOUGH of the 'aww it's not the dogs fault' bullshit that some people come out with. THESE ARE NOT PETS AND SHOULD NOT BE AROUND IN SOCIETY AND DOMESTIC HOMES. It needs to be against the law to have one. Don't just muzzle them all. They all need to go!

I had never even heard of these dogs til last year. Why are they suddenly fucking everywhere?!

R.I.P. Esther Martin. Flowers That poor woman. As has been said, what a horrific way to die. 😢

.

CantDealwithChristmas · 05/02/2024 11:19

Rangelife · 05/02/2024 11:06

My BIL is a dog trainer - he has trained dogs to sniff out dry rot, disease, bombs and now trains guide dogs. He has given lectures and been on the TV about dog behaviour. He always maintains that dogs are animals and that they need treating as such. Not as 'fur babies' (boak) or members of the family but animals who come behind humans. If they a threat to humans they are gone.

I don't know why there has been a cultural shift to see dogs in such an emotional way. I walk often, in isolated places, and I am absolutely sick of the mentality 'love me, love my dog'. I don't like dogs, I never will. It isn't an offence for me to tell you to get your off lead dog away from me and your dog, to me, isn't a friend. I don't want it jumping up or saying hello to me. I am allowed to dislike something. Until we change the psychology around dogs, namely projecting human like attributes and emotions onto them, we won't shift the risk.

Problem is that people have been projecting their emotions onto dogs for the past 30,000 years. That is how the dog's genetic ancestor managed to hijack our oxytocin pathways and thus eventually became canis domesticus.

There are instances of dogs being regarded as human-like across all cultures and going back a very long way. For example, the passage in the Odyssey (composed c 8th century BC but the underlying stories probably much older) where Odysseus' dog is the only one to recognise him when he returns to ithaca after 20 years in disguise, the dog's sheer joy a dn love shown to Odysseus is described in very human terms.

Like it or not dogs and human brains have evolved alongside each other for a long time so I don't think we can turn off that projection. It happens with other animals too. If you look at how, say, safari workers tlak about the animals they observe and interact with.

I also am mindful that human beings are also animals.

Bomb-sniffing dogs are amazing - kudos to your BIL for doing such an important job :-)

whichspidermummy · 05/02/2024 11:19

ShoePalaver · 05/02/2024 09:49

There is a ban on breeding them but it only started on 31st January

The ban on breeding actually came in on 31st December 2023, only a month before you said I realise, so unless under 6 weeks, the puppies would've just escaped the ban.

Ravensky · 05/02/2024 11:17

When a society has become full of anti-social wankers supporting one another and taking great pleasure in threatening anyone that questions their anti-social behaviour (I. E. Dangerous dogs), you're on a big downward spiral I. E the UK.

These people have been brought up to know nothing other than being bitter and twisted and treating everyone that's questions them like shit and getting away with it. The more of them there are and the less punishment there's is, the worse it gets.

Society has basically gone to shit and it's only going to get worse as the law tiptoes round upsetting majority numbers and that's the problem.... Anti-social twats are ever increasing in number and decent people are being marginalised.

Mummytummy123 · 05/02/2024 11:10

I worry that there will be a lot of owners out there defiant of the ban - I can’t see things actually changing. Who would challenge a person in the street over a non muzzled XL bully?

On a further note this latest attack happened within a home by a non muzzled dog - registration of the dogs has zero factor in prevention here - who is going to muzzle their dogs within their home, especially given their own views that they are gentle? What’s to stop one of their dogs escaping out the front door? Jumping a fence?

Sorry but I absolutely agree that there should be a cull of the breed - this situation cannot be controlled as we are relying on owners being good owners and time and time again, we are proven otherwise - that’s my opinion

We went to a supermarket recently and in the entrance was a ‘hard man’ stood there with his bully, right where we had to walk past to leave. DD was utterly terrified.

Rangelife · 05/02/2024 11:06

My BIL is a dog trainer - he has trained dogs to sniff out dry rot, disease, bombs and now trains guide dogs. He has given lectures and been on the TV about dog behaviour. He always maintains that dogs are animals and that they need treating as such. Not as 'fur babies' (boak) or members of the family but animals who come behind humans. If they a threat to humans they are gone.

I don't know why there has been a cultural shift to see dogs in such an emotional way. I walk often, in isolated places, and I am absolutely sick of the mentality 'love me, love my dog'. I don't like dogs, I never will. It isn't an offence for me to tell you to get your off lead dog away from me and your dog, to me, isn't a friend. I don't want it jumping up or saying hello to me. I am allowed to dislike something. Until we change the psychology around dogs, namely projecting human like attributes and emotions onto them, we won't shift the risk.

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 11:04

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 05/02/2024 10:59

A golden retriever went for one of the vets throats just last week. They're quite often not as friendly as you'd think.

Yes and you could pull it back couldn't you, as i have not read of a Vet mauled by Golden Retriever.

Talk about missing the point.

Maverickess · 05/02/2024 11:02

Tracker1234 · 05/02/2024 10:34

I have seen a photo of the owner of these dogs and I wasnt surprised he looked that that with the hate and attitude in his face 'I can do what I like'.

I am sure the house was tiny yet he had two 'dogs' plus puppies presumably because he is looking to 'sell' them to other stupid people who thought a dog like this makes them look hard. What a scum bag and I have just heard he has been let out on bail

See imo, this is the problem, people like this just taking over society and making other people's lives a misery and they seem relatively unchecked. These dogs are just a symptom really.
I live near an area where the 'hard man' attitude prevails unfortunately, it's a deprived area for sure, crime is high and barely responded to, it's the same people, the same families who are stealing cars, or driving around without insurance like idiots and crashing into other people, driving while under the influence of God knows what and while already banned for driving under the influence of God knows what, taking what they want and threatening anyone who gets in their way - and these dogs are now a symbol of that type of person, because they're huge, strong and have a propensity to be aggressive (if you think that they were bred originally to take down bulls who can weigh up to a ton and have muscle on muscle, they had to be to do that!)
We as humans bred them to be like that and now they're in the hands of some of the most irresponsible and anti social people, who don't care about the dog, they want the fear and status symbol it provides, so instead of breeding out the characteristics that make them dangerous and unpredictable, they're being bred in.

It's a human made and human perpetuated problem. We can ban the breed, we can destroy and remove the dogs, we can stop any more being bred and let the breed die out, and that will stop these types of dogs killing and maiming people, but until we tackle the type of people that are using these dogs in this way, another method to be anti social and dangerous will take it's place and the cycle will start again. These dogs are a target for these people because of their breed.

That's not to say that I think the ban shouldn't be happening, it absolutely should, we can't carry on with these dogs behaving like this, and responsible owners of these breeds need to recognise that as well, they are responsible and neuter/train/muzzle their dogs but they do need to accept that this type of dog attracts the type of people who don't. I am seeing a lot of "I hate this government" and "It's not fair" posts from owners who have complied and who are responsible owners, and no it's not fair I agree with that, but that doesn't mean something doesn't need to be done either.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 05/02/2024 10:59

Devilshands · 05/02/2024 10:35

That would include banning retrievers…you know, the most family friendly dog there is

A golden retriever went for one of the vets throats just last week. They're quite often not as friendly as you'd think.

Everanewbie · 05/02/2024 10:58

hotdiggetydog · 05/02/2024 09:43

What a horrible, sneering thing to say.

Accurate though...

BoobyDazzler · 05/02/2024 10:56

hotdiggetydog · 05/02/2024 09:43

What a horrible, sneering thing to say.

I do sneer at arseholes like this, why wouldn’t I?

it’s true there is a type that own XL bullies

  • scum men
  • women with saviour complexes who like scum men
girlfriend44 · 05/02/2024 10:55

Some people shouldn't have dogs.

I wouldn't go to a house where there were dogs like that
Was it her son and had she been there before?

HellsAngel81 · 05/02/2024 10:50

Devilshands · 05/02/2024 10:35

That would include banning retrievers…you know, the most family friendly dog there is

Hmm, I have encountered many not-so-friendly goldies in my time as a veterinary nurse.

I firmly believe that ALL dogs should be licensed, and that the owners must go through some formal training (ie Kennel Club Good Citizen Award), before being deemed competent.

My heart goes out to this lady and her family, and also the dogs and their pups - they are victims too of an incompetent owner!

Mrsjayy · 05/02/2024 10:47

Hereyoume · 05/02/2024 09:59

Please explain?

I think I have raised some reasonable points.

really reasonable points!

FlameGrilledSquirrel · 05/02/2024 10:44

They're a weapon and should be dealt with accordingly.

In the same way a border collie will try and herd anything that moves, a weapon of a dog will attack. It's what they are. We have spent generations making dogs do what we desire them to do from working to attack to being companions.

Add into the mix fucking idiot owners who want one to look well 'ard before they bang on about feds whilst salivating over Peaky Blinders and you've got accidents waiting to happen.

HoneyButterPopcorn · 05/02/2024 10:43

It’s a bloody miracle the child wasn’t attacked too.

justaboutdonenow · 05/02/2024 10:43

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 10:39

You 'd have an "allowed list" of breeds, HRPs would be on it, regardless of weight.
Dobermanns and Rottweilers imho would not be, at least without muzzle restrictions in public.

Goldies aren't always the family friendly breed they used to be, there are lines with severe resource guarding issues.

Still nowhere near the risk that bullies are, but they do highlight years of unchecked, rampant backyard breeding that has resulted in where we are today.

Tracker1234 · 05/02/2024 10:39

Well the owner is back out until March.

justaboutdonenow · 05/02/2024 10:39

PaulCostinRIP · 05/02/2024 10:34

@Mrsjayy the understanding that I have is that Esther the victim was grandmother to an 11 year old boy who was in the house when the dogs attacked. His mother was Esther's daughter and she has passed away. The boy had a close bond with his grandmother as he lived with her for awhile after his mother died.

He now lives with his father who is the owner of the dogs.

The aunt of the boy who is also the daughter of the victim is the one speaking in the media.

As the boy lost his mum wouldn't SS be involved with placing him in that home?

I don't know much about the system, but surely whenever a child loses a parent there are outside agencies involved for the child's wellbeing.

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 10:39

Devilshands · 05/02/2024 10:35

That would include banning retrievers…you know, the most family friendly dog there is

You 'd have an "allowed list" of breeds, HRPs would be on it, regardless of weight.
Dobermanns and Rottweilers imho would not be, at least without muzzle restrictions in public.

Swipe left for the next trending thread