Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies

584 replies

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 07:36

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies whilst apparently separating fighting bully pups.

Longer jail sentences, minimum of 5 years for owners of dogs that kill people for not controlling them.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
Emotionalsupportviper · 05/02/2024 12:41

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 07:44

I'd add an additional sentence for the irresponsible owner who bred them. There were puppies there. It's been known for ages the ban was coming in. Why breed them.

Crack down is needed on these idiots.

Edited

It seems that other family members knew what breed these dogs were. It's a pity they didn't report these illegal puppies before someone was killed. Had the pups been taken away and euthanised (or at least confiscated so that he couldn't sell or otherwise dispose of them), and the owner prosecuted, this poor woman may still be alive, and that poor little boy wouldn't have had to witness his grandmother being slaughtered.

Y6yhnsr5 · 05/02/2024 12:37

That's horrible. Ban those things already!!! FFS, how many more people need to die?

ClockworkDisaster · 05/02/2024 12:35

Hereyoume · 05/02/2024 09:53

So much hysteria on this thread.

Dogs are animals, they have sentience, they behave like, well, animals. You cannot hold a person responsible for murder or manslaughter because a dog has killed someone. From the dogs point of view a person is just another animal, and animals kill other animals, sometimes for food, sometimes for territory, sometimes animals even kill and eat their own young.

If someone climbs a fence at a zoo and sticks their arm inside a tigers cage, we don't blame the tiger for ripping their arm off, we would all say how stupid the person was. But for some reason people don't seem to be able to apply the same logic to dogs. XL dogs are selective bread to be as big, strong and aggressive as possible, so it's not really a surprise that so many people are killed by them. It's like keeping a lion in your house. You know how cats like to play with toys and sometimes scratch an bite people, but a tabby isn't going to kill anyone, a lion however, behaving in exactly the same way absolutely would kill you. But they're both still cats. Same difference between a jack russel and an XL.

Blaming owners for a dogs behaviour is just nonsense, dogs are animals, they think for themselves. BUT, some dogs are dangerous, like some cats are dangerous, depends on the size of the animal. So a better solution would be to pass a law criminalising the possession of certain berrds who by their very nature are exceptionally dangerous, such as the XL.

So, let's say a MINIMUM term of imprisonment for anybody found in possession/ownership/control of known dangerous dog breeds. And all animals of type PTS, without exception. That way we could ensure the "extinction" of those breeds.

Remember, we actually allow people to train dogs to attack and bite people, and we pay them to do it. So it's a little hypocritical to ignore police dogs and their behaviour, but suddenly call for the imprisonment of "Dave" who's Alsation got a little bit over excited at the park and knocked a kid over.

Police dogs are well trained though. They bite certain parts of people on command. They also stop on command. It’s not mindless and uncontrolled. Their handler spends years training them and making sure they respond as they should.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 12:35

I find the daily mail type outrage on here ridiculous. 'They all need to go'; they all need to be euthanised, shoot them all, owners of them are 'scum' 'thick' and the like.

Wouldn't it be fun to do a large statistically valid sample of IQ tests of XL bully owners and see what the average score is. I hope some journalist or researcher takes up your challenge. I don't think it's an outrageous hypothesis that the average would be very significantly below the 100 average.

It's fairly obvious already from the comments online and to journalists on the topic, but perhaps such a study would remove these wails of how "unfair" it is to "stereotype" people who are fulfiling the stereotype they apparently reject to such an extent that they are almost a caricature of it. Although I doubt many such people would be keen to sign up to do an IQ test and expose just how unintelligent they really are. I mean, these are people who continue to keep an animal in their house which could kill them or their children any time it feels like it. They are people with such a low level of capability for rational thought that they perceive other people pointing out how unwise this is as a great injustice, yet simultaneously they don't think it is unjust that other people are ripped to shreds and killed and horrific ways by their "pets" and can't comprehend that this is slightly more important than whether it hurts their ego to know that others observed that their intelligence is manifestly well below average.

Whoopaday · 05/02/2024 12:23

CantDealwithChristmas · 05/02/2024 11:52

Oh OK I had previously understood that police canine specialists used a tranquilliser dart then destroyed the dog off site, thank you for correcting me! :-)

That might be the case for a lot of forces if there is a dog contained in a house and you have time to wait, but the chances of having someone in the area whilst someone is being mauled to death is low. At the time it’s whatever you’ve got, even if that’s a shovel if you’re just ordinary response.

SomeCatFromJapan · 05/02/2024 12:19

@bintybooboo doesn't it give you pause that the only breed you hear of being so protective of their puppies that they have to maul an adult woman to death is an xl bully?
Think of the vast amounts of puppies bred by people who don't know what they are doing, or backyard breeders. Yet no cockerpoo mother has ever mauled an adult to the point of death, no pug, no labrador.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 12:15

@CantDealwithChristmas yep. They are wolves, but worse in some cases like this "breed".

We need to come down much harder on all of this. People's pets should not inconvenience others in any way, let alone put them at physical risk. That's so obviously unacceptable that it's baffling anybody thinks there should be any kind of trade off here. Why should somebody else have their life impacted in any way by your pet?

There needs to be a very strict licencing regime for any dog owners. It will need to be expensive, requiring certified training, full enclosure all around the property with double barriers i.e. a very tall, robust wall or fence in addition to the doors etc (the poor man who was killed not long ago was killed by dogs that escaped through a window). Regular checks on this. No animals over a weight that a small child could not fight them off. No dangerous animals in a home where children live otherwise either dog removed and PTS or child removed into care of responsible adults. No dogs off lead in public places at all, only on fenced-in (registered througj dog licence) private property or in registered enclosed dog exercise fields. Dog licence fees to be set at a level to properly monitor and enforce all of this.

Enough is enough. The anthropormorphism is ridiculous. These are animals and if they pose any danger to humans then they should not be in human spaces.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 12:08

If these "dogs" are "allowed to follow their instincts", which are to kill and maim, then clearly they should not be in a residential area and in a home where a child lives.

The poor woman who was ripped to pieces tried to separate the fighting dogs with a broom because she was instructed to do so by their owner. The man who thought it was appropriate for a boy who had already been berieved of his mum to have to live in terror in a house with EIGHT of these dogs.

He should be prosecuted for child abuse as well as manslaughter.

Trying to blame the woman for doing what the owner told her to do is disgraceful. He knew the dogs were fighting each other already hence giving her this advice. He knew they were aggressive, so it was only a matter of time until they attack a human rather than each other. And he had his child living in the house, but still continued to illegally have these dogs there, breed them, put his child and any visitors and neighbours also at risk.

The people that have kept these dogs despite all of the evidence that they can turn at any second and kill children and adults are disgusting. They aren't just taking a risk with their lives but those of family and neighbours or random people who happen to cross their path somehow. It is unacceptable and anybody who thinks it's ok to put other people at risk for the sake of a pet has something seriously wrong with them.

Sususudio · 05/02/2024 12:02

Thread has gone as expected, Cars, cats and collies compared to XL Bullies. And a bit of victim blaming.

CantDealwithChristmas · 05/02/2024 12:02

Rangelife · 05/02/2024 11:53

@CantDealwithChristmas that is fascinating regarding the oxytocin pathways - so neurodevelopment has aligned in terms of the way we (as human animals) interact with animals? I had no idea that this was a thing, thanks for the knowledge. Sounds like we have been groomed by the animals as much as we groom them! Peak MN. I do find BIL's work fascinating as he uses techniques and behaviour modification methodology (click training, classical conditioning etc) that I am interested in (did a bit of neuroscience in my MSc).

Yes, animal behavourists and evo biologists do theorise that dogs (not sure about other animals) and humans neurodevelopment has gone side by side for about 30,000 years.

Evo biologists theorise that the dog's ancestor (not a wolf exactly, a cousin of the wolf) first approached human hunter gatherer tribes about 30,000 years ago. They theorise that the first contact was made between pups and children (puppies and children form very close bonds to this day).

Humans and dogs quickly realised that there was a mutually beneficial relationship - dogs could help with protection, tracking, sniffing out food sources; humans could give dogs food and protection in return.

Both humans and dogs show increased oxytocin activity when they look into each others' eyes; numerous peer reviewed studies have been done to show this.

Humans go into deeper sleep when they sleep alongside dogs. Dog owners consistently show lower levels of stress and better heart thealth (although correlation isn't causation as dog owners also tend to be more physically active.)

the evolutionary bond is very, very old.

Fun fact - evo biologists believe that all dogs' eyes used to be a very cold light blue, like wolves', but some gradually evolved to brown eyes as this made them look less threatening and 'cuter' to early humans.

If you look into a dog's eye you'll see that its real pupil is tiny and quite repitilian looking. The big 'fake' pupil and brown iris is window dressing only to make them look more cute and human so we'll look after them.

Yes, they groomed us and we groomed them!

Bishopsgirl · 05/02/2024 12:02

@Schnauzersaremyheros That is exactly what I thought when I read the article. I totally agree with the new laws regarding these dogs but it makes you wonder how the parent dogs had been treated and it was obviously triggered out of fear for their puppies, by them seeing a broom being taken to them. Absolutely tragic all round, totally the fault of the idiot owner, RIP to this poor lady.

bintybooboo · 05/02/2024 11:59

I have now read that this woman, and may she rest in peace, had been trying to separate two puppies from 'fighting' with a broom. The mother's instinct to protect her young no doubt kicked in, hence a tragedy.

Why on earth do we think that dogs should somehow understand what seems to be 'expected' of them these days. They are no longer allowed to be dogs - children are allowed to crawl all over them, we stick them in handbags, dress them up, but we never allow them to be 'dogs' with instincts, not taking time to make proper educated decisions about dog ownership. It's like if someone went up to your child and hit it, you would be expected to stand back and not retaliate, because 'violence' would not be the answer. Most of us would attack and viciously at someone who hurt our child. If you did, you would be shot. But dogs are not allowed to have this instinct. It would be good if someone could tell us how to get rid of it, but they can't. Shoving puppies around with a broom is an act of aggression, and the dog retaliated. If that is indeed what happened.

I find the daily mail type outrage on here ridiculous. 'They all need to go'; they all need to be euthanised, shoot them all, owners of them are 'scum' 'thick' and the like.

When you manage to shoot every xl bully in the country what exactly do you think those who never take responsibility for their dogs - whatever size they are, whatever breed they are - are going to do? They're going to move on to the next breed so until you sort out the people who use these dogs as status symbols, protection in drug rackets and the like, its never ending. The human cost will go on. But, hey, we shot all the xl bullies, so that should make you feel better. It is always going to be the responsible owners who bear the brunt of idiots like the owner in this instance. You will find, I'm sure, that most dog owners and particularly bull breed owners absolutely abhor owners such as this, who has done nothing but brought many many innocent dogs into BSL.

A dog has been shot because it did what it was supposed to do, protect its young, a woman is dead, the owner of the dog allowed his son to witness an horrific incident, the emergency services have had to deal with it, and all because the owner wanted to make money. He flouted the law as it stands at this time; he refused to conform at all in any way. He didn't care about the dogs, that he allowed to be in this situation, he didn't care about his son, and he definitely didn't care about the woman, and I believe he was the one who said she should use a broom to stop whatever was going on. A backyard breeder displaying the most ignorant traits possible, who wilfully put that woman in a dangerous place. That man is the one you should be blaming. It is his fault, and only his fault.

This man needs to be charged with manslaughter; he needs to be banned from ever having a dog. He needs to go to prison for a very long time. However, instead of being charged with manslaughter, I think, he has, at this time, only been arrested for offences under the Dangerous Dogs Act, so tell me again that government cares about the people who have been victims? That they care enough about YOU to prevent these things from happening. They don't, but Joe Public and the media should, and efforts should be put into wanting the law changed so that we can deal with this owner, and the like, and take owners and breeders like this off our streets.

rwalker · 05/02/2024 11:54

To me having one of these as a pet is no different than keeping a lion as a pet

there just not suitable
trained or not
there too big and powerful to be cooped up in a house

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 11:53

They were lucky their armed police unit was near by, lots of rural areas would have a long wait for armed response.

Apparently it is "snobbery" to note such things, but it is unsurprising that there is an armed police unit fairly nearby given the well-publicised issues with the area where this incident occurred.

Rangelife · 05/02/2024 11:53

@CantDealwithChristmas that is fascinating regarding the oxytocin pathways - so neurodevelopment has aligned in terms of the way we (as human animals) interact with animals? I had no idea that this was a thing, thanks for the knowledge. Sounds like we have been groomed by the animals as much as we groom them! Peak MN. I do find BIL's work fascinating as he uses techniques and behaviour modification methodology (click training, classical conditioning etc) that I am interested in (did a bit of neuroscience in my MSc).

CantDealwithChristmas · 05/02/2024 11:52

Whoopaday · 05/02/2024 11:42

You need a vet to tranquillise animals. Police have guns. Guns or tasers, so they have a choice of shooting or not shooting. They needed the dogs off the woman and didn’t have time to wait for the in call vet to tranquillise. They were lucky their armed police unit was near by, lots of rural areas would have a long wait for armed response.

Oh OK I had previously understood that police canine specialists used a tranquilliser dart then destroyed the dog off site, thank you for correcting me! :-)

blackpanth · 05/02/2024 11:52

Hereyoume · 05/02/2024 10:15

Yes.

But only if you own one of the banned breeds, the same should apply to someone who owns a collie.

Definitely not!! Collies are lovely.

Andthereyougo · 05/02/2024 11:52

DrunkenElephant · 05/02/2024 07:47

In front of her 11 year old grandson too. That poor boy Sad

i think the child’s mother died in recent months. ( grandmother’s daughter) The poor woman was visiting her grandson and this happened. Poor child is traumatised and grieving already and now witnessing this and a further death in his family. I hope he’s taken good care of.

ShoePalaver · 05/02/2024 11:51

Whoopaday · 05/02/2024 11:42

You need a vet to tranquillise animals. Police have guns. Guns or tasers, so they have a choice of shooting or not shooting. They needed the dogs off the woman and didn’t have time to wait for the in call vet to tranquillise. They were lucky their armed police unit was near by, lots of rural areas would have a long wait for armed response.

The dogs would need to be captured and restrained or put in a cage before being tranquilized. A vet can't just walk up to an aggressive dog and inject it. Even if they did it will take several minutes for the dog to go to sleep. That's if you could even find a vet willing to come out at short notice.
Potentially they could be caught on a dog catcher pole but that would be more dangerous and would probably take longer than shooting. The priority was to get them off the woman so unless 2 skilled and equipped police dog handlers were on site it doesn't seem like a quick option. You won't find a private vet willing to come out and catch an aggressive dog that is mailing someone to death.

ShoePalaver · 05/02/2024 11:45

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 05/02/2024 10:59

A golden retriever went for one of the vets throats just last week. They're quite often not as friendly as you'd think.

Lots of dogs are aggressive at the vets. Not nice obviously but it doesn't reflect what they are like as family pets. At the vets they are scared and sometimes in pain or ill, being subjected to unwanted poking and prodding and having their warning signals ignored.

Agree with you lots of retrievers are aggressive though, I don't think they are a good pet for homes with children. Labradors are better

Whoopaday · 05/02/2024 11:42

CantDealwithChristmas · 05/02/2024 10:38

I was interested to read that the police shot both dogs on site rather than (as is more usual) tranquillising them and destroying them elsewhere.

They must have been totally out of control

I think the socio-economic aspects of the Bully XL phenomenon needs to be explored more, they are most prevalent in socially deprived areas and many people see them as a form of protection/intimidation.

Mind you, the owner looks like a right King Cnut.

You need a vet to tranquillise animals. Police have guns. Guns or tasers, so they have a choice of shooting or not shooting. They needed the dogs off the woman and didn’t have time to wait for the in call vet to tranquillise. They were lucky their armed police unit was near by, lots of rural areas would have a long wait for armed response.

Ravensky · 05/02/2024 11:38

@SweetBirdsong i literally can't bear to imagine the pain she suffered but I bet the scrote that owns the dogs doesn't give a damn and that's the sort of people we're dealing with. They do not give a damn. There's only one fit punishment for him and that's enduring the same fate she did.

If the law was harder on people like him, we'd see less horrific behaviour and society would be better. As it is, people like him behave how the hell they like and get away with it. It won't change though will it, because, 'human rights'. The same human rights that the scrotes don't afford to those that have to live in the same fucking country as them.

Once upon a time scrotes like him wouldnt have lasted five minutes. His neighbours would have dealt with him and probably before he got chance to reproduce with a bit of luck.

I am absolutely sick to death of the pits of society, ruling society.

user1497207191 · 05/02/2024 11:37

Ravensky · 05/02/2024 11:17

When a society has become full of anti-social wankers supporting one another and taking great pleasure in threatening anyone that questions their anti-social behaviour (I. E. Dangerous dogs), you're on a big downward spiral I. E the UK.

These people have been brought up to know nothing other than being bitter and twisted and treating everyone that's questions them like shit and getting away with it. The more of them there are and the less punishment there's is, the worse it gets.

Society has basically gone to shit and it's only going to get worse as the law tiptoes round upsetting majority numbers and that's the problem.... Anti-social twats are ever increasing in number and decent people are being marginalised.

I fully agree. We're basically a lawless country now as the police are impotent and incompetent. We've had a few decades of them ignoring the "small" stuff and pandering to minorities, and that's just given the green light to "certain" sectors of society to do what the hell they want, whether it's anti-social behaviour, tax evasion (black economy), driving offences (speeding, parking, mobile phones, no road tax, no insurance, no driving licence, etc), shoplifting, street crime, drugs, etc etc.. Now things are so bad, the police have lost all hope of enforcing anything but the worst crimes (or the easy targets like speed cameras).

ShoePalaver · 05/02/2024 11:37

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

The restrictions only say it has to be neutered. The restrictions for chimps are more onerous

HPFA · 05/02/2024 11:34

Rangelife · 05/02/2024 11:06

My BIL is a dog trainer - he has trained dogs to sniff out dry rot, disease, bombs and now trains guide dogs. He has given lectures and been on the TV about dog behaviour. He always maintains that dogs are animals and that they need treating as such. Not as 'fur babies' (boak) or members of the family but animals who come behind humans. If they a threat to humans they are gone.

I don't know why there has been a cultural shift to see dogs in such an emotional way. I walk often, in isolated places, and I am absolutely sick of the mentality 'love me, love my dog'. I don't like dogs, I never will. It isn't an offence for me to tell you to get your off lead dog away from me and your dog, to me, isn't a friend. I don't want it jumping up or saying hello to me. I am allowed to dislike something. Until we change the psychology around dogs, namely projecting human like attributes and emotions onto them, we won't shift the risk.

100% agree with all of this.

It drives me mad when dogs (on lead or off) come running up to you and the owner says patronisingly "he won't harm you, he's just being friendly". Maybe I just don't want to interact with any dog!

Swipe left for the next trending thread