Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies

584 replies

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 07:36

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies whilst apparently separating fighting bully pups.

Longer jail sentences, minimum of 5 years for owners of dogs that kill people for not controlling them.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
Babsexxx · 05/02/2024 13:20

Highly doubtful though I still see a good few red nose pitbulls about and they where meant to be banned in 1991! It’s shocking they will find a way around it! Bring back the dog license I say!

IWroteTheOther51 · 05/02/2024 13:17

With the order to neuter them all or face having them seized and destroyed then technically the breed will die out over the next decade in the UK?

Not everyone who owns these dogs fits the stereotype being pedalled here. Plenty of people are happily complying with the laws.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2024 13:16

Swizzlersandtwizzlers · 05/02/2024 13:11

I was going to say something similar.

This poor boy, his mum and now maternal grandmother is dead. He probably lives with his Dad, he will need to find a new home soon. His Dad seems highly irresponsible though so perhaps it’s for the best.

On the subject of not assuming things, how much says that dad will avoid a custodial sentence because "he has to be there to raise the poor lad" - especially considering that care places are severely stretched?

ThereIbledit · 05/02/2024 13:15

OpieMo · 05/02/2024 13:07

For someone to be willing to enter a home with not one, but multiple XL bullies? Already shows a certain level (or lack) of education sadly. All we can do is stay as far away as possible. The second we see a pitbull out and about my child goes on my husband's shoulders and we leave the area. Parents who willingly bring them into their home with children present need investigating frankly.

Whilst I behave much like you do if I see an unmuzzled XL in public, I'm not sure it's right to cast aspersions on the lady who died. She was there to see her grandson, who had a father who owned and bred XL. It's him I don't peg as very educated, and if I'm casting aspersions on anybody it's the many who breeds XL bullies and keeps them int he same home as his son - I could well believe that he said to the kid's grandmother - a woman who has no legal rights to access the grandson - that she can see her grandson at his home or not at all.

WWYD in those circumstances? I'm not sure I'd make the same choice if there was my grandson involved or not.

daffodilandtulip · 05/02/2024 13:15

KeeeeeepDancing · 05/02/2024 07:59

From the times- who on earth hears screaming and doesn't do anything about it?

Xyz , 38, who lives in a property behind the address where the attack occurred, said she had been in the garden at the time. “It was all quiet and then we heard dogs barking, and then we heard someone screaming,” she said. “It seemed like the screaming of a child. That went on for about ten minutes. We went back in after a while because it sounded horrific.”

Maybe they knew the dog and the family. Those "types" are often well known in the area. People wouldn't want to get involved.

I'd phone the police or something though, I wouldn't just go back inside and pretend it wasn't happening.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2024 13:13

For someone to be willing to enter a home with not one, but multiple XL bullies? Already shows a certain level (or lack) of education sadly

It's a fair point, OpieMo
Nobody would blame poor grandma for wanting to see the grandkids, or for the fact she was attacked, but surely she could have seen them somewhere else?

And as you rightly said, that's apart from what they were doing in a house with children in the first place

Swizzlersandtwizzlers · 05/02/2024 13:11

Daffodil18 · 05/02/2024 08:53

Yes I do think jail would be reasonable seeing as the breed is now banned. However I’m a little stuck in this case. The young boys mother and grandmother have now passed away. Where will he go if his father goes to jail. Such as shame for the poor boy.

I was going to say something similar.

This poor boy, his mum and now maternal grandmother is dead. He probably lives with his Dad, he will need to find a new home soon. His Dad seems highly irresponsible though so perhaps it’s for the best.

SquirrelSoShiny · 05/02/2024 13:07

IWroteTheOther51 · 05/02/2024 12:55

I only know one XL bully. She belongs to a nice middle-class family who are passionate about large breed dogs - they have a cane corso as well. She's incredibly well-trained and looked after. She's not crazy about her new muzzle, but the law is the law.

The ban is a bit pointless - the criteria for identifying these dogs is so woolly and irresponsible owners will just move on to the next breed.

Yes I'm sure they have all sorts of reasons for keeping these specific dogs - from feeling a superior dog owner ('See! MY dog hasn't killed anyone I am clearly a dog whisperer and not just another vanilla, middle-class labradoodle owner!') to other complex psychological reasons ('I got bullied at school and I may be a middle aged accountant called Eric - but I'm still a tiger at heart! I have subdued the savage beast! Hear me roarrrr!').

I'm being facetious but the fact remains: their passions and inadequacies shouldn't be allowed to put others at risk. These dogs need to quietly disappear from the world.

OpieMo · 05/02/2024 13:07

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2024 12:54

To be fair having brought Poundland Ali G into your family probably indicates you haven't got much by way of common sense or critical thinking skills

And that's why it's perhaps pointless to ask "Why didn't the family report?"

Nobody denies this is an awful tragedy, but let's not assume that the rest of the family had any more sense than him

For someone to be willing to enter a home with not one, but multiple XL bullies? Already shows a certain level (or lack) of education sadly. All we can do is stay as far away as possible. The second we see a pitbull out and about my child goes on my husband's shoulders and we leave the area. Parents who willingly bring them into their home with children present need investigating frankly.

Babsexxx · 05/02/2024 13:06

Exactly THIS it absolutely is not our responsibility to worry about weather or not a dog is good or bad particularly with this killer breed!

oakleaffy · 05/02/2024 13:06

NewOrder · 05/02/2024 09:54

Exactly. If my Italian greyhound ever went for me I know I could yeet it to the moon with one swift kick (I wouldnt, because she wouldnt!)

The thought of an Iggy being yeeted to the moon, spindly legs wheeling and big eyes 👀 and little ears flapping- 💕
An Iggy bite would be like being bitten by a mouse!

LimberlostLark · 05/02/2024 13:05

I really don't know why successive Govts don't stand up to the dog lobby.

To be fair, most people anti-bred ban are against it because they think it's a short term, ill thought out law that is long overdue a proper overhaul that does not result in weird anomalies such as puppies from the same litter finding themselves on opposite sides of the law - because of natural variation in leg length etc.

Most people wanting stronger laws want them because the current law is a short-term, ill thought out law that is not preventing dog attacks to the degree it should or could.

I am not sure there is a lobby that is anti any laws at all. (Except the hunting lobby who continue to succeed in getting their dogs left out of any real controls at all).

These dogs are extremely poorly bred, poorly raised and poorly trained. The result is a temperamentally unstable animal with immense power. It is both the shitty breeding and the training that has failed them.

I'm not defending them - they could all go tomorrow afaiac. But I do think until we rethink dog laws and put greater focus on owner qualification then we will see these dogs replaced with another breed within a very short few years. Take a Cane Corso and have career criminals breed a few gens, like the XL has been bred, and it will kill people (for example).

Successive governments haven't failed to take on the dog lobby (imo); they have failed to give enough of a shit to put time and effort into better, more rounded dog laws. The cynic in me says that's because it's not their 'kind' of pensioners and children dying.

somekittenmittens · 05/02/2024 13:05

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 05/02/2024 10:59

A golden retriever went for one of the vets throats just last week. They're quite often not as friendly as you'd think.

How did it manage to miss? If an XL or any other dog went for the throat you wouldn't be able to stop it, through the dog meaning it and it's pure strength. Golden retrievers can be twats but the power and intent is different behind them, they will never reach the same intensity a bloodsport dog will and they lack the same muscle. I think you must have an agenda, if you're someone who handles dogs every day as a vet helper and you would care to mention an aggressive golden but you've never felt the intensity of a bull breed when it's switched on and feel like mentioning that, I've felt it as someone who has had my hands on far fewer total dogs.

Babsexxx · 05/02/2024 13:05

YANBU I am absolutely sick to death of seeing all these unnecessary deaths that are completely avoidable! I am however worried sick for scotland I joined some xl bully sites on sm just purely to see what was going on and what all these idiots where going to do keep them or get rid and the bus loads of them going up to Scotland was shockingggg!

Then not to mention the huge fallouts from people lying about the dogs temperaments! Plenty of upset from original owners pissing and crying because they have had there dogs returned even tied up to there front gardens etc it is absolutely ludicrous!!!!

Ive got a bloke on my sm who regularly updates photos of his unleashed unmuzzled xl on walks! Like he is begging to be reported! Maybe these idiots are actually waking up to them having these killing machines and low key hoping they will be reported/dog removed!

OpieMo · 05/02/2024 13:04

Doesn't matter how 'good' an owner is tbh. Good owners can reduce the risk of these animals reverting to their nature, but there have also been plenty of cases of XL bullies raised from puppyhood by excellent owners who have either eaten their owners or killed someone else. That's the issue with these dogs. Doesn't matter how good an owner you are. The chances of them following their nature and mauling or killing someone are still there.

Not to mention, people shouldn't have their lives dependent on whether a random stranger is a 'good owner' or not. There is no place in our society for that level of risk, for whether someone lives or dies while popping to the shops is reliant on how good the owner of that dog is. You will never eradicate bad owners, it isn't possible. I'd still like to survive, thanks.

Sad to see the news. Yet another nannying from that well-renowned peaceful, loves children, nanny dog breed.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/02/2024 12:57

Biddie191 · 05/02/2024 12:51

I was listening to a radio interview with DJ Spoony (who has an XL Bully) last week, saying the ban was crazy, his dog is 'the softest thing ever' etc. I wonder if he'll revise his opinion at all now. They all seem to be the 'wouldn't hurt a fly' type, until they attack.
They're bred to be aggressive, and also their physiology means that many are uncomfortable, if not in pain the majority of the time due to their mass being too much for their joints, plus breathing difficulties, so what you have is a ticking time bomb. When I'm in pain, I have a far shorter temper than not, so this, coupled with being bred for aggression is cruel, and highly dangerous.

their physiology means that many are uncomfortable, if not in pain the majority of the time

This is a good point.

IWroteTheOther51 · 05/02/2024 12:55

I only know one XL bully. She belongs to a nice middle-class family who are passionate about large breed dogs - they have a cane corso as well. She's incredibly well-trained and looked after. She's not crazy about her new muzzle, but the law is the law.

The ban is a bit pointless - the criteria for identifying these dogs is so woolly and irresponsible owners will just move on to the next breed.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2024 12:54

To be fair having brought Poundland Ali G into your family probably indicates you haven't got much by way of common sense or critical thinking skills

And that's why it's perhaps pointless to ask "Why didn't the family report?"

Nobody denies this is an awful tragedy, but let's not assume that the rest of the family had any more sense than him

Biddie191 · 05/02/2024 12:51

I was listening to a radio interview with DJ Spoony (who has an XL Bully) last week, saying the ban was crazy, his dog is 'the softest thing ever' etc. I wonder if he'll revise his opinion at all now. They all seem to be the 'wouldn't hurt a fly' type, until they attack.
They're bred to be aggressive, and also their physiology means that many are uncomfortable, if not in pain the majority of the time due to their mass being too much for their joints, plus breathing difficulties, so what you have is a ticking time bomb. When I'm in pain, I have a far shorter temper than not, so this, coupled with being bred for aggression is cruel, and highly dangerous.

RubyEarWax · 05/02/2024 12:50

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

SquirrelSoShiny · 05/02/2024 12:48

wubwubwub · 05/02/2024 07:51

Because, until something happens to a loved one they'll convince themselves it's "the owner not the breeeeeeed" even now you'll probably have the family going it wasn't the dogs fault...

Yep. They're literally already saying that. To be fair having brought Poundland Ali G into your family probably indicates you haven't got much by way of common sense or critical thinking skills.

I'm genuinely angry and upset at this story and the absolute fucking fools defending these dogs. These dogs need to be allowed to die out as a breed. They by definition attract a certain sort of idiot owner. The rest of us need protected from them.

This poor woman and poor family. It is just a pointless waste of a life.

oakleaffy · 05/02/2024 12:46

Schnauzersaremyheros · 05/02/2024 08:02

This poor woman was advised to use a broom to separate the puppies - with the parent dogs in the same room!

WTAF?! Of course the parent dogs were going to react to a perceived threat towards their pups 😡

Normal non fighting breeds don’t need separation when they are tussling- they don’t bite each other, they wrestle but there is no malice .
Fighting DNA pups fight to death and even decapitate each other.
Normal pedigree dogs wouldn’t have sperm donor and “mother “ in same premises
that’s sheer back yard breeder crap right there.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2024 12:45

BoobyDazzler · 05/02/2024 07:41

The owner looks like your typical XL bully owning scrote too, doesn’t he.

They nearly always do - it's just so depressingly predictable

Also why there's little point in ever more stringent laws, since too many who cause the real problems consider them optional

For me, the only thing that's likely to work is seizure of any of these things seen out without a muzzle. A risk to those seizing of course, but maybe stun darts could be an option?

SlothMama · 05/02/2024 12:43

Even if every XL bully was destroyed scum like him would just move onto the next breed

RubyEarWax · 05/02/2024 12:43

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned