Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies

584 replies

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 07:36

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies whilst apparently separating fighting bully pups.

Longer jail sentences, minimum of 5 years for owners of dogs that kill people for not controlling them.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
oakleaffy · 05/02/2024 13:46

Babsexxx · 05/02/2024 13:39

Yes they are very aggressive I have one that’s constantly outside the school gates each morning seemed extremely friendly owner had lead no muzzle it came bounding up to me, me being a dog lover didn’t hesitate to go in for a stroke it went for me! There must be something in the red gene mutation as they are far more susceptible to aggression my auntie worked as a vet in the 90s when they where constantly seeing red cockers in for rage syndrome!

There is indeed mention of a gene mutation in XL’s for sudden rage aggression.
Red Cocker Rage was mentioned in same article.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/02/2024 13:44

WhatWhereWho · 05/02/2024 13:44

Have you reported him though? Or just ignoring it and criticising him on here?

I was wondering, too.

WhatWhereWho · 05/02/2024 13:44

Babsexxx · 05/02/2024 13:05

YANBU I am absolutely sick to death of seeing all these unnecessary deaths that are completely avoidable! I am however worried sick for scotland I joined some xl bully sites on sm just purely to see what was going on and what all these idiots where going to do keep them or get rid and the bus loads of them going up to Scotland was shockingggg!

Then not to mention the huge fallouts from people lying about the dogs temperaments! Plenty of upset from original owners pissing and crying because they have had there dogs returned even tied up to there front gardens etc it is absolutely ludicrous!!!!

Ive got a bloke on my sm who regularly updates photos of his unleashed unmuzzled xl on walks! Like he is begging to be reported! Maybe these idiots are actually waking up to them having these killing machines and low key hoping they will be reported/dog removed!

Have you reported him though? Or just ignoring it and criticising him on here?

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/02/2024 13:43

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 05/02/2024 13:33

Which side of the debate do you stand on, sususudio?

It was me that mentioned collies, I did so because they are a good example of innate breed characteristics/behaviours being expressed in pet line dogs. There are others (Jack Russell's digging, retrievers carrying things in their mouths, beagles and their difficulties with recall...). Why people can accept breed characteristics in some breeds but absolutely deny them in others baffles me.

A lot of the trouble now is also people buying working-type dogs from working parents, which have been specifically and intensively bred to do a particular job, and then expecting them to fit into a 9-to-5 lifestyle, left at home alone a large part of the day with nothing to do, and then not properly exercised and occupied even at the weekend because the owners want a "rest".

Dogs in this situation quite literally become insane.

There are "pet" strains of many working breeds now where the instincts that have been bred in for centuries are bit dampened by selective breeding- if you want a border collie, get a pet strain one* - don't go to a farm and get one that's been bred to be on its paws running about after sheep for a solid 12 hours, and using its initiative when it needs to. Dogs like that find pet home very hard to cope with even when they have company all day and are properly occupied.

*However still expect it to need a heck of a lot of exercise and to be mentally stimulated. They are energetic, clever dogs - you can blunt these instincts little, but nor erase them.

Edited for spelling

kitsuneghost · 05/02/2024 13:42

Whatayear2023 · 05/02/2024 13:37

Sorry to ask but I've read artivle twice and still not sure.... the lady who died the dogs were her family members as her grandson was at house so sons daughters house?

The gran's daughter was the boy's mum
She died and so 11 year now with his dad (the scrote). Grans son-in-law
Gran was visiting to see her grandson.

oakleaffy · 05/02/2024 13:41

jasflowers · 05/02/2024 08:56

I did, the pp said the woman tried to separate the fighting puppies and they turned on her, as any dog would do.

Edited

Wouldn’t happen with non fighting types of dog.
Nice pups don’t fight with each other so hard that the owner says to part them with a broom
. Non fighting breeds / types responsibly bred would all have had new “vetted” homes booked long before sperm met egg.
They’d be off to their new loving homes at 9 weeks.
This idiot was trying to offload these fighting dogs at £500
Zero takers.

Pits and pit cross pupsare notorious for fighting to the death.
Sometimes the mother kills them.

That woman who took on a “ fat “ XL that produced 8 XL puppies is going to have plenty of sibling battles on her hands .
It’s all fun and go fund me’s til it’s not.

Babsexxx · 05/02/2024 13:39

Yes they are very aggressive I have one that’s constantly outside the school gates each morning seemed extremely friendly owner had lead no muzzle it came bounding up to me, me being a dog lover didn’t hesitate to go in for a stroke it went for me! There must be something in the red gene mutation as they are far more susceptible to aggression my auntie worked as a vet in the 90s when they where constantly seeing red cockers in for rage syndrome!

kitsuneghost · 05/02/2024 13:38

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 05/02/2024 13:35

In an ideal world, yes, but that would be so expensive and difficult to administer in the real world that it would pretty much be impossible.

Yes it would take a lot of time to get assessed (5-10 years maybe) but if you want a dog so badly you will need to wait. would also give people more time to be sure it is the right option.
Also a limit of dogs owned at one time means reassessments could be put in place.

daffodilandtulip · 05/02/2024 13:37

If your dog weighs at least half your weight, you aren't talking your dog for a walk, they are taking you for one.

Indeed. There's a woman near us with an XL. She's always walking it in the kids park. She stops and tells you to go around her because she can't move him over. She actually admits that she can't move it. What chance would any of those kids have if it ran off from her? (I haven't seen it since the rules came in, so wonder what she will do.)

Whatayear2023 · 05/02/2024 13:37

Sorry to ask but I've read artivle twice and still not sure.... the lady who died the dogs were her family members as her grandson was at house so sons daughters house?

justaboutdonenow · 05/02/2024 13:36

Thindog · 05/02/2024 13:23

I think the ban on XL bullies will just lead to people getting a different potential savage beast that’s still legal. How about an Akita?

I don't think Akitas, much like Belgian malinois & Caucasian shepherds, will ever attain the same level of popularity, as if they are kept/managed inadequately they have no problem letting their handlers bloody well know about it.

They're a lot more niche & difficult to live with on a day to day basis, if they're bored they will destroy the house or bark incessantly, if they are handled poorly they will retaliate.

The reason bull breeds are popular is because they are comparatively easy dogs to live with & will put up with all manner of mismanagement by their owners.

I think it will be one of the other sizes od American bully (there are several), corsi or another bull breed or bull breed mix, like bull herders, that are the next 'thing'.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/02/2024 13:35

Babsexxx · 05/02/2024 13:20

Highly doubtful though I still see a good few red nose pitbulls about and they where meant to be banned in 1991! It’s shocking they will find a way around it! Bring back the dog license I say!

Are "redness pitbulls" particularly aggressive? This is interesting. I've never heard about this, but I do know that aggressive traits in many breeds are often associated with particular colours.(eg golden cockers are more likely to be snappy than black, apricot poodles than other colours) etc, and there are also some colours which are more associated with trainability eg solid coloured cockers are reputedly easier to train and more biddable than the broken colours ones. (I say reputedly because I don't know if this is merely apocryphal, but I do know that most people I personally know who have working dogs prefer the solid colours.)

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 05/02/2024 13:35

kitsuneghost · 05/02/2024 13:32

Owning any dog (or other dangerous animal) should be licensed.
By license I don't mean fill a form, pay some money and job done
I mean visits and assessments by animal experts to assess the environment and the fitness and mental health of the prospective owner.
Dog types (if any) should be given permission based on these assessments.

The license should also be removable with change in circumstances or complaints

In an ideal world, yes, but that would be so expensive and difficult to administer in the real world that it would pretty much be impossible.

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 05/02/2024 13:33

Sususudio · 05/02/2024 12:02

Thread has gone as expected, Cars, cats and collies compared to XL Bullies. And a bit of victim blaming.

Which side of the debate do you stand on, sususudio?

It was me that mentioned collies, I did so because they are a good example of innate breed characteristics/behaviours being expressed in pet line dogs. There are others (Jack Russell's digging, retrievers carrying things in their mouths, beagles and their difficulties with recall...). Why people can accept breed characteristics in some breeds but absolutely deny them in others baffles me.

Babsexxx · 05/02/2024 13:32

Yeah my auntie worked as a vet many years ago and said red cockers where extremely susceptible to it suffered terribly with rage syndrome it was like a pandemic terrible! Exactly these dog bites are capable of deaf! I have a cocker and she’s a lovely beautiful dog who I can physically manage and handle! Why people even entertain getting ANY breed of dog the cannot over power themselves is beyond me!

kitsuneghost · 05/02/2024 13:32

Owning any dog (or other dangerous animal) should be licensed.
By license I don't mean fill a form, pay some money and job done
I mean visits and assessments by animal experts to assess the environment and the fitness and mental health of the prospective owner.
Dog types (if any) should be given permission based on these assessments.

The license should also be removable with change in circumstances or complaints

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 05/02/2024 13:29

The ban guidelines are bullshit, the ban is ill thought out and rushed through.
ive lived through it being Rottweilers being the problem, then staffs, then pit bulls and now xl bullies.
the bans do not work. People just move onto a different breed or type.

the xl bully breed doesn’t exist, so you’ve loads of Heinz dogs caught up in it who happen to meet it. It’s always the same owners finding ways round it. They’ll find a way round this. We need decent breeding and owning regulation it would also stop things like the obscene frog / toad craze being common place.
that all said we can’t even stop people cropping ears in this country and that’s been banned for decades.

Tracker1234 · 05/02/2024 13:28

The owner of this dog has one brain cell although he thinks he is is the dogs bollocks. Hard man that he is. How did I know he looked like that, already had a child, lived in a tiny house and then his tiny brain decided he would breed XL bullies and sell on.

BECAUSE HE IS ALLOWED TO!!! THE NEIGHBOURS MUST BE SICK OF HIM THROWING HIS WEIGHT AROUND THE NEIGHBOURHOOD.

Must judge at all though....

DdraigGoch · 05/02/2024 13:26

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 08:02

Question to the 4% of voters who feel the owner of these dogs that kill shouldn't be sent down for 5 years minimum. Surely it's a lethal weapon?

What's your view then, the 4%?

It would be nice if the man who killed someone when doing twice the speed limit got as much as five years - he got four and will probably be out in two. The widow and children have effectively got a life sentence. Sentences are pathetic all round.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/02/2024 13:25

Thindog · 05/02/2024 13:23

I think the ban on XL bullies will just lead to people getting a different potential savage beast that’s still legal. How about an Akita?

Akitas are beautiful but unpredictable dogs - and very strong.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/02/2024 13:24

Babsexxx · 05/02/2024 13:05

YANBU I am absolutely sick to death of seeing all these unnecessary deaths that are completely avoidable! I am however worried sick for scotland I joined some xl bully sites on sm just purely to see what was going on and what all these idiots where going to do keep them or get rid and the bus loads of them going up to Scotland was shockingggg!

Then not to mention the huge fallouts from people lying about the dogs temperaments! Plenty of upset from original owners pissing and crying because they have had there dogs returned even tied up to there front gardens etc it is absolutely ludicrous!!!!

Ive got a bloke on my sm who regularly updates photos of his unleashed unmuzzled xl on walks! Like he is begging to be reported! Maybe these idiots are actually waking up to them having these killing machines and low key hoping they will be reported/dog removed!

Golden retrievers (and golden cockers) at one time had a strain which tended to "rage syndrome" - the dogs would attack anything and anyone, out of the blue with no warning. (I don't know the cause - possibly a form of epilepsy?). However through careful breeding by responsible breeders this has been eliminated as a breed trait, though it can occasionally turn up in any badly-bred/ inbred animal. The border collie I mentioned in a previous post exhibited this, and was totally unaware of his surroundings during the episode, and often seemed confused and very meek when the (thankfully short - usually less than a minute) episode had passed. He was euthanised.

However I can't imagine that even the worst of them presents a tenth of the threat of the average XL bully.

Bishopsgirl · 05/02/2024 13:24

It should also be against the law to have one of these dogs if you have children or children visiting the house. If the owner had told the poor grandma to take a broom to the puppies if they started fighting, then he'd probably told his young son to do exactly the same thing. This whole set up was a ticking time bomb.

Thindog · 05/02/2024 13:23

I think the ban on XL bullies will just lead to people getting a different potential savage beast that’s still legal. How about an Akita?

Swizzlersandtwizzlers · 05/02/2024 13:22

It's a pity they didn't report these illegal puppies before someone was killed. Had the pups been taken away and euthanised (or at least confiscated so that he couldn't sell or otherwise dispose of them), and the owner prosecuted, this poor woman may still be alive, and that poor little boy wouldn't have had to witness his grandmother being slaughtered.

Exactly, it says something that they all went along with this . I’d be making a stand and refusing to engage with the dogs and asking for them to be locked away or meeting my relative outside away from the dog.

When a close friend got a pitbull type dog - I stopped visiting for several years which meant I couldn’t babysit anymore, but would still take her kids out on day trips. About 7 years the dog sadly attacked her middle child and she got rid of it anyway.

The fact they all continued to visit the house and interact with the dogs without reporting anything speaks volumes. I really hope there’s at least one sensible person in the family who can look after the boy.

Not to mention, people shouldn't have their lives dependent on whether a random stranger is a 'good owner' or not. There is no place in our society for that level of risk, for whether someone lives or dies while popping to the shops is reliant on how good the owner of that dog is. You will never eradicate bad owners, it isn't possible. I'd still like to survive, thanks.

This is so true. I don’t even engage in the bad owner vs bad breed debate because it’s pointless. If someone is attacked, it will be of no comfort to them that it’s the “owners fault”

I agree with the poster who said the government need to stand up to the dog lobby. So do businesses etc. i was in a brunch place and this dog couldn’t leave me alone. I couldn’t see the owner, think they must’ve been round the corner on a table out of my line of vision. So I had to ask the staff to get it away from me, but why all cafes & restaurants don’t insist dogs are kept on leashes is beyond me? Why is it ever acceptable to have a customers dog wandering around? I just left the cafe as I didn’t feel comfortable and left a review describing what’s happened. More businesses need to know not everyone - including dog owners - see dog friendly venues as a positive.

OpieMo · 05/02/2024 13:21

ThereIbledit · 05/02/2024 13:15

Whilst I behave much like you do if I see an unmuzzled XL in public, I'm not sure it's right to cast aspersions on the lady who died. She was there to see her grandson, who had a father who owned and bred XL. It's him I don't peg as very educated, and if I'm casting aspersions on anybody it's the many who breeds XL bullies and keeps them int he same home as his son - I could well believe that he said to the kid's grandmother - a woman who has no legal rights to access the grandson - that she can see her grandson at his home or not at all.

WWYD in those circumstances? I'm not sure I'd make the same choice if there was my grandson involved or not.

Personally, there is quite literally nothing that would entice me to enter into a home with an XL Bully present. Even if it meant being told I couldn't see my relative anywhere else. The risk is too great. Look at this tragic situation, she might have gone to see her grandson but he has ended up experiencing horrific trauma witnessing what happened. Now he doesn't even have his grandmother.

The pro-pitbull faction have a LOT to answer for, you just have to look and you see endless 'they're soft as anything, daft as a brush, more likely to lick you to death haha' nonsense. People who are less educated or less willing to do their own research can easily fall for it. Which is wild considering we have a survival instinct that should naturally recoil in the presence of these animals. I don't mean to sound like I'm blaming the dead, just saying, nobody should be complacent. Don't let family or friends gaslight you into agreeing to go and be in the same room as these animals. It's not worth losing your limbs, or your life.