Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies

584 replies

ABCDEFGHIJK123456 · 05/02/2024 07:36

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies whilst apparently separating fighting bully pups.

Longer jail sentences, minimum of 5 years for owners of dogs that kill people for not controlling them.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
RubyEarWax · 05/02/2024 17:19

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/02/2024 17:19

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 05/02/2024 15:26

I agree with you. Unfortunately, XL's don't appear to have a 'pet strain' line at all and instead seem to be a toxic combination of intensively bred for purpose (reactive aggression) and utterly unsuitable environment (overcrowded homes, young families, insecurely fenced, no socialisation, no appropriate enrichment or redirection of unwanted behaviours).

I agree.

There will never be a "pet strain" of a breed like this.

Fizbosshoes · 05/02/2024 17:17

Dj spoony was on the radio last week to defend XL bullies (he got one as a family pet and it allegedly proves everyone who thinks it's unsuitable, wrong, when they see what a big softy he is 🙄)

The nature/nurture argument. Irresponsible dog owners will be and are irresponsible with any type of dog. However the risks are too great when an irresponsible owner is combined with an aggressive breed of dog who weighs the same as an adult human. There was a dog mentioned on the radio that weighed 52kg, last week.
Last year in some news story there was a dog that weighed 12st. I imagine even the most experienced and responsible owner would struggle to control, or , if needed, overpower a breed that big. There surely has to come a point where the size/muscle mass/jaw strength etc has to make it unsuitable as a domestic pet in any circumstances.

Most fatal dog attacks seem to happen in a home setting so the muzzle in public won't prevent that.

Funshrubs · 05/02/2024 17:15

SweetBirdsong · 05/02/2024 14:34

Sadly I have to agree with your posts @Ravensky I don't like the idea of an eye for an eye (makes the world go blind and all that!) But you're right - this country needs much stiffer sentences for EVERYTHING, including people who breed aggressive dogs (basically train them to be aggressive.)

There is a whole generation of horrible, entitled-to, aggressive 'I will do what the fuck I like' arseholes in the UK now - in fact probably 2 generations and possibly a 3rd - who think they can do what they want and are constantly breaking the law.

TV documentaries feature them, like the police chase programmes, the nightmare tenants ones, and even the hospital/ambulance ones. Littered with ugly abusive, vile articles - many whom have never done a day's paid work in their life, and act like the world owes them a living. Shouting and spitting at the police and attacking paramedics, and causing fights and brawls outside clubs and pubs, and carrying weapons (knives and shivs etc.)

I'm in my mid-late 50s - and I was a child/youth in the 1970s and 1980s, and I NEVER remember behaviour like this, or people like this. I have no idea where it all went wrong, and when this type of person emerged.

This type of person is one of the reasons me and DH moved to a little rural village off the beaten track. 4 miles from a little town, with less than 400 people, no buses, no shops, no nothing, just a Church and a pub, and a village hall where they have social events for people. Oh and a little primary school that has 31 pupils - just 2 classes. And one nursery. So 9 kids in the nursery, 11 in class 1 (that has 5 to 8 year olds,) and 11 in class 2 that has 9 to 11 year olds.

There are another 20 or so 11-18 y.o. kids but they go to the Comprehensive school in town. The bus takes them and brings and back every school day. The kids here are hugely respectful and polite and pleasant. And there are ZERO people like 'that type' in my village.

It's like a breath of fresh air being here compared to the town we lived in before for some years. It was fine 25 years ago and earlier, when we were a lot younger, but since around the late 1990s, it has got quite rough in some parts. Lots of crime and violence in some parts of the town. Where we lived was OK, but was only half a mile from a 'rough area,' and a lot of break-ins and car thefts started to occur near us, and you never felt safe outside your own garden after dark/after 7pm...

You can hear a pin drop at night here, there's nothing but fields and woodlands for 4 miles, (and the canal and the river.) And I can walk for miles - even in the evening/in the dark, and feel perfectly safe!

!

Edited

The exact same reason why I’m so glad and thank my lucky stars everyday that I live rurally and can bring my DC up rurally.

I feel so sorry for people (especially people with young families) that live in these horrible neighbourhoods/ towns/ cities that can’t afford to leave and have to put up with encountering arseholes like this on a daily basis.

The U.K. has gone to shit.

Ravensky · 05/02/2024 17:13

@SweetBirdsong completely agree with you. Its so sad to see communities deteriorating like they are with seemingly no one or no organisation trying to stop the rot as it were. Council estates used to be a hell of a lot safer than they are now and many were lovely communities to bring up children.

I was literally having the same conversation with someone yesterday about the road we grew up on 25/38 years ago. There was maybe one family who were considered a bit of a pain but it that amounted to them being maybe a bit untidy and their kids being a bit loud and occasionally picking fights with other kids in the street. But it was always incredibly safe for children to play out.

Now it's a different story.

Now it's at least half the road that cause trouble and the trouble is on a whole other level. It's drugs, violence between adults and teens/kids, shouting and screaming in the street, driving like absolute idiots. Never safe for children to be out playing anymore and of course, XL bullies.

I too moved away and live similarly to yourself and I'm so glad I do but I feel so sorry for my friends and family that have to live near these types of people.

It seems to me, you're okay if you're wealthy enough to be able to choose to not life anywhere near scum or you're the scum. Everyone in middle has to suffer the scum.

The scum breed like bloody rats as well but the authorities have neither the will nor the funds to do anything about it because guess what? They're wealthy enough to not have to live near the scum themselves.

Morvillehrs · 05/02/2024 17:12

I’m not scared of dogs, grew up around different breeds but these terrify me, I walk with a limp and one dog (xl bully) looked irked by it, looked like it wanted to rip my face off. And the muppet walking it couldn’t control the lead.

Its not the dogs fault they were bred and I’m sure they are generally okay but that one time they go they really go and there’s no getting them off you. So sorry for yet another victim.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 05/02/2024 17:05

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 05/02/2024 16:21

I queried because 911 isn't the number for police or any emergency service in the UK and a Met police offer would know that.

I got it mixed up in my mind. He probably did say 999. I mistakenly thought the number had changed. I was wrong.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 05/02/2024 17:03

Pallando · 05/02/2024 16:12

I have to post in defence of Dobermans! If you look up deaths from dogs in the UK, there is only one Doberman in the list and if you look at the details it seems that the dog was trying to help its own who had had a seizure.

We have a 21 month old Dobie, and we have to be careful of people in the house as he loves everyone so much he sometimes manages to give them a "Glasgow Kiss" in his enthusiasm. He tried to jump into the plumbers arms...

He is super-tolerant as well (of our kids and the 9 month old sprocker). I wouldn't let him loose near small children as he is big and clumsy. I have lost count of the number of little old ladies who want to say hello as they had Dobermans in the past!

I have had words with him about the fact that he is bred to be a personal protection dog, and he can't do that if he is a mile away chasing deer (he is not let of the lead outside secure fields any more).

Breed does matter, but also the individual dog!

My grandad in Germany had a childhood Doberman dog who was very loyal and a family dog as well as protective.

My uncle and aunt in England had a Doberman too, who was the soppiest thing ever with family and friends but sounded aggressive when barking and could attack burglars if needed. Fine when they had children.

My other aunt and uncle had and have long haired German Shepherd dogs who are family and protective dogs.

Totally down to owners and training of their dogs. Some breeds are stronger and harder to control.

elledee412 · 05/02/2024 17:03

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 05/02/2024 08:47

All dogs that a toddler could not beat in a fight should be put in grave. No exceptions.

This is unhinged. You’d have all Golden Retrivers, Labs, Shepherds, Setters, most Spaniels, and almost every other family dog put to sleep? All of those breeds - and plenty more perfectly safe breeds - are bigger than a toddler.

somekittenmittens · 05/02/2024 16:55

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 05/02/2024 13:55

Thank you for mansplaining.

Where is the mansplaining?

whatistheworld · 05/02/2024 16:50

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 10:29

Dogs are animals, they have sentience, they behave like, well, animals. You cannot hold a person responsible for murder or manslaughter because a dog has killed someone

If owners cannot be held responsible it follows that they have no control over the animals, and therefore blows the "it's the owner not the dog" argument to pieces. And it follows from that, that the only effective way to protect the public is for nobody to be allowed to own a large dog that could seriously injure a human, including small children.

The UK is also very unusual in that so many people think it's acceptable to have any dog in a public place and not on a lead. The law needs to be changed so that any dogs not banned entirely based on size per the above must be on a lead at all times when not on someone's private property or in a registered and secure dog exercise field. Owners of dogs should also have to have their premises checked regularly to ensure they are secure with sufficiently high walls/ fences that dogs cannot escape from their property. This should be funded via dog licences that all dog owners must pay for. Anybody not complying with licencing rules should face a very large fine/ prison for non-payment and non-compliant dogs PTS.

We need to start prioritising people over dogs.

the difference here is that I would choose to stick my arm in a tiger cage and it would be MY fault. If I go for a walk and an XL bully dog attacks me, when I am just minding my own business, its the fault of the dog and the owner of the dog!!

If a tiger excaped from a zoo and killed people then the zoo would be responsible. They are animals and we need to treat them as such and be responsible for them at all times.

I have a dog, a labrador, that I walk off lead. I walk her off lead because she has 100% recall to my whistle, she is also trained to walk next to me if we meet another dog. If i tell her she can 'say hello' she may choose to interact with the other dog. If i say nothing she will walk beside me. That is because I have TRAINED her. I have spent HOURS doing this and I am aware of where she is at all times.
She would be on a lead on footpaths at all times too.

I am a responsible owner, she has been neutered, microchipped and insured.

oakleaffy · 05/02/2024 16:49

icelolly12 · 05/02/2024 16:31

Owners of dogs should also have to have their premises checked regularly to ensure they are secure with sufficiently high walls/ fences that dogs cannot escape from their property.

You're living in cloud cuckoo land 😂

I wanted to adopt a tiny Lurcher from RSPCA...they insisted on 2 metre high fencing or no dog!
I'm very glad they did insist, as it meant I didn't have to worry when she was in the back garden.
Fence {custom made bespoke} cost way more than she did.
Good fences make good neighbours.

Dog warden came round to check as well!

oakleaffy · 05/02/2024 16:43

SicParvisMagna · 05/02/2024 15:53

I live in Clacton, so just down the road from Jaywick. Brooklands, where this happened is one of the most deprived areas in not just the UK but I'm sure I read somewhere in the whole of Europe. The lady who went back inside after hearing screaming? Probably used to it. Whenever Jaywick is in the local news it's all "ohhh they're all salt of the earth that lot. Wouldn't hurt a fly". Total and utter bollocks. Crime, drugs etc is rife. Police don't really go there unless they absolutely have to. The whole place needs bulldozing.
It is a hell hole. A lot of the houses were built as holiday chalets in the 50's. They were not designed for living in. Some don't even have basic amenities. They are also tiny. I'm talking glorifed garden sheds. The idea of having that many dogs in there is horrific, let alone ones as big as XL bullies. The scrote who owned these is my age. I'm not sure if he's local enough to have gone to the local secondary schools. I don't recognise him but I do recognise his attitude. His sneer. Lots of blokes this way have it. I'll be honest the amount of staffs and bullie type dogs down this way I'm actually amazed it hasn't happened sooner.
That poor poor 11 year old.

Edited

I googled...It does indeed seem desperately run down.
Trip advisor said it's grim, too with dog shit in abundance and dirty nappies strewn on the 'beach'.
Expect those that can get the hell out ..it looks like a sort of run down trailer park crossed with a shanty town.

Grandmother killed by 2 XL bullies
0MammaBear0 · 05/02/2024 16:39

We need tough jail sentences for irresponsable owners who don't register and neuter their restricted dog breeds... These bully breeds are a menace to public safety!! What some people don't know is that these dogs were bred and selected to be violent and deadly to fight in pit fights for sport... They're genetically wired to kill

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 05/02/2024 16:33

Pallando · 05/02/2024 16:12

I have to post in defence of Dobermans! If you look up deaths from dogs in the UK, there is only one Doberman in the list and if you look at the details it seems that the dog was trying to help its own who had had a seizure.

We have a 21 month old Dobie, and we have to be careful of people in the house as he loves everyone so much he sometimes manages to give them a "Glasgow Kiss" in his enthusiasm. He tried to jump into the plumbers arms...

He is super-tolerant as well (of our kids and the 9 month old sprocker). I wouldn't let him loose near small children as he is big and clumsy. I have lost count of the number of little old ladies who want to say hello as they had Dobermans in the past!

I have had words with him about the fact that he is bred to be a personal protection dog, and he can't do that if he is a mile away chasing deer (he is not let of the lead outside secure fields any more).

Breed does matter, but also the individual dog!

I’m old enough to remember when dobermans and Rottweilers were the status dog of choice and people were calling for them to be banned.

the same shit dog owners that exist now existed then, they moved on to the next “type” of choice. The dogs are victims of fashions. Only now they breed them to spec, the poor monstrosity’s created. It’s not fair on the dogs produced, to be breed to ultimately die.

that’s what the law needs to address, it’s always the shit humans doing this to animals. Wether In poor breeding or poor ownership.

icelolly12 · 05/02/2024 16:31

Owners of dogs should also have to have their premises checked regularly to ensure they are secure with sufficiently high walls/ fences that dogs cannot escape from their property.

You're living in cloud cuckoo land 😂

thenightsky · 05/02/2024 16:27

Mrsjayy · 05/02/2024 15:57

I watched a programme years ago about Jaywick it was either presented by Ross Kemp or Danny Dyer anyway people were basically living in a run down pontins and the "salt of the earths" were terrifying!

Oh yes, I remember watching some of that programme. The houses/chalets looked barely habitable.

BeaLola · 05/02/2024 16:26

Assuming the reports I have heard are correct and it was her grandsons father who was the owner and the child lived in that house and the father owned the dogs and puppies then it is an extremely sad world we live in that he prioritised those dogs over his own child.

peakygold · 05/02/2024 16:25

The whole breed should be exterminated. No-one should die like that.

MalcolmTuckersSwearBox · 05/02/2024 16:21

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 05/02/2024 15:54

Yes I just told you! He said he had just come off duty and didn’t have his stab vest on and if he did have it on, he would’ve stepped in.

Sounds like you don’t believe me but it’s true! Even the shopkeeper didn’t want to get involved.

I’m not naming the area but it sits cheek by jowl with what used to be a deprived area but has got gentrified in last 15 years or so. So it’s not as rough as eg heart of Brixton or Stockwell.

Edited

I queried because 911 isn't the number for police or any emergency service in the UK and a Met police offer would know that.

couiza · 05/02/2024 16:19

I wish they'd ban all domestic dogs. Really I do, I am sick of them everywhere and the idolisation of their owners, who expect me to ooh and aah and suffer them everywhere I go. If I open my mouth to object to a dog running towards me the owner often replies, ah s/he's just playing etc. No not with me they're not. Can't go for a walk, for a coffee, to the shop, for a drink without these hairy creatures all in these places with me.

Working dogs are all that should be allowed. There is no room left for people in urban areas not to mind thousands of dogs. Begone!

I am a bit wired about this subject because 15 years ago I was attacked by a large dog in the local park. Knocked me down and I suffer the consequences of that injury to this day. So nothing will change my mind. I do not like what dogs are doing to our environment and our quality of life.

So there, I feel better after getting that out.

I am terribly sorry for the lady who died.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 05/02/2024 16:16

Angrycat2768 · 05/02/2024 16:13

The problem with the 'Its not the dogs its the owners' is that aggressive shits who don't know how to control dangerous dogs and have no intention of being responsible always go for dogs that cause the maximum damage. You don't get these morons walking round with a cockapoo on a lead. It's a bit late to say 'Oh you're a bad owner' once a dog has killed someone and been shot dead as a result.

The bans don’t address these owners though. They just move on to the next status dog, it’s happened for as long as I’ve been alive.
so both statements are true. It’s not the dogs it’s the owner, and it’s the breeder that produces the status breed capable of this

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/02/2024 16:16

Like everything else and it is a huge failing with so much in the UK, there is little enforcement of the law

Ain't that the truth jasflowers Sad

Angrycat2768 · 05/02/2024 16:13

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

The problem with the 'Its not the dogs its the owners' is that aggressive shits who don't know how to control dangerous dogs and have no intention of being responsible always go for dogs that cause the maximum damage. You don't get these morons walking round with a cockapoo on a lead. It's a bit late to say 'Oh you're a bad owner' once a dog has killed someone and been shot dead as a result.

Pallando · 05/02/2024 16:12

This reply has been deleted

Troll banned

I have to post in defence of Dobermans! If you look up deaths from dogs in the UK, there is only one Doberman in the list and if you look at the details it seems that the dog was trying to help its own who had had a seizure.

We have a 21 month old Dobie, and we have to be careful of people in the house as he loves everyone so much he sometimes manages to give them a "Glasgow Kiss" in his enthusiasm. He tried to jump into the plumbers arms...

He is super-tolerant as well (of our kids and the 9 month old sprocker). I wouldn't let him loose near small children as he is big and clumsy. I have lost count of the number of little old ladies who want to say hello as they had Dobermans in the past!

I have had words with him about the fact that he is bred to be a personal protection dog, and he can't do that if he is a mile away chasing deer (he is not let of the lead outside secure fields any more).

Breed does matter, but also the individual dog!

Swipe left for the next trending thread