Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the school should do something?

92 replies

Bwahaha · 05/02/2024 03:25

My children go to a primary school in London with children from diverse national and religious backgrounds. There are no rules around what food parents are allowed to bring into the classroom except the usual ban on nuts.
As a result, children are constantly getting a ton of treats: it really adds up with more than twenty birthdays, lots of national, international, and religious holidays. Once the class rep even brought cupcakes to celebrate their dog’s birthday.
Last week alone my child had fairy bread for Australia day heaped with hundreds and thousands, a cake takeaway, and a massive cupcake with tons of sugar cream for someone’s birthday the next day. As you can imagine, they simultaneously took a 3 day holiday from dinner.

AIBU to think the school leadership are missing in action here? And should maybe help the parents understand this is not ok?
Also, if you’re a parent, knowing what we know about sugar today, do you really think it’s ok to give other people’s kids treats all the time without asking?

OP posts:
Tempnamechng · 05/02/2024 08:50

It isn't going to be every day though, is it. There are approx 30 children per class, and if each child brought in class treats a couple of times a year- once for their birthday, and once for their dog's birthday or religious festival, then you are averaging twice per year per child, which is 1.5 treats per week tops during term time. Just make sure they eat healthier at home and let them celebrate with their friends. Many cultures use sharing food as a way of strengthening their community ties.

Bwahaha · 05/02/2024 08:49

To those saying that there’s nothing wrong with having a bit of sugar every day, that’s true if you’re having a bit of fruit, but I’m not sure that’s actually right if you’re talking cakes and so on.

There’s a lot of science out there, quoting a Harvard study “Consuming foods and beverages high in added sugars during childhood is linked to the development of risk factors for hear disease, including an increased risk of obesity and elevated blood pressure.” & “Schools, parents, health professionals, and policy makers should work together to help children develop healthier eating and drinking habits at early age.”

Sugar is basically the new “smoking”.

And even if it were 100% healthy, why should other parents get to decide for me how often and how much sugar my child has access to? I find this quite undermines parenting strategies around how to develop healthy eating habits. For example, I may promise my child we’ll bake a cake on Thursday only to find out at pick up that they’ve already had a big cupcake with icing.

OP posts:
Yesnosorryplease · 05/02/2024 08:40

Primary schools have 10 year olds in too. And it's entirely reasonable for you to have conversations from the get go with your child about different parents having different rules.

This doesn't go away op, how do you manage parties etc? In those early years of school my DC went to parties and ate rubbish nearly every weekend. That really did spoil their appetite for dinner at home. I just went with the flow, made sure we ate a healthy selection of nutritious food at home and took good care of their teeth.

Now they're in high school they are able to choose what they like in the canteen and could go to the shop and buy rubbish every day if they so choose. Luckily mine don't, (maybe because they haven't been hugely restricted?) And they largely make healthy and balanced choices.

I would be really wary of inflating this into a massive issue. Raise your concerns with school, talk to your child and ask them not to eat anything without asking you, but keep it all in perspective.

AbsentCause · 05/02/2024 08:12

It’s not just a bit of sugar here and there. It’s most days, sometimes twice (Cubs, swimming, afterschool club etc often join in). Around Christmas and Easter it’s even more.

It means cake / sweets are no longer a treat (in the sense of something you have on a special occasion) but a daily part of their diet. That isn’t how I eat, and isn’t an healthy habit, in my opinion. And it meant I felt I couldn’t give them much sugar at home as they got so much elsewhere.

I’d ask primary school for a discussion about it, and offer solutions and alternatives that have been suggested on this thread.

Spendonsend · 05/02/2024 08:09

I agree OP. The schools my children went to had this rule and the schools i work at did too.

timesogin · 05/02/2024 08:03

On self control - actually mine are very self controlled and are in the early years of school. They ask if they can have something handed out at the end of the day and depending on time and plans I'll either say yea or have it for pudding.
They don't 'guzzle' but can keep things in a sweet box and have a little bit at a time.

Being over controlling and clearly conveying messages about how often you can have sugar does set it up as 'bad' whereas having a little bit most days helps them regulate and not put it in their heads as something really extra special

Things handed out at school shouldn't stop baking and ice cream at the weekend or at home unless you have decided to only have it once or twice a week. Which in itself is conveying a message that leads them to 'guzzle' when they get the opportunity

BendingSpoons · 05/02/2024 07:19

At our school, if you want to give out sweets, they do it at pick up time. That way the parents can say no if they want and can intervene so it isn't eaten straight away. Obviously it's trickier when it is a cupcake, rather than a wrapped sweet.

As an aside, I don't find it easy to give out something cheap that is not sugary and not plasticity either!

Bwahaha · 05/02/2024 07:10

@HoppingPavlova Have you ever seen 4 and 5 year olds exercising a great deal of self control? Turning down chocolates and sugary treats while all their classmates happily guzzle them?
I did mention this is primary school in my OP - we’re not talking 10 year olds who should know better.

And to others who have suggested filling a form out: yes I could ask the school to leave my child out when treats are distributed. And how do you think they would feel then? I don’t think it would be fair to single out my child just because the school won’t do their job in gatekeeping and saying no to parents who should know better.

Also, for those saying a bit of sugar here and there can’t hurt, yes, I agree. But when your children start having it in school all the time you start to feel curtailed in your ability to serve it at home and do fun things like baking or going out for an ice cream because you know other parents have been giving your child cake while you entrust the school with their care.

OP posts:
Contraversialcate · 05/02/2024 07:08

I’d say majority of kids it does impact their meal. Plus childhood obesity crisis. Plus inclusion of all the class. 2 out of my
3 DD can’t eat most of the stuff handed out

Sugargliderwombat · 05/02/2024 07:06

Just say it nicely and you won't be 'that' parent. It's quite unusual for schools to do this. We ask parents to bring either something healthier or something tiny like bubbles to give out. Some children have bought the class a book before, too.

Contraversialcate · 05/02/2024 07:06

I am so totally with you. We get sweets for 30 kids bdays and it really impacts my DD. Let alone her sister cannot have sugar due to a rare genetic condition so we are quite strict as a family and he sister won’t be allowed any of the stuff handed out at the school gate. I asked school to consider putting a stop to it for 3 reasons 1) health of our kids 2) cost / not everyone can afford it 3) inclusion and intolerances / allergies. Suggested bday kid brought in their favourite book to read instead. Was given flat no, it’s not their problem what parents hand out. I might take in some gummies or special brownies next time lol

Airdustmoon · 05/02/2024 07:03

My DC’s school banned sweets and cakes for birthdays, to encourage healthy eating and teeth etc. It didn’t deter anyone, the birthday DC just stands outside the school gates a little bit away from the entrance handing them out instead, and the parent sends a message to the class WhatsApp group saying it’s the DC’s birthday and they’ll be there. At least as a parent you can control it if you don’t want your child to have any but going out of the other exit, although I think it’s harmless as it’s usually a teeny bag of haribo or a lolly.

The dog’s birthday cupcakes, Australia Day etc is taking it too far though.

Bwahaha · 05/02/2024 06:57

@Neodymium That’s a really interesting point about Australia day. Another parent in the class was pointing out that sometimes when parents come into class to lead activities for these celebrations they can be insensitive to the diverse opinions or experiences of children in the room.

According to the Australian mums leading this activity it’s common to have “Fairy cake” on Australia day which consists of bread covered in heaps of hundreds and thousands.

Oops. This may actually be a bit outing (but I have name changed for the occasion).

OP posts:
LaPalmaLlama · 05/02/2024 06:56

They probably just need to limit the number of occasions so maybe birthdays ( children not dogs)only. Then it’s going to be max once every couple of weeks given some kids won’t do it and others have birthdays in the holidays and then some will double up if kids have birthdays close to each other.

IloveAslan · 05/02/2024 06:52

WaitingfortheTardis · 05/02/2024 04:55

I think that sounds lovely actually, dd earts healthily at home so I've no problem with the birthday cupcakes and other treats that come around. I'd be sad to see them stopped as i also think it's a social thing. I don't really see why one treat in a day means your child doesn't eat their dinner.

I agree. This all sounds a bit ridiculous, a bit of sugar every day is not going to harm them.

HFJ · 05/02/2024 06:46

Regarding the cultural tolerance aspect, if I were a savvy headteacher I’d be inviting said parents to join the parent commitee. Then I’d have the curriculum lead meet with them to gauge the possibility of augmenting the curriculum with a ‘world foods day’.

timesogin · 05/02/2024 06:39

I think you are massively over-reacting
Childhood obesity and rotten teeth aren't being driven by a snack a week from school
It's normal to celebrate events with sweet things - because they taste nice
And if your kid wasn't hungry for dinner you could have moved it a bit later or given them something lighter. It sounds like they were honouring their hunger.
Why spoil it for everyone?

ComeAlongPeggy · 05/02/2024 06:37

One of our previous (state) schools banned bringing in things to eat for birthdays. Instead, each child was encouraged to bring a book to donate to the library instead. SO much better. (And actually cheaper than making 30 cupcakes!)

HFJ · 05/02/2024 06:33

I recommend you write a letter/email to the headteacher and chair of governors stating the following:

  1. you are concerned about the number of sweet treats being handed out to children on a regular basis
  2. despite the good intentions behind this, it undermines your authority as a parent and also means that your home cooked meals are going to waste as it disrupts your children’s hunger signals
  3. you are concerned about the impact on dental health
  4. the fact that this appears to be the norm means that there will be some struggling parents who feel undue pressure provide similar treats when they cannot afford to

I did exactly this after the umpteenth day of my children bouncing out of school holding a bag of haribo because it was yet another pupil’s birthday.

Headteacher and CoG got back to me straight away. ‘This is exactly what we needed to have the warrant to put in place a new policy’.

The whole phenomenon was banned.

my children have never forgiven me

Yesnosorryplease · 05/02/2024 06:25

How does having a cake at 3pm lead to your child not eating dinner? My DC eat almost continually....

I just can't get exercised about this stuff. My DC have a very healthy diet at home, we take good care of their teeth, they are very active and healthy weights. If you know they've had sweet treats at school then just calibrate and have less at home those days? Or just explain to your DC that they are to say "thank you but not for me" if you feel strongly about certain things. All my DC have JW classmates who do this. I have taught my DC to avoid things other people have touched as I'm paranoid about sickness bugs, so they say no to cakes but yes to for eg sweets in packets.

One of my DC has lots of children at school who are having a very hard time (refugee hotel) and can't attend parties and celebrations outside of school, so that class have actually upped the celebrations in school to ensure they are included as much as possible. There's also been a lot of sharing of different foods/traditions from around the world and that's been great for all the DC to expand their knowledge and horizons a bit.

eggbot · 05/02/2024 06:19

There are other ways to celebrate than stuffing your face with crap everyday

HappyDaze23 · 05/02/2024 06:17

Our school doesn’t allow food to be brought in. Lollipops (which I also don’t agree with) can be purchased from the school office if you feel it essential to give a treat on a birthday. I think this is the right approach.

It isn’t just the sugar for me, I have a child who is allergic to dairy, eggs, lentils, nuts and sesame. Having to navigate both his safety and his exclusion from multiple celebrations every week would be so stressful.

firstbabyworries · 05/02/2024 06:14

*disagree not disadvantage!
Another poster said about teaches children self control. Yes absolutely, however, this is school, why are the school not teaching different ways to celebrate rather than guzzling mountains of sugar and additives? Surely if we as parents taught self control but then the school didn't shove these things at our kids that would be better?
On another point, how do you expect a 2 year old to feel if all the friends are eating cake or sweets but he knows he's not supposed to? Either feel different, or do it in secret, great, well done!

Neodymium · 05/02/2024 06:13

I’m Australian and we barely celebrate Australia Day here. It’s offensive to the First Nations people as it’s celebrating a day of mourning for them. Yes we get a day off but most enlightened Australians don’t celebrate anything. Actually most people I saw celebrating were the new immigrants who got their citizenship on Australia Day.

i wouldn’t even like my kids to be part of any celebration for Australia Day that is absurd.

dog thing is absurd too. Kids bday fair enough.

firstbabyworries · 05/02/2024 06:07

@Bwahaha I have had this conversation with my child's school. I honestly don't understand why we have this obsession with celebrating everything with sugar.
We have sweet things in the house(very little) but we in no way make them into a treat. It teaches the wrong kind of food association and like another poster said we have an obesity crisis as well as a dental crisis.
The school tried to tell me that they only do it as a celebration, which I said I disadvantage with, then explained that it may be a Christmas celebration, an Easter celebration, Diwali etc then it may also be the kids birthdays. I pointed out that it may become a celebration every week then. They are reviewing the policy.
They have also sent out healthy teeth fliers and introducing brushing teeth in the classroom.
Very strange word we live in

Swipe left for the next trending thread