Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I clear DHs debt with savings or take another card out for him to keep paying it back so he takes full responsibility for his mistake?

37 replies

Hazlenutlatte · 04/02/2024 20:17

DH has a credit card with £4.5k on it though it's in my name as my credit rating is a lot better than DHs, though so far he has made all payments towards it. It was a balance transfer at 0% for 18 month, DH has only managed to get it down for £4.5k from £7k during that term. I have been on maternity leave so have been unable to save anything to put towards it, I returned to work a few months ago.
There is no question that this is DHs debt, not mine. Long story short, he made a poor business decision that backfired massively and I took out the balance transfer card for him as he was paying over £100 a month in interest alone and he couldn't get one himself.

I earn a lot more than DH and now that I have returned to work I have been able to save some money. Maternity leave ate all our savings so I went back with very little left over.
However, I am projected to have saved £4000 by the time the 0% period comes to an end in April. DH should be able to cover the last £500 himself and it would clear the debt. I could then concentrate on starting to save up for us again.

DH works very hard and we split bills proportional to our income. But despite paying a lot more towards our bills, I still end up with more 'spare money' than DH does which we don't split, we just put in savings and they are for the family but technically, it's my money.
It's a bit of a bone of contention that we don't just split money all from one pot but DH is self employed, in a partnership and doesn't have a business bank account so it's very hard to work out exactly what is his money and what is the business' money so it has been his choice to agree what he needs to contribute towards family bills but otherwise keep our finances separate even though he'd definitely have more disposable income for himself if we split it but there we are. So I have saved this money but I do consider it 'our' money.

I don't want to take out another 0% balance transfer card as honestly it just irritates me being in my name and sat there every time I open my banking app reminding me what a mess DH let himself get into before he told me how deep he'd got himself. But he simply cannot afford to clear it himself and I can. I also doubt DHs credit rating is good enough to take out such a high card on a long term 0% deal now either. So if we did do this, it would still have to be in my name.

Do I just suck it up and pay it off and be done with it or do I take out another card and let DH keep paying it back, incredibly slowly.

I'm annoyed at DH no end but really want to be clear; he is a good man, a good dad and a good husband. He works very hard and pays what he can and earns enough that his contribution to our family finances does contribute to our quality of life. He just made a bad mistake and got overwhelmed by it. He didn't tell me what was happening because I was pregnant and very unwell in pregnancy and he was hoping he could sort it before he had to worry me, this didn't happen obviously. So please no 'LTB'. Just genuinely, what should I do? Pay it off with our savings or let DH keep paying slowly on another card in my name?

OP posts:
Nopicplease · 04/02/2024 20:29

I think if the balance is on a 0% card and you're earning interest on the savings, you should probably take out a new card and keep your savings.

Niegenug · 04/02/2024 20:28

I also think,it would be best to just use your savings to pay off the rest of the debt. Then to forget about it. With the issue around you having more spare money than him, to then ask him to repay you will likely breed resentment in the long run.

So clear it and start afresh. Just remind him that you won't be bailing him out again if he runs up credit card debt that you are not ware of/haven't jointly agreed.

AutumnFroglets · 04/02/2024 20:27

He gets his own card. He pays it off. He still seems financially irresponsible and no lesson has been learnt unfortunately.

Keep your finances seperate otherwise he will continue to pull you down too but one of you needs to ensure the baby has a roof over it's head.

EDIT - DH is self employed, in a partnership and doesn't have a business bank account so it's very hard to work out exactly what is his money and what is the business' money

I would find the above to be extremely concerning tbh.

Noicant · 04/02/2024 20:26

I would pay it off and draw a line under it too. If someone is a fundamentally decent human being who made a stupid mistake and you love them then yes of course you should step in rather than admonishing them. I’ve made mistakes, Dh has made mistakes, thats life. We try to learn and not do it again.

If you can help and you don’t then I think it could be really damaging, plus how would you want to be treated if you were in his shoes. Reciprocal empathy and sharing is really important in a marriage imo.

PussInBin20 · 04/02/2024 20:26

I would pay it off and not have to worry about it further but would make sure he knew you wouldn’t be impressed if he did it again.

Quitelikeit · 04/02/2024 20:25

Pay it off.

Why would you ask on here if you should pay his debt off?

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 04/02/2024 20:25

I would only consider clearing it if:

  1. he opens a seperate business a/c
  2. pays himself a regular wage from the business (he can always take a dividend or bonus if he makes more but he needs to establishbs minimum viable salary)
  3. he understands it's once only
PinkFrogss · 04/02/2024 20:24

What was it actually spent on?

Your finances sound very confusing.

GOODCAT · 04/02/2024 20:23

You pay it off and he pays you

fost · 04/02/2024 20:22

Whichever option annoys you the least.

I'd likely go for the extra card so he can clearly see his debt and carry on paying it down rather than thinking of it as all over and done with and perhaps doing something similar again, but if seeing it in your banking app pisses you off, then use savings to pay it off.

In the end it makes very little difference, either you'll have the money in savings or available credit on the card if you need it for an emergency, the only difference is the small amount of interest you'll gain if you keep the 4k in savings and have the debt on a 0% deal.

FloydWasACat · 04/02/2024 20:22

Pay it off and draw a line under. With the reminder of not to make silly financial decisions without discussing them. I get you OP, I really do but this could end up in bitterness and I don't think either of you want that.

Riverlee · 04/02/2024 20:20

I think dh has done quite well to get it down from £7k to £4.5k, so that’s £2.5 paid off.

Could you pay it off and dh pays you? Maybe set up a standing order to pay you directly each month.

Swipe left for the next trending thread