Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you vanished tomorrow, would your DP/DH care adequately for your kids?

185 replies

Naptrappedmummy · 04/02/2024 14:54

Mine would - but not to the standard I do. It wouldn’t be anything social services-worthy but food wouldn’t be wiped off faces, school uniform would probably be worn one day too many, dinner would be fish fingers and baked beans, the TV would be on too much. That sort of thing.

For some reason thinking about it makes me really stressed!

OP posts:
HappyAsASandboy · 04/02/2024 16:32

Adequately, yes. They'd be fed and washed and their clothes/homework/house would all be clean, complete and tidy.

They would essentially be left to raise themselves emotionally though. Hugs would be in short supply once the toddler years had passed. It would be a very efficient but mostly soulless household.

theleafandnotthetree · 04/02/2024 16:31

I think this is not a representative group - when I look around at the families I know, I could see serious deficits in how the children would be cared for and reared in quite a high proportion of cases. I think part of that is cultural, I'm in Ireland and the Irish Mammy is not just a stereotype. The average mum I know tends to so much in the family structure, arguably too much in terms of molly cuddling etc that the contrast would be enormous. Quite a few men I know, even if decent men and involved fathers to the extent of driving kids to activities etc, leave huge swathes of childbearing, decision making etc to their wives. I dated a chap for a while and when he was widowed, it was his sister that took on a huge amount of the care role. Again, this was not some uncaring prick - I think he was just clueless and lacking in experience.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 04/02/2024 16:31

aren't used to doing bath, evening meals, days out etc for 2 dcs without the other parent helping.

@gavory sorry, but this can't be true! You can't manage your own two children by yourself?

Bunnyhopskip · 04/02/2024 16:29

Yes he'd cope fine, with probably support from grandparents. The DDs would probably learn quite quickly how to do their own hair, as whenever I'm away I come back to low ponytails (the only hairstyle he's mastered) that don't look very well brushed 😂. I'd worry about their emotional needs as they grew and became teens, as he's not very good at all with dealing with emotion, and knowing what to say when someone is upset. The rest, food, clothing, schooling, etc, he'd be absolutely fine with as does alot of that anyway.

Chylka · 04/02/2024 16:28

he’d be fine. I mean, he’d be a widowed dad so some standards would slip, as they would for anyone when they’re suddenly doing it all themselves, but the same would be true if he died and I had to do it all alone.

Tree12 · 04/02/2024 16:28

Mine is amazing with the kids but I think he’d struggle with the housework and paying the bills etc.

SwordToFlamethrower · 04/02/2024 16:26

No. But he'd die trying.

Hankunamatata · 04/02/2024 16:24

Their physical needs and running the household. Their emotional needs and communication, not a bloody hope in hell

crackofdoom · 04/02/2024 16:22

If XP cared for our son full time the way he cares for him on the weekends he has him, the school would probably flag him up with social services for neglect. No showers, clothes unwashed and teeth untrusted, junk food, unlimited screen time and rarely leaving the house.
In reality, I'm sure he would do just enough to avoid that, but DS2 would have a sad life of it and probably be partially raised by his teenage brother.

gavory · 04/02/2024 16:22

I'm a sahm and DH would realistically have to get a nanny to replace me, to cover his work hours. Anything after that would be a struggle for him as we tend to parent the dcs equally at weekends and evenings, we often focus on one child each so aren't used to doing bath, evening meals, days out etc for 2 dcs without the other parent helping. Then he'd end up dropping standards but so would I in that situation. He'd probably end up paying for quite a bit of outsourcing.

Simonjt · 04/02/2024 16:21

They’d be fine, we recently moved country and he moved over first with the children, it was for about six weeks. He did everything a parent needs to do, he struggled with hair care due to a disability, so booked them in for a wash and style twice a week.

newnam · 04/02/2024 16:14

Yes, obviously things would be different to how they are now though.

My DC are girls though so there would be a worry surrounding emotional support.

Icantbedoingwithit · 04/02/2024 16:13

Physically and financially yes, emotionally and mentally no.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/02/2024 16:11

PictureALadybird · 04/02/2024 15:16

Of course. I wouldn’t have had kids with someone who wasn’t an equal parent Confused

You can’t always tell.

My ex spent a fortune on our fertility treatment. Spend hours decorating our girls nursery. Shopped for them constantly. Poured over baby name books. Absolutely doted on them for the first 4 months.

Then got bored. Walked out when they were 6 months. He saw them on and off depending on which new girlfriend he was looking to impress at the time.

They’re at Uni. One hasn’t seen him for 4 years and the other for nearly 2 years

Facetube · 04/02/2024 16:04

Notamum12345577 · 04/02/2024 15:52

Come on guys, you are all supposed to say no! Don’t you realise this site thinks all men are useless and don’t do a fair share of child rearing etc?! 😁

IME on these types of thread the classic mumsnet response is "absolutely - I can't believe you would breed with someone who you hadn't vetted in their French plait skills, financial stability and general perfection first Shock" 😂

headcheffer · 04/02/2024 16:01

Yes. He's an excellent Dad. The things he can't currently do because I do and are not his "domain" he would learn to do. Including French plaits - he taught himself how to do ponytails Smile

Survivingmy3yearold · 04/02/2024 15:56

Yes, absolutely! It may look different to how I care for them and I can see less of the extra curricular activities and fun bits happening but they would be well taken care of. I think the main things he'd struggle with are the mental load of remembering birthday parties, discos, dentist appointments, vaccination appointments etc and Christmas and birthdays, I genuinely don't think he has any idea how much thinking, time and effort goes into making things like that happen. He'd have to learn pretty quickly though!

Alwaystired23 · 04/02/2024 15:54

Yes, Dh would care for them as well as me. The only thing I think would be a problem for him, is keeping on top of the washing. He'd probably do it, and it would never get put away. They'd just live off piles of clean washing in the utility. He would, however, feed them well, ensure they shower and brush their teeth daily, and help with their homework, make dc2 packed lunch, take them to all their clubs, kiss them goodnight, tuck them into bed and listen about their school day, because he does all these things anyway!

0rangeCrush · 04/02/2024 15:54

Mumof2NDers · 04/02/2024 15:49

Same here.
DH would feed them etc but he’s useless with the emotional aspect. It’s not really his fault and he has got better over the years but he’s a bit emotionally retarded if I’m honest.
We were brought up very differently. I was brought up by 2 loving parents who attended to our emotional needs well. DH was brought up by his emotionally closed off mum, his dad left for another woman. His dad was a violent bully.
DH was brought up without love or care and his basic needs weren’t met.
He struggles to understand why our (ND)DC’s need so much emotional support.
He feels he turned out ok! I beg to differ!
I love him though ❤️

Ick at using the word retarded.

Sturnidae · 04/02/2024 15:54

Absolutely. Wouldn't have married or had kids with anybody who I would have felt couldn't.

Notamum12345577 · 04/02/2024 15:52

Come on guys, you are all supposed to say no! Don’t you realise this site thinks all men are useless and don’t do a fair share of child rearing etc?! 😁

Creatureofhabit87 · 04/02/2024 15:51

100% he’s better than me!! He’s attentive, thoughtful, plays amazingly with him, puts him to bed every other night, gets up early sometimes like I do. No doubt in my mind!

PicaK · 04/02/2024 15:50

He's my ex-dh but he'd absolutely step up. The things you've mentioned aren't that important. Love, warmth, food etc are. Ex has taken on more since we split. It's easy to let one person be in charge of certain things.
I struggled with the lawn mower, the car stuff and the bins when he left. But I've got on top of it slowly.

GRex · 04/02/2024 15:49

Emotionally and basic childcare practicalities would be fine. Maybe some things would be done later or a dentist not booked for a while or whatever, but together they would get on top of it. Financially it would be more of a strain, which would lead some tricky choices after a year or two. I don't know how he would sort out probate, nor bill switching, nor keeping track of the old digital photos etc, as DH doesn't do well at any type of admin; my sister and his brother would support hopefully.

Mumof2NDers · 04/02/2024 15:49

Allfortheloveofabiscuit · 04/02/2024 15:16

They'd be clean, fed but not healthily etc. It'd all be very practical but as for emotional support, they'd want for that. Dh and I balance out well. Im too soft but keep mental health in check, dh can be too militant but better at insisting chores are done more quickly, to a better standard etc.

If dh vanished they'd be minded, fed, clean etc but a bit more laid back. Theyd get there eventually! Theyre teens so it's mostly the emotional (and financial support) at this point anyway

Same here.
DH would feed them etc but he’s useless with the emotional aspect. It’s not really his fault and he has got better over the years but he’s a bit emotionally retarded if I’m honest.
We were brought up very differently. I was brought up by 2 loving parents who attended to our emotional needs well. DH was brought up by his emotionally closed off mum, his dad left for another woman. His dad was a violent bully.
DH was brought up without love or care and his basic needs weren’t met.
He struggles to understand why our (ND)DC’s need so much emotional support.
He feels he turned out ok! I beg to differ!
I love him though ❤️