Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you vanished tomorrow, would your DP/DH care adequately for your kids?

185 replies

Naptrappedmummy · 04/02/2024 14:54

Mine would - but not to the standard I do. It wouldn’t be anything social services-worthy but food wouldn’t be wiped off faces, school uniform would probably be worn one day too many, dinner would be fish fingers and baked beans, the TV would be on too much. That sort of thing.

For some reason thinking about it makes me really stressed!

OP posts:
thebestinterest · 04/02/2024 17:22

Yes!

fussychica · 04/02/2024 17:13

Mine is grown now but he would definitely have managed without me. He was a stay at home dad in the early 90s when it was a pretty unusual thing to do. He was brilliant at it, very organised, capable and probably much better than I'd have been as a SAHM.

FieldInWhichFucksAreGrownIsBarren · 04/02/2024 17:09

Yes but I'm not certain he would be adequate emotionally unfortunately.

spriots · 04/02/2024 17:07

TwylaSands · 04/02/2024 16:58

It isnt regional. It is social circle. All the dads in our circle are equal, competent parents. The only ones who arent are in my circle through being related and not by choice!

in answer of the initial question, i would hope he would be a mess looking for me.

but generally speaking he is an equal and competent parent, does 100% of the cooking and a good chunk of the cleaning.

Social circle / community that's kinda what I meant.

I do think there is a regional component to social circle norms though - London has more two income families because of cost of living, as a PP was saying, places like Ireland can tend to have more emphasis on the maternal role etc.

Of course it's only a component, I am not saying region is the only element here at all

Like you, my social circle is full of dads who parent equally

CeratopsofthePharoahs · 04/02/2024 17:04

He'd do very well.
Was in hospital just over a year ago for almost a week and he was fine. He already does plenty of domestic stuff.
If he struggled anywhere it would be time. My children are old enough to bring themselves home from school if necessary but DH simply doesn't have the extra hours in his day to dedicate to things like school projects or the like.
Like a pp we balance each other well on the emotional side of parenting - I'm softer and they open up to me about stuff more and DH is stricter so stuff actually gets done!
DH would also have to put up with my mum blustering in and trying to take over. She means well but it can be a bit.... much.

MangshorJhol · 04/02/2024 17:04

Yes he would. Practically and emotionally. He’s a top notch dad who carries the mental load equally. He sees the children for who they are sometimes better than I do (I tend to worry about the mundane- he does all the mundane stuff but is also good at seeing the big picture). If he was gone we would really struggle- he’s the light of our lives.

He’s introverted so my only worry would be in terms of play dates and such like. I don’t see him approaching other parents to set it up. And all their clothes would come from the Gap and that’s it. But he’s a fabulous dad. His mum was very sick as a child and his dad stepped up. So he’s had an excellent role model growing up.

spriots · 04/02/2024 16:58

A close relative of mine sadly died when her children were 7 and 5. Her husband has done a truly amazing job and they are both now adults.

Wider family did rally round, but he did 95% of the work. And has never dated since she died - he didn't have time or inclination.

He did do it differently, I would say, his kids have always pitched in more than other kids their age, from quite an early stage, they would take part in housework and cooking etc but I think that's a good thing

TwylaSands · 04/02/2024 16:58

spriots · 04/02/2024 16:48

I think it is fairly representative - quite a few posters have said something similar to you, and the same on the thread about going into hospital.

I think the thing is that there are different types of community and regional differences etc - in our group of friends, dads are pretty involved, quite a few took shared parental leave. Because we are in London, loads of us don't have family support so that probably pushes the dads to be more involved too.

DH would probably be a better single dad than I would be as a single mum to be honest - we have different strengths and weaknesses as parents but he is better organised than me by far.

It isnt regional. It is social circle. All the dads in our circle are equal, competent parents. The only ones who arent are in my circle through being related and not by choice!

in answer of the initial question, i would hope he would be a mess looking for me.

but generally speaking he is an equal and competent parent, does 100% of the cooking and a good chunk of the cleaning.

CherryPiePiePie · 04/02/2024 16:55

BlueRidgeMountains · 04/02/2024 16:39

I am a lone widowed parent, thankfully my children are young adults now but that has been a worry, what is something happened to me?

Foster care unless you have family to care for them. Mine would go into foster care as no family help.

Shergill15 · 04/02/2024 16:53

This is a worry of mine. Ex lives abroad and hardly sees DD so it would be a massive upheaval to start with. I expect he would outsource the majority of parenting to his mother. DD would be fed, clothed, taken to school etc. But emotional support, facilitating of activities and social life would definitely be lacking. I'd rather she went to my sister or a close friend if anything happened to me in all honesty

DelphineFox · 04/02/2024 16:48

It was the other way round as he dropped dead. I think he would have done a decent job if it had been me though.

thecatsthecats · 04/02/2024 16:48

Sort of.

Baby is four months old and naturally thinks mum is everything and dad is this funny guy who can't do milk but does good shushy walks.

But after a short sharp shock of adjustment to them both, they'd work it out.

However, today he has man flu, and therefore is The Most Beleaguered Person In The World. Not sure I'd leave him with the cat.

spriots · 04/02/2024 16:48

theleafandnotthetree · 04/02/2024 16:31

I think this is not a representative group - when I look around at the families I know, I could see serious deficits in how the children would be cared for and reared in quite a high proportion of cases. I think part of that is cultural, I'm in Ireland and the Irish Mammy is not just a stereotype. The average mum I know tends to so much in the family structure, arguably too much in terms of molly cuddling etc that the contrast would be enormous. Quite a few men I know, even if decent men and involved fathers to the extent of driving kids to activities etc, leave huge swathes of childbearing, decision making etc to their wives. I dated a chap for a while and when he was widowed, it was his sister that took on a huge amount of the care role. Again, this was not some uncaring prick - I think he was just clueless and lacking in experience.

I think it is fairly representative - quite a few posters have said something similar to you, and the same on the thread about going into hospital.

I think the thing is that there are different types of community and regional differences etc - in our group of friends, dads are pretty involved, quite a few took shared parental leave. Because we are in London, loads of us don't have family support so that probably pushes the dads to be more involved too.

DH would probably be a better single dad than I would be as a single mum to be honest - we have different strengths and weaknesses as parents but he is better organised than me by far.

NCfor24 · 04/02/2024 16:46

Well I've just been away for two nights and DH has got 2 kids to swimming and cadets, 1 to football and hosted a play date. I usually do these things and he did message to confirm timings but all was well. If I disappeared he'd be fine but they'd probably have to do less hobbies due to time.....I usually do the hobbies taxiing around but DH cooks. If I was a solo parent they'd eat a lot less healthy and balanced as I'm not a great cook and DH likes cooking. But I'd learn!
When they came to collect me from the station 2 of the kids had their pj's and onesies on, but it is Sunday so that's not unusual really. I don't think any of them have showered in my absence though! But there's no neglect, dirty clothes or missed events so I know DH would solo parent just fine.
We have life and critical illness cover plus death in service benefit so we would each be able to take a year off work in the event of the other's death and settle kids into a new normal.

Hoglet70 · 04/02/2024 16:45

DS has left school now but totally confident that if I had died some years ago then DH would have done a fab job. DS would probably be better house trained and not so spoiled too!

Ponderingwindow · 04/02/2024 16:43

I’m better at managing our teenagers ASD. I have a huge advantage, I also have ASD and she and I have remarkably similar presentations. I’ve basically been her in-house OT and therapist. So that would be a loss for both of them.

but overall they would be fine.

BarbaricPeach · 04/02/2024 16:39

Yes, he'd do an excellent job. But his strengths are different to mine. So overall he'd do a great job but there would be areas that weren't as good as if I were around. We work well as a team because of this.

BlueRidgeMountains · 04/02/2024 16:39

I am a lone widowed parent, thankfully my children are young adults now but that has been a worry, what is something happened to me?

RosieAway · 04/02/2024 16:38

@Froggy99 really? You can’t imagine a man turning abusive after having a baby? Or any other reasons apart from the one where you’re assuming I’m a fool? No? Then lucky old you

BlueRidgeMountains · 04/02/2024 16:37

Most men move on very quickly, then it would all down to Stepmum.

MuchTooTired · 04/02/2024 16:37

I think they’d be fine. I’d be a bit worried about emotional support for them, but ultimately the kids would be absolutely fine without me (apart from the fact their mum disappeared, that’ll stay with them forever).

DuchessNope · 04/02/2024 16:36

My husband is a SAHD so yes absolutely! He’s a brilliant brilliant dad in almost all ways. The only thing that would worry me would be the social side - I do all the play date arranging, taking to parties and so on. Also he is not at all arsed about holidays so I wonder if he’d bother. Basically he’s quite introverted, he’s very emotionally available to DS and I but doesn’t have much social contact beyond that except what I drag him along to.

Toottooot · 04/02/2024 16:35

Yes - why wouldn’t my husband be able to take perfectly good care of his child?

gwenneh · 04/02/2024 16:35

Absolutely. We both have different things that we prioritise, but it would all get done and I wouldn't worry about it being to a lesser standard.

Froggy99 · 04/02/2024 16:34

RosieAway · 04/02/2024 15:24

Absolutely not. Doesn’t warrant thinking about

Then why make babies with him?

Swipe left for the next trending thread