Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tech moguls are protecting their kids from social media but not ours... Are many parents pushing back in the UK?

117 replies

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 14:32

https://www.fastcompany.com/90900166/tech-social-media-protection-children

Following on from the Brianna Grey mums thread.. It's interesting to read that many of the top tech execs have been raising their kids social media free... The wealthier families we know have kids who are protected more from social media than others. These families can afford a lot of extracurriculars & days out/holidays etc so the kids are kept busy.. I do agree that we are really starting to see the horrendous effects of social media but will this be another example of where wealthier parents or more clued in parents are better able to protect their kids?
So many times we have been out for dinner & have been sat beside toddlers glued to Peppa Pig etc (at full volume) it's bloody ridiculous...

OP posts:
CHRIS003 · 04/02/2024 15:18

I don't think it makes a difference whether you are wealthy or not.
Yes wealthy parents can afford a wider range of activities other than tech
But they are also more likely to be able to afford a wider range of tech for their kids.
A family on less income may not be able to afford lots of activities but they are more likely to share tech in the home.
One playstation for the family a family laptop / computer
I remember a story during the pandemic about people donating tablets and laptops to poorer families so that children had one each to access school lesson s online during the lockdowns,
Local to me I heard a story about a single mum with 4 school aged kids who was trying to access lessons with one smartphone that was hers ! So she had some old tablets donated to her.
Surely these children are potentially less exposed to social media at a young age than a wealthy family who can afford for their children to have a phone each and laptops that don't have to be shared.
Poorer families also don't have unlimited WiFi packages sometimes.
A better off family will have an unlimited package which can contect lots of devices.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/02/2024 15:18

The OP is right- deprived towns with one run down park it’s inevitable parents are more likely to turn to screens.

I think the OP's mistake is in thinking that rich kids don't turn to screens, not that poorer ones do. Not all rich kids are heavily scheduled, especially those whose parents work long hours. And even those who do lots of other stuff almost certainly get loads of screen time too. They aren't going to exclude themselves from online social interaction just because mummy and daddy can pay for them to play 3 instruments and go horse-riding. You can't honestly think that they are so busy that they don't have time to share photos of all their swanky holidays and cool activities etc on social media?

DeedlessIndeed · 04/02/2024 15:17

@YetMoreNewBeginnings - fair enough. People may think it's extreme and it may well not be for everyone.

But I think it's no different that ensuring DC aren't watching inappropriate films or reading inappropriate magazines back in the day.

I also believe that being 100% open with DC about what monitors and measures are in place so they don't feel they are spied on.

OriginalUsername2 · 04/02/2024 15:17

YouTube is packed with Gen Z (I think) making videos about how millennials are messing up their gen alpha kids with YouTube. Search “gen alpha is doomed” for an endless scroll.

Maxus · 04/02/2024 15:16

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 04/02/2024 15:11

The OP is right- deprived towns with one run down park it’s inevitable parents are more likely to turn to screens.
Of course kids find joy in imagination and their own toys etc- but you throw a few weeks at half term with crap weather into the mix what are parents to do.
costs:
For my 2 children:
local petting farm- food for animals and entry, £30
the bigger farm with activists £60 family ticket
theatre trip for 3 of us £60
trampolining 1hr £15 pp
soft play c.£15-£20 per hour depending on which we go to
swimming c.£15 for 3 of us
activities cost money

all these activists fill 1hour in a day!

Activities es don't have to cost money. When my kids where younger they went to the park, nearby steam, played with friends on bikes, invited friends over, went to friends houses, played board games, water fights. The list is endless. No it doesn't cost

lifeispainauchocolat · 04/02/2024 15:12

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 04/02/2024 15:11

The OP is right- deprived towns with one run down park it’s inevitable parents are more likely to turn to screens.
Of course kids find joy in imagination and their own toys etc- but you throw a few weeks at half term with crap weather into the mix what are parents to do.
costs:
For my 2 children:
local petting farm- food for animals and entry, £30
the bigger farm with activists £60 family ticket
theatre trip for 3 of us £60
trampolining 1hr £15 pp
soft play c.£15-£20 per hour depending on which we go to
swimming c.£15 for 3 of us
activities cost money

all these activists fill 1hour in a day!

Many families in deprived areas won't own any screens to begin with, though.

So it's not a case of "screens or farm park" it's "sit at home or play in the park".

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 04/02/2024 15:11

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 14:48

But I will stand by my opinion that wealthier families will have more money to throw at their kids to keep them more engaged in more wholesome persuits than Minecraft!

The OP is right- deprived towns with one run down park it’s inevitable parents are more likely to turn to screens.
Of course kids find joy in imagination and their own toys etc- but you throw a few weeks at half term with crap weather into the mix what are parents to do.
costs:
For my 2 children:
local petting farm- food for animals and entry, £30
the bigger farm with activists £60 family ticket
theatre trip for 3 of us £60
trampolining 1hr £15 pp
soft play c.£15-£20 per hour depending on which we go to
swimming c.£15 for 3 of us
activities cost money

all these activists fill 1hour in a day!

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 15:11

To the person asking my dc are 12 & 10, get a movie at the weekends, only allowed screens for homework with dh & I in the room. This is our family decision & I don't give a rats arse what anyone thinks. Friends of theirs parents are now trying to cut right on the screen time their dc have.. However there seems to be no going back now & it has led to horrific arguements & one child attending counselling for screen addiction.. Once you give something it is very hard to take back.

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 04/02/2024 15:10

And yes, one of you has to play top trumps with them or help them with the sticker book or read a story.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/02/2024 15:10

Really it boils down to this imo:

The internet and social media are not going away. Whatever restrictions the government might be willing to impose will never go far enough to make parental vigilance unnecessary.

So parents should, to the best of their abilities, impose age-appropriate screen time limits, prevent underage social media use and delay giving children smartphones until necessary or at least genuinely useful.

Schools do, and parents should, continue to educate themselves and children about the downsides of technology and social media.

The only barrier to this is not financial, it is a lack of parental awareness, knowledge, ability or effort.

Maray1967 · 04/02/2024 15:09

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 14:54

@OverTheCountryClub but it's unnecessary screen time. In a restaurant when your sat next to paying customers it's completely unreasonable to have a toddler on a screen with the volume turned up. The message is the parents would rather not parent their child & are relying on a screen to keep their child entertained instead of engaging with him /her... The boundaries are already being set.

Yes, I agree. You have to put the effort in. Ours knew that restaurants were where top trumps came out - but not when the food arrived. When younger, they had sticker books or just normal books! We only had meals in front of the TV on Saturday tea time for pizza night. No TV allowed in the morning. Ours went to nursery so we didn’t have GPs childminding and doing things their way so that was easier.

You need to start as you mean to go on. Take books and card games etc with you. Don’t take a tablet and keep your phone out of sight.

Barrenfieldoffucks · 04/02/2024 15:08

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 15:02

Out of interest if you want adult conversation why not hire a baby sitter or ask family to mind for a couple of hours?

Because actually the whole experience of going out to eat is a nice one. On the whole when I see families with tablets the kids are watching them after eating while waiting for parents to finish a relaxing drink, coffee, chat etc. Or waiting an age for food to.come out. They don't take over the whole meal.

PermanentIyExhaustedPigeon · 04/02/2024 15:08

I'm skint and my teenager doesn't have access to most social media.

He has a smart phone, with WhatsApp. No TikTok, no insta, no Snapchat, no FB, no youtube. I can see what apps he downloads and have to approve them. I can also see how long he spends on what apps.

He is allowed to watch all his special interest YouTube videos on the TV in the living room. Often I'll sit down and knit with him and watch stuff he is interested in. So he isn't deprived of everything YouTube has to offer, he's just not allowed to sit on his own and watch whatever shite the algorithms throw at him!

We go out a lot. Dog walks, museums, the odd theatre trip, castles, nice gardens, that sort of thing. Free stuff mostly but obviously some of it does have a cost attached. The shit they want when they've seen it on YouTube ain't free either though! Stanley cups and wanky trainers etc... I'd rather spend the money we do have on things that actually enrich his life!

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/02/2024 15:07

I think one of the biggest problems is that so many parents don't realise how apps work. They know that "everyone" is using them, but don't realise the ones where randoms can speak to their children or the level of content they are accessing.

I also think there's a large number of parents who don't realise how late at night their children are on their phones! I think a lot loosened the rules during lockdowns, understandably in many ways as we were all under pressure, but it has had an ongoing impact.

Maxus · 04/02/2024 15:07

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 15:02

Out of interest if you want adult conversation why not hire a baby sitter or ask family to mind for a couple of hours?

Why should they have to? If this works for them that's all that matters.

WaitingforSpring24 · 04/02/2024 15:05

I think gaming and using apps at dinner are complete red herrings. I let my kids use their iPads at dinner when we are out whilst not eating. They are bored and adult talk is boring. It’s really not the problem here to be honest. My kids are very articulate and highly social, letting them use their devices when out has not hindered their sense of social awareness or our bond.

But my oldest has had all sorts of stuff using Snapchat, has become way too body conscious using instagram, been approached by random strangers using odd internet sites that his mates said were fun etc etc. I kept an eye on these, good communication and we kind of navigated through them. But these social media sites are toxic.

Newsenmum · 04/02/2024 15:03

Watching tv/tablet is a completely different topic. And it’s the only way the parents can take them out.

I can’t take my autistic child out to eat due to the stress he feels, only sometimes can we do it if he’s got a tablet. Trust me, most parents would prefer to engage with their kids if they could.

lifeispainauchocolat · 04/02/2024 15:03

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 15:02

Out of interest if you want adult conversation why not hire a baby sitter or ask family to mind for a couple of hours?

Not everyone has those options.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/02/2024 15:02

But also he's adamant that all internet usage will be strictly monitored as there is such deplorable and dangerous content accessible to anyone with a phone in their pocket.

On here you tend to get ripped to shreds if you admit to monitoring your child's internet access.

I was called intrusive and borderline abusive for having a policy whereby we don't have phones in bedrooms at night, no apps can be downloaded without my permission (I have to approve it from my phone) and kids phone content is regularly checked.

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 15:02

Imnotabigbeliever · 04/02/2024 14:58

Sometimes we go out for meals with no tech and talk to the kids and sometimes we have tech so we can have an adult conversation.

In the 80s/90s my parents would take us to Little Chef or Happy Eater and we’d go to the Lego table of play outside. I don’t think places like that exist anymore.

Out of interest if you want adult conversation why not hire a baby sitter or ask family to mind for a couple of hours?

OP posts:
Hermione101 · 04/02/2024 15:02

Many of the boys at my son’s prep play about Minecraft, mine is not allowed. They’re all 6 and 7. It’s not about money. It’s about parents actually parenting and having the common sense to say no, whatever their socioeconomic bracket is.

I wouldn’t say it’s about extracurriculars, although that may keep them busy. It’s often about the expectations parents have for their children and what they value as a family.

Video games are probably ok after a certain age and with clear boundaries. Social media is ultra high processed food for the brain. Total garbage.

WaitingforSpring24 · 04/02/2024 15:02

The problem isn’t really gaming though. Or amount of screen time.

It is social media sites and also YouTube (which has disturbing content). And being introduced to these at 12/13.

Really all kids should not be on social media until they are 16. None at all.

Barrenfieldoffucks · 04/02/2024 15:00

It's a lazy argument that has been had so many times on here, but not related to your point on social media so I won't bother going through it again.

How old are your kids and what is your approach with them?

With our 3, they are allowed things like Snapchat and WhatsApp once at high school when they get a phone. (Only 2 out of 3 this far, they're 13 and 12) This has timers and locks on, and all privacy settings up high. Passcodes have to be known by us, and we can check any time.

But they are also very busy. During the week they each have an activity every day, from rowing to badminton, skateboarding, the gym, scouts etc. So it's all a balance.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/02/2024 14:59

I'm not a fan of devices at the dinner table either, but I think it's a bit of a separate issue to the dangers of social media. Watching Peppa Pig on a tablet is no more addictive than watching tv ever was. It's just more portable! For example some people have the tv on constantly, even when having dinner. That's not a new thing.

DeedlessIndeed · 04/02/2024 14:59

DH works for a US tech company that hosts other websites. He is head of a department that covers, amongst other things, all cases where content hosted has abuse reports by members of the public.

I am pregnant with our first and we've already agreed to raise baby with as little exposure to SM as possible. Definitely no photos on SM as the things possible with AI now are horrific.

But also he's adamant that all internet usage will be strictly monitored as there is such deplorable and dangerous content accessible to anyone with a phone in their pocket. Children (and many adults) can so easily be sucked in by manipulative bad actors.