Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tech moguls are protecting their kids from social media but not ours... Are many parents pushing back in the UK?

117 replies

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 14:32

https://www.fastcompany.com/90900166/tech-social-media-protection-children

Following on from the Brianna Grey mums thread.. It's interesting to read that many of the top tech execs have been raising their kids social media free... The wealthier families we know have kids who are protected more from social media than others. These families can afford a lot of extracurriculars & days out/holidays etc so the kids are kept busy.. I do agree that we are really starting to see the horrendous effects of social media but will this be another example of where wealthier parents or more clued in parents are better able to protect their kids?
So many times we have been out for dinner & have been sat beside toddlers glued to Peppa Pig etc (at full volume) it's bloody ridiculous...

OP posts:
BoohooWoohoo · 04/02/2024 16:25

I think that your argument has been diluted somewhat with your updates.
Minecraft is very wholesome and educational depending on how you play. If you wanted a “not wholesome” example then you’re after something like Fortnite where strangers can (and do) talk to kids and many happily volunteer their ages and names of their school.
Tech moguls know how addictive SM is but there will also be an element of wanting to protect their kids from trolls who would delight in harrassing, sending viruses or hacking their children because of who their parents are.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/02/2024 16:16

They do but they aren't the only option. Playing frisbee coasts the price of a frisbee and it can be used loads of times, good for all ages.

Playing with a frisbee requires a safe space to play with it in.

One of the biggest problems parents face now is a lack of safe play spaces. We live in a “nice” place and the park still has occasions of having smashed glass around and in particular, since lockdown, has an issue of rubbish dog owners with poorly trained dogs.

Simonjt · 04/02/2024 16:13

We’re a low tech family, I was a low tech child, I’m 36, I got my first mobile phone at 20, my first computer at 22-23.

Our son (8) doesn’t own a phone, he also doesn’t have access to any computer games where you can chat to other players etc. Neither he or our 2 year old have a tablet. He does have a kindle, but as I’m tight arse its a really old one that has no functions beyond reading books.

If we go out to eat no tech is used (that includes the adults), lots of places have things children can colour in, but we usually take something simple with us to give them something to do. We don’t really use social media/use tech a lot in front of them, so its fairly unusual for them to see us on the phone on our phones.

When I was a child portable tech was game boys, I had one, all my friends did, but I don’t remember ever seeing a child playing one in a cafe etc.

As far as social media, for us we won’t allow before 13 as thats the advised age for most platforms, but then it will be monitored and time per app will be set.

We no longer live in the UK, where we live is much more child centred, you just don’t see tablet/phone families in cafes etc.

ConcertaFirstTimer · 04/02/2024 16:10

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 04/02/2024 15:11

The OP is right- deprived towns with one run down park it’s inevitable parents are more likely to turn to screens.
Of course kids find joy in imagination and their own toys etc- but you throw a few weeks at half term with crap weather into the mix what are parents to do.
costs:
For my 2 children:
local petting farm- food for animals and entry, £30
the bigger farm with activists £60 family ticket
theatre trip for 3 of us £60
trampolining 1hr £15 pp
soft play c.£15-£20 per hour depending on which we go to
swimming c.£15 for 3 of us
activities cost money

all these activists fill 1hour in a day!

They do but they aren't the only option. Playing frisbee coasts the price of a frisbee and it can be used loads of times, good for all ages.

We used to make mud slides in the stream, dam up the stream, build dens in the woods, climb trees and balance along fallen trees, go on scavenger hunts for feathers, pebbles etc. We'd go for walks and get them to forget the walks were 'boring' by asking stuff like: 'What is your dream house?' or 'How would you spend a million pounds?'

Inside we'd read books, do drawing, painting and junk modelling, do 'science' experiments like making a volcano out of cardboard then making it erupt with baking soda and vinegar, turn big boxes into rockets, trains etc, play hide and seek or sardines, play charades, bake cookies, make pizzas or popcorn.

All of these are free or almost free, but I admit they are time and energy comsuming. An exhausted parent, working full time, is unlikely to have the drive to do this week in week out.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/02/2024 16:03

So give them books/colouring stuff/games to play quietly rather than playing peppa pig in a shared space? If nothing else, it’s being an inconsiderate clown to everyone else around you! (But that’s a separate issue).

Well yes it can be, but it's not inconsiderate if they use headphones. I never used screens with mine in that situation and often used colouring books. There's little doubt Peppa Pig would keep them quieter (with headphones)! But expecting a child to be silent all meal is unreasonable anyway. I just think that there is often a large element of snobbery (both intellectual and the regular kind) and superiority, masquerading as concern about screens, in the perennial 'Peppa Pig at the restaurant is bad, colouring books are good' debate. Also a heavy dollop of luck in how easy your children are.

Also, cutting off the latter half of my post (where I talked about balance) to further your argument is bad form.

Yes, you're right. Apologies, I forgot about that bit.

Caravaggiouch · 04/02/2024 16:00

Peppa pig on a tablet is far closer to TV than to social media. Judge away, but you’re diminishing your argument by throwing in that kind of comment.

Clarabell77 · 04/02/2024 15:58

Peppa pig isn’t social media.

Sturnidae · 04/02/2024 15:56

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 15:36

It's so true. We rely on our local library so much.

Okay, and what about those communities without a library? Or other public spaces?

pinkstripeycat · 04/02/2024 15:54

CatamaranViper

yes good post.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/02/2024 15:54

That's the difference, you use headphones. You are not inflicting your kids noise on the people sat next to you.

So now you don't mind the screen use as long as you don't hear it? I'm confused.

pinkstripeycat · 04/02/2024 15:54
  • extra activities
pinkstripeycat · 04/02/2024 15:53

Totally agree with AllProperTeaIsTheft

OP, what do you think we all did before tech came along? We didn’t have actuaries available to us, they didn’t exist.

My DC are late teens and don’t use social media as it doesn’t interest them. They’d rather go out and meet their friends

CatamaranViper · 04/02/2024 15:42

So are you complaining about tablets at dinner, social media or gaming? Because they're all different things with some crossovers in places.

Tech in general, I'd probably argue that there is a need for exposure to these as many, many jobs now require basic tech understanding and, let's face it, it's becoming more and more important.

DS is 7 and he wants to be a game designer and coder. Can't really do that without a computer or tablet.

Sturnidae · 04/02/2024 15:38

Follow on from my post before it's jumped on, obviously I know minecraft isn't the only game out there, but it's the one OP has used by example. OP you've conflated various "issues" and tried to lump them together. A toddler watching peppa is not the same as teens on social media. Gaming is not the same as teens on social media. These are all hot topics but not one in the same.

Personally, the old saying of "everything in moderation" rings true for me. It's not healthy to be stuck indoors on screens all day, but it is something that is prevalent in modern life, and unless you are part of a wider community that practices a complete ban, it's going to be relevant to your child, and it's better for them to start learning about positive relationships with technology earlier in life than it is to let them at it at whatever age with no real ingrained understanding of staying safe online.

That's probably part of how those wealthy folk in silicon Valley manage it, a lot of their kids attend Steiner and similar alternative education systems where none of them have access to technology. Though I've personally known quite a few steiner kids who got their first phones at 15 and suddenly became zombies accessing all kinds of horrific content so it's not all sunshine and rainbows 🤷‍♀️ equally, I've known some who've had the absolute opposite and had free access to all kinds of media from a young age, even pre-social media, and they're well adjusted adults (and some are not!) 🤷‍♀️

Balance and helping your child learn healthy limits is more important, and I'd go as far to say joining your child in their interests, regardless of what they are, so that you actually have an understanding of them. When I was a child/young teen I was reading loads of inappropriate for my age books, but my mum liked to brag about my reading and how I wasn't watching horror films or playing video games all of the time, had she read some of those books herself she would have been horrified at what she was allowing me to buy and borrow from the library!

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 15:37

WaitingforSpring24 · 04/02/2024 15:33

I think it’s smug middle class posturing to be honest about colouring books in restaurants to look down their nose at families where the kids are on screens.

And it’s really nothing to do with the dangers of social media.

I let my kids on their devices in restaurants, always with headphones. They are polite, well mannered, sociable and lovely. I’m just not up my own arse about it and expect them to talk animatedly about politics or the price of houses. When they eat we chat and when they are waiting they are on the devices.

I’ve several friends who never let their kids on devices at restaurants. They do several activities with their kids, send them to great schools, expose them to a rich and varied life.

Many of them now have older teenagers who have eating disorders, high anxiety, off school, most of the girls have one label or another, whether it’s mental health or a diagnosis. They all started to have problems / want an identity when they used social media at age 13. Every last one of them.

We need to smarten up! See where the dangers really lie.

That's the difference, you use headphones. You are not inflicting your kids noise on the people sat next to you.

OP posts:
Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 15:36

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 04/02/2024 15:11

The OP is right- deprived towns with one run down park it’s inevitable parents are more likely to turn to screens.
Of course kids find joy in imagination and their own toys etc- but you throw a few weeks at half term with crap weather into the mix what are parents to do.
costs:
For my 2 children:
local petting farm- food for animals and entry, £30
the bigger farm with activists £60 family ticket
theatre trip for 3 of us £60
trampolining 1hr £15 pp
soft play c.£15-£20 per hour depending on which we go to
swimming c.£15 for 3 of us
activities cost money

all these activists fill 1hour in a day!

It's so true. We rely on our local library so much.

OP posts:
WaitingforSpring24 · 04/02/2024 15:33

I think it’s smug middle class posturing to be honest about colouring books in restaurants to look down their nose at families where the kids are on screens.

And it’s really nothing to do with the dangers of social media.

I let my kids on their devices in restaurants, always with headphones. They are polite, well mannered, sociable and lovely. I’m just not up my own arse about it and expect them to talk animatedly about politics or the price of houses. When they eat we chat and when they are waiting they are on the devices.

I’ve several friends who never let their kids on devices at restaurants. They do several activities with their kids, send them to great schools, expose them to a rich and varied life.

Many of them now have older teenagers who have eating disorders, high anxiety, off school, most of the girls have one label or another, whether it’s mental health or a diagnosis. They all started to have problems / want an identity when they used social media at age 13. Every last one of them.

We need to smarten up! See where the dangers really lie.

Foxblue · 04/02/2024 15:32

It's very frustrating to see some of the responses on that other thread
'My child will be socially isolated without a phone' er, better that than groomed or dead, surely.
'Kids get around these things all the time'
So, what - you don't even try?
'They'll see if from their friends anyway'
They aren't with their friends 24 hours a day, presumably.
'Well my child just naturally learnt to limit themselves, I think limits make kids want it more'
Okay, but a lot of the apps are signed to be addictive - great that your kid could cope with it, but others can't, and it's a child!! Much like you wouldn't leave out a massive bowl of chocolate out around a 4 year old, because they might eat too much and make themselves sick, you need to moderate for them until their brains are a bit better developed!

It CAN be hard, but that doesn't remove the responsibility from every parent to try.
There is a midway point between 'no tech at all' and '24/7 access to every app and website on earth'

ElevenSeven · 04/02/2024 15:28

Yabu to try to turn it into a wealth issue.

If you don’t want it for your kids, you can say no. You are not less able to do this because you aren’t as rich as people you know

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 04/02/2024 15:26

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/02/2024 15:22

Is it not more that if you shove a tablet at a 2 year old during dinner they grow up in a culture where communication and family time are not prioritised and staring into devices is the norm, so that when that child is slightly older there’s nothing weird about spending way too much time on SM?

Maybe. Not necessarily. Like I say, I'm not a fan, but giving your small child something to entertain them while you get some rare adult conversation time during a meal out does not necessarily mean your child doesn't get plenty of family conversation at home every day. Or while they are out withyou and friends/extended family doing things that are more engaging for them than just listening to adults chat.

So give them books/colouring stuff/games to play quietly rather than playing peppa pig in a shared space? If nothing else, it’s being an inconsiderate clown to everyone else around you! (But that’s a separate issue).

Also, cutting off the latter half of my post (where I talked about balance) to further your argument is bad form.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/02/2024 15:22

Is it not more that if you shove a tablet at a 2 year old during dinner they grow up in a culture where communication and family time are not prioritised and staring into devices is the norm, so that when that child is slightly older there’s nothing weird about spending way too much time on SM?

Maybe. Not necessarily. Like I say, I'm not a fan, but giving your small child something to entertain them while you get some rare adult conversation time during a meal out does not necessarily mean your child doesn't get plenty of family conversation at home every day. Or while they are out withyou and friends/extended family doing things that are more engaging for them than just listening to adults chat.

Maxus · 04/02/2024 15:22

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 15:18

Because it's very anti social to start with... That's my opinion. Also as a family & especially with the cost of living crisis a meal out is a complete treat to us & we love family time & chats. It's a real bug bear to us that a selfish family next to us thinks it's ok to have Peppa Pig on full blast... Putting their needs above everyone elses... Either engage with your kid or buy them some head phones.

How is it antisocial? It's no more antisocial than giving your child a book, or a sticker book, or getting them to go into the soft play.

Sturnidae · 04/02/2024 15:19

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 14:48

But I will stand by my opinion that wealthier families will have more money to throw at their kids to keep them more engaged in more wholesome persuits than Minecraft!

This alone tells me you actually know sod all about social media and gaming tbh. Have you seen how creative kids can get within games like minecraft? Or the teamwork that goes into games with friends? There is a huge value in gaming for children and young people, obviously not to the detriment of outside time and screen free time/activities, but it has value even if you don't understand it yourself. Dismissing that entirely is narrow minded.

Also, kids having access to "chat rooms" on minecraft isn't possible if you actually do your job as a parent and help them access it safely (because it is impossible if you actually ensure your kids accounts are locked down and they can't access the wider servers, but heyho, just dismiss the entire concept because you haven't taken five minutes to use Google and find out how to do that).

Bridgetjoneski · 04/02/2024 15:18

Maxus · 04/02/2024 15:07

Why should they have to? If this works for them that's all that matters.

Because it's very anti social to start with... That's my opinion. Also as a family & especially with the cost of living crisis a meal out is a complete treat to us & we love family time & chats. It's a real bug bear to us that a selfish family next to us thinks it's ok to have Peppa Pig on full blast... Putting their needs above everyone elses... Either engage with your kid or buy them some head phones.

OP posts:
Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 04/02/2024 15:18

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 04/02/2024 14:59

I'm not a fan of devices at the dinner table either, but I think it's a bit of a separate issue to the dangers of social media. Watching Peppa Pig on a tablet is no more addictive than watching tv ever was. It's just more portable! For example some people have the tv on constantly, even when having dinner. That's not a new thing.

Is it not more that if you shove a tablet at a 2 year old during dinner they grow up in a culture where communication and family time are not prioritised and staring into devices is the norm, so that when that child is slightly older there’s nothing weird about spending way too much time on SM?

I spend a lot of time on the internet so I’m not a Luddite! I just think any access to the internet needs to be balanced with a love of books/creativity/nature/things that don’t involve a screen. Obviously the kid in the restaurant on a tablet is a small snapshot of a day - maybe they do balance it out. But I’m willing to bet a lot of parents opt for the path of least resistance.