Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get my teen 17 year old a Financial Advisor?

88 replies

Ischial · 04/02/2024 13:16

I want to DS to know how money works and to help him set up a plan. I am hopeless and I want him to learn whilst he is young.

I am a bit nervous about how to find legitimate Financial Advisors.

I personally don't think this is unreasonable.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ischial · 06/02/2024 18:54

@cheesehouse @Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic

I'm writing a list of all the books and podcasts mentioned here.

He's got money to start with and I think now is the time to create the habits that Remit and Eoin suggested. Also I'm going to get books and look into the lemon group or whatever it was called.

Thank you so much everyone, this was exactly the type of advice I was looking for. The non guru get rich quick charlatans. Flowers

OP posts:
cheesehouse · 06/02/2024 18:21

@Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic he can start with paper trading, that's a bit safer... :)

ReinNotReignItIn · 06/02/2024 18:16

Ischial · 04/02/2024 13:46

@Maireas You're right I do seem to remember him learning a bit and him mentioning APR etc, but not to the extent private schools teach children. They get a fantastic in-depth grounding in finance from a young age.

My kids have just left a private large London day school and never got that! I need a refund!

Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic · 06/02/2024 18:14

Came here to mention Ramit - plus there’s the emails and podcasts too.
Which are really interesting from a psychology point of view too.

Maybe a private tutor might be more helpful than a financial advisor.

And it’s so much quicker to learn by doing - so maybe give him some tools to experiment with. Bit of money to invest.
Credit card. Get him to speck up a house he likes the look of on rightmove? Idk. That might be a bit too easy for him.

cheesehouse · 06/02/2024 18:12

Perfect28 · 06/02/2024 14:11

I'm a little confused as to why it's the schools responsibility and failure that he is ignorant about financial issues OP? Haven't you been his parent all that time?

I do think education in the UK is quite remiss in this aspect compared to in other countries... Most British people I knew from (a top Russell Group so very middle class) uni in London regard/regarded investing as a big scary thing. At least with the Internet, info is a lot more accessible now!

cheesehouse · 06/02/2024 18:08

Well done OP, it's nice to hear you're enjoying some of the suggested resources from other posters! :)

Perfect28 · 06/02/2024 14:11

I'm a little confused as to why it's the schools responsibility and failure that he is ignorant about financial issues OP? Haven't you been his parent all that time?

chantelion · 06/02/2024 14:07

pinkstripeycat · 04/02/2024 14:22

In private schools they learn how money and wealth works from an early age. They practise on Investopedia from 12 years old

That’s news to me. All 3 of my DSis kids aged 14-25 awent to or are at private schools (different ones as they moved around) and none have taught this.

I’ve taught my own children to budget and invest. It’s pretty east to introduce them to savings, budgeting, ISAs and shares. Both have online banking and started off with an easy access account, savings account & Government Child trust fund & now the eldest has an adult ISA and buys his owns shares in companies he’s interest in.

Very much true. My ds is only 8 and they are introducing bugdeting, profit and loss and even the concept of interest. They have had a lot of Talks and presentations from people from the big banks coming in to introduce the ideas. A lot of the parents are in banking/financial industry too, including dh and myself who are happy to go in and speak to the kids.

Ischial · 06/02/2024 14:02

Ramit Sethi's playbook it so useful 😍

OP posts:
Ischial · 06/02/2024 13:49

OMG how can you not love Eoin McGee!

Just the type I'm looking for 😍

OP posts:
Ischial · 06/02/2024 11:12

@Animalfromthemuppets22 Brilliant! I'll look at that too. He's doing Business Studies, so it's good to see that teachers though it was a good addition to their studies.

OP posts:
Ischial · 06/02/2024 11:10

@MojoMoon I totally agree with you. That is why I have avoided it all together, because I do not trust those types. However like you say there is a simpler way with index funds that many have suggested here, which seems the most sensible approach.

I think he is sensible enough to avoid those guru types, but I would like to guide him towards what others have suggested here and not do what I did and let the gurus types put me off the whole thing.

OP posts:
MojoMoon · 05/02/2024 22:01

It's nice that you want to learn about things he is interested in.

I'd generally suggest scepticism about lots of people who are investment "gurus" or "experts".
It genuinely is really, really hard to beat the market over any length of time.
An "star" investment manager can have some brilliant years and then some dreadful ones. Almost no one beats the market forever (by which I mean consistently outperforms what you would earn if you simply put money in a simple index tracking fund).

Lots of people out there who want to sell investment secrets and strategies and techniques, lots of investment funds that charge high fees to manage your money.
They prey on your dreams that you might be the lucky one and make your millions and get out of your ordinary life...

You should both watch Dumb Money - was out in cinemas last year so prob on Netflix soon. A look at lots of people who put their money into GameStop because of what they read on the Internet.
A few of them made money....but a lot more did not.

A lot of the time, simple is good. In many things including investing your savings.

Animalfromthemuppets22 · 05/02/2024 21:54

How to be good with money is an excellent book, written by Eoin McGee. It's Irish, but the principles are transferable. He also hosts a TV show on rte of the same name that has been used in secondary schools as part of business studies.

Ischial · 05/02/2024 21:49

@MojoMoon Yes he knows that part of finance. I'm talking more about the investing part. Yes, I could tell him to research in his own but I like to have conversations with him about things and staying connected. He's learning to drive and we talk about that too!

OP posts:
Ischial · 05/02/2024 21:43

@Weegie91 Love You Tube. I've found him and I'll show my DS. Thanks for that.

I suggested he do Economics if he wants a finance career, but most of the class including him did badly at only GCSE level. I know the teacher was absent a lot then left and they couldn't get a replacement but most of the kids found it hard in general and flunked it. His friend's dad who's a chartered accountant ended up having to teach his son and wouldn't let him stay on in 6th form because of the horrendous lack of teaching in Economics.

OP posts:
MojoMoon · 05/02/2024 21:42

He is 17.
Surely if he is interested and engaged in the topic, he is more than capable of researching and reading about it himself and given it is not an area you have expertise to share with him? Particularly if that is what he is studying or planning to study?

Really at this point he should know how interest rates work and how much debt costs (credit cards, overdrafts and student loans) so that he doesn't run up any more than he really needs when studying.

Everything else is fairly abstract for another ten years until he might be earning enough to actually save some of it and not spend it all on rent, food and commuting.
So the only key message at this point is don't overspend and know what you are paying on your debt.

(I work for a large investment fund and accidentally fell into a career finance after studying something completely different and managed to grasp it all fairly quickly, although obviously always more to learn. And all I do with my own money is stick most of it in a very vanilla and low cost index tracking stocks and shares ISA. You can't really beat the market over the long run.)

Ischial · 05/02/2024 21:30

@cheesehouse I don't think you're being unkind at all! I'm really interested in what you have written. I do find it interesting myself and have been trying to learn too. All I keep thinking is that I'd like to invest in gold for some reason! Probably because I know what that is!
I think a step by step guide would be good. I'm looking at the links and books others have suggested.

I do think it's fabulous that they teach this in East Asia to youngsters.

OP posts:
TrishTrix · 05/02/2024 19:51

Parents have to take the lead on this I think. As per PPs. Teach him how to read a payslip. Do basic budgeting. Find a good savings accounts. Talk about ISAs. Reinforce the importance of pensions.

If you know about other investment strategies talk about them or highlight he needs to learn more when he has more money to save.

Girasoli · 05/02/2024 19:50

@Ischial the financial advisors I know studied economics at uni, and then got onto graduate schemes and got trained more on the job.

Your DS might enjoy economics at university if he is interested in business/investing. DH studied it and is still in touch with lots of uni mates and they mostly seem to have reasonably interesting and well paid jobs as adults.

Weegie91 · 05/02/2024 19:44

Get him to watch/read Ramit Sethi. Great financial advice about index fund investments, saving for a house/car/rainy day fund etc responsibly, how to use credit cards. Brilliant resource and most of it is free. He has a book on amazon and a YouTube channel. I've learned so much from him.

cheesehouse · 05/02/2024 19:34

Ischial · 05/02/2024 18:19

@DistantDiamondSky I was trying to be tactful and use inference, but it seems I will have to spell it out. I saw it with my own eyes and it is the type of school that only people with enormous wealth attend - not your bog standard private school. The type that would not break a sweat if VAT was added to school fees, as their money is abundant. Perhaps that's why the teach them young! How to keep your wealth 101!

That is lovely that your father did that for you. I hope that means you can retire early should you wish to.

Again, I genuinely am not trying to be unkind, and I understand your intimidation. I think you're glamorising and placing it on a pedestal a bit. Investopedia is free to use, just like Mumsnet and other sites. It's even a bit outdated as far as paper trading apps/sites go – lots of apps you could download on the app store this very moment come with more updated bells and whistles.

I grew up in East Asia and we were taught finances & investing young as very average children in very average schools.

If you're interested, I suggest learning along with your son! There's no need for an FA unless you're a HNW individual, but even then not all HNW individuals use them. FAs are not gods – and depending on appetite risk, some "finance bros" aren't even trustworthy beyond bull market runs or sunrise industry bandwagon results they use as proof of "competence".

You might want to start with looking at value investing, dollar cost averaging, blue chip stocks, and indexed ETFs. These are all fairly old school, conservative and safe.

Ischial · 05/02/2024 18:20

@Hankunamatata

OP posts:
Ischial · 05/02/2024 18:19

@DistantDiamondSky I was trying to be tactful and use inference, but it seems I will have to spell it out. I saw it with my own eyes and it is the type of school that only people with enormous wealth attend - not your bog standard private school. The type that would not break a sweat if VAT was added to school fees, as their money is abundant. Perhaps that's why the teach them young! How to keep your wealth 101!

That is lovely that your father did that for you. I hope that means you can retire early should you wish to.

OP posts:
DistantDiamondSky · 05/02/2024 10:10

My kid is in private school and absolutely does not get taught this stuff or shown Investopedia; there is a lot of misinformation at the moment about private schools!