Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or was what I did childish?

116 replies

hasbeen91 · 04/02/2024 11:23

So DH and I have recently split, PIL moved to another country a few months ago and they have never really had any involvement with the kids or offered childcare (I am aware they dont have to and thats their choice). They never ring the kids or anything so their only outlook to see them is through my facebook, I unfriended them. Not because I want to be horrible but because they have little to no impact on my life and now apparently they are p at me because they cant see regular updates on the kids. There are other ways to see them, facetime etc. I hate facebook, everything is so false, they comment on their birthdays how much they love them and I just think it is all for show, no 1 would know they didnt have any involvement in their life.

OP posts:
WombatChocolate · 04/02/2024 15:19

I think it was petty of you to do this. At the same time, I can understand why you wanted to be petty. You yourself have acknowledged yourself that you think it was childish.

When people separate, they don’t always behave well. Hurt makes people become petty and a bit bitter and try to hit-back. It’s hard to rise above it and do the bigger thing. It’s hard to think about the others involved such as the GP and very easy to just become Nyerere in the impact on ourselves.

OP, I think you’re right that it was a bit petty. Of course you were entitled to do it and yes, your ex should be updating his parents on the GC and yes, they should be maintaining better contact with the GC. But these things aren’t happening and two wrongs, don’t make a right.

You say that you’ve done it now and can’t undo it. I’m not sure that’s the case. If you really wanted to, you could reach out to them and say you’ve re-thought it and would like to maintain contact via Facebook. If you wanted you could also say the children would be glad to hear more from them. Your action doesn’t have to be the final word on this.

Probably your DC will benefit from contact with the GP and any actions you can take to keep them updated about what’s going on will probably aid that relationship into the future. It might pain you to think the GP tell the world they are invovled via a few off comments on FB, but in the end, you’re not responsible for their poor choices and only your own. And in this hard time when people are not always nice to each other and relationships are strained, being the bigger generous person won’t be the wrong thing.

Wooloohooloo · 04/02/2024 15:04

When I split from ex DP I unfriended all of his family on Facebook because I didn't feel it appropriate for them to be on my private page any more. Ex DP's parents are lovely, we still get on, they look after DD a lot but I didn't want the aggravation or worry about what I posted. I take a lot more pics than ex DP but send them all to him so he can share with his family.

TinyYellow · 04/02/2024 13:50

You have separated from your husband and his family, it’s perfectly normal not to want people connected to something you’re trying to move on from on your social media.

If the in laws want to know about their grandkids, they can ask. If they expect the responsibility to be on the parent to facilitate contact with the grandparents, they should have told their son.

MsGrumpytrousers · 04/02/2024 13:45

hasbeen91 · 04/02/2024 13:07

as I said for PIL to see them or else they wouldnt

Then not having to do that is a perk of getting divorced.

SweetBirdsong · 04/02/2024 13:44

Absolutely not unreasonable. As has been said they can get updates and pics from their son! I've been on Facebook for about 15-16 years, but I'm actually getting sick of it. I've got 75 'friends' on there - and there is only about 18 or 20 of them that I actually care about/have contact with much in real life.

There's a few ex work colleagues, and neighbours from my village, and old penpals, and folk I used to have in my life - (old neighbours from where I used to live, and old schoolmates etc,) who are constantly posting pictures of themselves and their 'adorable' husband and absolutely adorable perfect children ... Like 10 photographs a week of them and 'hubz' some weeks, and about 30 photographs a week of their children sometimes ... (THEY HAVEN'T CHANGED SINCE YESTERDAY!) and then they get a little bit snarky and funny and a bit 'confused' if someone doesn't like every single one.

Then you've got the 'brag about everything' ones, like an old school mate of mine who goes to 3 or 4 different countries each year - and NZ and Aus every other year as she has a son there. Cue 100s of photos for WEEKS of her NZ/AUS trip and pics of her amazing son and PERFECT grandchildren... with the tagline 'don't be jealous of my life. Oh go on then DO!' 😆

Hmm

I have another 3 or 4 people who go on and on and ON about how fucking amazing their grandchildren are, and actually one said she loves them more than her actual children. Make of that what you will! Photos of said grandchildren are posted every single DAY!

Then there are a couple of old friends (who are sisters,) who have 5 and 6 children each, and 18-20 grandchildren, (between them,) and about 12 great grandchildren (between them.) On at least 3 or 4 days of any given week, they post to celebrate a birthday of one of these 40-odd children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren, OR one of the many partners of the children and grandchildren - about 30 partners! (Great grands have no kids yet, still too young!) OR they post about an anniversary of one of the couples... Again, about 30 couples, so 30 anniversaries. You feel like you have to LIKE every single post, in case they are offended. And it gets exhausting!

Then there are about another 15 or 20 people who never ever ever acknowledge anything at all. Not one single photograph or any single post or anything.

Then you've got people who just post to slag people off and Facebook shame people - and as people have said - lots of people create a false narrative of this perfect life. 'Oh, what a wonderful man my man is!' And you know he's shagging the office clerk behind her back. It's embarrassing and it's cringe worthy.

I can't delete my Facebook cause I've got 15 or 16 years of memories and photographs on there. But I have put a post on it at the moment (using it as my cover photo) saying 'I'm off Facebook for the time being and am having a break from it... ' so I don't have to engage with people on there. I can engage with the 18 or 20 people closest to me - a few neighbours friends colleagues and close family - in real life. I don't need to brag or say how fucking wonderful my life is and how perfect my children are and how my relationship with my husband is soooooo superb and amazing and brilliant, on Facebook every fucking day.

.

olympicsrock · 04/02/2024 13:41

YANBU. You did right to remove them from your social media to allow you privacy.
DH can update PIL and pass on the Well Done’s .
His circus his monkeys now.
He should not have passed on their displeasure. Nothing to do with you now.

ICanSeeMyHouseFromHere · 04/02/2024 13:31

Honestly, I did the same too.

At first, I made the effort to visit ex-MIL, took the kids over (she also lives in a different country to me), responded to her requests for present ideas for the kids etc. Kept it pleasant.

Then I found out she'd visited our country, but hadn't bothered to tell me or my eldest (my youngest mentioned she was here when he went to see his dad one weekend - my eldest was away at the time), and that made me both angry and disappointed in her behaviour as my eldest loves her, and would have loved to see her (and I would have found a way to make it happen). So now she's blocked. Fuck that. No-one that thoughtless gets to take advantage of my generally good nature.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 04/02/2024 13:26

Corondel · 04/02/2024 11:33

Childish and passive-aggressive, and likely to have a negative pact on your children’s relationship with their grandparents.

What relationship? According to the OP they have made no effort to have one.
This will make precisely zero difference to that.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 04/02/2024 13:20

But surely they don't know whether they've been blocked or whether you've just done as thousands of people have been doing lately and deinstalled Facebook? They can't 'insist' that you keep Facebook (if you wanted to get rid of it) just to facilitate them looking at pictures of their GC.

Beautiful3 · 04/02/2024 13:17

They relied on your f.b updates to see what's going on with their grandchildren. I would say, I'm taking a break from social media. But you're welcome to facetime/call the grandchildren. Your ex can take photos and post on his f.b?

Healthyhappymama · 04/02/2024 13:12

No I personally don't think blocking is childish. As you said they have no interest in real life about children, they don't call or babysit. Why should they be pissed because they want to see updates and put fake comments. If they want updates they cal phone or other means.

Conkersinautumn · 04/02/2024 13:09

Its on their son to keep them up to date and support any sort of relationship with his children. I'd not raise it again but if ex does say you need your own privacy. They and the ex are being idiots here. It's Facebook its no basis for a relationship.

Bluenotgreen · 04/02/2024 13:09

This sounds like wifework tbh.

Their son is responsible for updating them on his DC. You aren’t doing it any more.

hasbeen91 · 04/02/2024 13:07

as I said for PIL to see them or else they wouldnt

OP posts:
dearymcdearface · 04/02/2024 13:05

If you hate FB why do you keep updating with photos of your kids?

You should respect their privacy anyway, they did not consent.

SKG231 · 04/02/2024 12:45

It’s not your job to update them on your children. When you’re with their son or not. Why is it that all plans are left to the wife to make, all presents to be arranged by the wife, communication etc.

he is their son, it is up to him to communicate with his parents.

Scarletttulips · 04/02/2024 12:40

I’ve never posted my children on FB - I respect their privacy. GP should do the same.

You did the right thing, they have your number if they wish to contact you or the children.

They lost their ability to brag? Boo Hoo.

Mnetcurious · 04/02/2024 12:30

Absolutely YANBU. Why should they be able to have a nosey at your life? It’s not your responsibility to keep your EX-pil updated on the children, that’s their son’s job. The exception might be if they still treated you as a dil who they love and care for, regularly kept in touch etc. but that’s not the case.

Moier · 04/02/2024 12:29

Up to their Dad not you.
I agree with you.

user1471522343 · 04/02/2024 12:29

Ok. No apologies required. I thought you were looking for opinions.

hasbeen91 · 04/02/2024 12:28

it literally changes nothing for the kids, it only benefits them

OP posts:
hasbeen91 · 04/02/2024 12:27

user1471522343 · 04/02/2024 12:26

My (maybe incorrect) assumption is that it’s in your kids best interests to have a healthy and warm relationship with their grandparents and so on this basis I would want to facilitate that relationship as far as possible.

yes it does mean you may be enabling some lazy grandparents but if it’s good for your kids then that’s the reason for doing it.

I don’t use facebook, never have, so don’t really understand how it work tbh, but if it leaving them on your Facebook account was the least time consuming option for you to allow this sharing of fairly simple information,
and if you now have to find another way to share it (by email or whatever)

then you may have cut off your nose to spite your face.

On the other hand if leaving them on your Facebook account allows them access into other areas of your private life then I would have done the same thing.

Yes it is up to your husband now and it sounds to me that by letting you know they were pissed off he was hoping that you would continue to do all the leg work of keeping them in touch. (No idea if this was a feature of your relationship with him). But don’t not do something because it helps them ( ex and grandparents) if it is going to help your kids.

what is the priority here?

I massively disagree sorry

OP posts:
user1471522343 · 04/02/2024 12:26

My (maybe incorrect) assumption is that it’s in your kids best interests to have a healthy and warm relationship with their grandparents and so on this basis I would want to facilitate that relationship as far as possible.

yes it does mean you may be enabling some lazy grandparents but if it’s good for your kids then that’s the reason for doing it.

I don’t use facebook, never have, so don’t really understand how it work tbh, but if it leaving them on your Facebook account was the least time consuming option for you to allow this sharing of fairly simple information,
and if you now have to find another way to share it (by email or whatever)

then you may have cut off your nose to spite your face.

On the other hand if leaving them on your Facebook account allows them access into other areas of your private life then I would have done the same thing.

Yes it is up to your husband now and it sounds to me that by letting you know they were pissed off he was hoping that you would continue to do all the leg work of keeping them in touch. (No idea if this was a feature of your relationship with him). But don’t not do something because it helps them ( ex and grandparents) if it is going to help your kids.

what is the priority here?

CunkEverywhereOnEverything · 04/02/2024 12:20

Not childish at all. If you were really close to them before the split and remained so after and then removed them as a big fuck you that would be one thing but you’re not close to them, they don’t make the effort by the sounds of it and now it’s their son’s responsibility to keep the relationship between his parents and the children going.

Swipe left for the next trending thread