Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Theunamedcat · 04/02/2024 14:41

We cannot prevent children smoking drinking and having sex underage how exactly will we police online? Parents will just put phones in their names or payg phones which don't even need to be registered to work

shreknjumps · 04/02/2024 14:35

Phones are completely banned at my kids secondary school, for both staff and students. They have to be turned off and in lockers at all times.

It makes a huge difference.

AliceA2021 · 04/02/2024 14:32

altmember · 04/02/2024 14:29

How is this case anything to do with kids using social media? The perpetrators were getting their fix from watching content on the dark web.

My point exactly. As much as I feel for Ms Ghey it's not as simple as she made out. She made various claims and suggestions un her interview that wouldn't work. She's obviously not an IT expert but a grieving mother.

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 14:32

Blahblah34 · 04/02/2024 14:23

Every parent of teenagers that I know says they wish they could ban phones. Yet then everyone says it’s impossible. Surely we need to find a way to make it possible?

So why don't they? Because they can. For their own kids. Or limit access. Or control usage.

What use is saying they wish they could but then do fuck all about it?

Why is everyone expecting the "government" to do something?

If you feel that strongly and it's that important,do it yourself (whether I agree or not it's irrelevant).

TheGander · 04/02/2024 14:32

Namechangenamechange321 · 04/02/2024 13:18

My cousin does not allow her 15 year old a smart phone. He has a Nokia or similar brick phone and uses her WhatsApp to message friends

That’s good your cousin can enforce it. My now 17 year old would never have accepted that at 15. For one thing he wanted to be in touch with his girlfriend ( and probably sexchat, let’s be realistic) and there’s no way he was going to do that via my phone.

SweetcornFritter · 04/02/2024 14:30

Children plotting to murder their fellow classmates is thankfully incredibly rare and child murderers have existed since way before the availability of social media. If there is evidence that social media has led to an increase in sadistic crimes by kids then by all means let’s have the debate about it but until then it should remain the parent’s responsibility to restrict or allow their child’s access to the internet and to have regular discussions with them about what they are seeing and who they are communicating with.

AliceA2021 · 04/02/2024 14:30

whiteroseredrose · 04/02/2024 09:39

Theoretically you can't have lots of the apps until you are 13, but lots of primary school DC still have tik tok, Instagram and the like. So banning them won't make a difference. Most DC use them without any issues.

Plus, Jamie Bulger's murderers won't have had phones and social media to plan, and that didn't stop them.

Exactly, I think a lot of people jump to blaming horror movies (back in the day), gaming and now social media.

Some individuals have early life trauma, dreadful experiences which impact decision making, anti social personality disorders, mad or bad.

It's multi factorial and not a black and white issue which many are oversimplifying

TheGander · 04/02/2024 14:29

It would require an authoritarian government to take charge and set the rules, as they do in China. Kids are banned from gaming except in certain hours there, I think the platforms are disabled nationwide. Anything less than that and people are going to find ways round it.

altmember · 04/02/2024 14:29

How is this case anything to do with kids using social media? The perpetrators were getting their fix from watching content on the dark web.

Thewishingchair123 · 04/02/2024 14:27

Blahblah34 · 04/02/2024 14:23

Every parent of teenagers that I know says they wish they could ban phones. Yet then everyone says it’s impossible. Surely we need to find a way to make it possible?

Agree. ‘Phone’ is a misnomer anyway - it’s a device which gives them access to hugely inappropriate content .

crochetmonkey74 · 04/02/2024 14:26

they are literally doing it now with vapes- like they did with cigarettes

Blahblah34 · 04/02/2024 14:23

Every parent of teenagers that I know says they wish they could ban phones. Yet then everyone says it’s impossible. Surely we need to find a way to make it possible?

CaptainPliskin · 04/02/2024 14:18

Goblinmodeactivated · 04/02/2024 14:07

We very much know that SM is not a positive influence in young people’s lives. That it is harmful. There is plenty of data that supports that.
It would of course be possible to make it much more difficult for children to access SM but there needs to be collective will to do so; and governments who prioritise well being over business interests. I don’t think we have either.

Exchange social media for tv, why do society have shows like csi, like Dexter etc various films glamourisimg crime etc

We need to retool society to make it better

Thewishingchair123 · 04/02/2024 14:17

D600 · 04/02/2024 14:12

Of course it can be done.

The minority requiring assistive technology can be catered to.

The UK needs to acquire a CAN DO attitude rather than endlessly saying it can't, and acquiescing to the Fuckerbergs of the world.

100% agree

D600 · 04/02/2024 14:12

Of course it can be done.

The minority requiring assistive technology can be catered to.

The UK needs to acquire a CAN DO attitude rather than endlessly saying it can't, and acquiescing to the Fuckerbergs of the world.

Goblinmodeactivated · 04/02/2024 14:07

We very much know that SM is not a positive influence in young people’s lives. That it is harmful. There is plenty of data that supports that.
It would of course be possible to make it much more difficult for children to access SM but there needs to be collective will to do so; and governments who prioritise well being over business interests. I don’t think we have either.

YankSplaining · 04/02/2024 14:06

I was a teenager in the early 2000s, before smartphones. The only social media, arguably, was LiveJournal, which only nerdy/creative kids had, anyway. There were still cases of teenagers plotting murders through technology. They just used AIM or email. People still found really horrible images and videos online, too.

Disallowing smartphones for younger teenagers might help stem the tide, but I don’t think it would completely solve the environment that contributed to this murder.

whiteroseredrose · 04/02/2024 13:59

I don't think social media or DC owning smartphones is the cause of Brianna's death.

Jamie Bulger's killers were able to plan their attack without it.

Maybe it's the parenting that's the problem. A PP has said that one of the killers' father is a sex offender. That is much more likely to be the driver than owning a smartphone.
From memory one of Jamie Bulger's killers also had a troubled background. Maybe that is where we should be looking.

We had a weird and nasty child in my primary school in the 1970s. She squashed a kitten with her bare hands and strung up a dog. No phones or any sort of media then, but domestic violence at home.

DC all over the country have and use phones and for the vast majority it isn't a problem. They are used within reason and the DC have other interests too.

They can be very useful. Mine got phones at 10 when they started walking to school alone. They also used them in secondary school, during lessons, for research.

The phones may be used as a tool, but are not the root cause.

Thewishingchair123 · 04/02/2024 13:55

i know it’s hugely complex but I’d like to see discussions from the government, tech companies , social media platform owners , schools to discuss best ways of doing this. A starting point is only allowing under 16s to have access to certain agreed phone models with an agreed age-appropriate range of apps which can be installed in said phones (to include assistive tech where necessary).phones are the hardest thing for parents to monitor 24/7. It would be a massive starting point at least. Of course some parents/kids will not agree/want to abide but the current norms and lack of restrictions are hugely worrying.

ConnectFortyFour · 04/02/2024 13:52

I completely agree with Esther ghey’s comments and hope this campaign gets loads of traction.

the Wild West of the internet was such a big part of this case. I believe one of the things that made Brianna vulnerable was her large online following which Scarlett would have seen and possibly been jealous of. I think Briannas mum is very brave and honest in saying it was difficult to control. You can see from the cctv footage that Brianna was addicted to her phone. It’s not realistic to expect parents to solve this at a household level, we need support from government and the tech companies.

DomPom47 · 04/02/2024 13:46

Schools would be grateful if there was a ban. It is possible. Some parents will defy the ban but if it was a law most wools abide by it.

Klcak · 04/02/2024 13:45

I agree with her, but it seems pretty much impossible.

My teens are OK without tik tok, Insta, facebook. One teen is also ok without snapchat, but the other teen asked us to have it because it's a primary means of communication with her peers. So we said yes to her having snapchat as it would have been silly of us to say no. She felt she needed it for communication. her location is hidden and she doesn't reply to randos.

both have whatsapp, but that's primarily for family and specific friend group stuff. it doesn't seem to be problematic, and both are old enough for it. (age limit 16)

They both watch loads of youtube.

A phone has now become quite a different thing to 10 or 20 years ago. It's now "necessary" and often has a lot of private information on. It's therefore very difficult to police. Taking someone's phone to go through the whole thing is pretty unacceptable once they reach a certain age. It really relies on old fashioned communication - talking about what is going on.

Acornsplop · 04/02/2024 13:45

I think most people would agree, but as others have said, the genie is out of the bottle and can't be put back in. Kids are tech savvy - way more than their parents in the main - and if they want to access something, one way or another, they will.

Sure, but lots if genies are out of lots of bottles!

We have regulation regarding alcohol, tobacco, car driving etc. We don't say "well children will find a way to access it so what's the point in regulating it". We make rules and laws to help to curb unwanted behaviour. We shouldn't just shrug and say 'oh well it's too late now,"

crochetmonkey74 · 04/02/2024 13:45

Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 13:43

Of course buses and trains have apps. National Rail Enquires.

I think the whole Internet needs regulation, rather than trying to restrict what technology children have access too.

People on MN go mental at the mention of the word "phone" but are content for kids to have tablets, ipads, ipods, laptops, xboxes and PlayStations. All of which can access the Internet and shed loads of unregulated youtube content.

But mention phone and it's NO NO

Because they have put the phone into peoples hands 24/7 in the way that these other devices haven't been

Opinuga · 04/02/2024 13:44

I agree with her. All three of those children - her daughter and the two murderers - were adversely affected by the social media they accessed and by living too much of their lives in an online unreality state.

It is absolutely possible to restrict it through licensing and lockdown controls for under 18s.