Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Mojodojocasahaus · 04/02/2024 16:24

Agree with the above - totally disinterested parents

girlfriend44 · 04/02/2024 16:16

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 15:43

So this kid spent hours and hours watching horror movies on Netflix. (Should we ban Netflix too btw?)

She skipped school.

She was possibly expelled /managed out from more than one school.(One article says several schools,the latest being the managed move to Brianna's school).

She drugged a classmate, something which was hidden in the move.

But it's not a systemic failure to act (on various people's part), no. It's social media's fault. Right.

It's probably something to do with a lack of discipline at home too and a lack of interest in her life.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 16:15

YoBeaches · 04/02/2024 15:25

@Bubble2024 I think the point is that in time, handing them a phone would be as bad as handing them a cigarette or a can of beer. You physically could do it, but you don't because there are consequences.

I love some of the ideas on this thread. I work in tech and would love to be part of a project that reinstalled safeguarding as a priority over convenience and peer demand.

Other than it’s not comparable at all and neither of those things are permitted in a multitude of settings. Where you can do it you largely do not see children. You cannot prevent kids from touching phones and no one is going to police it as is being suggested. It’s ludicrous. Add into that the fact that phones are increasingly used as assistive tech you’re going backward. This is like suggesting the solution to drink driving is ban cars. It is not.

JFDIYOLO · 04/02/2024 16:11

A company that markets mobiles that can only do phone calls (I remember them well ...) could do very well.

Kosher phones are already available

https://www.usmobile.com/blog/kosher-phone-plans-understanding-the-basics/

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 16:04

Out of curiosity, What would the penalty be?

Fernsfernsferns · 04/02/2024 16:01

carrotbagel · 04/02/2024 08:37

I don't think it's possible. Pandora's box has been opened. The genie is out the bottle. It's so sad and I wish it wasn't like this.

I disagree. A lot of teens used to smoke and now few of them do.

30 years ago when I was a teen under age drinking was completely normal. I was a 'good girl' and did well at school but still went to pubs with my friends with increasing regularity aged 15 an onwards.

We all drank A LOT.

the same with car safety, using seat belts and car seats, or helmets when cycling.

All things where new laws and regulation and education have changed norms to make things safer.

We can do that with social media too. We can change the norms and we should.

We will look back on this era and be shocked with what we've exposed teens to and how badly we have let them down, just like we do now about smoking ,or memories of sliding up and down the back seat of a car without seatbelts as a child.

@cazpar I agree delaying giving teens smart phones is part of it. They don't NEED them. they can and should start with a normal phone.

The govt should regulate, no smartphone or social media before 16

girlfriend44 · 04/02/2024 15:54

whiteroseredrose · 04/02/2024 13:59

I don't think social media or DC owning smartphones is the cause of Brianna's death.

Jamie Bulger's killers were able to plan their attack without it.

Maybe it's the parenting that's the problem. A PP has said that one of the killers' father is a sex offender. That is much more likely to be the driver than owning a smartphone.
From memory one of Jamie Bulger's killers also had a troubled background. Maybe that is where we should be looking.

We had a weird and nasty child in my primary school in the 1970s. She squashed a kitten with her bare hands and strung up a dog. No phones or any sort of media then, but domestic violence at home.

DC all over the country have and use phones and for the vast majority it isn't a problem. They are used within reason and the DC have other interests too.

They can be very useful. Mine got phones at 10 when they started walking to school alone. They also used them in secondary school, during lessons, for research.

The phones may be used as a tool, but are not the root cause.

That's how it started a payg that could call and text parents.

That's how it should stay. If you want to look things up use the family computer at home in the Main room.

That's how it was. As soon as it moved on to smartphones you could fit in your pocket and read anywhere it went downhill.

HoneyButterPopcorn · 04/02/2024 15:53

This might give parents a false sense of security - know where the kids are so assume they are safe?

We have one of those family and friends trackers on our phones - mostly used by DS to say ‘you in Waitrose? Can you get me more coffee and drop it over’ or my sister asking why I took the wrong road driving to hers.

We got it when DS started secondary school and noone has taken it off their phones.

Combattingthemoaners · 04/02/2024 15:52

A total ban is not going to happen. I agree age limits should be enforced and policed but it is unlikely to happen as it’s too far on now. The problem is that many parents are allowing their children to have social media from the age of 8 or 9 and then do not monitor their usage. They are not old enough to navigate the online world unsupervised. It would be like dropping them into the town centre for 2-4 hours a day and letting them get up to what they want.

There HAS to be more focused campaigns or advice for parents from a central government perspective. It isn’t an invasion of your child’s privacy to keep them safe online, it is your parental duty. Schools do a lot of work with children on internet safety, it is adults who need more training.

Sweden99 · 04/02/2024 15:51

@Outthedoor24, I don't know TBH. Sorry, I am not sure I even feel qualified to have an opinion.

HoneyButterPopcorn · 04/02/2024 15:50

Lots of failures, none joined up. Brianna’s mum wants to help young people with MH issues - which all of these young people seems to suffer badly from (not helped by social media).

I think more regulation of the nasties/porn/abuse sites, blocking content on age, education in schools (drop the ‘rainbow and bunnies’ ‘you can be whatever you wanna be!’ crap and teach kids that social media is like the bloody Wild West)…

The genie is out of the bottle. Toddlers can navigate around YouTube, we are bombarded with ads for phones/Camera apps, gaming, gambling…

Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 15:46

Sweden99 · 04/02/2024 15:33

Some might find this useful:
https://moochies.com/en-US/
For kids rather than teens though

Those are as much GPS trackers as they are anything else.

Is it really appropriate to be tracking teens, and encouraging them to think it's normal for parents or partners to track their every movement?

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 15:43

So this kid spent hours and hours watching horror movies on Netflix. (Should we ban Netflix too btw?)

She skipped school.

She was possibly expelled /managed out from more than one school.(One article says several schools,the latest being the managed move to Brianna's school).

She drugged a classmate, something which was hidden in the move.

But it's not a systemic failure to act (on various people's part), no. It's social media's fault. Right.

girlfriend44 · 04/02/2024 15:43

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Agree with her. Shame it's had to take killing to released it.

Go back to the old payg for kids it was much better.

YoBeaches · 04/02/2024 15:25

@Bubble2024 I think the point is that in time, handing them a phone would be as bad as handing them a cigarette or a can of beer. You physically could do it, but you don't because there are consequences.

I love some of the ideas on this thread. I work in tech and would love to be part of a project that reinstalled safeguarding as a priority over convenience and peer demand.

Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 15:20

LuciferRising · 04/02/2024 15:07

It isn't just phones though. It's tablets, laptops, computers, gaming devices, modern TVs, Kindles etc.

These are pervasive in our society; we depend on these things to live a modern life. With AI, it will grow. It is a whole other world on top of our physical one. We have to adapt to it, somehow.

At the moment we authorise any app DD downloads, her phone can only go through our wireless so goes through a proxy - we can look at the logs and restrict sites. We search her phone.

You can see the personality difference between her friends who access TikTok - at 11 and 12 - and those who don't.

Exactly it's not just phones. But people go mad at the word phone - a tablet is grand but no no not a phone

ChaosAndCrumbs · 04/02/2024 15:08

AliceA2021 · 04/02/2024 14:30

Exactly, I think a lot of people jump to blaming horror movies (back in the day), gaming and now social media.

Some individuals have early life trauma, dreadful experiences which impact decision making, anti social personality disorders, mad or bad.

It's multi factorial and not a black and white issue which many are oversimplifying

According to the media, the girl who fantasied about Brianna’s murder didn’t have a traumatic background. I do think this should be taken with a disclaimer, as we can never truly know what has happened to someone, neither can be know whether her brain (eg. Amygdala) appears different without a scan or - if it was - what caused this. However, I think while internet access and algorithms pushing similar and more extreme content couldn’t be argued to be the ‘root cause’, they can be argued to have perpetuated a fantasy world and repeatedly exposed the murderer to extreme content that she otherwise would not have had access to and which had potential to increase empathy deficit whilst providing information or ideas about how to kill.

I used to use pro-ana websites. I had Anorexia Nervosa. I still would have had it without the websites, but they did make me feel as if my beliefs around my body and food were normal because I was in an echo chamber where so many other teenagers felt the same. I supported the crackdown on those and would similarly support crackdown on social media for similar reasons because the algorithms perpetuate things. We know as adults when we search the term ‘pregnancy’, we get bombarded with diet pill and weight loss adverts. The more content teens watch about a similar subject, the more it is shown to them. That goes for everything, whether diet or meditation or mental illness or horror films or videos of dancing fruit. We’ve seen lots of damage done in various ways through exposure to misogynistic content, ‘perfect body’ content, extreme spirituality content etc.

I don’t think anyone is saying it’s a black and white issue - nothing is. Even smoking has other factors that raise or lower risk of health issues (I found this out when learning about Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency as my husband is a carrier). However, to me, it makes no sense to disregard amount of screen time, type of content, algorithms and access to content as participating factors.

LuciferRising · 04/02/2024 15:07

It isn't just phones though. It's tablets, laptops, computers, gaming devices, modern TVs, Kindles etc.

These are pervasive in our society; we depend on these things to live a modern life. With AI, it will grow. It is a whole other world on top of our physical one. We have to adapt to it, somehow.

At the moment we authorise any app DD downloads, her phone can only go through our wireless so goes through a proxy - we can look at the logs and restrict sites. We search her phone.

You can see the personality difference between her friends who access TikTok - at 11 and 12 - and those who don't.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 15:03

altmember · 04/02/2024 14:29

How is this case anything to do with kids using social media? The perpetrators were getting their fix from watching content on the dark web.

Exactly! We have a strong enough history of child killers to know it’s much more than SM.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 15:02

D600 · 04/02/2024 14:12

Of course it can be done.

The minority requiring assistive technology can be catered to.

The UK needs to acquire a CAN DO attitude rather than endlessly saying it can't, and acquiescing to the Fuckerbergs of the world.

You’re going to arrest parents for handing their child a phone to keep them amused on a train? In a hospital apt?

CaramelMac · 04/02/2024 14:53

Unfortunately it just is not possible, yes some good parents would stop their children having smart phones but plenty of others wouldn’t and some kids would just find a way around it, and I’d bet a pound to a penny those murderers can from troubled home lives.

Unfortunately a small percentage of the population are bad and will kill no matter what, I think that’s what has happened in this case.

equuscaballus · 04/02/2024 14:52

While not exactly the topic of the thread I feel this is related to the tech part of the equation.

In a Tedtalk a few years ago, a research team was trying to assess the impact of porn on teenage boys. They were unable to form a control group as they were unable to find ANY boys who didn't.

The consensus was, the age to buy your child a phone with internet access was when you were comfortable with them having unrestricted access to porn.

Obviously this translates to a lot of other areas on the internet, such as self harm and suicide sites.

Adhdeeedout · 04/02/2024 14:51

The problem isn’t just the platforms but what they allow to be posted annd their unwillingness or inability to act upon reported posts that are problematic at best.

furthermore we as parents need to teach our kids to be more open about talking about problems with peers or sitting down with our kids and policing their social media interactions ourselves. This shouldn’t be done in secret but with our kids beside us so it opens up much needed conversations about behaviour online and appropriateness.

And we also have to hold a degree of responsibility for raising entitled bullies. We see it daily on here, multiple times a post arseholes and bullies out in force where it’s unwarranted and if adults are showing their kids this is how we behave then why should we expect them to behave any differently?

The problem doesn’t lie solely with the software, it lies with how we ourselves behave and teach or accept our kids behaving.

Swipe left for the next trending thread