Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 18:28

Gymrabbit · 04/02/2024 18:28

Because I was slightly rephrasing what I said to make it clearer.

Other posters have engaged with my comments in a robust manner.

I consider teenagers dressing in porn inspired clothes for school ‘vile’ not those who call it out.

No. You are editing some pretty vile comments. All of which I’ve reported.

You are victim blaming and it’s gross.

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 18:28

I’m in awe of Esther too. Such grace and strength, trying to do something good at such a horrific time. My heart goes out to her. I think she is one of the best placed people to have a voice on this subject and as a parenting site MN should do everything they can to support her. The laws she is suggesting would have protected and made such a difference to my children.

Gymrabbit · 04/02/2024 18:28

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 18:21

Why do you keep posting gross comments and then editing them?

Because I was slightly rephrasing what I said to make it clearer.

Other posters have engaged with my comments in a robust manner.

I consider teenagers dressing in porn inspired clothes for school ‘vile’ not those who call it out.

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 04/02/2024 18:26

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 18:14

@soupfiend I honestly don't mind discussions as to why. I much prefer them as they tend to uncover a lot more going on, other systemic failures, I learn a lot etc.

But knee jerk, witch hunty , pie in the sky reactions like ban all smart phones/the internet until 18 are pointless. They focus on the wrong things, never go anywhere or end up with any real solutions or change and it just gives a platform to the sanctimonious to tell us how their 75 yo dad never needed a smart phone and their kid didn't even have a phone until 19. Yeah right. Never mind that I actually talked about the dangers of outright bans and how vulnerable it has left some of the kids I work with and I was completely ignored. Because no one actually wants to have a discussion or debate, just to beat a certain drum.

I agree with you whole heartedly on porn. I also see and acknowledge the dangers of SM . You know what I never see? Asks for bans of smartphone or the internet in that context. Sure there's talk about content and platforms but I have never seen someone say no man /boy should have access to a smart phone in case he accesses violent porn on it. It's never,ever even a consideration.

Also why is no one demanding the ban of Netflix(and such like) or no child having access until 16/18? It was also a contributing factor. By the sounds of it, it seems to have sparked /fed Scarlett's fascination with blood and gore and murder. In her own home,in plain view.

i know the school both girls attended were unaware of the full circumstances of the ‘managed move’ (which is truly appalling) but I wonder how much Scarlett’s parents knew?

I know that if I had been made to leave my school due to attempting to poison another child there would have been no netflix, no phones/internet at all (let alone dark web) and absolutely no hanging out in the park. My parents would have moved heaven and earth to get me help, and if all else failed, I would be living somewhere else. I would be the same with my own children. I would go to any extreme (including leaving my job, moving house, hospitalisation, etc) to prevent anything else from happening.

What the fuck were Scarlett’s parents doing? She sounds like she was failed as well.

(I am under no illusion that PD are notoriously difficult to treat - I work in a similar field) but it sounds like she was allowed to do what she wanted. It is unfathomable to me.

Allfur · 04/02/2024 18:23

Gymrabbit, horrible post - 'so called parent'? 'Pontificating'?

Sususudio · 04/02/2024 18:22

Esther Ghey is definitely not pontificating. I am in awe of her dignity and poise.

There has been some on this thread though. Really, if you don't have teen children, it's very easy to say you will do X or Y. In practice, not so easy. Youa re God to a 5 year old. You are not God to a 15-year-old. In fact, you are very far from God.

SongbirdGarden · 04/02/2024 18:22

My son never had a phone until he was 16. He didn't want one, and it was never an issue. He didn't feel left out. if he was asked why he didn't have one he said he said wouldn't use it.
He's 18 now and still not bothered about SM. He enjoys gaming online.
He has since said he's glad he never had access to SM at a younger age.
I do have another older son who had his first phone around age 13/14, but never caused any issues.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 18:21

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Why do you keep posting gross comments and then editing them?

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 18:20

Gymrabbit

She’s bravely trying to help other parents and protect children.

Maybe if you had had to deal with a child struggling with bullying, anxiety and fitting in you might understand that everything isn’t always black or white and parenting is 10 times harder.

StaunchMomma · 04/02/2024 18:19

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 18:07

I also notice that the focus seems to be on the female killer, the same applies to the boy.

There was always going to be a lot of attention on her because it's so rare for a woman to plan to murder in the way she did.

Yes, he was equally responsible and equally obsessed with death but she was the one who finalised the plans, did the research and picked the potential victims.

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 04/02/2024 18:19

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

I am not sure Esther Ghey is pontificating. More likely she is a desperate grieving mother who wants to warn others of the dangers so no one else ends up in her position. I think she more than anyone is acutely aware of the impact of SM in this case.

I hope she isn’t reading this, but if she is then 💐.

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 18:14

@soupfiend I honestly don't mind discussions as to why. I much prefer them as they tend to uncover a lot more going on, other systemic failures, I learn a lot etc.

But knee jerk, witch hunty , pie in the sky reactions like ban all smart phones/the internet until 18 are pointless. They focus on the wrong things, never go anywhere or end up with any real solutions or change and it just gives a platform to the sanctimonious to tell us how their 75 yo dad never needed a smart phone and their kid didn't even have a phone until 19. Yeah right. Never mind that I actually talked about the dangers of outright bans and how vulnerable it has left some of the kids I work with and I was completely ignored. Because no one actually wants to have a discussion or debate, just to beat a certain drum.

I agree with you whole heartedly on porn. I also see and acknowledge the dangers of SM . You know what I never see? Asks for bans of smartphone or the internet in that context. Sure there's talk about content and platforms but I have never seen someone say no man /boy should have access to a smart phone in case he accesses violent porn on it. It's never,ever even a consideration.

Also why is no one demanding the ban of Netflix(and such like) or no child having access until 16/18? It was also a contributing factor. By the sounds of it, it seems to have sparked /fed Scarlett's fascination with blood and gore and murder. In her own home,in plain view.

Gymrabbit · 04/02/2024 18:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 18:10

aramox1

I agree it was an utter utter nightmare in our house. Arguments between us, us and our teens - continuously. It was miserable and still didn’t stop the things that happened to my children.

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 18:08

Comtesse

How do you know she hasn’t got a burner phone?Are you going to keep her away from smartphones until she’s 18? Good luck with that.

aramox1 · 04/02/2024 18:07

I tried so hard to monitor my kid's stuff and limit the time. He said he hated me for it and we had so many fights. And there's so much that can't be blocked.

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 18:07

I also notice that the focus seems to be on the female killer, the same applies to the boy.

StaunchMomma · 04/02/2024 18:04

We need social media and sites such as youtube to provide apps for parents that alert us when our kids watch anything harmful or are contacted b y strangers.

We can't roll back tech that's already out there but we can make it unlawful for those companies to not do the absolute upmost to keep kids safe.

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 18:01

@ohdelay from what I understand, the parents of the victim didn't want to press charges.

Her old school wanted to permanently exclude her at first, but then agreed to a managed move instead. Apparently (I'm only quoting newspaper articles so I don't have actual first hand information) to give her a second chance.

The new school was told the reason was that Scarlett got caught once with edibles in school.

Pure speculation, but I wonder if her parents pushed for all this and the second chance. Mum seems to be a teacher. Professional courtesy? Disbelief a kid from a nice family would be that malicious? Compassion for her young age and the reluctance of the vicim's parents to press charges? I honestly don't know.

The head of Brianna's school has publicly said they didn't know, that they should have and she's asking for more cooperation and transparency between agencies.

Comtesse · 04/02/2024 18:01

My 13yo doesn’t have a smart phone, just a brick phone. She moans about it, but too bad. Kids in her class have got into a real pickle. It’s my job to do the right thing not just the popular thing.

I understand there are all sorts of restrictions on using Tiktok for kids in China - wouldn’t be such a terrible idea to do that more widely in my view…..

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 17:59

Im not sure anyone is saying it was the catalyst but as others have set out, content absorbed by her will have normalised what she felt, legitmised it, validated it, exicted her, gave her ideas about what to do etc etc

People dont make these arguments about how very violent dangerous porn doesnt affect men. We know that men and boys watching violent dangerous porn over and over again start to view or enhances their view of wanting that violence when with a woman. We understand thats the process and that it has a massive impact and is having an impact particularly on teen boys about what they think is normal sexual behaviour. In fact there is an issue with girls even thinking thats normal sexual behaviour and therefore they have to go along with it too because they are also exposed to this

Why are people so resistant to understanding why this violence she was absorbing (from a range of sources) was a contributory factor in what happened and her enablement?

QuillBill · 04/02/2024 17:57

SpicyMoth · 04/02/2024 17:43

Maybe I'm just too inexperienced/naïve as I'm only in first trimester with my first currently, but I don't want my kids having smart anything's.
No tablets, no smart phones, none of it until they can pay for it themselves and understand the value.
There's no reason for children to have access to these things to be quite honest and kids these day are growing up far too fast, they don't even LOOK like kids anymore half the time because they're so influence by what they see and access online.
Kids in single digits should not be begging their parents for a trip to Sephora and then running amuck for god's sake, they should barely be interested in makeup at all.
A bitch basic phone suitable for calls and texts for safety sure, but that's it.

Why do children need to be able to have access to all these things that clearly we cannot "parental control" adequately to begin with? And that they can learn to find workarounds for anyway?
Fairly sure phones that are JUST phones are still sold, are they not? Why is this necessary?

I really just do not understand this obsession with plonking kids in front of tablets and smart phones etc.
I keep seeing "funny" videos (really not funny to me, sad a depressing more like) of parents in restaurants drawing/colouring in placemats and their kids swiping away on tablet and phones playing games or watching something, for god's sake, WHY?!!!
I just don't get it.

There's middle ground though. It's not toddlers watching ipads in pushchairs or no technology at all.

The problem is that when your son is eight and all of his friends are talking about and playing live action versions of whatever is popular then at playtime and your son is standing on the sidelines because he's not allowed to play computer games it all becomes a bit more difficult.

And when they are twelve and using Snapchat to talk to each other and your child can't join in so gets left out of stuff then you will feel sad for him.

You clearly use social media so it's going to be tricky to justify that to a teenager.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 17:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Because it was vile.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 17:56

Fernsfernsferns · 04/02/2024 16:01

I disagree. A lot of teens used to smoke and now few of them do.

30 years ago when I was a teen under age drinking was completely normal. I was a 'good girl' and did well at school but still went to pubs with my friends with increasing regularity aged 15 an onwards.

We all drank A LOT.

the same with car safety, using seat belts and car seats, or helmets when cycling.

All things where new laws and regulation and education have changed norms to make things safer.

We can do that with social media too. We can change the norms and we should.

We will look back on this era and be shocked with what we've exposed teens to and how badly we have let them down, just like we do now about smoking ,or memories of sliding up and down the back seat of a car without seatbelts as a child.

@cazpar I agree delaying giving teens smart phones is part of it. They don't NEED them. they can and should start with a normal phone.

The govt should regulate, no smartphone or social media before 16

And how would they police that? No ipads? Laptops? All of it gone or just one device? It’s completely unrealistic and wouldn’t solve anything.

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 17:54

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 17:36

People are very keen to emphasis her use of the dark web, but while she may have accessed this, it wont have formed all of what she was exposed to, you dont have to access this to engage in interactions with unsafe people, people talking about violence, weapons, sexual fantasy, porn, all the child like anime stuff.
Until its all published (and this might not even be part of whats published as the detail is important and I suspect the pernickity detail isnt really being looked at), when, where and how did she access it, what did she access on that part of it

And when 'dark web' is mentioned is it what we understand to be the sections which you have to have TOR for, or is it just shorthand for all the nasties we're talking about anyway?

And I think as well people are getting too hung up on the phrase 'social media', I see it as just shorthand personally, it means whatever ability someone has to engage with and talk to and talk about or be exposed to information that is put there by a n other. ie, not an NHS website or childline or government websites but any old thing that any old person can set up, forums and the such like too.

It was the TOR stuff.

I don't see anyone asking for the ban for streaming platforms either despite her watching and rewatching quite gory horror movies on Netflix for hours on end.

Her actual plans and lists and fawning over serial killers were pen on paper.

Her drugging another kid was known to her old school and her parents.

People can blame SM all they want, but the truth is it was a possibly contributing factor , not the catalyst. Or the reason. Odds are it would've happened anyway, just to another kid ,in a different set of circumstances.