Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 20:04

Alcohol is not comparible as 100 times easier to monitor.

Borntrippy · 04/02/2024 20:02

Jesús wept. Mum can use social media because she’s an adult. She also has an income to pay for the device and internet. Children don’t have an income and shouldn’t do certain adult activities because they are harmful to children. Using social media is one such example but there are plenty more. Should mummy also allow DD or DS to drink wine because as she does?

Emily1583 · 04/02/2024 19:57

Video sharing sites can certainly be regulated better. There are actual death videos, street fights, animal cruelty videos open for anyone to find that should really be taken down. Of course clicks are money for those sites though.

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 19:50

SpicyMoth
You just can’t enforce that with 15, 16 and even 14 year olds.

Collecting phones in and limiting screen time caused us years of misery and arguments as it was. Both of which were completely fruitless as regards protection.

Borntrippy · 04/02/2024 19:49

So did he have a job to pay for his own phone bill or did you pay it for him? Who is actually in charge in your family? You the parent or your son the adolescent?

Cerealkiller4U · 04/02/2024 19:48

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 14:32

So why don't they? Because they can. For their own kids. Or limit access. Or control usage.

What use is saying they wish they could but then do fuck all about it?

Why is everyone expecting the "government" to do something?

If you feel that strongly and it's that important,do it yourself (whether I agree or not it's irrelevant).

Studies have shown it’s a behaviour which is mimicked. So the parent needs to stop using them in reality.

SpicyMoth · 04/02/2024 19:47

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 19:24

Snapchat is nothing compared to live streaming sites. Then there are all the games they can talk to others on, fitness apps… They communicate in all sorts of ways and have loads of options. You really have no idea how hard it is to monitor.

I agree with you wholeheartedly and know exactly how hard these things are to monitor - My parents had gone so far as to have legitimate spyware and keylogging and a myriad of other things on my devices and I STILL managed to get away with things I of course know they would be mortified if they found out I'd done/accessed.

Which is exactly why I'm of the strong opinion that they shouldn't have their own devices until they can pay for them themselves.
Again, family devices with actual "child and screen in eyesight" supervision, fine. Their own devices where they'll be able to find loopholes and workarounds? Absolutely not imo.

WhyIOughtTo · 04/02/2024 19:47

WhatsApp might not be here soon! Unless they open up their end to end encryption.

Then they will use something else. Confused

Borntrippy · 04/02/2024 19:45

It’s so disturbing to think how many millions of children worldwide are doing similar, while their parents are completely in the dark. The vast majority will not commit crimes but they are no doubt severely damaged as a result even if they may hide it well. Now think of the implications of this on a societal level. Makes you shudder.

Ilikedoughnuts · 04/02/2024 19:44

It shouldn't be up to companies to make social media/the internet safe, it's up to the parents to teach their children safety. No child should have a phone that's capable of accessing the internet. You can buy a phone from Tesco for £28, it makes calls & texts, that's all a child needs, any parent who buys their under 16 year old a phone capable of more than that is increasing their risk and should be ashamed of themselves.

Cerealkiller4U · 04/02/2024 19:43

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 13:15

You’re on mumsnet.

Yup. I said that in the post you quoted

Cerealkiller4U · 04/02/2024 19:43

QuillBill · 04/02/2024 13:11

No, because teenagers don’t phone each other or use old-style texts where every message costs 40p.

They use free messaging apps like Snapchat or WhatsApp.

WhatsApp might not be here soon! Unless they open up their end to end encryption.

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 19:27

SpicyMoth · 04/02/2024 19:18

@QuillBill@Sususudio
I specifically mentioned single digits and kids, then got replies talking about teens lol. 😂

Having a family computer or family tablet with set allocated times and that aren't in the children's rooms is very different from children having their own smart devices, is it not? :S
I don't really see where what I said implied "absolute nothing, not even games". Just not their own devices.

Again, maybe I truly am just naive as I said in my original comment - but I don't think single digit kids "need" smart devices under really any circumstances tbh.
Supervised access to a family computer in a family space, fine. Their own smart devices? No. My own and my DP's experiences are enough for me to know that that's not how we'd like to do things regardless of whether other's kids have access to these things freely or not.

"And when they are twelve and using Snapchat to talk to each other and your child can't join in so gets left out of stuff then you will feel sad for him."
Snapchat, the app that has been historically used for sending nudes whilst underage?
Yeah sorry, not happening.
Even if "all their friends" have it, I won't be okay with my child having snapchat access whilst they're a minor to be completely honest.
Maybe that's prudish, but I know what my friends and I did with it when it first came out and I don't think any of our parents knew at all.
The entire appeal of that app originally was that it doesn't keep chat logs or image history after a set amount of time was it not?
I just don't understand how that's an appropriate app for minors to have access to - because of the filters? Because you can make funny faces with it?
Then do those things with them on your phone, they don't need their own.

That's not even touching on the less unsavoury aspect of SC giving people complexes about how they look with the filters that are designed to make you look more attractive.
There's entire swathes of people who grew up on Snapchat who now can't stand to look at their own face without a filter on and have even gone to such lengths as having plastic surgery to make themselves look like they do with a SC filter on. Sorry but that's not healthy in my book and I don't want my kid's brains to be warped by that type of thing.

My original comment was not from a "judging PoV" even if people want to take it that way, it was from an "I don't understand this PoV".
Did we not all grow up hearing the saying "You wouldn't jump off a bridge just because all of your friends do"?
Just because it's everywhere or "all of their mates have it" doesn't mean it's right or healthy for them :S

Edited

While it's doubtful it will happen again, there was a need though during Covid.

Borntrippy · 04/02/2024 19:27

Indeed schools have a lot to answer for. As a former teacher I’ve seen how insidious the influence of over-use of tech has been not only on the student but also on making aspects of teaching even more burdensome for teachers. In the future I think we will see more and more tech free schools a la Steiner as I predict a significant minority of young millennial and Gen Z parents will want to prevent their children from the same harms they were exposed to.

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 19:24

Snapchat is nothing compared to live streaming sites. Then there are all the games they can talk to others on, fitness apps… They communicate in all sorts of ways and have loads of options. You really have no idea how hard it is to monitor.

SpicyMoth · 04/02/2024 19:18

@QuillBill@Sususudio
I specifically mentioned single digits and kids, then got replies talking about teens lol. 😂

Having a family computer or family tablet with set allocated times and that aren't in the children's rooms is very different from children having their own smart devices, is it not? :S
I don't really see where what I said implied "absolute nothing, not even games". Just not their own devices.

Again, maybe I truly am just naive as I said in my original comment - but I don't think single digit kids "need" smart devices under really any circumstances tbh.
Supervised access to a family computer in a family space, fine. Their own smart devices? No. My own and my DP's experiences are enough for me to know that that's not how we'd like to do things regardless of whether other's kids have access to these things freely or not.

"And when they are twelve and using Snapchat to talk to each other and your child can't join in so gets left out of stuff then you will feel sad for him."
Snapchat, the app that has been historically used for sending nudes whilst underage?
Yeah sorry, not happening.
Even if "all their friends" have it, I won't be okay with my child having snapchat access whilst they're a minor to be completely honest.
Maybe that's prudish, but I know what my friends and I did with it when it first came out and I don't think any of our parents knew at all.
The entire appeal of that app originally was that it doesn't keep chat logs or image history after a set amount of time was it not?
I just don't understand how that's an appropriate app for minors to have access to - because of the filters? Because you can make funny faces with it?
Then do those things with them on your phone, they don't need their own.

That's not even touching on the less unsavoury aspect of SC giving people complexes about how they look with the filters that are designed to make you look more attractive.
There's entire swathes of people who grew up on Snapchat who now can't stand to look at their own face without a filter on and have even gone to such lengths as having plastic surgery to make themselves look like they do with a SC filter on. Sorry but that's not healthy in my book and I don't want my kid's brains to be warped by that type of thing.

My original comment was not from a "judging PoV" even if people want to take it that way, it was from an "I don't understand this PoV".
Did we not all grow up hearing the saying "You wouldn't jump off a bridge just because all of your friends do"?
Just because it's everywhere or "all of their mates have it" doesn't mean it's right or healthy for them :S

Sash95 · 04/02/2024 19:01

The only reason why it wouldn't be possible is that marketing to children is extremely profitable. Personally, I don't see the need for a child to have a smartphone, but I understand that not everyone feels the same way. I think a happy middle ground would be a kid's social media platform, e.g. Facebook safe, with controls designed to protect kids. All videos must be checked and approved before they are allowed on the platform. Parents must register the account, and all activity can be monitored via their phone/laptop. Maybe even a limit on screen time? It shouldn't be hard to enforce, if underage kids are found using adult social media sites, IMO parents should be fined. If social media giants are failing to put adequate protection in place for child users, they should get lumped with a huge fine! As it stands, these companies are making millions out of kids, so there is no incentive to stop. I think that parents have a responsibility to protect their young kids; just because 'everyone at school has TikTok' doesn't mean they actually do, and it doesn't mean it's okay. For teens it is harder, for sure. I think the ideal is to have open conversations, to talk about what they are up to online, what funny videos they've watched etc. It's the secrecy that's the problem.

Just my views, and I feel quite passionate about this.

ChaosAndCrumbs · 04/02/2024 18:49

QuillBill · 04/02/2024 17:57

There's middle ground though. It's not toddlers watching ipads in pushchairs or no technology at all.

The problem is that when your son is eight and all of his friends are talking about and playing live action versions of whatever is popular then at playtime and your son is standing on the sidelines because he's not allowed to play computer games it all becomes a bit more difficult.

And when they are twelve and using Snapchat to talk to each other and your child can't join in so gets left out of stuff then you will feel sad for him.

You clearly use social media so it's going to be tricky to justify that to a teenager.

That’s my son, but he’s not stood on the sidelines. His friends do chat about video games, but they also chat about other things and when they chat games, they just explain what they’re talking about.

I will feel sad when the other boys are chatting on Snapchat (if they are), but it won’t change my mind and cause me to allow my son to use it.

In some ways it sucks, but I feel I’m appropriately parenting him and that’s what matters to me. I also make sure I support him in maintaining friendships and give him friendships revolving around groups that don’t need to involve video game chats.

I do totally get where you’re coming from, but my explanation re. Social media use would be that I model pretty healthy adult use, frequently go through phases where I don’t use it at all and use it at an appropriate age.

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 18:45

Government inaction as regards child and under 25 mental health support, SEN, tech, vaping…. is failing our youngsters.

They are just completely inadequate.

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 18:42

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 18:37

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot

Scarlet would have needed mental health support- there is none.

She will also have needed to want to engage and wanted to change, I cant see that being the case to be honest.

Notwithstanding that there probably wasnt anything on offer anyway even if she did.

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 18:40

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 04/02/2024 18:26

i know the school both girls attended were unaware of the full circumstances of the ‘managed move’ (which is truly appalling) but I wonder how much Scarlett’s parents knew?

I know that if I had been made to leave my school due to attempting to poison another child there would have been no netflix, no phones/internet at all (let alone dark web) and absolutely no hanging out in the park. My parents would have moved heaven and earth to get me help, and if all else failed, I would be living somewhere else. I would be the same with my own children. I would go to any extreme (including leaving my job, moving house, hospitalisation, etc) to prevent anything else from happening.

What the fuck were Scarlett’s parents doing? She sounds like she was failed as well.

(I am under no illusion that PD are notoriously difficult to treat - I work in a similar field) but it sounds like she was allowed to do what she wanted. It is unfathomable to me.

This is the most perplexing bit for me

In respect of the other child, the victim of the poisoning, was there a strategy discussion held about her being at risk, and if so what came of that, as in how was the risk lowered for the victim. Presumably it was lowered by the girl not being in contact with the victim anymore

Was the girl open to services, were elements of the family functioning or parenting of her raising cause for concern?

All of this will come out in the SCR but having worked with a lot of managed moves, often for violence or challenging behaviour, Im amazed that the new school didnt know the full details or werent given them. It doesnt make sense to me, but does it differ from LA to LA?

In any case, to be honest even if they had known of the full details, would they have been in a position to refuse the move? Would they have been in a position to change whether she was in the inclusion unit? Children are usually placed in those units within provisions because they cant manage the mainstream classes, theres no where else for them, sometimes they cant manage because of anxiety/SEMH (like Brianna) and sometimes because their behaviour is too challenging to manage in mainstream classes

I think she probably would have been in there with Brianna even if they did know about the full incident

There will have been other children in the unit just as vulnerable.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 18:38

Gymrabbit · 04/02/2024 18:32

I still stand by my comments in general but I see your point that a grieving mother may be reading this so am happy for them to be deleted on that basis.

Good news is no one cares if you’re happy or not.

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 18:37

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot

Scarlet would have needed mental health support- there is none.

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 18:34

@Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot I'm afraid I can only offer speculation on your other questions, which probably isn't advisable.

That's the thing, the were a lot of other issues at play here, a lot of questions to be asked etc. Only a small part of it is SM /smartphone related.

Gymrabbit · 04/02/2024 18:32

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 04/02/2024 18:19

I am not sure Esther Ghey is pontificating. More likely she is a desperate grieving mother who wants to warn others of the dangers so no one else ends up in her position. I think she more than anyone is acutely aware of the impact of SM in this case.

I hope she isn’t reading this, but if she is then 💐.

I still stand by my comments in general but I see your point that a grieving mother may be reading this so am happy for them to be deleted on that basis.