Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
soupfiend · 04/02/2024 09:26

Wexler1216 · 04/02/2024 09:18

I don’t see why people act like ‘oh, they could see horrific content at their friend’s house anyway, so there’s no point trying’ is such a gotcha, as if that’s at all comparable to having 24/7 unrestricted access to the internet. Many of the problems smartphones cause such as poor impulse control, degraded concentration span, obsession, going ‘down a rabbit hole’ etc. aren’t even relevant to occasional use.

And if you find out as a parent tht something is happening when they visit a friends house that you dont agree with/allow/approve of then just like any other thing thats going on, you either speak to that parent or you say they cant visit.

x2boys · 04/02/2024 09:25

Cazpar · 04/02/2024 09:21

They can join in "gossip, jokes, meeting up plans" etc with a regular brick phone.

No need for a smartphone.

They can't join in messenger groups though can they ?
My son and his friends are on discord and chat through that
I have a,Facebook messenger group that I chat to my friends through
And my DH chat ,s to.his mates on What,sApp.

KeepGoing2 · 04/02/2024 09:24

If they put ages restrictions on, this generation are very savvy on tech, they'd get a VPN installed.
They'd find a way.

This is the worst reason for doing nothing. Some kids might find a way round it but many wouldn’t, and it would be a big step away from the normalisation of phones for kids/young teens.

Spendonsend · 04/02/2024 09:23

I think software parent had that alerted them if inappropriate things were being watched would be great. We have similar software in school . It flags to an adult, and then you can go chat about it with the pupil.

I also dont believe companies cant do more to stop anyone watching torture on the dark web - not just children.

Its almost impossible to monitor tik tok and snapchat from what i can see. You need to leave it until as late as possible before your children go anywhere near them. But it is hard to stop a 14 year old. Especially when school uses apps for homework.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 04/02/2024 09:22

Possibly tin foil hat territory but I don't think there will be any political will for this. Mass media in all its forms is too useful for creating division and to spread the ideology of the moment. Individual attempts to limit children's access to social media would never become uniform and as others have said the tech savvy youth who outstrip alot of us by a country mile would find a way to circumvent said restriction.

I also agree that the more a thing us restricted the more attractive it becomes - see Prohibition.

We are unfortunately dependent on technology and it is escalating at every turn.

This particular tragedy is appalling.

I think the most important thing is to try and cultivate open and honest relationships with our children and be prepared to discuss everything that crops up in as level headed a manner as possible.

I've had discussions with younger males about Andrew Tate. It's difficult when you're internally seething but the merest twitch of disapproval sends them defensive. So softly softly it has to be.

It's a bit of a war between various factions to "catch 'em young" i feel.

Perhaps the answer is for our generation to stage a takeover of all social media platforms and drown it out to the point where kids wouldn't want to go near it.

But I suspect it is sadly a losing battle at this point.

Mishymashy56 · 04/02/2024 09:21

@Wexler1216 100% this! A small minority may figure out a way around not having a smart phone, but it may stop the vast majority from sitting alone in their bedrooms browsing adult content. Win? Nothing works 100%.

Cazpar · 04/02/2024 09:21

QuillBill · 04/02/2024 09:16

*Teenagers always cry because they're "being left out".

"But everyone else does X / has those shoes / that bag / goes to Y".

The answer I got was "well good for them, but you're not".*

It's not the same though as all that happened to you was you didn't have the shoes you wanted. Nowadays, if a teenager doesn't have a phone they are left out of conversations, jokes, fun, gossip and meeting up plans.

When my dd was about thirteen (now nineteen) she was in quite a large friendship group and one of the girls was a Jehovah Witness and she had no phone, she was definitely out of the loop despite the best efforts of the other girls.

It was a million times worse in lockdown but even in normal times she was just not in text conversations that were happening. I remember getting home from high school and waiting until 6pm for the free phone calls to start and phoning school friends who I had just seen two hours earlier.

They can join in "gossip, jokes, meeting up plans" etc with a regular brick phone.

No need for a smartphone.

theduchessofspork · 04/02/2024 09:20

TodayForTomorrow · 04/02/2024 09:02

Parents have let this happen over the last 20 years and as a parent of younger children, I'm pretty pissed off about it.

My kids only use tablets on long journeys and will not have consoles until they ask for them. I really worry about phones entering their orbit.

Right so when they ask you’ll give stuff to them and this is the fault of previous generations of parents and not you?

Cazpar · 04/02/2024 09:19

By sheer coincidence, this is my Sunday morning reading courtesy of the Spectator.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother
Wexler1216 · 04/02/2024 09:18

I don’t see why people act like ‘oh, they could see horrific content at their friend’s house anyway, so there’s no point trying’ is such a gotcha, as if that’s at all comparable to having 24/7 unrestricted access to the internet. Many of the problems smartphones cause such as poor impulse control, degraded concentration span, obsession, going ‘down a rabbit hole’ etc. aren’t even relevant to occasional use.

theduchessofspork · 04/02/2024 09:17

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:58

Look at those that invent those devices and apps. They didn’t give them to their kids until the children were a lot older.

https://www.businessinsider.com/screen-time-limits-bill-gates-steve-jobs-red-flag-2017-10

Of course they don’t.

A lot of the private schools in SF have a complete tech ban - although that’s more because the people that designed them know they are addictive and mess with focus, than from worry about content.

However this is dependant on active parenting.

QuillBill · 04/02/2024 09:16

*Teenagers always cry because they're "being left out".

"But everyone else does X / has those shoes / that bag / goes to Y".

The answer I got was "well good for them, but you're not".*

It's not the same though as all that happened to you was you didn't have the shoes you wanted. Nowadays, if a teenager doesn't have a phone they are left out of conversations, jokes, fun, gossip and meeting up plans.

When my dd was about thirteen (now nineteen) she was in quite a large friendship group and one of the girls was a Jehovah Witness and she had no phone, she was definitely out of the loop despite the best efforts of the other girls.

It was a million times worse in lockdown but even in normal times she was just not in text conversations that were happening. I remember getting home from high school and waiting until 6pm for the free phone calls to start and phoning school friends who I had just seen two hours earlier.

LoobyDop · 04/02/2024 09:15

I completely agree that it could and should be done. But you lot are the parents- collectively, you have the power. But as this thread demonstrates, you don’t have the will to see it through. Nobody else is going to do it for you. Your kids won’t police themselves, the tech companies sure as hell won’t do it, and if the schools tried half of you would be storming them with pitchforks. It’s on you, and you aren’t trying hard enough. It’s not that wildly different from Americans failing to do anything about gun laws.

Grandmasswag · 04/02/2024 09:15

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 09:06

Today just wait until you have teens. All very well feeling smug about “restricting access” for a 5 year old who knows no different but how will you deal with a 13 year old crying because she’s being left out because all her friends have phones and communicate that way but she doesn’t and is therefore being socially isolated due to your parenting choice? Phone use has been our hardest parenting aspect bar none.

This is a very good point. Although some parents seem to start ridiculously young with the unrestricted internet access I’m dreading the teen years. I don’t see the problem with messaging apps that are monitored for teens but all the other shite TikTok, Snapchat etc just seems a recipe for disaster. For a start it’s designed to be addictive and that on an undeveloped brain is worrying.

Clearinguptheclutter · 04/02/2024 09:13

unrealistic in this day and age sadly

a Tory mp said similar the other day - Miriam cates I think- and was widely derided (she is unhinged though, unless Mrs Ghey who has been extremely dignified throughout )

I do hope something happens in the wake of this tragic murder. Perhaps schools getting more involved.

A bit of off topic but it’s unbelievable that Scarlett assaulted another child and the new school that she was moved to (Brianna’s) wasn’t told. Surely that shouldn’t happen.

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 09:13

Well it was easy in the past because no one else had phones either. Isn’t that obvious?

I wish none of them had phones either and believe me we held out longer than most but in our society for your average sociable teen having no smart phone is unthinkable.

x2boys · 04/02/2024 09:12

Not all apps are bad either my son wss diagnosed with Diabetes last year ( he was seriously ill.on diagnosis) he now has a Dexcom,fitted to continually monitor his blood sugars and an app.on his phone alerts him if his blood sugars go-to low or high.

Megifer · 04/02/2024 09:12

TodayForTomorrow · 04/02/2024 09:02

Parents have let this happen over the last 20 years and as a parent of younger children, I'm pretty pissed off about it.

My kids only use tablets on long journeys and will not have consoles until they ask for them. I really worry about phones entering their orbit.

So you already do, and will do, pretty much what those parents you blame for this did? As ime it kind of starts with the console when they can use it as a way to socialise with pals online.

You kids will ask for a console from when they are about 5 BTW. And phones will enter their orbit at around 8 if not sooner. Good luck.

(my kids never got a tablet on long journeys, they read a book, and they got consoles when I decided they were ready)

SKG231 · 04/02/2024 09:12

sashh · 04/02/2024 09:06

A lot of children get hand me down phones when an adult upgrades theirs.

I don't like the idea of having a 'children's phone', it makes the 'adult phone' more desirable and doesn't stop you using other IT to access the web.

Also not all children come from loving homes, children need to be able to access things like childline, forced marriage information, information on drugs even abortion services.

How could this be enforced? And who buy? Do we want to criminalise a child for making a phone call?

James Bulger was not murdered because of accessing things on the internet.

James Bulger wasn’t killed because of his killers accessing things on the internet, he was killed because they had access to awful adult movies that included torture and murder.

so it is exactly the same context. Children accessing things they shouldn’t be.

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 09:11

Really? Every single friend of hers had a phone. They socialised and communicated via the phones. Without it dd (a non dramatic “good girl”) WAS being left out.

Put your phone in a drawer for a week and see how you get on.

We capitulated of course we did. She was starting to hate us.

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 09:10

sashh · 04/02/2024 09:06

A lot of children get hand me down phones when an adult upgrades theirs.

I don't like the idea of having a 'children's phone', it makes the 'adult phone' more desirable and doesn't stop you using other IT to access the web.

Also not all children come from loving homes, children need to be able to access things like childline, forced marriage information, information on drugs even abortion services.

How could this be enforced? And who buy? Do we want to criminalise a child for making a phone call?

James Bulger was not murdered because of accessing things on the internet.

How did children access those things before smart phones.

Children can have brick phones and access those things. There are safeguarding roles at school for children to approach if they need to.

We cant use this as an excuse to let phones parent children.

The same child that doesnt come from a loving safe family, is more likely to find dangerous unsafe links and interactions on an unmonitored internet, they are more vulnerable to this lack of oversight, not made safer by having it.

Rangelife · 04/02/2024 09:10

People (parents) need to think about the position they are coming from - restricting apps/social media is for the parents peace of mind that they are protecting their DC. Whilst they have unfettered access to the internet themselves as adults? The DC think another way. Collaboration on how, why, when and prevalence of using the internet should be with kids, not done to/at them. Knife crime resolution is taking kids along as the resolvers and it's working. We should go to the children with this issue - ask them what their take is IMO.

SKG231 · 04/02/2024 09:09

Do your research and make sure you have all parental controls on your child’s phone so they have to request to download apps, can’t go on certain websites etc.

make it clear it is a privilege not right to have a smart phone and it can easily be switched out for a basic phone used for calls and text.

also make it clear that you have rights to access the phone, not that you’ll be snooping at it every day but if you feel the need it is your right to look.

phones must be left downstairs before bedtime. No negotiations.

make sure they’ve watched educational videos about how what we put and say online is forever and it is as real as saying it to somebodies face.

make sure you communicate with your child and ask them often how life is going for them, if they have any worries and let them know you are always there for them no Mather what the issue is.

Sususudio · 04/02/2024 09:09

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 09:06

Today just wait until you have teens. All very well feeling smug about “restricting access” for a 5 year old who knows no different but how will you deal with a 13 year old crying because she’s being left out because all her friends have phones and communicate that way but she doesn’t and is therefore being socially isolated due to your parenting choice? Phone use has been our hardest parenting aspect bar none.

Before my children were teens and young adults, I had all kinds of rules I thought I would stick to. Guess what? They all collapsed in the pandemic. And some before.

I am currently trying to convince them to be wary of Tinder and Hinge. One sees my pov, the other doesn't.

Karwomannghia · 04/02/2024 09:09

I agree. I’d love to see the end of social media completely. It’s toxic and full of advertising for adults and incredibly dangerous for children.