Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Alwaystired23 · 04/02/2024 10:20

My dc is 12. He's has a phone and does go on YouTube, but he doesn't have any apps like WhatsApp, snap chat, etc.

Zanatdy · 04/02/2024 10:17

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 10:14

Is this information from the police investigation? Im wondering what is meant by that because people have different meanings to dark web

Not sure but just been mentioned in the interview with Brianna’s mum on BBC and was mentioned in the press the other day. Said she was watching videos of torture on the dark web

IhaveanewTVnow · 04/02/2024 10:16

My 22 and 19 year old when 3 or 4 years old didn’t sit in restaurants watching tablets and mobile phones. They coloured in pictures, played with little toys or Uno. Very Long car journeys we had a DVD player and watched DVDs or we played eye spy. They didn’t sit in their pushchair playing games on a mobile phone. We talked. They got their first phone when they went to secondary school. Then the arguing started with them. It was impossible to limit the time they spent on them and what they viewed. In the school playground they would view other kids phones who had unlimited access. They would go on play dates and play online games that were banned in my house. However they are now very respectful lads so we did something right. Still obsessed with their phones……but so am I - even now!

it wasn’t my kids generation that ruined it. It’s now. Speak to your kids in restaurants, play with them, take a colouring book, read to them.

Messyhair321 · 04/02/2024 10:16

No it's not going to happen, not that she's wrong, but from the dawn of time young people will always break boundaries. What needs to happen is creating better alternatives, better content & the culture of online available media which is safer & healthier for people, not just children.
These platforms are a lot of the time open to anyone, unmonitored to a large extent & it's not just parents responsibility, it's also the platform who often allow unsuitable content to go out.
I've also seen horrendous reels on FB which I will never forget it was that traumatic, so easy to click on something, thinking it's about one thing but turns out it's something entirely different. These videos are so easy to access yet even reporting it doesn't get anywhere.

BubziOwl · 04/02/2024 10:14

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 09:06

Today just wait until you have teens. All very well feeling smug about “restricting access” for a 5 year old who knows no different but how will you deal with a 13 year old crying because she’s being left out because all her friends have phones and communicate that way but she doesn’t and is therefore being socially isolated due to your parenting choice? Phone use has been our hardest parenting aspect bar none.

I do have a lot of sympathy for this view, however I was that 13 year old who wasn't allowed MSN or Facebook. I was 15 when my parents caved and let me. It did me no harm to wait those few extra years, and it wasn't as big of a deal as I made out to my parents. The most popular 'queen bee' girl in my year didn't have SM at all until she went to uni. People found ways to include her.

If people want to include you, they will. If they want to exclude you, they will. My (ex!) friends started excluding me when I was 16 - seeing it rubbed in my face on social media was awful.

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 10:14

Zanatdy · 04/02/2024 10:10

Scarlett was accessing the dark web. Even if social media for under 16 was banned this wouldn’t have stopped this murder. I do think these apps are bad for young kids, my friends youngest has had tik tok since year 5. I saw her once have a huge tantrum because of something and she was sending nasty messages to her friends on some child friendly app. My youngest thankfully naturally limited access to social media as she’s naturally introverted and didn’t want to get drawn into whole class apps which are generally full of horrible messages

Is this information from the police investigation? Im wondering what is meant by that because people have different meanings to dark web

Brightandbubly · 04/02/2024 10:13

The issue is not enough is being done to stop content that shouldn’t be viewed by anyone, it needs a worldwide response to stay ahead of the v ugly side of SM

Megifer · 04/02/2024 10:12

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 10:05

Well I didnt like to bring that into this thread but this is exactly right. I would argue that her child was exposed to dangerous and damaging content which led them to deal with their ASD and MH issues by considering they have a gender issue. It could have easily been something more dangerous.

Also agree. And some of the screenshots/snips I saw from Briannas tiktoks were quite provocative looking too for the age. So Brianna was clearly exposed to harm of a different type too. But I get the feeling reading some of the comments that Briannas mum acknowledged that tbf.

Zanatdy · 04/02/2024 10:10

Scarlett was accessing the dark web. Even if social media for under 16 was banned this wouldn’t have stopped this murder. I do think these apps are bad for young kids, my friends youngest has had tik tok since year 5. I saw her once have a huge tantrum because of something and she was sending nasty messages to her friends on some child friendly app. My youngest thankfully naturally limited access to social media as she’s naturally introverted and didn’t want to get drawn into whole class apps which are generally full of horrible messages

BibbleandSqwauk · 04/02/2024 10:08

Apps like Google family etc allow you to control what is downloaded, accessed, time limits, lock it etc. It's very easy to put on and sidesteps a lot of this. My kids are early teens. I can instantly block anything unsuitable ..I get a notification on my phone and the kids' phones won't open an app they've downloaded if it's above the PEGI rating I have set. They have WhatsApp and one has 30 mins of Snapchat a day but rarely uses it. No tiktok. Neither are excluded or ostracised and no one is getting shown stuff in the playground because if a phone is seem at school it gets confiscated and there is a detention.

Mobile phone and app use is absolutely embedded in life now, for education as much as anything else. I teach secondary, I'm a total luddite and wish it hadn't been invented but it has. I don't think legislation or brick phones til 16 is realistic but extensive, wide, educational info about parent controls, possibly at point of sale for phones with a service run via libraries maybe to help parents install it is an option. Also..parents pay the bill. You can just stop. Until they earn their own money, it IS up to parents.

Cascais · 04/02/2024 10:07

Ban smartphones for under 16s

Megifer · 04/02/2024 10:07

The dark Web isn't the issue. The sort of videos that kid would have seen willl be on reddit etc. The dark Web can actually be a good thing as it allows whistle-blowers for serious shit to contact journalists and organisations etc completely untracked.

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 10:05

TheOccupier · 04/02/2024 09:58

Impressive interview with Esther Ghey on Laura K this morning. She talked about the violent content accessed by Brianna's murderers and also how access to pro-ana content exacerbated Brianna's mental health issues, she seems to have completely accepts her child's trans identity. Where does she think that identity came from? Children with fragile mental health, eating disorders, neurodiversities and so on are the most vulnerable to online gender ideology.

Well I didnt like to bring that into this thread but this is exactly right. I would argue that her child was exposed to dangerous and damaging content which led them to deal with their ASD and MH issues by considering they have a gender issue. It could have easily been something more dangerous.

Dogdilemma2000 · 04/02/2024 10:04

I’m in a FB group which is mostly Americans. A lot of parent are moving to bark phones which don’t have access to social media and have far superior parental controls and auto flag ups of certain words & phrases.

Getting these available in the uk would be a start.

You aren’t going to get the horse back in the stable though. It bolted when we were teens. I didn’t have a smart phone as they weren’t invented yet and I was on all the pro-ana sites getting myself into a pickle.

Neriah · 04/02/2024 10:01

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:41

Why isn’t it possible though? If every child was not allowed the apps and there were restrictions on the internet. Wouldn’t that be better for the kids?

Children are growing up too soon.

I think most people would agree, but as others have said, the genie is out of the bottle and can't be put back in. Kids are tech savvy - way more than their parents in the main - and if they want to access something, one way or another, they will.

Not do I think that blaming social media is the answer - there has always been a tendency to look for something to blame when (especially) a child does something particularly horrific. Today it is social media. There was the same "moral panic" when watching a specific horror film was blamed for the actions of Jamie Bulgers killers - except that they hadn't actually seen the film in question! In the past it was the influence of devils and witches.

I am the last person to defend social media - I think it is way out of control, and I'm the one that has WhatApp and nothing more. I once wondered how you found the dark web, but still haven't got a clue. But there have always been "exceptional" cases of children who kill horrifically. The "fascination" is preceisly because they are rare cases, and in all there has been a moral panic around what caused it. But in the end, there is only one explanation. We like to think of children as innocent, naive and "pure". But they are adults in training, with all the same temptations, foibles and drives. Adults who deliberately kill do so because the want to. Children who deliberately kill also do so because they want to. There may be other factors at play - mental illness, environment etc. But in the end it comes down to having made a decision to kill because they want to. And we seek answers because we cannot accept that simple fact.

Potatoshigh · 04/02/2024 10:00

I didn't have a smart phone much till I was mid teens and it was fine. However that's not the world our children are living in, to say that we coped is a complete false equivalence.

It's like how we have no ability to function in this country with snow or power cuts but countries that have no power regularly are set up for it

For various reasons I often use a non smartphone for extended periods but always end up back with one.

In the last week for example my bus ticket is cheaper bought via app, the bus times are only available via app, the bus stop it's self just has a qr code. My parking is paid via app. To watch TV I had to sign in via the app on my phone to register my account.
Somethings you can do via phone but often you need to Google a number first which you can't do without Internet

My own family barely spoke to me last time because they communicate via groups on WhatsApp

I work in digital inclusion for the elderly who will emphatically tell you the world is set up for smart phones

Hijinks75 · 04/02/2024 09:59

Personally think her idea is good but it’s just not workable, working in mental health, the number of times we were told people were depressed/stressed etc because of something someone had said on social media was unbelievable, it’s also constant once it starts, one of those inventions that maybe wasn’t good

TheOccupier · 04/02/2024 09:58

Impressive interview with Esther Ghey on Laura K this morning. She talked about the violent content accessed by Brianna's murderers and also how access to pro-ana content exacerbated Brianna's mental health issues, she seems to have completely accepts her child's trans identity. Where does she think that identity came from? Children with fragile mental health, eating disorders, neurodiversities and so on are the most vulnerable to online gender ideology.

Spendonsend · 04/02/2024 09:55

I agree that murder is not the only measure of harm.

Even if no action is taken by a teen as a result of seeing rape or torture, i think seeing the rape or torture is harmful in itself.

Soontobe60 · 04/02/2024 09:53

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 09:06

Today just wait until you have teens. All very well feeling smug about “restricting access” for a 5 year old who knows no different but how will you deal with a 13 year old crying because she’s being left out because all her friends have phones and communicate that way but she doesn’t and is therefore being socially isolated due to your parenting choice? Phone use has been our hardest parenting aspect bar none.

Regardless of how long ago our children were teens, this type of behaviour existed. It’s really easy - just tell them no!

ParrotCatDog · 04/02/2024 09:52

This could be done at the contract level where eg vodaphone could do an under 18 contract that not only blocks adult content on the web, but also blocks snapchat, facebook etc access. I dont see why it couldn’t be done. Just needs a provider to step up.

however i do think people, adults are too quick to blame social media. She was accessing the dark web! Ive never been on there. I do websites, i cannot believe there is no trace to whoever set it up/paid for it. Its not a one off fee. Its ongoing payment for a website. Surely, someone knows who owns websites/content. If not, that needs tightening. Why we allow having a dark web in the first place with that kind of content is beyond me

CranfordScones · 04/02/2024 09:49

There's no evidence that the internet or social media has led to a rise in murders. It just mirrors the ills of society as they already exist.

The killers of Jamie Bulger didn't have access to the internet. But everyone at the time had their own pet theory as to what ought to be banned in order to banish all of society's ills.

Ditto Lizzie Borden.

Ditto Mary Bell.

We all have enormous sympathy for the family of Brianna Ghey. But their perception of the world has been hugely distorted by a very rare, tragic event. And they are not uniquely placed to solve the world's problems.

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 09:48

I agree with everything but in reality seriously what is a concerned parent to do? I can’t change society and prevent all the other teens having phones. So if you hold the line and your teen is quite literally the only one without a phone they are a socially excluded oddity who hate you.

x2boys · 04/02/2024 09:47

malificent7 · 04/02/2024 09:42

I agree with her. I admit...i can't get my head round what dd is doing online as she is private and a strppy teen. If all kids had brick phones, this would not be an issue.
Problem is, as adults we are role models and should have brick phones too. Is this going to happen? Er...no!

I mean we are all.commenting on a thread on mumsnet I'm on s tablet I expect others are on their phones .

KeepGoing2 · 04/02/2024 09:46

I don’t think education is enough and tbh in many areas of life it’s code for “let’s do fuck all” eg food companies advocate for education around healthy eating, phone companies want more education around phone use for kids etc. in other words “don’t regulate us please- it’s consumers’ fault if our products are harmful because they can’t resist what we’ve designed to be irresistible”.

Proof of age for social media, porn etc- all perfectly doable. It’s not being done because of people waving their hands and saying “too late now”- a counsel of despair.

Swipe left for the next trending thread