Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 10:51

Born how old are your children?

Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 10:51

Absolutely no access to social media apps until 16.

That's dead easy to say but when half the class are organising stuff via WhatsApp or Facebook then your restricting your kids social life.

Also so many youth groups communicate via FB and WhatsApp. At some point kids need to sort themselves out

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 10:50

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 10:24

My son was shown an Isis beheading on a phone in a lesson in an outstanding school with a very proactive no phone policy. I have literally just found out about it 4 years later. If it hadn’t been the classroom it would have been the playground and if it wasn’t the playground it would have been the bus. What was I supposed to have said no to exactly?

Steaming sites are full of paedophiles, grooming and abuse. My daughter told me pretty matter of factly that sleepover entertainment was often talking to strangers on streaming sites. All those blaming parents are you stopping your teens from attending sleepovers/ coffee in town, meet-ups etc or somehow enforcing no device bans on parents you rarely if ever meet?Teens are way ahead of all parents, they swap ways to beat the system spending a lot of time researching it. Those smugly saying just say no. No to what?

Just to be aware the most isolated teens are the ones most likely to work even harder at beating the rules set out by parents and finding company and entertainment online.

Well you surely wouldnt allow your child to stay over at a friends house if the friend's parents were running a crack house/prostitution taking place?

Why is this different?

You would say no?

Borntrippy · 04/02/2024 10:49

It’s not up to tech companies it’s up to parents. Be a parent, not a friend. Treat phones as you would alcohol, cigarettes, drugs and weapons. Of course most parents are also addicted to the internet so are reluctant to do what’s needed.

frostyfeet · 04/02/2024 10:48

Brianna was very popular on TikTok - maybe it gave her a sense of community and her life happier before the horror happened to her.

Angrycat2768 · 04/02/2024 10:46

ViolinSpin · 04/02/2024 08:51

I hope this lady's campaign gets a lot of support and something does change. It's absolutely terrible what happened to her child, such a tragic loss.

The article does also say she struggled to stop her own child from accessing inappropriate things online. Extremely sad all round.

The two convicted seem like incredibly damaged teenagers. What they did was horrific and evil. IMO bolstered by unfettered Internet access.

I think one of them was accessing violent sites on the dark web, so any ban of children from apps etc will be circumvented by a determined child, who is already disturbed. I suspect that Brianna and the children involved in her murder would still have accessed the content they were accessing, except they may have been accessing more brutal content, as they would have all tried to access the Dark Web as a result of being banned. They were all 3 very troubled kids, probably made worse by social media, but she herself said that she struggled to control Brianna's use of SM.
I do agree that the age needs to be raised for legal use of social media apps. My children are only allowed on Whatsapp and I have restrictions on their phones., but once they turn 13, you get a notification saying that you can no longer stop them from using the apps, and they have to consent to restrictions. 13 is still too young.

PaperWalkAndTalk · 04/02/2024 10:45

I agree that social media is obviously bad for children and has done a lot of damage to society.

But I have to also accept that every generation has a story like this, and social media wasn't around for previous murders of children by other children.

It's complex and don't think that a silver bullet is going to stop this sort of stuff from happening ever again (but may well limit it).

So yes, safe mobile phones etc for children is a good idea, but don't think it is going to fix everything.

Pleasegotobed · 04/02/2024 10:44

I think this is a fantastic idea and I wish it would become law. I would happily prevent all access to social media and almost all access to the internet for kids. It’s so hard to control even as a diligent parent

Borntrippy · 04/02/2024 10:42

No smart phones. Dummy phone and/or wrist tracker for worried parents. No tablets. Laptops only allowed for school work and used in common areas where you can see what they are up to. Absolutely no access to social media apps until 16. If you do this from infancy much easier but it can even be implemented later if you steel yourselves for complaints. Here’s the thing, you wouldn’t let your child take drugs, drive a car underage, smoke cigarettes etc etc and these devices have the potential to be just as dangerous for those too young to handle them.

Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 10:39

JustFrustrated · 04/02/2024 09:26

There are apps, I had Google link on both of mine which meant they couldn't download anything without my permission.

I've always conducted spot checks on their phones, not at night when they're asleep. But walk up to them randomly whilst they're using it and they hand it over, so they can't delete anything at the end of the day.

With my eldest, who Google link doesn't work for now, it's more frequent checking, having all her log ins and lots and lots of conversations.

Not fool proof by any measure, but it's something.

Google Family Link changes when kids turn 13 which complies with uk law.

I do think parents should have more control and companies should have responsibility until children are 16.

13 still seems very young to me. To have unfiltered and uncontrolled Internet access.

But then other things make little sense like Spotify kids can't link to an external speaker.

PrincessCharlette · 04/02/2024 10:38

Unenforceable unless you take the phone off them and good luck with that.

Tinseltiss · 04/02/2024 10:37

ten years ago when I was in school and longer when the internet was a bit newer I can remember being shown beheading videos, a lot of porn, am2 girls one cup if your around my age and was at school you’d of been shown this it’s where two girls looked in a cup and eat it one man one jar where a man put a jar uo his bum I can remember all of it so vividly and didn’t enjoy watching any of it but it was always being shown in school on peoples phones or shared on Facebook.

I hate the internet but unfortunately it’s not new anymore and I don’t think the violence in kids can be directly linked as there was not one child with a knife in my school when we went and I went to a very rough school in a very deprived area.

I think it’s a huge combination of things alot being grime musics and media like top boy for the gang violence and this case is so odd with the girls complete facination with killing.

notmyrealuserna · 04/02/2024 10:36

It was really hard with my dd when they were teens as they were the first generation to have this level of social media so we were literally going in blind. And I was from the last generation not to (typically) have a phone as a teen. So could not relate at all.

I would do things very differently now I know more

HoneyButterPopcorn · 04/02/2024 10:36

She is promoting a charity that focuses on the mental health of young people. Part might be trying to persuade parents to not slap a mobile phone into the hands of babes in prams, kids in restaurants etc and encourage them to do ‘real world stuff’.

this tech is out there but should be viewed as a tool - not entertainment/replacement of real life activities and experiences.

ColleenDonaghy · 04/02/2024 10:36

Have only read the start of the thread. Mine are still little but I suspect it's like trying to stop teenagers having sex - you can put in as many rules as you want, supervise them as closely as you like but if they are determined they will find a way. So it's more important to teach them how to have sex or use social media responsibly to minimise risk of harm to themselves and others.

As so many posters have said, the genie is out of the bottle.

Notmyfirstusername · 04/02/2024 10:36

@Chucklecheeks01 , I’m exactly the same. Age restricted Youtube, but no access to anything else due to having a criminal law background. I won’t have TikTok or Snapchat on my phone for the same reason, have limited Instagram, facebook and Twitter and no sharing my daughters names or photos either.
My 2 are both teenagers and have seen the damage it does to their friends. If their friends at school talk about stuff on tv, we’re happy to watch it with them so we can discuss any issues, and if they see stuff on their friends phones we talk about it together at home. At 13 they both got to choose the social media apps they wanted except TikTok. Both decided they wanted to continue without anything but WhatsApp, which we allowed.

therealcookiemonster · 04/02/2024 10:34

I mean if a child told his or her parents, I want to go and spent time chatting with a drug dealer/criminal/incel/paedophile/suicide enthusiast/psychopath all night tonight - the parents would absolutely say no. giving open access to the Internet is essentially the same thing, no limits who the child is interacting with. but most parents just let loose, I think mainly due to lack of awareness.

if we have time to legislate to give bankers back their bonuses, then we have time to legislate to protect our children. if the quality of the legislation is there, the technology will follow.

I can see the difference in the quality of life and cognitve and emotional development between children in my social circle who are exposed to unrestricted phone access v not. even if no extreme consequences, the cumulative, negative effects on a mass level are undeniable.

ExtraOnions · 04/02/2024 10:31

We need to take the focus off Social Media and phones, and put it back in the lack of Mental Health provision for young people. CAMHS is overwhelmed to stagnation, GPs won’t work with under 18s, Schools have neither the money or expertise, and Social Care isn’t interested unless there is life endangering neglect.

Parents need services that they can access to get support when their child is starting to struggle. Which service would be interested in “my child is watching violent videos on the internet” ? None. As a parent, of course you can cut the internet off, but that doesn’t address the issue of why they were looking at it in the first place.

It’s easy for the government to shove all this onto parents.. without any acknowledgement that they have continually cut services for years. it just took me 3 years to get an ASD assesment for DD, and to get anti-anxiety meds prescribed to help her function. In that time, it was her phone and SM that allowed her to stay in contact with the outside world

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 10:29

Yes ours watched tv at primary age but no other screens held off phones until secondary but couldn’t hold out longer than that as was affecting social inclusion it just was.

Whatafustercluck · 04/02/2024 10:29

The thing is, I remember this debate raging back in the 1990s with regard to 'video nasties' when James Bulger was murdered by Robert Thompson and John Venables - before we had phones and tech. Those boys were damaged and committed an evil crime. The average teenager these days would not go out and do this kind of heinous thing because they have access to horrible material and messaging apps. The news makes a big thing of the fact that these kids came from 'good families' but to plan and do something that awful, they were most definitely damaged and in need of some kind of intervention from someone. Those two would have done what they did regardless of their access to the dark Web and messaging apps.

But in parallel, do I wish we all had more control over everything our young people are routinely exposed to? Absolutely. Do I think that large social media corporations should do more regarding their social responsibilities and be far better regulated? Definitely. The 'always on' nature of social media is that there is literally no escape from anybody, or anything these days. Only last night, our 13yo ds was in tears due to a particularly vindictive exchange he had with someone he believed was a 'friend'. 30 years ago, this would have been left in the playground, both boys would have reflected overnight and come back to school remorseful the following day. But instead it escalates, and it escalates, and it escalates.

Also, the number of conversations I've had with ds about TikTok not being a reliable source of news content!

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 10:24

My son was shown an Isis beheading on a phone in a lesson in an outstanding school with a very proactive no phone policy. I have literally just found out about it 4 years later. If it hadn’t been the classroom it would have been the playground and if it wasn’t the playground it would have been the bus. What was I supposed to have said no to exactly?

Steaming sites are full of paedophiles, grooming and abuse. My daughter told me pretty matter of factly that sleepover entertainment was often talking to strangers on streaming sites. All those blaming parents are you stopping your teens from attending sleepovers/ coffee in town, meet-ups etc or somehow enforcing no device bans on parents you rarely if ever meet?Teens are way ahead of all parents, they swap ways to beat the system spending a lot of time researching it. Those smugly saying just say no. No to what?

Just to be aware the most isolated teens are the ones most likely to work even harder at beating the rules set out by parents and finding company and entertainment online.

peppermintcrisp · 04/02/2024 10:24

Smart phones have been the biggest issue our house. Until you have had teens with phones you will not understand the worry.

If you DC becomes withdrawn is it hormones or are they accessing troubling content. We managed to get our DDs phone once and she was accessing all sorts of morbid stuff. Going down rabbit holes is very easy. We had to confiscate the phone which then caused her to run away.

Our Government needs to find a solution. I support Brianna's mother and agree with a smart phone ban until 16.

Zanatdy · 04/02/2024 10:22

IhaveanewTVnow · 04/02/2024 10:16

My 22 and 19 year old when 3 or 4 years old didn’t sit in restaurants watching tablets and mobile phones. They coloured in pictures, played with little toys or Uno. Very Long car journeys we had a DVD player and watched DVDs or we played eye spy. They didn’t sit in their pushchair playing games on a mobile phone. We talked. They got their first phone when they went to secondary school. Then the arguing started with them. It was impossible to limit the time they spent on them and what they viewed. In the school playground they would view other kids phones who had unlimited access. They would go on play dates and play online games that were banned in my house. However they are now very respectful lads so we did something right. Still obsessed with their phones……but so am I - even now!

it wasn’t my kids generation that ruined it. It’s now. Speak to your kids in restaurants, play with them, take a colouring book, read to them.

Same for my kids who are 30, 19 and 16. Eldest two didn’t have a phone until secondary, youngest was around year 5 as she had her dads old phone but only had what’s app and a few friends. I never restricted access to phones, and to be honest none are obsessed with them. Daughter who had a phone the earliest uses hers the least. I’ve always let me kids regular their own bedtime / phone use as they were pretty good at doing it, I might not have if they were up on phones all night. It is tough as a parent trying to limit access as friends will undoubtedly let them use their phones and then you’ve got no control at all. It’s tough for sure and I do think Pandora‘a box has been opened now

TheTimeIsNowMaybeNow · 04/02/2024 10:21

Some people just have it in them, they grow up to be the Peter Sutcliffe and Fred west's of the world . Doubt stopping access to the Internet would stop them

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 10:20

IhaveanewTVnow · 04/02/2024 10:16

My 22 and 19 year old when 3 or 4 years old didn’t sit in restaurants watching tablets and mobile phones. They coloured in pictures, played with little toys or Uno. Very Long car journeys we had a DVD player and watched DVDs or we played eye spy. They didn’t sit in their pushchair playing games on a mobile phone. We talked. They got their first phone when they went to secondary school. Then the arguing started with them. It was impossible to limit the time they spent on them and what they viewed. In the school playground they would view other kids phones who had unlimited access. They would go on play dates and play online games that were banned in my house. However they are now very respectful lads so we did something right. Still obsessed with their phones……but so am I - even now!

it wasn’t my kids generation that ruined it. It’s now. Speak to your kids in restaurants, play with them, take a colouring book, read to them.

Put them in front of a screen. DVD player is still a screen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread