Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
NeedToChangeName · 04/02/2024 11:18

I think better to clamp down on content being available in the first place, rather than try to prevent teens from accessing it

Or, pay for youth workers to steer them towards better choices. If no one watched these sites, they would disappear

Fewer CYP use drugs and alcohol than in the past. Society can move in a positive direction

MoreCraicPlease · 04/02/2024 11:18

A small town in Ireland brought in a voluntary code where the primary schools argued for no phones before secondary school (aged 12/13 in Ireland). Last I heard it was going well and still in force.
https://www.itv.com/news/2023-06-08/parents-in-irish-town-unite-to-say-no-to-their-children-having-smartphones

Parents are often afraid to say no on an individual basis but fine on a group basis. That might be more realistic than expecting phone companies to take care of this.

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 11:17

mine both use buses / trains / online banking etc everything you do as an adult on your phone - how would that work then?

sashh · 04/02/2024 11:17

User135644 · 04/02/2024 09:29

It's no catch-all. Even music. Some rap/drill stuff they listen to nowadays is not something kids should be listening to. Cardi B and the like is bad enough.

Wave you seen any opera? Don Giovani isn't calling women bitches but he might as well. Carmen is racist.

Madame Butterfly? A 15 year old married to an older man, it's like a plotline from Eastenders.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 11:17

No. Absolutely not. Do not victim blame this.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 11:16

Borntrippy · 04/02/2024 11:01

You have wristband trackers for worried parents. And dummy phones.

Are you joking?

Ponoka7 · 04/02/2024 11:15

Milkmani · 04/02/2024 11:01

Make smart phones illegal for under 18s. Yes of course it’s good for them to have a phone to access phone calls and texts in case of emergency, even Google maps. But let’s be honest, what is the benefit of smart phones for todays teens and pre-teens? If it’s the law then children are less likely to be made fun of when they have parents who restrict smart phones/social media use. Hopefully this will be lobbied in the next few years

How would that have stopped Jenkinson accessing the dark Web on her tablet/ipad?

The idea of parents having to connect their accounts and gaving an alert when certain words are put in, or certain websites is good. Then we actually charge parents for child neglect when things go wrong. We need early intervention and criminal sanctions, so parents lives are made more difficult if they are badly failing their children. The every child matters strategy was a good one and the policies put in place enforced after the James Bulger murder (both boys had dropped off everyone's radar). We won't get what's needed because inclusivity was never going to work. Children's services are underfunded and there's a percentage of children who we are happy to write off.

Spendonsend · 04/02/2024 11:15

All this focus on parents is letting the creators of these apps and technology off the hook somewhat.

I can see the average teen is tech savy and can get one over their parents. Are they really more tech savy that these companies.

Of course parenting is part of the solution but i reckon til tok could do more if it wanted too

Sureaseggs44 · 04/02/2024 11:14

PeggySooo · 04/02/2024 11:09

Brianna spent most of her time alone in her room because she was autistic and had ADHD. She mostly socialised online. I think if she hadn't, she'd have been much worse mentally than she already was.

I am also autistic and have adhd and online communities have kept me sane at times of my life.

Some of the issue with this case is Scarletts unrestricted access to the Internet meaning she could access the dark Web and Google whatever she wanted. She also had plans to kill and kill lists in plain sight in her room. Why wasn't anyone checking?
However, Scarlett was always going to do this type of crime, with or without the Internet.

I don’t think you can say that as a fact . If you are constantly watching things that appear to make violence acceptable / normal / exciting then it may actually affect your actions .

DixonD · 04/02/2024 11:14

Something like this does exist though - my child has an iPhone with an Apple ID that is linked to mine. She can’t add contacts or apps without my my permission. I get a message every time.

Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 11:13

Milkmani · 04/02/2024 11:01

Make smart phones illegal for under 18s. Yes of course it’s good for them to have a phone to access phone calls and texts in case of emergency, even Google maps. But let’s be honest, what is the benefit of smart phones for todays teens and pre-teens? If it’s the law then children are less likely to be made fun of when they have parents who restrict smart phones/social media use. Hopefully this will be lobbied in the next few years

WTF stop and think that through.

Job at 16 but not allowed a phone to check the train times ?

It's verging on the the ridiculous that at 17 yo mother can't take her toddler to soft play as they need an Adult over 18 .

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 11:13

This reply has been deleted

We made the decision to take this one down.

CaveMum · 04/02/2024 11:12

@Sureaseggs44 I highly recommend the book "The Irrational Ape" to discuss and learn more about teaching critical thinking, it's a few years old so out of date given the pace of AI development, but it's definitely worth reading.

DH did a course recently on AI which he found fascinating and I bought him the book "The Coming Wave" which is a really good exploration of the potential (for both harm and good) that AI represents.

Bumpinthenight · 04/02/2024 11:12

I have had all the Snapchat and tik tok arguments with my DD (16). She's given up now!

It does take an interested parent to monitor and care about what is being accesses on the Internet. Whether that is via phone, tablet, computer.

My DD still has Family link on her phone. Her usage before 13 was a lot healthier than it is now so I think it is even more important to educate her on the safety of phones. Also, she is supposed to be revising, not Instagramming! She has time limits set for each app and understands why they are there. We can extend these limits at a press of a button. We can also turn her phone off if needed. She understands that having a phone is not a right and if she wants us to continue paying the bill, she'll put up with our rules/restrictions.

It's been hard work to get where we are now but that hard work has paid off. Many parents don't want that hard work and then have to deal with the consequences at a later date. Hard to lock the stable door and all that...

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 11:11

Borntrippy · 04/02/2024 11:01

You have wristband trackers for worried parents. And dummy phones.

DD's bus pass is a QR code on her phone.
All her homework is on an app. Some can be done in her books which is fine, even if research is required. Some (including revision) are on more apps and websites and need to be handed in online.
They got a frikking team project to do for homework and it was a pain for all of them to be available on a suitable platform. DD ended up doing the whole thing herself, then copying and pasting for the others so they could write it in their books.
Her timetable is on an app.
In some lessons they're asked to research things on their phones or log in to x website or app to do whatever.
If things are cancelled or set up she gets an email or notification.
She's only 12.🙄

That's just the basic stuff. I know you mentioned the secure laptop in the communal room. If parents are savvy enough and willing to police a laptop, they can police a phone/tablet too. If they're not, then that laptop is just as dangerous as a phone, so a pointless measure and even a risky one as parents will think their kid is safe and not doing x,y,z because they don't have a phone.

mumda · 04/02/2024 11:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PeggySooo · 04/02/2024 11:09

Brianna spent most of her time alone in her room because she was autistic and had ADHD. She mostly socialised online. I think if she hadn't, she'd have been much worse mentally than she already was.

I am also autistic and have adhd and online communities have kept me sane at times of my life.

Some of the issue with this case is Scarletts unrestricted access to the Internet meaning she could access the dark Web and Google whatever she wanted. She also had plans to kill and kill lists in plain sight in her room. Why wasn't anyone checking?
However, Scarlett was always going to do this type of crime, with or without the Internet.

Sureaseggs44 · 04/02/2024 11:09

CaveMum · 04/02/2024 11:02

We're at a similar tipping point with AI right now - I can only hope that people (companies, governments, etc) have learned the lessons around the lack of regulation of social media and step in now to regulate AI while it is still in it's relatively early stages. Don't be mistaken, we're approaching another industrial revolution, probably the most significant one to date.

Yes I totally agree AI is already being used for war propaganda and if we don’t teach critical thinking ( we may already be too late ) then people will believe anything they see is real .

I was watching the video about the strictest headmistress and her legal high court case and she has some interesting things to say about letting children be children and levelling up actually gives them more tools to be free later in life . She believes no children under 15 should have smart phones .

Boathouse5654 · 04/02/2024 11:08

Alargeoneplease89
So you’re lecturing and blaming other parents but not checking your own child’s phone. How on earth are you so positive your 15 year old is so different and in some kind of protective bubble. The reason you’re not checking your teens phone is because it’s impossible, the same as everybody else.

Dancerprancer19 · 04/02/2024 11:08

I would love to see schools take a lead on this by pushing the message to parents and teens consistently.

I was shocked recently to learn than half my child’s peers in year 4 have a mobile phone! It’s crazy to me.

CHRIS003 · 04/02/2024 11:06

I think the idea of children's phones for under 16 wouldn't really work
Nor would banning them from social media
But I think a culture change in limiting and monitoring usage
First of all parents need to stop saying they can't stop their children accessing this content in the home.
Parental controls on broadband & phones
Turn off the WiFi at bedtime
Make sure phones & laptops are used under supervision inside the home
Parents need to lead by example - look at how much time they spend on social media- if your child sees you posting pictures and living your life online they copy it.
Stop saying they don't have time due to work or they don't feel comfortable invading their child's privacy.
In school
I watched a Korean show on netflix which had a school scene- all the children put the mobile phones in a box at the start of the lesson and collected them at the end.
Or
Headteachers at secondary - could look into a system for banning phone at breaktime
If child needs a phone for a particular reason then maybe phones could be booked in to the office for instance with a letter of consent from parent stating why their child needs a phone.
Headteachers at junior schools - should look at whether mobile phones should be bought into school.
A cultural change is needed on the relationship between children and their phones.

Rightsraptor · 04/02/2024 11:06

I mentioned to a friend who works in a school that I think mobile phones shouldn't be used in school but she said schools often need the children to use them in class. This is an independent school which also seems to have a high number of troubled kids. If it's true that schools require them, then they are a huge part of the problem.

There is already a smart phone that won't download certain apps, but I've forgotten its name I'm afraid. I know it's American. So children can use it for transport information, which they may well need, but not access the more worrying apps.

CaveMum · 04/02/2024 11:05

On another note, my DD (9) has been having counselling for unrelated matters. One of the first questions the counsellor asked was "does she have access to social media?" When we said no her response was to hold out for as long as we possibly can - that 80% of the the problems she sees in children and young people can be traced back in some form to social media use.

DD has been asking for a phone for a while, but the requests have definitely gotten more frequent now. She claims "most" of her friends have them (I know a few do, mainly children whose parents are separated and they use the phone to keep in touch with the non-resident parent) but I've drawn a line in the sand and said her 11th birthday is the absolute earliest she will get one. Her birthday will be 6 months before she starts secondary school so I see that as a reasonable point in time. We've not agreed to a particular type of phone or anything like that, and if I don't think she can demonstrate the maturity to use it responsibly then she will get a simple brick phone over a smart phone.

Milkmani · 04/02/2024 11:04

DragonFly98 · 04/02/2024 11:01

I don't want my teen dd to have social media so we refused initially the result was a depressed and isolated teenager who was left out and already doesn't feel she fits in due to autism. It's not that black and white.

If smart phones were not accessible for under 18s this would not be an issue. Good on you for trying, like you said your child became isolated for not accessing what everyone else could and that is not something a parent would want - cause potential resentment and an unhappy child. If they made it illegal for under 18s to have smart phones it would give the parents the power to restrict and stop the bullying/isolation of not being able to access social media

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2024 11:04

Absolutely. As a nearly 50 so non digital native it’s all frankly terrifying. Dh already working out non AI jobs to advise teens to go for their first choices won’t exist in 10 years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread