Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 11:38

Their social media algorithms directed them to the darker side of the internet

That's not how it works or what the dark web is. Jesus.

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:37

AcridAndStanLee · 04/02/2024 11:21

The apps are not the problem. Bullying is. We need to raise our children to do better. Don't bully, call it out when you see it and get better support from the police and the schools.

I hate bullying but we will never ever be rid of it. Equally there is no harm in tackling it from all angles. We, as women, know men are unsafe yet take measures to protect ourselves in certain environments because their behaviour is sadly inevitable. It's not different to tech and children. Simply saying the problem is bullying is weak and absolving yourself of responsibility.

TeenLifeMum · 04/02/2024 11:36

Dd1 got WhatsApp in year 7 (closely monitored with the no deleting messages rule), in year 10 she got insta after a long conversation, year 11 she’s got Snapchat. Dtds are year 8 and got Snapchat at the same time - dtd2 came to me with a speech prepared about how she’d use Snapchat and the mitigations she’d put in place to protect her. It’s on trial.

I’ve spoken openly about my concerns. my colleague’s daughter had 2 dc commit suicide due to Snapchat bullying 2 months apart. I hate it but also acknowledge dd was being left out because her friends had another world that she wasn’t part of. We talk about it a lot and they are open dc ego tell us what’s happening in “phone world”. I check their messages - they know I do. I don’t check dd1 (she’s 16 and has built my trust) but I’ve said that if I was ever worried about her I would check her phone.

parenting with phones is very stressful and I think there’s a balance but it can go very wrong.

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:35

Littlemisscapable · 04/02/2024 11:28

But weren't these teenagers on the dark web etc. That isn't accessible through apps or whatever....these teenagers seem incredibly troubled - this is such extreme behaviour.. therefore it's a lot more than the Internet that caused their behaviour. Way more at play here.

Their social media algorithms directed them to the darker side of the internet

EachandEveryone · 04/02/2024 11:34

I notice the Jewish school boys who get on my bus dont have smart phones but old school phones so it can be done. And for them everyone is the same so I suppose it makes it easier.

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:34

It's entirely possible to police their phones. "If you want a phone before you're 16 and are expecting me to pay for it I want you to hand it for inspection when asked/weekly/fortnightly/monthly" it's as simple as that.

MissBurnOut · 04/02/2024 11:32

Petrarkanian · 04/02/2024 11:26

I work in a secondary school with a no mobile policy, we also require all phones to have parental controls on. The number of parents who object to this is insane. Why wouldn't you want your kid to be protected?

It's too late in my opinion, when toddlers have ipad holders on their push chairs, how do you change this ingrained behaviour.

This is the same at my school too. The amount of parents who complain about our “no phones” policy is surprising. I’ve had many parents tell me that their children spend hours on their devices after school and they either don’t see this as an issue (as the children are “socialising with friends”) or do it for a quiet life as limiting devices at this stage causes huge rows with their DCs.

Namechangenamechange321 · 04/02/2024 11:30

Megifer · 04/02/2024 09:12

So you already do, and will do, pretty much what those parents you blame for this did? As ime it kind of starts with the console when they can use it as a way to socialise with pals online.

You kids will ask for a console from when they are about 5 BTW. And phones will enter their orbit at around 8 if not sooner. Good luck.

(my kids never got a tablet on long journeys, they read a book, and they got consoles when I decided they were ready)

I agree. My 9 year old has been nagging for a console for ages. I’ve held out so far. Not sure when I’ll get him one but it’s nowhere on the horizon yet….

BoohooWoohoo · 04/02/2024 11:30

In an ideal world children wouldn’t be on social media but in reality many parents wouldn’t abide by a ban and it wouldn’t be possible technically unless the government wanted to spy on people’s phones like in China. I’m not even sure how to check what my child saw on the Dark Web which is presumably where the extreme content is posted.
When a parent finds something troubling on their kid’s phone, what are the realistic chances of getting help ? I don’t see CAMHS, the health service or social services rushing with therapy and solutions tbh. I’ve read posts on here where poster’s children do dangerous things like send naked selfies and there’s no proper help that can fix that problem.
Plus there’s a major problem that many schools use apps for homework and learning meaning kids need a smart phone or other device.

Littlemisscapable · 04/02/2024 11:28

But weren't these teenagers on the dark web etc. That isn't accessible through apps or whatever....these teenagers seem incredibly troubled - this is such extreme behaviour.. therefore it's a lot more than the Internet that caused their behaviour. Way more at play here.

MissBurnOut · 04/02/2024 11:26

"Not possible" my arse.

@Cazpar

Agreed!

Petrarkanian · 04/02/2024 11:26

I work in a secondary school with a no mobile policy, we also require all phones to have parental controls on. The number of parents who object to this is insane. Why wouldn't you want your kid to be protected?

It's too late in my opinion, when toddlers have ipad holders on their push chairs, how do you change this ingrained behaviour.

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 11:24

PeggySooo · 04/02/2024 11:19

Do you not understand that Scarlett had a kill list which involved other children who were not trans?
That she's made another kill list whilst in detention?
Or do you purposefully ignore these things because it fits in with your anti trans nonsense? Why are you victim blaming?

Edited

Im not sure I can answer your question

I know she had kill lists, past and present. I dont believe Brianna was killed for being trans so not sure of your point there and Im not 'anti trans' (whatever that is in this context) so I cant answer you

Mementobento · 04/02/2024 11:24

It’s pretty much impossible to get credit if you’re under 18, as passport verification etc is required. I think we should apply the same rigorous controls to certain apps, particularly Snapchat. Snapchat is the app of choice for drug dealers and paedophiles to groom children.
The internet and smartphones generally, I think this is already a problem too big, but where we know certain apps carry a massive risk where strangers can offer children easy opportunities to purchase drugs and vapes, it isn’t good enough to say there’s nothing we can do. There must be some things we can do.

Daisydoor12 · 04/02/2024 11:23

I agree with Brianna’s mother but just banning under 16s or, as some suggest under 18s, from having a smart phone won’t be enough. I would firstly ban phones and tablets for anyone under age of 7. Use of iPads etc removed from ks1 curriculum, devices which allow tablets to be attached to cots/pushchairs banned, young children if they are using them indoors they would no doubt say at school/nursery this would become a safeguarding issue just like if they reported watching inappropriate tv etc. Secondly as Children/teenagers have access to tablets, laptops etc the problem would continue just not on a phone. The security around social media apps need to be tighter. Downloading and using them under 18 against the law, huge media/advertising campaigns saying the reasons, tighter controls on downloading eg credit card verification, passport, national insurance number etc. Monitoring of social media (this is where ai could be useful) and harmful content reported, deleted and traced back to who is responsible. As humans we generally follow social norms and don’t want to break the law therefore if the above occurred it would become common place in society and followed just like any other law.

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 11:23

Dancerprancer19 · 04/02/2024 11:08

I would love to see schools take a lead on this by pushing the message to parents and teens consistently.

I was shocked recently to learn than half my child’s peers in year 4 have a mobile phone! It’s crazy to me.

Schools do. We had endless assemblies and info sent to parents about social media,age limits, safe usage etc.

The issue is tricky in two ways.

One, many schools encourage children to use educational apps (including in the form of rewards,certificates etc) so they need some form of device. Covid made it all 100 times worse as so much of it was online,and some things stayed online. It was a lot easier and cheaper to have a phone or tablet(especially if there were old ones knocking about in the house) , than getting a dedicated laptop for it, or sharing.

Two, and the real issue here , they can't make parents(or their children) comply.

We had a really serious issue with phones for one class. Parents coming in complaining daily , not one of them took the phone away, or at least deleted the blooming apps or set some restrictions.Not one of them realised that even if their child was the victim, they as parents were part of the problem. Any suggestions of limiting access was met with anger,aggression and accusations we don't care, we can't be bothered and we're not safeguarding their children.

AcridAndStanLee · 04/02/2024 11:21

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:41

Why isn’t it possible though? If every child was not allowed the apps and there were restrictions on the internet. Wouldn’t that be better for the kids?

Children are growing up too soon.

The apps are not the problem. Bullying is. We need to raise our children to do better. Don't bully, call it out when you see it and get better support from the police and the schools.

Sureaseggs44 · 04/02/2024 11:21

Spendonsend · 04/02/2024 11:15

All this focus on parents is letting the creators of these apps and technology off the hook somewhat.

I can see the average teen is tech savy and can get one over their parents. Are they really more tech savy that these companies.

Of course parenting is part of the solution but i reckon til tok could do more if it wanted too

Tik tok don’t want to . They don’t care .

soupfiend · 04/02/2024 11:21

Sureaseggs44 · 04/02/2024 11:14

I don’t think you can say that as a fact . If you are constantly watching things that appear to make violence acceptable / normal / exciting then it may actually affect your actions .

We (the big we) generally accept that if a child grows up around unsafe, unpredictable, violent, aggressive parents, that this will have a significant effect on their development and their propensity to commit crime/violent crime in later life

Yet we find it very difficult to accept that if the same child is exposed for hours and hours on end via the internet/phone/laptop whatever, to the same thing, that this will also have an impact on their behaviour.

For those saying the killers would have killed anyway, even without all this exposure.

Butterdishy · 04/02/2024 11:20

It comes down to parental responsibility IMO. There's no need for teens to have unrestricted access to devices - it's not good for any of us. Restrict what they can access and don't leave them with their phones 24/7.

PeggySooo · 04/02/2024 11:19

This reply has been deleted

We made the decision to take this one down.

Do you not understand that Scarlett had a kill list which involved other children who were not trans?
That she's made another kill list whilst in detention?
Or do you purposefully ignore these things because it fits in with your anti trans nonsense? Why are you victim blaming?

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 11:19

Rightsraptor · 04/02/2024 11:06

I mentioned to a friend who works in a school that I think mobile phones shouldn't be used in school but she said schools often need the children to use them in class. This is an independent school which also seems to have a high number of troubled kids. If it's true that schools require them, then they are a huge part of the problem.

There is already a smart phone that won't download certain apps, but I've forgotten its name I'm afraid. I know it's American. So children can use it for transport information, which they may well need, but not access the more worrying apps.

I work in a school. They’re banned and should be in their lockers.

Do you know who complains about this rule the most? Parents.

CaveMum · 04/02/2024 11:18

There needs to also be standardised policies in schools around mobile phone use. We're looking at a private secondary school for DD (unpopular opinion on MN for some I know 😜), I was really pleased to read their mobile phone policy use which is that parents need to complete a form at the start of the school year stating that their child has permission to have a phone at school and that the phone is handed to the Tutor and the start of the day and given back at the end of the day unless there are extentuating circumstances. If a parent needs to contact their child then it has to be done through the school office.

skyeisthelimit · 04/02/2024 11:18

It is possible if parents make it possible. DD wasn't allowed certain apps until she was old enough. She was allowed enough apps that she could play games and talk to her friends. She didn't have a smart phone until she was 11 and starting secondary school. There are kids as young as 5 being given smart phones by their parents.

I know the passwords to everything and can access her phone at any time. If she changes any passwords then I can take the phone away. She is 15 now and I trust her more, but she knows that I still have the right to access her phone.

We had a case of grooming in our family several years ago, involving a 12yo and a21yo and it actually went to court, so I have been very aware of the damage that phones can cost.

DD is 15 now and has no interest in TikTok at all. She can't understand her peers who are addicted to it and addicted to their phones.

If more parents put their foot down and made their kids get off their phones, it would make a huge difference. But a lot of parents don't care. A lot of parents are just happy that the kids aren't bothering them.

The change has to start with the parents. Check the apps, limit the time spent, turn off the wifi overnight, remove the phones from meal tables, insist on free time without the phones.

Yes the Government can step in and do something, yes the schools can go on about the dangers of social media, but it has to start with the parents removing the access/phones from the children.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 04/02/2024 11:18

SKG231 · 04/02/2024 09:09

Do your research and make sure you have all parental controls on your child’s phone so they have to request to download apps, can’t go on certain websites etc.

make it clear it is a privilege not right to have a smart phone and it can easily be switched out for a basic phone used for calls and text.

also make it clear that you have rights to access the phone, not that you’ll be snooping at it every day but if you feel the need it is your right to look.

phones must be left downstairs before bedtime. No negotiations.

make sure they’ve watched educational videos about how what we put and say online is forever and it is as real as saying it to somebodies face.

make sure you communicate with your child and ask them often how life is going for them, if they have any worries and let them know you are always there for them no Mather what the issue is.

Realistically I do think this is the best we can do