Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CaptainPliskin · 04/02/2024 11:48

If we want a better society then why do we allow shows like csi , why do some films tv shows glamourise crime, what about books about infamous individuals, what about various music's ? ECT

basically to reshape humanity it would be something similar to the film equilibrium with Christian bale

Spendonsend · 04/02/2024 11:47

Sureaseggs44 · 04/02/2024 11:21

Tik tok don’t want to . They don’t care .

I know. But lots of manufacturers dont want to do things but are made to be legislation or consumer demand or via law suits holding them responsible.

OhmygodDont · 04/02/2024 11:46

We use the iPhone controls so they have to ask and be approved for apps and you can see how much time they are spending on what.

The issue is those who don’t have any controls. Also thing like TikTok being recorded and then shared onto YouTube and even found onto children’s YouTube at times. So one minute you can be on a documentary about dart frogs and the next is some TikTok about frogs but then that leads to just YouTube TikTok.

So many schools now want the children to have apps for homework, my dds school she has five different online app accounts for homework and study. Bus tickets are cheaper on the app than having to buy on the bus, who 9/10 want payment via card/phone rather than cash too. Want to check your school dinner balance it’s on an app and that’s the only way to check it.

You would have to actually pass a law to ban smart phones for people under a certain age, schools would need to then change how they do everything too. Back to everything via paper not thinking that everyone has a smartphone, no more say online homework because a lot of people use tablets and phones not pcs and a tablet is just as easy to get all these apps and whatnot as a phone so you’d have to ban them for children too.

Would need the councils to open up all the library’s again. To make sure all children had access to the things they need for learning as most parents can get a smart phone on contract for say £20 a month can’t get a whole pc and wifi for that.

Libraries should be reopened anyway btw. But you are asking for so many things to have to change. I don’t think it will happen but I’ll continue to have monitoring and checking on my children’s smart phones though. They are after all my cast offs so free and I know exactly how they work.

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:46

ShoePalaver · 04/02/2024 11:43

Parents will mostly abide by the law, as long as they understand the harms. There are not many parents buying their kids cigarettes.

Schools need to stop encouraging children to use devices. If they require a smartphone for homework they are a big part of the problem.

This. Schools are a huge part of the problem by insisting on tech. Even in reception their reading homework is to be done on a tablet.

VickyEadieofThigh · 04/02/2024 11:45

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:41

Why isn’t it possible though? If every child was not allowed the apps and there were restrictions on the internet. Wouldn’t that be better for the kids?

Children are growing up too soon.

It's possible for parents to do a lot about it - but as some/many will not, it's a battle that cannot be won.

CaptainPliskin · 04/02/2024 11:45

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:41

Why isn’t it possible though? If every child was not allowed the apps and there were restrictions on the internet. Wouldn’t that be better for the kids?

Children are growing up too soon.

It would be better but then we would need every one to follow the rule

Butterfly44 · 04/02/2024 11:45

Murder is pretty rare at that age.

Not allowing access to certain apps compared to their friends breeds resentment. The best way is to build their own knowledge around safety, confidence and give them the ability to know right from wrong and to speak up.

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:45

Hereyoume · 04/02/2024 11:42

Thats incredibly naive.

I suppose you never lied to your parents either.

I did but equally I didn't have a good relationship with my parents. I adopted what I'm talking about with my own teens and it worked. Like I say it's not about being right all the time, it's about them knowing it's safe to have privacy but it's safe to make mistakes and it's safe to speak up about them. I don't want my teens to not be sneaky and to not lie, it's part of how they learn and part of how they grow up, but I want them to know someone's got their back and someone's keeping an eye on their sneakyness.

TodayForTomorrow · 04/02/2024 11:45

I don't mind them having an offline switch or something, (I had a Gameboy and a DS growing up) but I will not be putting one in their hands before they even know what one is. Someone has already said they'll be asking for it at 5. My son is just 7 now and doesn't show any interest in gaming whatsoever. He thinks a Playstation is the climbing frame at the park.

I know a lot about apps, VPNs and social media. I also work with teenagers, so I know that there will be a lot of pressure for them to have some kind of social media or else be an odd one out. However in an ideal world, it would not be uncommon in their friend group, and I could get them a dumb phone that has very limited capabilities.

ShepherdMoons · 04/02/2024 11:44

The use of smartphones and issues around it are really a parenting issue. How we introduce our dcs to the smartphone and how we limit its usage, etc is largely about parenting and educating children that the internet is not innocuous.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 11:44

Hereyoume · 04/02/2024 11:43

How do you check if the parents have done that?

We don’t check. We ask them to sign up to school policy. But they complain. They complain about kids not being allowed phones in lessons as well.

Hereyoume · 04/02/2024 11:43

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 11:41

Exact same experience.

How do you check if the parents have done that?

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 11:43

NotARealWookiie · 04/02/2024 11:41

I actually thing the idea of and under 16s phone is genius and would need to be enforced with legislation but could make a massive difference and I think broadly parents would go for it. Most parents I know are worried by phones and social media. Most kids have their phones bought by their parents and would not have the money to try to go out and illegally by an expensive phone. So whilst there will always be exceptions I think it could help.

it would probably be a bit like the smoking age, yes a lot of them will try smoking under age but we don’t live in a society where 12 year olds can go and buy cigarettes and take up smoking. Most parents wouldn’t support this or buy them cigarettes because it’s illegal and bad for them. A few exceptions to the rule but broadly benefits the health of our children.

Other than a decent chunk of kids are given hand me down phones. This requires all to be able to afford to purchase a phone specifically for their child. Which many cannot. And how would you enforce it? Make it a criminal offence giving children old phones? Is it illegal for a child to touch a phone not designed for under 16? It’s not practical.

ShoePalaver · 04/02/2024 11:43

BoohooWoohoo · 04/02/2024 11:30

In an ideal world children wouldn’t be on social media but in reality many parents wouldn’t abide by a ban and it wouldn’t be possible technically unless the government wanted to spy on people’s phones like in China. I’m not even sure how to check what my child saw on the Dark Web which is presumably where the extreme content is posted.
When a parent finds something troubling on their kid’s phone, what are the realistic chances of getting help ? I don’t see CAMHS, the health service or social services rushing with therapy and solutions tbh. I’ve read posts on here where poster’s children do dangerous things like send naked selfies and there’s no proper help that can fix that problem.
Plus there’s a major problem that many schools use apps for homework and learning meaning kids need a smart phone or other device.

Parents will mostly abide by the law, as long as they understand the harms. There are not many parents buying their kids cigarettes.

Schools need to stop encouraging children to use devices. If they require a smartphone for homework they are a big part of the problem.

Xtraincome · 04/02/2024 11:43

It all comes down to parenting, OP. Strong rewards for minimal use, setting a good example yourselves and engaging actively with your children often - that's mitigating risks but not eliminating them by a long shot. And why any child posts anything on SM before they are 16 is beyond me!

Every generation will have an example of what poor parenting looks like, SM and excessive Internet use is ours. As was sending your small children out all day with no adult supervision - although I will be lambasted for this opinion as so many of that generation claim it was character building and whatever 🙄.

We, as parents needs to manage it, simple as. There is absolutely no way to police it effectively.

Milkmani · 04/02/2024 11:42

Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 11:13

WTF stop and think that through.

Job at 16 but not allowed a phone to check the train times ?

It's verging on the the ridiculous that at 17 yo mother can't take her toddler to soft play as they need an Adult over 18 .

Maybe 16 would be a better age if that is the case. But to train lines not have apps and also the buses? What is your suggestion regarding smart phones for children, do you really think they have been really beneficial in the last 10 years?

Hereyoume · 04/02/2024 11:42

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:41

You cannot "check" your kids phones, whatever you may believe, absolutely anything can be hidden by using apps or file managers. I have an app on mine, a photo and message "vault". It looks and works exactly like a regular calculator, until I type in a specific series of numbers, then the app opens. There are literally hundreds of these types of app on the Play Store. So, all those parents who "check" their DC phone are wasting their time

youre assuming parents aren't tech savvy and don't know this.

Monitoring their phones isnt about discovering all their dark secrets it's fostering trust and ability to talk to each other. Start the conversation "before I look through your phone do I need to know anything?" Teens like to be sneaky but if your relationship is good they will be able to hide very little from you and the threat alone will be enough for a confession.

Thats incredibly naive.

I suppose you never lied to your parents either.

NotARealWookiie · 04/02/2024 11:41

I actually thing the idea of and under 16s phone is genius and would need to be enforced with legislation but could make a massive difference and I think broadly parents would go for it. Most parents I know are worried by phones and social media. Most kids have their phones bought by their parents and would not have the money to try to go out and illegally by an expensive phone. So whilst there will always be exceptions I think it could help.

it would probably be a bit like the smoking age, yes a lot of them will try smoking under age but we don’t live in a society where 12 year olds can go and buy cigarettes and take up smoking. Most parents wouldn’t support this or buy them cigarettes because it’s illegal and bad for them. A few exceptions to the rule but broadly benefits the health of our children.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 11:41

Petrarkanian · 04/02/2024 11:26

I work in a secondary school with a no mobile policy, we also require all phones to have parental controls on. The number of parents who object to this is insane. Why wouldn't you want your kid to be protected?

It's too late in my opinion, when toddlers have ipad holders on their push chairs, how do you change this ingrained behaviour.

Exact same experience.

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:41

You cannot "check" your kids phones, whatever you may believe, absolutely anything can be hidden by using apps or file managers. I have an app on mine, a photo and message "vault". It looks and works exactly like a regular calculator, until I type in a specific series of numbers, then the app opens. There are literally hundreds of these types of app on the Play Store. So, all those parents who "check" their DC phone are wasting their time

youre assuming parents aren't tech savvy and don't know this.

Monitoring their phones isnt about discovering all their dark secrets it's fostering trust and ability to talk to each other. Start the conversation "before I look through your phone do I need to know anything?" Teens like to be sneaky but if your relationship is good they will be able to hide very little from you and the threat alone will be enough for a confession.

angeltop · 04/02/2024 11:39

There is a utube of Zuckerberg in front of a committee accused of not adhering to an online child safety bill.

ShoePalaver · 04/02/2024 11:39

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:41

Why isn’t it possible though? If every child was not allowed the apps and there were restrictions on the internet. Wouldn’t that be better for the kids?

Children are growing up too soon.

Completely agree. Of course it's possible if the will is there. At some point age restrictions were introduced for smoking, alcohol, buying knives, guns, sex, marriage, working long hours, compulsory education, driving, car seats..... A smart phone ban for under 18s no different and I have no doubt it will come at some point, the question is when.
Smart phones are probably more detrimental than smoking for children or not using car seats.

Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 11:38

NeedToChangeName · 04/02/2024 11:18

I think better to clamp down on content being available in the first place, rather than try to prevent teens from accessing it

Or, pay for youth workers to steer them towards better choices. If no one watched these sites, they would disappear

Fewer CYP use drugs and alcohol than in the past. Society can move in a positive direction

Clamping down on the content is certainly one of the better ideas.

But nobody owns or is completely in-charge of the Internet

Milkmani · 04/02/2024 11:38

Ponoka7 · 04/02/2024 11:15

How would that have stopped Jenkinson accessing the dark Web on her tablet/ipad?

The idea of parents having to connect their accounts and gaving an alert when certain words are put in, or certain websites is good. Then we actually charge parents for child neglect when things go wrong. We need early intervention and criminal sanctions, so parents lives are made more difficult if they are badly failing their children. The every child matters strategy was a good one and the policies put in place enforced after the James Bulger murder (both boys had dropped off everyone's radar). We won't get what's needed because inclusivity was never going to work. Children's services are underfunded and there's a percentage of children who we are happy to write off.

Same for tablets/iPads, I don’t give them to my children for an easy life. Like you say, parents need to be held accountable. My sister is autistic and growing up she was without the iPad/tablet as they didn’t exist - this seems to be a common excuse. They need to make these devices without access to internet - only apps for learning/school work. I’m sorry but children should not have their own ipad/tablet if it is to be used without supervision.

Hereyoume · 04/02/2024 11:38

You cannot "check" your kids phones, whatever you may believe, absolutely anything can be hidden by using apps or file managers. I have an app on mine, a photo and message "vault". It looks and works exactly like a regular calculator, until I type in a specific series of numbers, then the app opens. There are literally hundreds of these types of app on the Play Store. So, all those parents who "check" their DC phone are wasting their time.

And "burner" phones are sold for £50 around here, the kids even joke about them they are so common. So all that life 360 and parental software stuff is pointless too. Lots of kids swap "burner deets" and some give their "real" handsets to friends who will hang out where the child is supposed to be, in case their parents have a location app, but the DC is actually somewhere completely different and using their burner.

Kids will ALWAYS find a way around.

If mobiles didn't exist, no iphones, no apps, nothing, and I invented one, with all the current social media and browsers pre installed, they would never allow me to sell it, citing child safety concerns, privacy, stalking potential, access to porn etc.

We have sleepwalked into a mass surveillance society, where "social credit" is now as real as your Experian score. A single 30 second TicTok clip can ruin your business, get you fired, make you unemployable, drive you to suicide.

I'm not sure what the answer is.