Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wholeheartedly agree with Brianna Ghey’s mother

543 replies

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 08:34

I spotted this article this morning. We personally do not allow Tik Tok, Insta, Facebook, Snapchat. For our eldest who has just got a phone when starting Year 7. However we have succumbed to whatsapp.

What are people’s thoughts? How can we ‘police’ our children’s phones?

Or AIBU and there is no policing for social media? I know my Year 7 child’s friends do have these apps. Not all of them though.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

Brianna Ghey and her mother Esther pictured together before her daughter was murdered

Brianna Ghey: Ban children's access to social media apps, her mother says

Scarlett Jenkinson, who killed Brianna, had watched videos of violence and torture on the dark web.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68193103

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Isitautumnyet23 · 04/02/2024 12:21

Littlemisscapable · 04/02/2024 11:28

But weren't these teenagers on the dark web etc. That isn't accessible through apps or whatever....these teenagers seem incredibly troubled - this is such extreme behaviour.. therefore it's a lot more than the Internet that caused their behaviour. Way more at play here.

Exactly - taking tech away from most teenagers because of two extremely disturbed individuals is like banning the internet for adults because the tiny minority use it for horrific things.

She was a deeply disturbed child who in my opinion should never have been free to attend school. How did she poison classmates in her previous school and then be allowed to attend school and make friends with a vulnerable girl like Brianna?

There is something deeply wrong with the system that this girl was not already locked away in a secure place.

CaptainPliskin · 04/02/2024 12:20

Society still produced individuals like Genghis khan, attlia the hun, Alexander the great all these before modern technology, tv, library's etc

when the tech improves or if it's already available Could genetically engineering humans to provide part of the solution to improve humans ?

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 12:11

ShoePalaver · 04/02/2024 11:59

Guessing you're quite young! I had a job from 13 until 32 with no smart phone. I used to commute by train for 5 years pre smart phone. My dad still has no smart phone and commutes by train.

How do you check train times? Or get a phone number?

They don’t issue paper copies anymore.

KeepGoing2 · 04/02/2024 12:10

What’s interesting is how quickly screens for little ones have become normal. I remember posting on a forum when DS was about 4 about how to distract him on a long train journey and the most popular suggestion was wrapping up small things to do as presents- box of crayons, stickers etc- and unwrapping one every hour. No one suggested screens because they just weren’t a thing for kids, this is not much more than a decade ago.

Bubble2024 · 04/02/2024 12:10

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:46

This. Schools are a huge part of the problem by insisting on tech. Even in reception their reading homework is to be done on a tablet.

I have never heard of that re reception.

but insisting on tech is actually largely about accessibility. To even the playing field. Using tech for learning is not the issue here.

BrieAndChilli · 04/02/2024 12:09

I think parents need to be better educated on what steps they can put into place. DH is very IT savvy so we have the following things in place, which is not a magic solution but does help a little.

  • to download any app including free ones a message is sent to his and my phones and we have to authorise it.
  • our home internet and phone data are blocked to prevent accessing sites with adult content. Means I can’t access sites like the magazine cosmopolitan and some other random ones that aren’t ‘adult sites’. Doesn’t mean that they don’t come across inappropriate content but it helps reduce it
  • we have all passwords and access to the cloud.
  • we have find my phone on all our phones. It goes both ways so they can see where we are too. Because it’s always been that way they don’t see it as spying but understand it is just a tool to help keep them safe eg if they were late we could see where they are etc. or find phones when they have been dropped in a field!
  • when they got phones in year 6 ready for going to secondary we would read all messages each night and could discuss what language was appropriate to help teach them the nuances of texting etc

of course the above measures don’t mean they are safe and we try and have open discussions with them and are hopefully bringing them up to be kind respectful people.

TitusMoan · 04/02/2024 12:09

Sususudio · 04/02/2024 08:58

I do hope there is a backlash like there is against UPF.

That’s a backlash for people with their eyes and ears open though. That’s a very small percentage. The rest of the population are busy consuming absolute shite day in day out.

kikilaw · 04/02/2024 12:09

This lady is saying what we all know to be the truth. It is difficult though as the cat is out of the bag but if it means current 4 and 5 year olds are safer by the time they are teens I am all for it. Children with sm accounts need to be the outliers not the norm.

I have teens. It is near impossible to monitor their sm behaviour and presence. My dd is 15 and only allowed whats app but she still accesses load of crap on youtube etc. She is the only one in her peer group that doesn't have tiktok, snapchat etc. shes at an indi school with lots of nice professional parents and there is constant gossip of sexting and sharing of videos etc. i can easily see how a vunerable child could fall down a rabbit hole. My dd had tiktok but i took it away when i saw how much trans activism was being shared - she was only 12 then and it was a big wake up call to me as to how invasive sm can be.

There is a lot of money in it though - so many want to ensure the gravy train keeps running.

AcridAndStanLee · 04/02/2024 12:09

@ShoePalaver but using a phone for train times is perfectly normal. Saying you didn't used to has no relevance. We used to lock people up in a home if they had a disability, doesn't make it right.

@LetsgoLego you misunderstand. I'm not being weak and absolving responsibility. I'm taking all the responsibility that I should raise my daughter right and ensure she is as balanced and well rounded and kind as she can be. If she receives a message from someone odd or watched a video she knows isn't right we have a conversation about it.

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 12:08

Isitautumnyet23 · 04/02/2024 12:06

Without sounding rude, a year 7 isnt going to be into blanket forts or alot of the things suggested above. Maybe upto Year 3/4 at tops. We are out and about all the time, but im happy for my kids to use tech as everything is about balance. Lots of kids use tech instead of watching tv these days (and all of us 90’s kids loved our tv shows!). They will watch their favourite You Tubers instead of the programmes we put on after school (Grange Hill etc). We were still into screens it was just the tv instead of the tablets they have today.

No I know they're not but my suggestions weren't just for teens.

If you've got your teens into hobbies as primary kids though they'll probably be wanting to practice or do things related to them by year 7

Isitautumnyet23 · 04/02/2024 12:06

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:54

It's not difficult to be tech free. Parks are free, sports clubs and scouting/cadets are cost effective activities, gardening at home or community spaces is free too... That's before we look at the indoor activities kids can help with like drawing, reading, cooking (not even baking just helping make dinner), DIY, housework, blanket forts, Lego, Meccano etc etc.

Without sounding rude, a year 7 isnt going to be into blanket forts or alot of the things suggested above. Maybe upto Year 3/4 at tops. We are out and about all the time, but im happy for my kids to use tech as everything is about balance. Lots of kids use tech instead of watching tv these days (and all of us 90’s kids loved our tv shows!). They will watch their favourite You Tubers instead of the programmes we put on after school (Grange Hill etc). We were still into screens it was just the tv instead of the tablets they have today.

Mama1980 · 04/02/2024 12:03

I support her 100% none of my children have a phone or access to social media. I have one in her twenties who got a phone when she was 19 and barely uses it to this day and a 15 year old, son who doesn't have one. Their social lives were always just fine. It's something I feel very strongly about.

ShoePalaver · 04/02/2024 11:59

Outthedoor24 · 04/02/2024 11:13

WTF stop and think that through.

Job at 16 but not allowed a phone to check the train times ?

It's verging on the the ridiculous that at 17 yo mother can't take her toddler to soft play as they need an Adult over 18 .

Guessing you're quite young! I had a job from 13 until 32 with no smart phone. I used to commute by train for 5 years pre smart phone. My dad still has no smart phone and commutes by train.

PaperDoIIs · 04/02/2024 11:59

Hereyoume · 04/02/2024 11:38

You cannot "check" your kids phones, whatever you may believe, absolutely anything can be hidden by using apps or file managers. I have an app on mine, a photo and message "vault". It looks and works exactly like a regular calculator, until I type in a specific series of numbers, then the app opens. There are literally hundreds of these types of app on the Play Store. So, all those parents who "check" their DC phone are wasting their time.

And "burner" phones are sold for £50 around here, the kids even joke about them they are so common. So all that life 360 and parental software stuff is pointless too. Lots of kids swap "burner deets" and some give their "real" handsets to friends who will hang out where the child is supposed to be, in case their parents have a location app, but the DC is actually somewhere completely different and using their burner.

Kids will ALWAYS find a way around.

If mobiles didn't exist, no iphones, no apps, nothing, and I invented one, with all the current social media and browsers pre installed, they would never allow me to sell it, citing child safety concerns, privacy, stalking potential, access to porn etc.

We have sleepwalked into a mass surveillance society, where "social credit" is now as real as your Experian score. A single 30 second TicTok clip can ruin your business, get you fired, make you unemployable, drive you to suicide.

I'm not sure what the answer is.

The point of supervision and checking isn't to bring the risk for everyone down to 0. That would never work, it doesn't work with anything else . The point of it is to be aware, have conversations with your kid, keep an eye on what's going and in reality to buy time for those lessons and conversations to sink in and their brains to mature some more. Simply by making it slightly more difficult, rather than at their fingertips will deter some kids(can't be arsed) or at least postpone it for a while.

All the runarounds you mention do involve planning and resources. Having the money,the friends who would be willing,the know how . They're not impossible to find, but it's not easily accessible on a whim either.

DD atm can't download anything on her phone without my permission because it's linked to my account and it requires the password every time . A password she doesn't know. I mean sure, she could have a friend willing and knowledgeable enough to have those apps and then transfer them to her phone. I'm open to that possibility, but in my opinion that's less of a risk than her having full access to anything and everything, or no access at all so having to hide ,lie and find all the runarounds.

Isitautumnyet23 · 04/02/2024 11:59

Butterfly44 · 04/02/2024 11:45

Murder is pretty rare at that age.

Not allowing access to certain apps compared to their friends breeds resentment. The best way is to build their own knowledge around safety, confidence and give them the ability to know right from wrong and to speak up.

Agree completely with this. If you deny them tech, they will be the kids at parties glued to tech as soon as they go to someone’s home or a sleepover. As you say, better to build up confidence of speaking up when something’s not right and knowing that they never give out personal information etc. Get them to stick to small Whats App groups with close friends and get to know friends parents. Make sure you have access to the phone and just keep on eye on what is being written.

I used to phone friends on the landline at the weekend - time and technology has moved on and they Whats App each other these days. Its making sure kids use it sensibly that matters.

Tatumm · 04/02/2024 11:56

Under 16s phones are unworkable as a solution. The social media companies need to be compelled by law to police their platforms more carefully.

Beryls · 04/02/2024 11:55

In the 90's it was violent video games and 'video nasties' that caused kids to hurt and murder eachother until research was done which showed otherwise. Think of the number of children who access the Internet who do NOT hurt or murder anybody. There's something wrong with the children who did this, same as there is with adults who murder people.

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:54

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 11:51

@LetsgoLego made me think that this was the first year I didn’t buy my eldest some Lego for their birthday. It’s trying to think of all the things that will distract the kids. Books and pencils in restaurants, rather than phones. It’s hard, very if the friendship circle is tech heavy. Thankfully my DCs (the eldest) isn’t tech heavy. I do worry about my youngest though, year 4. Her circle does use more tech. And I’m really monitoring this.

It's not difficult to be tech free. Parks are free, sports clubs and scouting/cadets are cost effective activities, gardening at home or community spaces is free too... That's before we look at the indoor activities kids can help with like drawing, reading, cooking (not even baking just helping make dinner), DIY, housework, blanket forts, Lego, Meccano etc etc.

wishmyhousetidy · 04/02/2024 11:53

Landlubber2019 · 04/02/2024 08:55

I agree and the social media sites need to be held to account. Teenagers and children will always seek a loophole so it needs to water tight.

I can open a bank account online, but not in someone else's name. The technology suggests it's available, but SM sites simply don't care enough about investing!

This is very true. The social media companies need to be held accountable and they just are not.
we tried to lock down social media sites and they just use friends phones or use VPN’s Parents can’t or don’t do it and it is up to social media sites to do it or be held accountable. Something that cannot be policed is damaging our children, sometimes permanently
Many probably the majority of teens have accounts that their parents are unaware of and parents that think their children are not accessing unsuitable sites I think are deluded. Teens experiment and strive to push boundaries and they are, well many of them are damaged by what they see

OhmygodDont · 04/02/2024 11:53

I agree the tech is creeping in younger and younger. When my now year 3 moved schools in year 1 within a couple of days she had been asked for her Roblox user and if she had a Fortnite account. That was certainly not an age I was expecting that at despite having two older children.

Moonpig82 · 04/02/2024 11:51

@LetsgoLego made me think that this was the first year I didn’t buy my eldest some Lego for their birthday. It’s trying to think of all the things that will distract the kids. Books and pencils in restaurants, rather than phones. It’s hard, very if the friendship circle is tech heavy. Thankfully my DCs (the eldest) isn’t tech heavy. I do worry about my youngest though, year 4. Her circle does use more tech. And I’m really monitoring this.

OP posts:
Isitautumnyet23 · 04/02/2024 11:51

I think it depends on the child - my Son is the same school year as yours and I dont mind Whats App as he uses it to chat away with friends, arrange things, share videos etc. I will give it a quick look once or twice a week. The only things I have seen that have been ‘bitchy’ have been from girls he is in a few groups with girls from his Primary. The boys are usually just talking about gaming, memes etc. He is a sensible boy, fantastic group of lovely friends, know all of the Mums too (of his Primary friends) so easy to pass on info if something wasn’t appropriate in the groups.

I think we can’t really talk about Brianna’s killers in the same way that we talk about our kids. From what I read, she was a deeply troubled girl, had been expelled from school, tried to poison kids etc. If I had a child like that, absolutely no chance they would have a phone and she should never have been allowed in a normal school.

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 04/02/2024 11:50

i think there needs to be a massive shift in accountability for parents around the use of devices and knowing what their children are up to and just generally forcing parents to stop being such wet fucking blankets about their kids tbh.

My mum and dad were hippyish ‘gentle’ parents when we were growing up and we were allowed a fair bit of ‘managed freedom’ - but they knew what we were up to and there were definite expectations around respecting them, the importance of being at home as a part of the family, communicating with family about our lives and there is no way they’d have allowed us to stare dead eyed into a device for hours and hours, plotting a murder. They knew my friends, they knew what I was looking at online and they had expectations about where was acceptable to go (including online!), what I was doing/thinking/who I was talking to. And it worked! Even now at 35 making my parents feel proud and doing the right thing is a source of motivation for me.

There seemed to have been SO many extremely serious red flags with Scarlett where this awful tragedy could have had a different outcome. She was devious and manipulative, and I think she will be diagnosed with ASPD in future but at the end of the day, she was a child and not a particularly bright one either. Hindsight is of course 20/20 but the adults should have stepped up - they failed horribly.

RIP Brianna 💐.

NotARealWookiie · 04/02/2024 11:50

Ah, I can see the too difficult light has come on for you very quickly.

As I said, it would need to have the attached legislation so yes it would be illegal to sell a phone to a child and technically enforceable by law. However of course in this country our laws basically police is by consent rather than police officers running around enforcing everything. I’ll compare it to smoking again, it’s illegal to sell cigarettes to children and the police are very unlikely to run around arresting people who let children touch cigarettes but broadly it works.

I do agree that hand me down phones are common but it wouldn’t take long for the under 16s phones to be available second hand in places like CEX and there could be a trade in scheme for old phones when they are introduced.

Given the impact of social media on phones on our children’s mental health, it’s worth considering rather than simply dismissing.

LetsgoLego · 04/02/2024 11:48

Butterfly44 · 04/02/2024 11:45

Murder is pretty rare at that age.

Not allowing access to certain apps compared to their friends breeds resentment. The best way is to build their own knowledge around safety, confidence and give them the ability to know right from wrong and to speak up.

But if their friendship group are all tech-lite there won't be a problem. If we switch the culture back to tech free it will help.

In positive news there is an upsurge in teens asking for dumb phones and social media trends to get out and touching grass so the tide is turning.