Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Food portions and how to laugh this off??

608 replies

PenisPortions · 04/02/2024 01:01

Help me dear mners, my dh is gaslighting me into accepting his penis portions and I need your stories of similar craziness to help me laugh it off..!

In laws came round, we had two large steaks for dinner. MIL wasn't keen on steak so we made her a stuffed pepper and sides so she was catered for and happy. FIL wanted half of one of the steaks, fine. Dh asked what I thought about that and I said yes fine we'll just share the rest. Dh looked confused for a bit and I said I think it's enough between the two of us to share the remainder.

FIL cooked the sides, DH bbqed the steaks (i was in with the baby), and I come out to see three plates of food. Two have half a steak on them and the third has a whole steak, which dh had claimed as his plate.

I was like ummm are you not splitting it? He said yes I did, and I kind of laughed in disbelief saying no you've given yourself twice the amount of food as me! He got really defensive, said this was what we agreed (not true), and got cross. I told him I was going to even things out, so cut off some of his, and he was so grumpy about it, saying he'd said he wanted a full one and I agreed to that. No "I'm sorry I misunderstood and under catered for you, let's split it like grown ups".

It is such a stupid little thing but keeps playing on my mind, what on earth was that?! Please tell me stories of similar imbalances that your partners have tried to get away with to help me put it into perspective.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
shearwater2 · 04/02/2024 10:40

RosesAndHellebores · 04/02/2024 10:33

It sounds as though you all have issues with food, sharing and table manners.

You should have had three steaks. Thank goodness MIL wanted a stuffed pepper. If Yr DH wanted a whole steak, why couldn't you and/or FIL have had steak and lamb chops to even it up.

I cannot bear the premise of counting food. You were both poor hosts.

If you turn up uninvited as a late addition you get what you are given. PIL were lucky that there was any food for them at all.

YireosDodeAver · 04/02/2024 10:39

Why laugh it off. Your DH was being selfish and greedy. If he wanted a whole streak to himself he should have gone out and bought more steaks.

When not breastfeeding the average woman does need fewer calories than an average man. If I eat the same as DH and we aren't actively trying to lose weight, i will put on weight and he stays the same weight. If we are actively trying to lose weight and eat the same he will lose weight twice as fast as me. So I have got used to giving myself approx 4/9ths or 3/7ths of any meal we are sharing so just giving him one more scoopful than me. Except for chocolate puddings which are strictly 50:50. And no way would he get twice as much as me. He needs about 200cal per day more, not double.

However it's not about penis portions but different metabolisms and I am sure there's some men with a metabolism more similar to mine. And when you are breastfeeding you need more anyway.

shearwater2 · 04/02/2024 10:38

Will people stop repeating the nonsense that by default men need more calories or protein? It entirely depends on the individual.

FrenchFancie · 04/02/2024 10:35

‘The way to a man’s heart is through his stomach’

preferably with a sharpe knife? (I’m joking and not advocating actual violence).

I have also noticed penis portions and my MIL is particularly guilty of this one. Drives me insane. DH is generally a good bloke but after years of getting first dibs at food as oldest son, he will unthinkingly take the biggest / best of everything unless it’s pointed out to him, and will comment if he doesn’t get this (like a bread bun had a bit missing and I put it on his plate randomly - he commented ‘oh I see you gave me the bad one’ - well someone has to have it and I don’t see why it has to automatically be me!!)

InASnowGlobeSpinning · 04/02/2024 10:34

Women don't 'resent men not being hungry' @Sweden99 - they resent the default assumption always being that they should be the one to sacrifice, make do, martyr themselves for other people, go without so men never have to. Society conditions girls from birth to 'be kind', to always consider other needs before their own and to step back so other people (men) can take what they want first. That isn't to say that all women actually are selfless, but that society holds that up as a model of proper femininity. It tells girls to make less of themselves, always. And that's a message we should counter by showing girls that it is ok to be assertive and to state what you want - it's ok to want things in the first place! That doesn't mean being selfish, it means not rolling over and letting other people be selfish. Women get an astonishing amount of pushback when they try this.

Calliopespa · 04/02/2024 10:34

RosesAndHellebores · 04/02/2024 10:33

It sounds as though you all have issues with food, sharing and table manners.

You should have had three steaks. Thank goodness MIL wanted a stuffed pepper. If Yr DH wanted a whole steak, why couldn't you and/or FIL have had steak and lamb chops to even it up.

I cannot bear the premise of counting food. You were both poor hosts.

Yeah it sounds a right scrabble.

RosesAndHellebores · 04/02/2024 10:33

It sounds as though you all have issues with food, sharing and table manners.

You should have had three steaks. Thank goodness MIL wanted a stuffed pepper. If Yr DH wanted a whole steak, why couldn't you and/or FIL have had steak and lamb chops to even it up.

I cannot bear the premise of counting food. You were both poor hosts.

Calliopespa · 04/02/2024 10:31

theduchessofspork · 04/02/2024 10:19

It doesn’t have to be fillet steak though does it?! He can have a tuna sarnie later.

Men’s calorie needs are not relevant to the stealing of fillet steak.

But the problem in this instance is there weren’t enough steaks without chopping them into bits. The obvious division was a whole plus two halves ( or four halves, but MIL obviated the need for that). Once you start chopping them into quarters it isn’t really steak anymore; it’s in the downward spiral towards mince!

QuestionableMouse · 04/02/2024 10:29

BronwenTheBrave · 04/02/2024 06:12

What a bastard. Lots of red flags here. Time to get your finances in order and consult a solicitor. It only gets worse from here. You deserve so much better than this.

Really?! Over 1/4 of a steak? 🤨

oakleaffy · 04/02/2024 10:27

Corondel · 04/02/2024 01:12

Why would you want to ‘laugh it off’? Who bought the meat and under-catered for the three people eating meat?

This.
Also- what does it have to do with penis size?
Daft to buy too little steak ( or whatever) when feeding others .

Sweden99 · 04/02/2024 10:25

As a young man, I would typically eat cheaper alternatives to my girlfriend. I could buy lots of small sausages for the price of a small steak. I got the food I needed. Of course, that is not always possible and then it is difficult.

Codlingmoths · 04/02/2024 10:24

I didn’t know about the protein need myself but Dh cooked me all the steak as my iron was terrible post birth several times. It’s hard to recover from the birth with iron at rock bottom and it’s hard to boost the iron levels with a baby sucking it out of you. Steak for me, all the steaks, with spinach and broccoli chased with some OJ.

Codlingmoths · 04/02/2024 10:22

Here are protein needs per day of the average man and breastfeeding women. Please memorise this so you never again wade into an argument claiming of course
he needs double the steak you do he’s a MAN. Your women friends will love you for
it if they are at the pregnant and breastfeeding stage.

Food  portions and how to laugh this off??
OrangeMarmaladeOnToast · 04/02/2024 10:22

Calliopespa · 04/02/2024 10:18

It annoys me when men do this and claim they should have the bigger portion, but when a ( similarly annoyed) friend and I looked into it, male bodies definitely need more calories so I guess there’s a certain logic to it.
If it’s something like a few chocolate truffles to be shared I think it’s still unreasonable but actually in the steak instance it is probably hard to make a scientific case ( though breastfeeding might change it).

Steak is in fact one of the easiest foods to make a scientific case in favour of the woman having more, because women need more iron than men. Look into more than just calories, if this is the approach you're taking.

eurochick · 04/02/2024 10:21

@alittleprivacy the recommended calorie intake is 2000 for women and 2500 for men. Breastfeeding adds 500. So they both needed to eat the same in this case.

FluffyFanny · 04/02/2024 10:20

Bloody hell!

Fillet steaks are never that big- they really only vary by thickness.

In my house I'd have let Dh have a whole one rather than faffing about trying to divvy up 3/4 of a steak- because it's not that big a deal, DH is bigger and always eats more than me at every meal, and I am generous and nice.

Actually though, it probably wouldn't have happened that way though because my FIL would never have accepted half of a fillet steal knowing there was meant to be a fillet steak each for DH and I, because he has far more manners than that and he would have had the lamb chops.

Codlingmoths · 04/02/2024 10:20

alittleprivacy · 04/02/2024 10:03

  1. I said he was a dick in this instance.
  2. Men have a higher need for protein, so unless that bread and butter was 75% butter, then no. That wouldn't have done the trick really.

The op is breastfeeding. Did you think about this for a minute before spouting men deserve all the good stuff? I googled, I didn’t even have to click. Ignore the bullshti about assigned male at birth. Men need less protein per day than breastfeeding women. Men have no practice in not assuming they need more of anything they want and women like you feed into that immense self-centredness. He should have given the
op the whole steak and shared one with his dad.

Sweden99 · 04/02/2024 10:20

InASnowGlobeSpinning · 04/02/2024 10:13

He could have added cheese to the bread and butter - but the point is here, as in all the penis portion threads, he wanted more of the best bit. That's always the case in penis portion threads - that women are left hungry at the expense of filling men up. The men are never expected to put up with being a bit hungry or - shock horror - filling up on carbs for once rather than expensive protein.

Women who come on and complain about penis portions don't mean they got given an appropriate amount of food in comparison to their male partners; they mean they got given something inadequate on the basis that they're a woman and should put up with being hungry or given something less satisfying. There's a pattern of giving men the best stuff, not just bigger portions. But always posters will jump on saying men need more calories, ignoring that it isn't only about number of calories on the plate. When people here mock penis portions (that phrase has started to grate now I've typed it four times!) they are mocking the idea that men deserve better than women, rather than the idea that men need a bit more than women. Talking about respective calorie requirements misses the point.

For all the women who think men should have the best cuts, there are many more who resent men not being hungry. And selfishness is universal.

theduchessofspork · 04/02/2024 10:19

alittleprivacy · 04/02/2024 10:03

  1. I said he was a dick in this instance.
  2. Men have a higher need for protein, so unless that bread and butter was 75% butter, then no. That wouldn't have done the trick really.

It doesn’t have to be fillet steak though does it?! He can have a tuna sarnie later.

Men’s calorie needs are not relevant to the stealing of fillet steak.

Calliopespa · 04/02/2024 10:18

TimeForTeaAndG · 04/02/2024 01:14

Penis portions are where the man is automatically allowed to have more food purely because he's a man.

It annoys me when men do this and claim they should have the bigger portion, but when a ( similarly annoyed) friend and I looked into it, male bodies definitely need more calories so I guess there’s a certain logic to it.
If it’s something like a few chocolate truffles to be shared I think it’s still unreasonable but actually in the steak instance it is probably hard to make a scientific case ( though breastfeeding might change it).

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/02/2024 10:18

Marchintospring · 04/02/2024 10:15

The way to a mans heart is through his stomach.

@Marchintospring

you are so right

op shouldn’t have had any of the steak she should have let her husband have it all to make him happy as a man

therealcookiemonster · 04/02/2024 10:18

Marchintospring · 04/02/2024 10:15

The way to a mans heart is through his stomach.

having spent quite a lot of time studying the anatomy of the area. I can confidently tell you this is not the case. the way to a man's heart is usually through the neck or the groin, or by cracking open his chest.

Marchintospring · 04/02/2024 10:15

The way to a mans heart is through his stomach.

InASnowGlobeSpinning · 04/02/2024 10:13

alittleprivacy · 04/02/2024 10:03

  1. I said he was a dick in this instance.
  2. Men have a higher need for protein, so unless that bread and butter was 75% butter, then no. That wouldn't have done the trick really.

He could have added cheese to the bread and butter - but the point is here, as in all the penis portion threads, he wanted more of the best bit. That's always the case in penis portion threads - that women are left hungry at the expense of filling men up. The men are never expected to put up with being a bit hungry or - shock horror - filling up on carbs for once rather than expensive protein.

Women who come on and complain about penis portions don't mean they got given an appropriate amount of food in comparison to their male partners; they mean they got given something inadequate on the basis that they're a woman and should put up with being hungry or given something less satisfying. There's a pattern of giving men the best stuff, not just bigger portions. But always posters will jump on saying men need more calories, ignoring that it isn't only about number of calories on the plate. When people here mock penis portions (that phrase has started to grate now I've typed it four times!) they are mocking the idea that men deserve better than women, rather than the idea that men need a bit more than women. Talking about respective calorie requirements misses the point.

SurvivingTheSeasons · 04/02/2024 10:12

Really selfish. When my DC were under 1 and I was breastfeeding, DH would always make sure I got the bigger portion if in a situation like that. If I'd mentioned splitting it equally he wouldn't have any of it. Now he'd split it without asking.

Swipe left for the next trending thread