Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Safari parks in Britain,

68 replies

isitoknottohaveaname · 03/02/2024 21:28

Is it ok to breed animals in zoos/safari parks, like lions,/pandas/ penguins etc which are now forced to live in vastly different environments that they've evolved to live in? Are we helping them survive extinction or are we keeping them here for our entrainment?

OP posts:
RunningFromInsanity · 03/02/2024 23:18

It’s a balancing act.
No one is going to a zoo to see a tiny obscure frog species that is on the brink of extinction.
People are going to the zoo to see the baby giraffe. The entrance fee and money they pay to see that baby giraffe funds vital programmes to save the frog and other endangered species.

They need the cute baby animals to draw in the customers to raise the money.

But do look at the Aspinall foundation and the huge impact they are having on reintroducing Gorillas.
Damian Aspinall’s slogan is ‘it’s too late to rewind but together we can rewild’

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/02/2024 23:11

The animals seem to have a pretty good life there too - lots more space than in many other zoos because of the location

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/02/2024 23:10

I’m not an expert, but when I go to Whipsnade zoo they seem to do really good work. Alot of great conservation work, including helping to save endangered species from extinction.

isitoknottohaveaname · 03/02/2024 23:05

MandyMotherOfBrian · 03/02/2024 22:53

Depends on the zoo. They may be part of the various international breeding programs, and some of those will be returnees to the wild, or they might not be and they’ll be destined to forever spend their lives in captivity. But being part of the breeding programs doesn’t guarantee success or even competence if Knowsley and the experience with the Amur Tigeress is anything to go by. It’s true that The Aspinall Foundation breed to return to the wild (in fact their intention is to rewild as many animals as possible if they are in any way suitable) but honestly, unsure what the point is if the reason they’re endangered in their natural habitat is all down to human activities and that hasn’t changed. Half of the first group of gorillas from Howletts were killed once they were rewilded to Gabon, might have been humans or might have been that animals raised in captivity simply cannot survive in the wild. Or, like the Langurs (amongst many other animals there), they’ll be going back to an increasingly small, extensively managed, area in their native habitat - simply to keep them safe, but it’s hardly natural. Rewilding the elephant family to Kenya is constantly being rescheduled for various reasons and there isn’t any guarantee they’ll be safe once there. If the original habitats of these animals no longer exists or are now too dangerous for them to survive naturally, then what’s the point?
Yes, we’re keeping them alive for us, vanity conservation.

Edited

Thank you so much for explaining. It's really helpful 😍

OP posts:
thistimelastweek · 03/02/2024 22:58

Zwellers · 03/02/2024 22:53

thistimelastweek so every animal in captivity lives in misery. Seriously.

It's living unnaturally.

It's just existing.

So what's the point?

The point has to be about us, not them.

isitoknottohaveaname · 03/02/2024 22:54

thistimelastweek · 03/02/2024 22:51

OP, I completely get what you are saying.

What's the justification for the unnatural imprisonment of a few poor creatures?

A breeding programme for what? Reintroduction into a wild that doesn't support them naturally? Cos we've already fucked that up for them.

Our entertainment? Obviously not OK

Our education? These days we've got sophisticated ways of achieving that without torturing live animals.

Is it really OK to keep a species alive at the expense of the misery of an individual animal?

I agree. I'm thinking about cows. They're only here so we can use them

OP posts:
Zwellers · 03/02/2024 22:53

thistimelastweek so every animal in captivity lives in misery. Seriously.

MandyMotherOfBrian · 03/02/2024 22:53

Depends on the zoo. They may be part of the various international breeding programs, and some of those will be returnees to the wild, or they might not be and they’ll be destined to forever spend their lives in captivity. But being part of the breeding programs doesn’t guarantee success or even competence if Knowsley and the experience with the Amur Tigeress is anything to go by. It’s true that The Aspinall Foundation breed to return to the wild (in fact their intention is to rewild as many animals as possible if they are in any way suitable) but honestly, unsure what the point is if the reason they’re endangered in their natural habitat is all down to human activities and that hasn’t changed. Half of the first group of gorillas from Howletts were killed once they were rewilded to Gabon, might have been humans or might have been that animals raised in captivity simply cannot survive in the wild. Or, like the Langurs (amongst many other animals there), they’ll be going back to an increasingly small, extensively managed, area in their native habitat - simply to keep them safe, but it’s hardly natural. Rewilding the elephant family to Kenya is constantly being rescheduled for various reasons and there isn’t any guarantee they’ll be safe once there. If the original habitats of these animals no longer exists or are now too dangerous for them to survive naturally, then what’s the point?
Yes, we’re keeping them alive for us, vanity conservation.

thistimelastweek · 03/02/2024 22:51

OP, I completely get what you are saying.

What's the justification for the unnatural imprisonment of a few poor creatures?

A breeding programme for what? Reintroduction into a wild that doesn't support them naturally? Cos we've already fucked that up for them.

Our entertainment? Obviously not OK

Our education? These days we've got sophisticated ways of achieving that without torturing live animals.

Is it really OK to keep a species alive at the expense of the misery of an individual animal?

hellsBells246 · 03/02/2024 22:50

Animals, not animate 🙄

hellsBells246 · 03/02/2024 22:50

@isitoknottohaveaname - So why can't we breed from them and send them on their way

Well, think about it. Why are some animate in trouble? Because their habitat is endangered - humans encroaching on it, rainforest being cut down, poachers.

So where would you release an elephant or rhino?

Honestly, op, if you really wanted to, you could Google this stuff and not just ask randoms on here.

Look at www.whipsnadezoo.org/conservation for some inspo!

Zwellers · 03/02/2024 22:50

Op just bw honest here if you are anti zoo . the majority of animals you see in zoos have been captive bred for generations. Good zoos act to preserve animals through breeding programmes like Durrell with pink pigeons, Madagascar pochard and lion tamarin or Chester with javan green magpie. Not all animals will go back to the wild but without zoos the california condor, Arabian oryx or per davids deer would have been lost. Would you rather they just went extinct due to your ignorance. Also remember animals don't think like us. A hippo in a zoo doesn't remember africa. But whatever anyone says I suspect you will just say I don't like zoos they are wrong. If that's what you believe fine. But don't say breeding in zoos doesn't work . That just not true.

isitoknottohaveaname · 03/02/2024 22:49

ThursdayTomorrow · 03/02/2024 22:43

I really feel sorry for all those animals in zoos and safari parks. Born purely for humans to gawp at. I completely disagree that seeing an animal in person is needed to fuel a passion for conservation.

I agree, this is the point I'm trying to make

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 03/02/2024 22:47

hoarahloux · 03/02/2024 21:46

They're not, though? Chester Zoo does fantastic work with breeding programs to eventually release animals back to the wild both in the UK and abroad. Most accredited zoos have this kind of breeding program. Where are you getting your information from?

And so does Yorkshire Wildlife Park. They also rescue animals in captivity that are kept in horrific conditions.

https://www.yorkshirewildlifepark.com/lion-rescue-2/

Lion Rescue 2 | Yorkshire Wildlife Park

A race against time to save four Ukrainian Lions

https://www.yorkshirewildlifepark.com/lion-rescue-2

hellsBells246 · 03/02/2024 22:45

ThursdayTomorrow · 03/02/2024 22:43

I really feel sorry for all those animals in zoos and safari parks. Born purely for humans to gawp at. I completely disagree that seeing an animal in person is needed to fuel a passion for conservation.

These days safari parks have areas where animals can go to be off show.

carerneedshelp · 03/02/2024 22:44

isitoknottohaveaname · 03/02/2024 22:27

I honestly believe that animals like hippos and giraffes shouldn't be stuck in horrible enclosures thousands of miles away from their natural habitat just so they can breed more poor babies to keep tourists happy

What do you define as a horrible enclosure though?
Animals in Zoos and safari parks in the UK generally have a decent amount of space. Food readily available and world class veterinary care. They do not have a constant threat of predators either.
No they don't have the infinite amount of space they would in the wild but frankly they do have a much better standard of living than their wild cousins. And please note that most wild animals travel such vast areas for food and water not for pleasure.
Animals in zoos usually live significantly longer than their wild cousins

hellsBells246 · 03/02/2024 22:44

isitoknottohaveaname · 03/02/2024 21:36

I've always gone along with zoos are doing conservation work etc but how? Breeding hardly ever works

Of course it does. Lots of zoos are very successful at breeding certain animals, and these animals then go to other zoos to improve breeding populations across Europe. Some animals are easier to breed than others, of course.

ThursdayTomorrow · 03/02/2024 22:43

I really feel sorry for all those animals in zoos and safari parks. Born purely for humans to gawp at. I completely disagree that seeing an animal in person is needed to fuel a passion for conservation.

XenoBitch · 03/02/2024 22:37

isitoknottohaveaname · 03/02/2024 22:27

I honestly believe that animals like hippos and giraffes shouldn't be stuck in horrible enclosures thousands of miles away from their natural habitat just so they can breed more poor babies to keep tourists happy

I don't think any animal in a zoo has been taken from the wild. They are usually bred in captivity or rescued from elsewhere (circus or pets).

I have not been to a zoo in years (last time was Durrell in Jersey, and a lot of their resident animals are endangered in the wild anyway).

I think it is important that the general public can see these animals in person. to do so fuels passion for the next generation of conservationists that will be breeding and helping more animals.

TurnLeftAtTheRoundabout · 03/02/2024 22:35

So I heard in a podcast recently two things.

  1. some animals are being replaced by robot animals in zoos. I cannot find the article they were referring to but have a quick Google and you can see it might become a thing. People can experience the animals in a realistic way, without the animals being captive.

  2. More of a sidenote, but on the protecting animals front... In America, there is a massive poaching problem. So they started using robot animals to catch the poachers. The problem is, that the animals had to be more and more realistic each time. So one guy developed a deer that lifted its tail and passed brown m and ms to appear more realistic! This is from 2016: https://www.nrdc.org/stories/nab-poachers-government-turning-dead-animals-robots

To Nab Poachers, the Government Is Turning Dead Animals into Robots

Some of the taxidermied wildlife even poop M&Ms....

https://www.nrdc.org/stories/nab-poachers-government-turning-dead-animals-robots

isitoknottohaveaname · 03/02/2024 22:31

Are we keeping these animals alive for us?

OP posts:
LocalHobo · 03/02/2024 22:30

Zoo's definitely can help to avoid extinction. The international scheme for Tasmanian Devils is a good example of this.

isitoknottohaveaname · 03/02/2024 22:27

I honestly believe that animals like hippos and giraffes shouldn't be stuck in horrible enclosures thousands of miles away from their natural habitat just so they can breed more poor babies to keep tourists happy

OP posts:
Ducksinthebath · 03/02/2024 22:21

But if they’re being born here won’t they adapt to an extent?

My friend’s parents are from an equatorial country. She was born here and spends the whole summer indoors with the curtains drawn and the fan on high.

(yes, I know people aren’t animals)

Swipe left for the next trending thread