Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GP surgery sent letter to deter us book appointment for toddler

239 replies

Watapain · 03/02/2024 15:24

Today we received letter from Surgery saying that we have booked several appointments in the last month for our toddler who has been sick often and has got a recurring issue needing doctors attention. We should consider other alternatives and not see the GP.
This has really concerned us as me and DH never see the GP. I am fuming as they have sent a form asking us to sign an undertaking that we acknowledge the letter. We are not happy about it and to sign the letter.
Have you been through anything similar and how do we approach about complaining about it as the tone on it seems threatening that they are looking to remove people from their list.

OP posts:
Clevesian · 03/02/2024 19:21

Hi, I work for the NHS. Completely understand how worrying this must be for you.

You could try your MP, CQC, Healthwatch - but as others have said, perhaps the best start would be letter to Practice Manager setting out your concerns and requesting a response. I’d suggest copying it to your local Integrated Care Board (ICB, they replaced Clinical Commissioning Groups).

PALS (patient advice and liaison service) is an health trust (hospital etc) thing. Your practice may have a PPG (patient participation group), but I’d still suggest first approach as above.

Disclaimer: acronyms and organisations correct at time of writing. Give the NHS six months and it’ll probably have changed. Again. And this is part of the problem!

Hope it gets sorted for you.

LauderSyme · 03/02/2024 19:17

LauderSyme · 03/02/2024 19:10

I have been told (by people who work as GPs at different practices) that a high percentage of the patients they see every day are the worried well.

So there definitely are people out there who happily use resources they don't need and thereby make it harder for those who do need them to access them.

Am not saying at all that OP falls into this category.

Mind you I didn't quiz them about their failure to diagnose rate. Maybe they only thought their patients were the worried well because they failed to actually diagnose what was wrong with them!

That also seems to happen a lot with GPs if anecdotal evidence is to be believed.

DodoTired · 03/02/2024 19:14

socialdilemmawhattodo · 03/02/2024 19:00

I had a work colleague who would rush their pfb to A&E for every sniffle. My Doctor had a watch and wait approach which I grew, as a new parent, to really appreciate. I knew the surgery was there if I really needed them if DC deteriorated. But otherwise I needed to be patient. It was helpful as I grew into new parenting. For pre-schoolers there are normally midwives or community nurses - perhaps your surgery feel those are better 1st options.

Im not sure where you live?
midwives discharge babies after 28 days post birth, they certainly do not work with preschoolers.
we don’t have any “community nurses” either (im in London)

CHRIS003 · 03/02/2024 19:11

TigerRag · 03/02/2024 18:55

What other help? I've got numerous long term health issues and there are long waits to see consultants.

Multiple appointments for same thing.
Diabetes review
This is what would have happened 20 yrs ago :

One appointment with diabetes nurse or practice nurse
They would do bloods
Blood pressure
Foot check
Dietary advice
Weight check etc
Medication
Appointments 2 ( one to get blood results and medication review )

Diabetes review in 2023
Support worker
Takes blood pressure
Foot check
Bloods
Phone appointment for blood results with support worker
Support worker refers to gp to check results
Pharmacist calls to check medication
Phone appointment with Diabetes nurse
Diabetes nurse doesn't give diet advice referes to a Support group run by another provider or a virtual support group
Appointments 5
Several more if you count the sessions of the support group!

Far more appointments needed now for one annual checkup than 20 years ago

Hakunatomato · 03/02/2024 19:10

Sending a letter like they did may not have been pleasant to receive, but it is doubtful that a complaint would very far. It would not be considered serious professional misconduct. At the very best, the health authority may ask the practice to review sending out this type of letter, but they have sent it within medical practice guidelines. You would be best to go to another GP to register.

LauderSyme · 03/02/2024 19:10

I have been told (by people who work as GPs at different practices) that a high percentage of the patients they see every day are the worried well.

So there definitely are people out there who happily use resources they don't need and thereby make it harder for those who do need them to access them.

Am not saying at all that OP falls into this category.

VaccineSticker · 03/02/2024 19:08

It’s rather condescending when practice managers or the nhs like to inform you about the different services one can try before hearing off to the GP as if we haven’t already tried everything alread…and the fact that they think that we ALL LOVE the hassle of waiting on the phone at 8am to beg for an appointment so we can hang out at the doctor’s surgery for half a day.…or the fact that we ALL love hanging out at A&E for 6+ hours with a poorly loved one that’s not been seen by a doc because they can’t give us an appointment. sigh…

Complain OP!

Paw2024 · 03/02/2024 19:06

I've been to the GP 4 times in a month and needed seeing and there were no other options

1 - UTI, given antibiotics
2 - UTI, not resolved, antibiotics extended
3 - UTI still there, given different antibiotics
4 - allergic reaction to the second lot of antibiotics

Hakunatomato · 03/02/2024 19:05

Your GP practice are actually allowed to remove you from their list without giving a reason, the same way you can go and register elsewhere without giving reason or notice. Your health authority has an obligation to provide you with a GP, which they will do.

Isthisexpected · 03/02/2024 19:02

PegasusReturns · 03/02/2024 15:37

I would write back stating that you were alarmed to receive their letter and ask them to clarify which of the appointments they feel were unnecessary.

I would do this and also forward to my MP, CQC and Healthwatch. Disgraceful.

OnceAgainAgain · 03/02/2024 19:02

Hi OP,

Before you go to the CQC and HealthWatch, it would be a good idea to contact the practice manager and talk it though with him/her first. It's almost certainly a computer error. If you ask about it they can just bin it and let you get on with your life.

Ilikedoughnuts · 03/02/2024 19:01

@ToHellBackAndBeyondBeyond inappropriate. If a child or even adult needs medical attention, they need to see a medically trained professional. I would ask for a referral to whichever specialist is required and make a complaint.

Sorry @ToHellBackAndBeyond , unsure why it tagged you and I can't figure out how to remove it

Datafan55 · 03/02/2024 19:01

TigerRag · 03/02/2024 18:55

What other help? I've got numerous long term health issues and there are long waits to see consultants.

I mean eg if a patient has a pattern of symptoms that put together might indicate a specific problem or source of help that the patient is unaware of. For example if you keep getting chest pains and asthma attacks, a referral for pulmonary rehab can be a good call (took an asthma nurse to suggest it for me, but it helped).

--
(If you're waiting to see consultants and need a GP appt in the meantime, that can't be avoided).

Bunnycat101 · 03/02/2024 19:00

I have had periods with both my children when they have been at the gp extremely often and then months with nothing. It’s entirely possible that people are very frequent users during periods of acute illness because they then end up going down with something else.

example 1: child saw gp day 1, admitted to hospital with an infection, saw gp a few days after she was home as still poorly and again a few days later when she was dehydrated after vomiting for 10 days straight on the antibiotics. Same child then got bronchiolitis 2 weeks later plus a secondary lung infection. A few more gp visits and another admission to hospital. We were probably at 5/6 gp visits within 6 weeks.

example 2 - child v bad vomiting bug and dehydrated. Gp saw and then asked to see them again that afternoon and the morning after as child was borderline for admission. 2 weeks later, very similar thing happened again with another 2 visits and borderline admission. So 5 in a month. Both times she’d have most likely been admitted if we’d just gone to a&e and weren’t under the supervision of a Dr in primary care doing fluid diaries.

Both of those periods were hideous to be frank but our frequent gp use was entirely appropriate. Thankfully neither have needed to be seen for at least 18 months and hoping that continues!

socialdilemmawhattodo · 03/02/2024 19:00

I had a work colleague who would rush their pfb to A&E for every sniffle. My Doctor had a watch and wait approach which I grew, as a new parent, to really appreciate. I knew the surgery was there if I really needed them if DC deteriorated. But otherwise I needed to be patient. It was helpful as I grew into new parenting. For pre-schoolers there are normally midwives or community nurses - perhaps your surgery feel those are better 1st options.

sexnotgenders · 03/02/2024 18:59

Densol57 · 03/02/2024 17:37

OP - answer the question people are asking
was he prescribed antibiotics 4 times ?

Erm, I think you (and quite a few others) have gotten rather over invested in this one. Demanding the OP answer your question is a bit crazy. We can all post whatever we want, but she doesn't owe you anything.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 03/02/2024 18:56

It sounds dangerous to send such letters to parents of children, in particular toddlers.

CHRIS003 · 03/02/2024 18:55

PissOffCancer · 03/02/2024 15:36

Computers only generate what they’ve been programmed to generate. Did the computer also put the letter in an envelope, stick a stamp on it or frank it, then put it in the mail bag?

Standardised computer generated letter !!
Don't blame the computer system - the computer system needs reviewing if is sending out letters to genuine cases - if a child needs antibiotics on each occasion then there is a genuine reason for them to visit the GP !!
As a manager it is surely up to you to make sure the software being used is fit for purpose and if it isn't then it needs to be redesigned - this is part of the issue with problem with our NHS.
I recently had to cancel an appointment sent out for a national screening programme because I am already under consultant review yearly and already have the screening done by them. Their reply said thankyou for informing us.
The screening programme computer system doesn't know about people who are ready under a consultant for the same problem. I took time to cancel my appointment so it could be given to someone else ,not everyone will do this - so how many appointments slots are lost this way? It surely wouldn't take much effort for a consultants admin team to contact the national screening programme with a list of patients that don't need an appointment would it ?

TigerRag · 03/02/2024 18:55

Datafan55 · 03/02/2024 18:39

OP is getting a bit of a rough time from some posters. It doesn't matter if the child needed four sets of antibiotics - you can occasionally end up with multiple appointments for one issue.

Lots of opinions re computer generated letters that I agree with. To add - GP surgeries should be looking at people repeatedly coming eg in a year .... To discourage those who misuse the system, to maybe see a trend for a long term issue (and help them with that!!), even to point to CBT for health anxiety... But an automatic letter for four appts in a month is stupid. Like OP said, it has worried them.

Edited

What other help? I've got numerous long term health issues and there are long waits to see consultants.

Verbena17 · 03/02/2024 18:52

You would think any doctor of any worth would see a child however many times the parents brought them in (assuming there’s nothing like FDIA involved).

I’d say 4 times in a month with meds prescribed for a recurring illness for which the child had been previously hospitalised, doesn’t warrant any letter of that kind!

Mycatsarethebest · 03/02/2024 18:50

Watapain · 03/02/2024 16:30

I will be contacting cqc and local healthwarch

How about actually asking for an appointment to speak to the practice manager and expressing your feelings about this? You can then see what they have to say about it and you may be able to come to some resolution with them about the way forward? Surely this is a practical solution as opposed to firing it up when it may not be necessary?

commonsense61 · 03/02/2024 18:50

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

NotQuiteHere · 03/02/2024 18:48

Densol57 · 03/02/2024 17:37

OP - answer the question people are asking
was he prescribed antibiotics 4 times ?

Does it really matter?
A visit to GP cannot be justified unless somebody needs antibiotics?
I don't think a pregnant mother of a toddler would like to go to see her GP just for fun.

TheBayLady · 03/02/2024 18:45

That is shocking. I know some people book appointments for the most ridiculous things but to send such a letter to parents of a toddler that has been admitted to hospital is shocking. And the excuse of a computer generated letter is a cop out.

Bubble2024 · 03/02/2024 18:42

StarlightLime · 03/02/2024 17:13

He didn't need antibiotics on a weekly basis 🤔

Exactly So what were they other appointments?