Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GP surgery sent letter to deter us book appointment for toddler

239 replies

Watapain · 03/02/2024 15:24

Today we received letter from Surgery saying that we have booked several appointments in the last month for our toddler who has been sick often and has got a recurring issue needing doctors attention. We should consider other alternatives and not see the GP.
This has really concerned us as me and DH never see the GP. I am fuming as they have sent a form asking us to sign an undertaking that we acknowledge the letter. We are not happy about it and to sign the letter.
Have you been through anything similar and how do we approach about complaining about it as the tone on it seems threatening that they are looking to remove people from their list.

OP posts:
Motherbear44 · 03/02/2024 20:13

PegasusReturns · 03/02/2024 15:37

I would write back stating that you were alarmed to receive their letter and ask them to clarify which of the appointments they feel were unnecessary.

Absolutely this. You need to find out if you genuinely are on the naughty step - and if not, clarified.

Bestyearever2024 · 03/02/2024 20:13

Watapain · 03/02/2024 16:30

I will be contacting cqc and local healthwarch

Absolutely.

I'd also send it to my MP and my local newspaper and 'chat' Facebook group

Utterly shocking

Jakadaal · 03/02/2024 20:09

pam290358 · 03/02/2024 19:49

I’m sorry but this is jut another example of the way in which government is pushing us toward private health care. GP surgeries are private businesses and as such they can throw you off their lists for whatever reason they want. If you’re too expensive as a patient you’re not viable. Suck it up or don’t vote Tory.

They are basically private businesses but are also independent contractors working to an NHS contract. If they remove patients it can be challenged and the practice has to
show robust evidence as to why they have removed patient. The first line of their contract is ' to provide services
To those who are or believe themselves to be ill'

Sapphire387 · 03/02/2024 20:07

I think this is awful.

As a comparison, I have suffered on and off with my mental health and health anxiety in general since I lost my elder two kids' dad a few years ago.

I know for a fact that across the top of my record at my GP surgery it says to always offer me a face to face same day appointment if I ask for one. This being because they know me, knew my late partner, know the kids... they treat my family as whole people. The GP's at my surgery are really kind.

They absolutely should not be discouraging you from accessing medical help for your child, that's out of order.

lV12 · 03/02/2024 20:07

The sheer number of times I’ve been dismissed by GPs
I hear the same from my friends, family, colleagues etc
Smart people, articulate people who have to shout to get anywhere
My heart breaks for those who aren’t as privileged
The healthcare system is a disgrace, on its knees, and leadership is absent

JinglePringle · 03/02/2024 20:07

elliejjtiny · 03/02/2024 20:02

The problem with this type of letter, and the attendance ones from school, is that the people who the letter is aimed at won't care and will just carry on but the people who get sent one because they genuinely are ill a lot will be upset.

You are totally right. This is the exact problem with these types of letters. I got the attendance one after DD had chickenpox, they literally wouldn't let me send her in but then I get a letter because her attendance is low, I was upset by it because there was nothing I could do.

OP take this as far as possible it is disgraceful, definitely shouldn't be sent to parents of young children it could deter them from seeking help when it is needed.

Jakadaal · 03/02/2024 20:06

What a ridiculous approach from your GP surgery. Ask to speak to the Practice Manager in the first instance and ask their rationale for this approach. It could simply be that they have done a basic data search and sent out blanket letters to those who have come out of the search for x number of appointments etc. I would also second your approach to contacting Healthwatch and ICB ( am ex primary care commissions manger/practice manager so that would be my approach)

elliejjtiny · 03/02/2024 20:02

The problem with this type of letter, and the attendance ones from school, is that the people who the letter is aimed at won't care and will just carry on but the people who get sent one because they genuinely are ill a lot will be upset.

Watapain · 03/02/2024 20:00

It's so disgraceful and I had so much respect for NHS all this time but now I feel disgust about the desperate approach they are taking to deter people from using services. I still respect all the hardwork of doctors and nurses but the leadership and direction it's going in is worrying.

OP posts:
lV12 · 03/02/2024 19:59

MumblesParty perhaps gp practices should realise this is going to create extra work for themselves and not deter patients in the first place. Mind actually boggles.

OP, pls contact CQC, health watch and your MP. GP surgeries need to understand they cannot do this, even if it means creating extra work. It’s called protecting patient safety.

Watapain · 03/02/2024 19:57

Also, not to mention about the recent Post office debacle and how people were wrongfully blamed and prosecuted, let's not forget that.

OP posts:
VWT5 · 03/02/2024 19:56

I would also suggest mentioning this to your Health Visitor, possibly let your midwife know too.

Watapain · 03/02/2024 19:56

Thanks for the helpful responses. I am thinking of taking it to the local healthwatch, CQC and potentially MP. Me and DH never use the service. My DH hasn't been to GP for years. I am really appalled by this letter and their approach to deter people. It's not just about me, I feel concerned for other children and parents who may lose confidence because of such a letter and if something happens to the child who'll be responsible for that. I have paid taxes all my life and I am so appalled by this is what I get in return. Also, I use to work for NHS myself, so contributed fair share to NHS.

OP posts:
pam290358 · 03/02/2024 19:49

I’m sorry but this is jut another example of the way in which government is pushing us toward private health care. GP surgeries are private businesses and as such they can throw you off their lists for whatever reason they want. If you’re too expensive as a patient you’re not viable. Suck it up or don’t vote Tory.

3luckystars · 03/02/2024 19:49

OMG i have seen it all now, that’s disgraceful!!!!!!

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2024 19:45

Watapain · 03/02/2024 15:29

4 times in a month. DC needed antibiotics

Make a complaint OP. that’s appalling.

MumblesParty · 03/02/2024 19:44

I’ve been a GP for over 25 years.
In that time, I’ve seen it become much harder to get appointments. One reason for this is the expanding (particularly elderly) population.
Another reason is the vast increase in bureaucracy. Most GPs will now have at least one admin session per week, simply to deal with bureaucracy, such as audits, complaints, CQC, various NHS-mandated schemes etc. The list is endless.
So people should think very carefully before they involve MP, CQC, NHSE etc. Because in the time it takes for a GP to deal with just one such complaint, they could see 20-50 patients.

Something like OP’s issue could be resolved by a quick chat with the practice manager.

Butterandtoast · 03/02/2024 19:43

Completely understandable that people need to go to the gp more frequently as you're only allowed to talk about 1 problem per appointment. They can't have it both ways!

Regarding op, I would personally go into the surgery and ask to speak to someone about it. I'm assuming you don't take your toddler there frequently in normal circumstances so they need to realise its inappropriate to basically threaten you when your child has been ill over a month.

Twilight7777 · 03/02/2024 19:41

Not only would I not sign the letter, I’d be forwarding the letter to the practice manager and asking them to explain which of the appointments were unnecessary and what were you meant to do instead, and if your child is one with chronic conditions, I’d be asking exactly which specialists they’d like to refer you to as apparently the gp isn’t appropriate. If I didn’t get a decent response from that, I’d be going to the NMC and PALS.

MixedCouple · 03/02/2024 19:41

My Mum had a text to say something similar. But she has long term health issues which require attendance to Nurses and Doctors every month. So she just ignored it.

I would call and ask to speak to the Practice Manager or email them and explain your childs needs. Do they expect you to go to A&E???

Fam23 · 03/02/2024 19:35

Boopeedoop · 03/02/2024 15:30

I would be forwarding a copy to.cqc.

This is a bit much I think.
Just ignore it and seek help if you feel you need it. I don’t think they can remove you/ your toddler.

MumblesParty · 03/02/2024 19:34

MP? CQC? Blimey do people really have such an appetite for conflict and hassle that they’d do this?
Just send the letter back with a note saying you’re a bit confused by it, and would welcome to opportunity to discuss it with the practice manager.

Pixie2015 · 03/02/2024 19:33

Dont let it upset you - they can’t remove you for going - there may be a scheme going on locally to contact x number of appointments in a month to keep people know alternatives. I am gp and we have some amazing pharmacy services.

people have clusters of when they see GPs more especially if very unwell. Don’t worry and hope your little one is better soon.

someone said contact cqc - it could be seen as positive they are contacting those using the service - don’t waste time on it, try and have good weekend x

lentilrice · 03/02/2024 19:31

Sunshine322 · 03/02/2024 19:22

I think it’s reasonable to ask someone who is a multiple attendee at a gp practice to consider alternatives. Health care professionals should actually screen who is receiving the letters though -four visits in a month will be justified in some cases but not in others. An ‘automated’ service doesn’t distinguish between the two so should not be used. Babies and children are different than adults, they can’t really tell you what is wrong for a start. Sometimes parents need the reassurance of a gp assessing their little one.

I think is more reasonable for the GP to find out at an appointment why they are attending so often if it is a problem, not send a letter. A f2f chat to find out if someone has health anxiety would bemore beneficial to both parties. I go a lot to the GP as I have multiple conditions, including immunosuppression which means I get a lot of infections. I’d be appalled and very upset if the computer picked this up and sent me a letter asking me to consider alternatives. I can’t imagine pitching up at A&E every time I needed antibiotics is a reasonable use of the NHS. It would cost them far more for a start but also I’d have no continuity of care.

Sunshine322 · 03/02/2024 19:22

I think it’s reasonable to ask someone who is a multiple attendee at a gp practice to consider alternatives. Health care professionals should actually screen who is receiving the letters though -four visits in a month will be justified in some cases but not in others. An ‘automated’ service doesn’t distinguish between the two so should not be used. Babies and children are different than adults, they can’t really tell you what is wrong for a start. Sometimes parents need the reassurance of a gp assessing their little one.