Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GP surgery sent letter to deter us book appointment for toddler

239 replies

Watapain · 03/02/2024 15:24

Today we received letter from Surgery saying that we have booked several appointments in the last month for our toddler who has been sick often and has got a recurring issue needing doctors attention. We should consider other alternatives and not see the GP.
This has really concerned us as me and DH never see the GP. I am fuming as they have sent a form asking us to sign an undertaking that we acknowledge the letter. We are not happy about it and to sign the letter.
Have you been through anything similar and how do we approach about complaining about it as the tone on it seems threatening that they are looking to remove people from their list.

OP posts:
Ryanstartedthefire2 · 03/02/2024 21:56

Someone has reason to believe you are wasting nhs resources. What we're the 4 appt in one month for? One a week is a lot. My husband's granny was the same. She should've got such a letter. Doctors are busy

queenmeadhbh · 03/02/2024 21:56

RuthW · 03/02/2024 15:31

I'm a manager in a surgery. I expect it was computer generated to everyone who had a certain amount of apps over a certain amount of time. You will not be removed from their list.

I imagine it's to make people aware that there are loads of other services you can go to that isn't a gp. The gp is not aways necessary.

If that sort of thing is done then it is absolutely awful that it doesn’t take into account who and what the appointment is for. For a baby/toddler/child this letter should categorically not be sent, and for adults I don’t believe it should be sent to anyone who was actually prescribed treatment in any of their appointments!

Haffiana · 03/02/2024 21:55

Watapain · 03/02/2024 20:26

To everyone who is saying this is just an admin error and I should just brush it off, how do you feel about a vulnerable mum who receives this letter and is too terrified to phone the Surgery as she's worried her name might be removed from the list? If something happens to the child, who'll take responsibility? I can't be the only one receiving this letter. It's wrong on many fronts.

But you seem unable to simply contact the practice and speak to them in order to clarify what the letter means. Why are you worrying about mythical 'others'?

Would you consider yourself vulnerable? Are you terrified?

VaccineSticker · 03/02/2024 21:55

fleurneige · 03/02/2024 21:00

My cousin who is a GP told me she had one patient who brought her child to the surgery at least twice a week- for vague tummy pains that never ever turned out to be anything at all. Calling wolf ...

One out of how many patients?
Not everyone is a time waster and is a hypochondriac, and just because they can’t find the cause of the symptoms or validated the symptoms, does not mean that’s it’s all in the patients’ heads.
Ive heard enough of this patient thrashing and bashing comments blaming them for blocking appointments for no obvious reason. Maybe a tiny tiny minority is a hypochondriac and need reassurances but the rest aren’t.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 03/02/2024 21:52

You've been asked about how many of your attendances involved being given treatment, and haven't answered. You've been asked to share the exact wording of the letter, but haven't.

If you did those two things then if they show that you did need to see the GP and that that they have in fact threatened to delist you, it's likely that you wouldn't be getting as much pushback as you are.

kittensinthekitchen · 03/02/2024 21:50

Oh FFS, why are these "OMG how shit is the NHS" threads always connected to a 'new' poster? Almost every single fucking time.

OP, you said yourself they tried to direct you towards more appropriate services. Given that they know the reason for your appointments, I'd guess it is thought you have been using the service unnecessarily. If you disagree, fine challenge them, but don't do a wide-eyed naive "oh noes, someone will actually die because mean manager said no health care for you!", because even by your own (very limited) explanation, that's not what happened.

Watapain · 03/02/2024 21:43

NHS is an organisation which is accountable to the patients as we pay NI for it to work. If they don't work for their patients then complaints need to be made to improve the services or raise concerns.
There have been huge failings in the past and if no one bothered there would still be lives being lost. I don't care about the dismissal from some posters. We all should stand for the right things.
https://news.sky.com/story/nhs-maternity-scandal-police-looking-at-over-700-cases-as-part-of-maternity-failings-at-shrewsbury-and-telford-nhs-trust-12583615?authId=19meyg7_a*UG45OF9lUC16MFVzNGRjaVl0WGpEdWZSckEzSU54eU9uTWZuUU42aDhDVTF6a1FXSEhnOE9BUHNObk9FT2pNQg..

NHS maternity scandal: Police looking at over 700 cases as part of failings at Shrewsbury and Telford NHS Trust

West Mercia Police investigation has identified 823 cases between October 2003 and the present date, including four cases that have occurred since 2019.

https://news.sky.com/story/nhs-maternity-scandal-police-looking-at-over-700-cases-as-part-of-maternity-failings-at-shrewsbury-and-telford-nhs-trust-12583615?authId=1*9meyg7*_a*UG45OF9lUC16MFVzNGRjaVl0WGpEdWZSckEzSU54eU9uTWZuUU42aDhDVTF6a1FXSEhnOE9BUHNObk9FT2pNQg..

OP posts:
Halloweenrainbow · 03/02/2024 21:39

Surgery blaming the patient instead of taking responsibility for not triaging and signposting to alternative service if they feel this is more appropriate.

lV12 · 03/02/2024 21:37

Give0fecks
yes im v aware of impact of GMC investigations into doctors
That’s on the GMC and lack of support for doctors - not on patients

very happy to give OP benefit of doubt and give them advice on what they have posted.
if true, this has potential to seriously harm patient safety

Give0fecks · 03/02/2024 21:29

@lV12 and Drs have died / committed suicide because of spurious and over zealous complaints against them. And GPs are leaving in their droves because no one wants to do the job anymore.

we don’t know any of the facts here, and the @Watapain is refusing to answer any details or post the letter, most likely because she’s misrepresented it’s contents.

mumda · 03/02/2024 21:29

AnotherSurvivor · 03/02/2024 15:33

I would forward it to my M.P. and ask if they're aware of this.

At the very least!

This needs some sunlight

lV12 · 03/02/2024 21:15

Just like the dismissal on this thread…

lV12 · 03/02/2024 21:14

I’ve known people die because of dismissive GPs
all you need to do is google news

CucumberBagel · 03/02/2024 21:14

Give0fecks · 03/02/2024 20:29

Oh dear Jesus - the hysteria and frothing on this thread is unbelievable. @Watapain i pretty much guarantee you’ve either got the wrong end of the stick or are making a mountain out of a molehill. Post the a picture of the letter (anonymised) and prove me wrong 🤷‍♀️ And as for all the posts saying go to the GMC etc, it really is unbelievable.

My thoughts exactly.

lV12 · 03/02/2024 21:14

Jesus Christ the people not getting that patient feedback is critical and that’s what the CQC, and other health bodies are there for 😵‍💫

CostelloJones · 03/02/2024 21:12

fleurneige · 03/02/2024 21:09

which ones?

Of course, a letter should not be sent, but an appointment made to discuss the reasons why the mother is requesting such regular appointments. We of course have no idea about the previous history of the patient/mother either. There is probably more to this than we know. Or it could have been a mistake. It needs a proper discussion and explanation from GP/nurse/practice manager- and possibly, social services- depending on other issues.

Of course the letter is unnecessary for someone using the visit frequently in a short space of time where really needed. There is probably more at play IMO. But I agree that the letter is not right and regardless of which way round it is the surgery could handle it better.

That would be the sensible decision wouldn’t it… talk to the practice for proper clarification on the matter.

but the amount of people that seem to think going to your MP and putting on your best sour face for a page in the Sun is going to make you popular with the surgery is mad

fleurneige · 03/02/2024 21:09

CostelloJones · 03/02/2024 21:04

The frothing on this thread… all I can say is WOW

which ones?

Of course, a letter should not be sent, but an appointment made to discuss the reasons why the mother is requesting such regular appointments. We of course have no idea about the previous history of the patient/mother either. There is probably more to this than we know. Or it could have been a mistake. It needs a proper discussion and explanation from GP/nurse/practice manager- and possibly, social services- depending on other issues.

justasking111 · 03/02/2024 21:08

Our pharmacy is too small to have a room for diagnosis. It's part of the surgery building. I've asked for advice in the past, heard others asking. They always politely direct us to reception

CostelloJones · 03/02/2024 21:04

The frothing on this thread… all I can say is WOW

Frenzi · 03/02/2024 21:03

Pharmacies can only prescribe if they sign up to the new scheme.

The surgery I work for is in a town with two pharmacies. One is very big in this area. The other is a nationwide chain. Neither of them have signed up for the new scheme and, as far as we know, have no intention of doing so. Therefore if you go to them about wounds/uti and the other 5 things that are being promoted they will direct you to your GP.

We already do lots of signposting from the GP - to the pharmacy, urgent treatment centres and 111 (we rarely direct to A&E - if you are ringing your GP surgery about something it really isn't and A&E problem). 9 times out of 10 we signpost them, they are signposted back to the GP surgery and we end up with a call back from (very understanably) pissed off patient who has been passed around - just because we are all folllowing NHS Englands instructions. The whole system is breaking down.

So yet again the government/press are promoting something that isn't quite what is seems.

Capkayser · 03/02/2024 21:00

It's disgusting. Go to the papers with this and the health ombudsman.

fleurneige · 03/02/2024 21:00

My cousin who is a GP told me she had one patient who brought her child to the surgery at least twice a week- for vague tummy pains that never ever turned out to be anything at all. Calling wolf ...

ChihuahuasREvil · 03/02/2024 20:59

If they have concerns about you repeatedly taking your child to the doctor for no reason they should be raising a safeguarding concern with social services, otherwise you should be forwarding the letter onto the care quality commission for their attention.

Scarletttulips · 03/02/2024 20:54

If something happens to the child, who'll take responsibility? I can't be the only one receiving this letter. It's wrong on many fronts

Scarmongering.

You take your toddler to the pharmacist- they are good and deciding if your DS requires a doctor.

Yoi know working for the NHS the doctors are overwhelmed with patients that don’t need to be see and could go to the chemist - and let’s face it - most get a GO appointment to avoid paying pharmacy prices. they’ve changed the rules so pharmacies can now prescribe - well they could before!!

Frenzi · 03/02/2024 20:53

And no - you should absolutely not receive a computer generated letter about this. GP surgeries cannot threaten to throw you off their books for using them too much!