Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GP surgery sent letter to deter us book appointment for toddler

239 replies

Watapain · 03/02/2024 15:24

Today we received letter from Surgery saying that we have booked several appointments in the last month for our toddler who has been sick often and has got a recurring issue needing doctors attention. We should consider other alternatives and not see the GP.
This has really concerned us as me and DH never see the GP. I am fuming as they have sent a form asking us to sign an undertaking that we acknowledge the letter. We are not happy about it and to sign the letter.
Have you been through anything similar and how do we approach about complaining about it as the tone on it seems threatening that they are looking to remove people from their list.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JenniferBooth · 05/02/2024 14:17

Just seen in our fb group that the online booking system at our surgery has closed for the day ..............at 8.11am "as we have reached capacity for the day"

Trinnitus · 05/02/2024 13:05

And maybe the practice has a point. Perhaps the OP is overusing the GP service. In that case, somebody senior from the practice needs to pick up the phone and have a conversation with the OP about the issue and discuss other ways of them accessing help. A letter like this is inflammatory and not helpful in anyway. Asking a patient to sign a receipt is such a bizarre request.

of course, this is another sign of the NHS in collapse. But this is not the way to go about reducing demand.

Trinnitus · 05/02/2024 12:59

MumblesParty · 03/02/2024 20:25

I give up, I really do.
OK OP, don’t bother to have an adult conversation with the practice manager about this rude and upsetting letter. Go straight for the kill - MP, CQC, NHSE, in fact, why not go and camp outside number 10 till Rishi Sunak listens to your anger.
Meanwhile the GPs in the surgery can spend all those potential appointment hours dealing with the fall out. You all only have yourselves to blame when you can’t get appointments.
You may all hate me for what I’ve said, but I’m a GP and I know how it is.
And no point in having a go at me because I’m going to hide this annoying thread now, so you’ll be wasting your time.

Edited

As a senior doctor, I find your response dismissive and quite childish. The surgery is at fault here. I agree that talking to the practice would be a good first step. But you can’t blame people who feel they might not be taken seriously by a surgery that sends this kind of letter.

lieselotte · 05/02/2024 12:47

fleurneige · 05/02/2024 12:31

Which other country? You force GPs to become 'employees of the State' and they will just be gone, like dentists. Can't you see that? there are shortages all over the world, where they would get much higher pay, much better conditions. Why should they stay?

"Can't you see that" is SOOOOO patronising.

So why do GPs and dentists have to be independent, but other medical (hospital-based) staff are employees of the state? What's the distinction in your view?

lieselotte · 05/02/2024 12:46

caringcarer · 03/02/2024 23:19

Can you clarify did you DC attend GP surgery 4 times in a month and given antibiotics on all 4 occasions or just once or twice?

The antibiotics are not relevant.

What is relevant, is that the OP was worried about her toddler and got through the triage process to see her GP.

An automated letter has been inappropriately sent.

You can't make an appointment for a small sniffle anymore.

Gruffallowhydidntyouknow · 05/02/2024 12:45

Watapain · 03/02/2024 15:29

4 times in a month. DC needed antibiotics

Every time?

fleurneige · 05/02/2024 12:31

Which other country? You force GPs to become 'employees of the State' and they will just be gone, like dentists. Can't you see that? there are shortages all over the world, where they would get much higher pay, much better conditions. Why should they stay?

DodoTired · 05/02/2024 11:37

fleurneige · 05/02/2024 11:16

Within the next 10 years- it won't be possible to find an NHS GP for many people- just as for dentists now. Because GPs are self employed, and not servants of the Government, or the people. They have a choice.

Hopefully the government will make them employees of the NHS, like in other countries. This “private business” of a vital primary care service that’s a gatekeeper to the rest of the NHS is ridiculous.

DodoTired · 05/02/2024 11:34

fleurneige · 05/02/2024 09:52

Have you ever worked for a GP practice? Or been a GP? I'm afraid, you have no idea of the realities. Having different of categories of patients, patient care and relevant fees, is NOT done by the GP at all.

You do realise GPs are leaving in droves, and are not being replaced. Many are going to work abroad, or in private care. And just like any professionals, YES, they can choose their clients, aka patients- especially if they feel that the patient-GP relationship is not working, for the patient, or the doctor. Just like dentists.

Its not done by the GP but it was negotiated on their behalf by their organisation.

and I find it shocking that GPs are private businesses unlike the rest of NHS employees (thats a bizarre remnants of pre-war Britain), and I also find it shocking that they complain about working too much when there are never after hours services, they can work part time etc. Comparably paid professionals (eg lawyers or bankers) work much longer hours and do not moan about it. (Im a lawyer)

fleurneige · 05/02/2024 11:16

Within the next 10 years- it won't be possible to find an NHS GP for many people- just as for dentists now. Because GPs are self employed, and not servants of the Government, or the people. They have a choice.

fleurneige · 05/02/2024 09:52

DodoTired · 04/02/2024 21:51

Well I recently read that the GPs were offered flat rates for patients (which would mean less bureaucracy) during one of the contract renegotiations, and they wanted to be paid more so have gone for rates depending on the patient illness, type of care etc. which of course means tons more paperwork.
so that endless bureaucracy GPs complain about is self inflicted

Have you ever worked for a GP practice? Or been a GP? I'm afraid, you have no idea of the realities. Having different of categories of patients, patient care and relevant fees, is NOT done by the GP at all.

You do realise GPs are leaving in droves, and are not being replaced. Many are going to work abroad, or in private care. And just like any professionals, YES, they can choose their clients, aka patients- especially if they feel that the patient-GP relationship is not working, for the patient, or the doctor. Just like dentists.

TigerRag · 05/02/2024 07:16

fleurneige · 03/02/2024 21:00

My cousin who is a GP told me she had one patient who brought her child to the surgery at least twice a week- for vague tummy pains that never ever turned out to be anything at all. Calling wolf ...

My parents were accused of this. 15 years later it turns out their concerns were right. And I'm now fighting to get someone to realise it's causing the symptoms I'm having.

jeremykylieminogue · 04/02/2024 22:23

@DodoTired your comment is ignorant and and based on no knowledge and understanding of the work plead of GPS and the expectations about their work.

DodoTired · 04/02/2024 21:51

MumblesParty · 03/02/2024 19:44

I’ve been a GP for over 25 years.
In that time, I’ve seen it become much harder to get appointments. One reason for this is the expanding (particularly elderly) population.
Another reason is the vast increase in bureaucracy. Most GPs will now have at least one admin session per week, simply to deal with bureaucracy, such as audits, complaints, CQC, various NHS-mandated schemes etc. The list is endless.
So people should think very carefully before they involve MP, CQC, NHSE etc. Because in the time it takes for a GP to deal with just one such complaint, they could see 20-50 patients.

Something like OP’s issue could be resolved by a quick chat with the practice manager.

Well I recently read that the GPs were offered flat rates for patients (which would mean less bureaucracy) during one of the contract renegotiations, and they wanted to be paid more so have gone for rates depending on the patient illness, type of care etc. which of course means tons more paperwork.
so that endless bureaucracy GPs complain about is self inflicted

Dearover · 04/02/2024 17:36

This outrage is all very dramatic with letters to MPs etc. A simple call to the practice manager could clear this up or lead to taking it further if necessary.

The OP said that her child had 4 visits to the GP in Jan and was prescribed antibiotics. She hasn't said if there were 4 x prescriptions or how many visits to the GP they had previously made, so they could have been making regular trips for concerns which could be dealt with elsewhere. For all we know, the first visit in January may have been completely necessary and the other 3 could have been handled by a quick trip to the pharmacist.

fleurneige · 04/02/2024 10:38

TheSnakeCharmer · 03/02/2024 22:46

Be a grown up?? How insulting to the OP. Make a drs appointment? When she's been told not to, to discuss a non medical issue? That if the trust has gone on both sides she could find another GP?? Drs aren't there to 'trust' their patients. They are there to assess their medical conditions. And why should she have to potentially leave the surgery and travel to one further afield (which may or may not accept her as a patient)? What if she can't get to another one easily. What if this letter creates an anxiety and causes her to second guess every appointment in the future, regardless of where she goes. It's a very alarming letter to receive.

To be successful, it has to be a two-way thing. Trust on both sides, means that the GP who repeatedly is not 'trusted' by the patient, will possibly, and quite within their right- say that the professional relationship with that patient is not working, and that it is better to find another GP. And yes, doctors are well within their rights to say this, and that it is for the well-being of both, firstly, the patient.

darkmodeera · 04/02/2024 00:54

PegasusReturns · 03/02/2024 15:37

I would write back stating that you were alarmed to receive their letter and ask them to clarify which of the appointments they feel were unnecessary.

This

caringcarer · 04/02/2024 00:28

SleepingStandingUp · 03/02/2024 23:52

If OP phones up for an appt, she probably has little say in who she sees tho so it's up to reception to send him to a nurse if they think that's better. I frequently end up seeing the paramedic not the GP and indeed our last visit with DS before he ended up in hospital was with her. No disrespect to her, she gave the same antibiotics the Dr would have given.

At my surgery they ask who you want to see, GP or nurse.

Teenie22 · 04/02/2024 00:23

Awful. That’s a terrible approach. I would complain and find another GP surgery. Hope your little one is ok.

SecretDoor · 04/02/2024 00:12

https://www.england.nhs.uk/high-intensity-use-programme/

This is the guidance to English hospitals looking at patients who frequently attend the emergency department. These patients often have unmet needs and are frequently vulnerable or from socially deprived backgrounds. The idea is to use a coaching approach and de-medicalise and de-criminalise the pattern. Not to use an authoritarian or chiding letter

NHS England » High Intensity Use programme

https://www.england.nhs.uk/high-intensity-use-programme/

CrappySack · 03/02/2024 23:58

Watapain · 03/02/2024 21:43

NHS is an organisation which is accountable to the patients as we pay NI for it to work. If they don't work for their patients then complaints need to be made to improve the services or raise concerns.
There have been huge failings in the past and if no one bothered there would still be lives being lost. I don't care about the dismissal from some posters. We all should stand for the right things.
https://news.sky.com/story/nhs-maternity-scandal-police-looking-at-over-700-cases-as-part-of-maternity-failings-at-shrewsbury-and-telford-nhs-trust-12583615?authId=19meyg7_a*UG45OF9lUC16MFVzNGRjaVl0WGpEdWZSckEzSU54eU9uTWZuUU42aDhDVTF6a1FXSEhnOE9BUHNObk9FT2pNQg..

I think you've given the game away here OP.

SleepingStandingUp · 03/02/2024 23:52

caringcarer · 03/02/2024 23:20

Not necessarily my practice nurse can prescribe antibiotics.

If OP phones up for an appt, she probably has little say in who she sees tho so it's up to reception to send him to a nurse if they think that's better. I frequently end up seeing the paramedic not the GP and indeed our last visit with DS before he ended up in hospital was with her. No disrespect to her, she gave the same antibiotics the Dr would have given.

lV12 · 03/02/2024 23:51

I fully appreciate the pressure of working as a GP and how under funded the system is and how many posts are unfulfilled

But I also agree with this;

They have gone barking mad, GPs, with their online appointments, early retirements and part-time working.

SleepingStandingUp · 03/02/2024 23:50

As an aside op, I'd say if your child has been prescribed four lots of antibiotics in a month, you DO need a different service. DS has just got back from three days in hospital and finished five days of IV antibiotics because the four doses of antibiotics we've had since mid November have done nothing. Hospital picked up a chest infection which listening couldn't as well as treating the tonsillitis the antibiotics hadn't cured.

Please escalate his care if the last batch of meds haven't worked.

k1233 · 03/02/2024 23:39

I would send a letter acknowledging receipt of their letter. In it I would say that, as you would be aware, DSs appointments during this time were related to XYZ condition and resulted in XXX treatment, which is only available from Drs, GPs being more appropriate in this situation than emergency departments. You acknowledge that other service providers may be more appropriate for other ailments and, where those ailments occur, will seek relevant providers.