Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 4 weeks summer is ok

414 replies

comeonlabour · 03/02/2024 14:21

So as the title suggests, if the plans do go ahead to make summer hols 4 weeks I for one am not against it. I always think 6 weeks is way too long so 4 is more manageable

Also we will have longer half terms of 2 weeks in some cases instead of 1 so all good

Anyone else feel the same/agree with me

OP posts:
DrMadelineMaxwell · 03/02/2024 20:12

That proposal is a farce.
It asks a few standard 'Do you agree/disagree?' questions about the proposed changes, then asks what affect you think it will have on the Welsh language.

leilani83 · 03/02/2024 19:36

The whole argument for shorter holidays because of childcare is crazy - school isn't childcare!! And the stage of life when this is an issue won't last forever, and it isn't just about you! People need holidays: kids, parents, teachers! This culture of long working hours and long school days and longer terms is terrible for everyone's mental health - we aren't worker bees just bred to feed the economy!

boys3 · 03/02/2024 19:32

and this is the joint letter from all the teaching unions plus the tourism and farming industry,

Dear Minister,

"We write to you to express our deep concern at the decision of the Welsh Government to engage in a public consultation over the reform of the schoolyear, when there has been no serious attempt to engage appropriately with the sectors and organisations that represent the many people across Wales who will be detrimentally affected by the recommendations that have been presented.

"We believe that there is limited recent and relevant research that supports the recommendations and that they are based upon a long-held prejudice regarding the school summer break. This proposal runs the risk of fixing a problem that does not exist, when there is also little public appetite for such a change. In the Welsh Government commissioned Beaufort Report, the key findings state that "the majority of participants were content with the shape of the current school year".

"All of the education unions are incomplete agreement that the reform of the school year proposals are unacceptable. The summer break is already amongst the shortest in Europe.

"The educational reasons the Welsh Government give for the reforms are not substantiated by research, including the view that there is a detriment to children’s learning. Countries that appear above Wales in the Pisa league tables have significantly longer summer breaks.

"We would argue that the proposed changes will actually do damage to secondary learners, as a week is taken from the crucial autumn term and transferred to the quieter post examination period. Every secondary teacher knows that this is a serious error.

"The education unions are also incredulous that, at a time when schools are facing a crisis in funding, recruitment and pupil behaviour, the Welsh Government should be so engaged in this entirely unnecessary distraction. Representatives from the tourist industry, the second largest employer in Wales, have also expressed their dismay at the formal consultation

"The proposal to add a week to the October half term would be a disaster for many, especially those in rural/mountainous areas where the weather at that time of year can be grim, and would mean an 80%* reduction in revenue for that week if compared to the one lost in the summer term.

"Last October, in half term, Wales endured a named storm and many attractions had to close on the Thursday of that week and did not reopen for the rest of the week. The tourist industry also employs many young people during the summer break period.

"The current six-week period allows time to train and properly engage with, youngsters, many of whom are experiencing their first opportunity in the workplace. Many will be denied this opportunity if the holiday periods are cut short by these proposals.

"Farming representatives also have concerns about the proposed reform –arguing that many farming businesses that have diversified into the tourism sector benefit from a six-week peak season where the weather is far more favourable for visitors to enjoy the countryside and Wales’ visitor attractions.

"Under the proposals, visitors will be faced with limited time in the summer to enjoy Wales at its finest. There is also concern where there are "honey pot" areas, confining the timeframe with an increased number of visitors to these parts, will impact on those running farming businesses in rural Wales causing disruption, especially in coastal areas or National Parks.

"The prospect of shorter days associated with an extended October half-term break will not be as enjoyable and could result in the loss of these visitors as holidays are taken abroad. Farmers are also concerned about the impact on the Royal Welsh Show.

"This is a wonderful vocational educational experience for the next generation of farmers as well as being the one opportunity a year when many farming families are able spend time together away from the farm. The Royal Welsh Agricultural Society (RWAS) has already publicly stated that schools remaining open during show week could lead to an estimated £1 million loss of revenue and thus endanger its future viability.

"Sixty-eight per cent of show visitors attend as part of a family group. If it is term time in Wales during Royal Welsh Show week, young people and those working in schools will be denied the opportunity to attend the show legally with their families.

"They will also be denied the opportunity to compete in its events, and the show will be denied its role in the education of Welsh youngsters, which is to help them develop into rounded individuals who will contribute to Wales’ future prosperity.

"The RWAS has stated that it does not wish to negatively impact other agricultural shows and national events, such as the Eisteddfod, which follow the Royal Welsh Show in the calendar by moving its own dates. Indeed, as many of these events share the same contractors and vendors, it is unlikely that moving show dates to accommodate a change in school holidays would be viable.

"The show is the largest agricultural event of its kind in Europe and, as such, affords Wales the opportunity of international attention. It embodies the Welsh Government’s vision of a Wales which, as outlined in the Well-being of Future Generations (Wales) Act, prospers in regards to its people, culture and economy.

"Endangering the show’s future by having schools open during the event also endangers Wales’s future prosperity. We call upon the Welsh Government to withdraw its proposals to reform the school year.

"Experts in education, tourism and agriculture have all argued strongly against these proposals as the Welsh Government is not addressing these concerns. We believe that these proposals do not come from relevant and recent research and will not best support children in their learning.

"The arguments against these proposals that we state in this letter are just a few of many arguments that we have all repeated time and again to Welsh Government officials, but no one is listening. Possibly of greater concern are all the unintended consequences that will surface only after the damage is done.

"We call upon the Welsh Government to withdraw these proposals and redirect its energies to the real challenges that face Wales and to stop fighting unnecessary battles."

* The signatories to the joint letter are: NASUWT CYMRU, NEU CYMRU, UCAC CYMRU, ASCL CYMRU, NAHT CYMRU, NFU CYMRU, FUW CYMRU, UNISON CYMRU, GMB WALES & SOUTHWEST, RWAS, WAVA

ThePenguinIsDrunk · 03/02/2024 19:16

YABU i don't think kids get enough hols as it is and my lot really benefit from 6 weeks to really decompress in a way they don't over 2 weeks

boys3 · 03/02/2024 19:15

ClumsyNinja · 03/02/2024 18:41

Good grief! We have 12 week school summer hols here in Ireland.

I guess on the plus side, we’ll be able to visit the UK and enjoy the attractions without hordes of English kids getting in the way. 😂

Indeed @ClumsyNinja. but it’s only Wales that are thinking about this. Or rather the Welsh Government. You’d still have the English hordes 😀to contend with even if Wales did go ahead.

HappyAsASandboy · 03/02/2024 19:11

For working parents (me!), 4 weeks would be better due to childcare.

For the kids, 6 weeks or even longer is a proper break between academic years. It lets them travel, relax, be bored, grow up, forget the pressures of last year, properly pause, before the next academic year starts.

I now have kids with 9+ weeks of summer holidays and apart from the logistical nightmare of childcare and some children only having 6 weeks, 9+ weeks is great for them. I will take that logistical nightmare on the chin for a few years to give them the long break.

mitogoshi · 03/02/2024 19:11

Is prefer longer, many countries have 10 weeks. Gives you a chance to do something like residential summer camp or summer programmes like in the USA. I could never send mine because we were still in school in July

VampireWeekday · 03/02/2024 19:09

Why would I want to be forced to take massive amounts of my annual leave in October and February instead of lovely summer? Why would my kids want this, either?

Mangerine · 03/02/2024 19:04

No way I love the 6 weeks!!! I have 8 left with her and she will continue having 6 weeks off!!!

Fucking farse this country is becoming.

FluffytheGoldfish · 03/02/2024 19:00

It won't just be parent's trying to squeeze their leave into 4 weeks. What about the partners of teachers? DH has had people complaining and suggesting that he no longer booked time off during the summer as our children have left school despite the fact they know I teach.

VivaVivaa · 03/02/2024 18:58

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 03/02/2024 18:45

Nope. Lone parent with a full time job and no family childcare ever, even for a day. And my kids can't do clubs so I have to pay for nannies for them in the school holidays and for wrap around care.

I still think that 6 weeks isn't long enough. School is a terrible environment for children and they need at least one decent respite from it per year.

I agree with you on a lot of things. School starts too early for little children and takes up too much of childhood. You must realise though that ‘paying for nannies’ is massively out of reach for most working families? It must give your DC amazing continuity and a great break over the summer though!

MrsHamlet · 03/02/2024 18:57

DinnaeFashYersel · 03/02/2024 18:54

They need to drop the word 'British' out of it cause Scotland will never go for it.

It's a stupid idea, full stop.

DinnaeFashYersel · 03/02/2024 18:54

MrsHamlet · 03/02/2024 18:48

The "advanced British standard" is years off, if it ever happens.

They need to drop the word 'British' out of it cause Scotland will never go for it.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 03/02/2024 18:50

Having said that, long holidays for teens gives them the opportunity to engage in self directed projects that younger kids can’t, which is valuable for exploring what they like and want to do after secondary school.

This is bonkers. Young children especially learn more through natural play and are less suited to a school environment. My children get so frustrated with school because they have so many projects they want to do at home: ideas for drawings and crafts and things they want to make out of a cardboard box etc etc. Their imaginations and creativity are crushed by the demands at school that they do what school wants them to rather than drawing prototypes for robots and playing music and collecting random stuff from outside to make a collage with or whatever. Books they want to read, music to listen to, puzzles to do. They are early primary. It's bad enough they have to spend so much time at school as it is. The summer holidays are what make it almost bearable.

megletthesecond · 03/02/2024 18:50

I'd have loved this when my dc's were younger, as long as the extra holiday time was added to Xmas and Feb half term.

Hated rushing around on dark days, illness and putting them in holiday clubs in winter.

MrsHamlet · 03/02/2024 18:48

The "advanced British standard" is years off, if it ever happens.

DinnaeFashYersel · 03/02/2024 18:46

@spriots

*But there may be quite a lot of change if we move to the advanced British standard or a different baccalaureate style system anyway

There's not a chance you could align all the nations of the UK to a 'British' standard.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 03/02/2024 18:45

VivaVivaa · 03/02/2024 17:31

I’m curious. For PPs saying the holidays are important to give DC a break - do you all have a SAHP? Because my friends and I (all of whom have 2 parents that work in some capacity) seem to all be doing a hodgepodge of clubs, child minders, family, passing round friends, calling in favours…Hardly a break for the DCs as much as we’d like it to be. The opposite intact, due to massive upheaval in routine.

Nope. Lone parent with a full time job and no family childcare ever, even for a day. And my kids can't do clubs so I have to pay for nannies for them in the school holidays and for wrap around care.

I still think that 6 weeks isn't long enough. School is a terrible environment for children and they need at least one decent respite from it per year.

ClumsyNinja · 03/02/2024 18:41

Good grief! We have 12 week school summer hols here in Ireland.

I guess on the plus side, we’ll be able to visit the UK and enjoy the attractions without hordes of English kids getting in the way. 😂

Bubble2024 · 03/02/2024 18:40

Morred · 03/02/2024 18:05

@Bubble2024 same way I sort it for the 6 weeks in summer now. Except it would mean fewer weeks in a row for DC shoved into holiday clubs, because between us DP and I could probably manage a week or even two at Easter, a week in May/June and a week together in August (or some arrangement like that).

Edited

You’ve got two children with different schedules. That’s the issue.

Also a lot of holiday clubs are round out of secondaries so they’re gone too.

jannier · 03/02/2024 18:40

Who wants a long October or Feb holiday in soggy cold Britain not everyone can afford abroad and all this would do is make summer more expensive and harder to get as all parents now competing for 4 weeks not 6

Bubble2024 · 03/02/2024 18:39

Isitovernow123 · 03/02/2024 18:05

Why do you need childcare for secondary school children?

I wouldn’t leave an 11 year old at home without any supervision for 8 plus hours a day.

spriots · 03/02/2024 18:39

MrsHamlet · 03/02/2024 18:30

I would love to have 3 weeks in late May/early June half term and then 4 weeks in late August/early September

Which would require wholesale changes to GCSE and A level teaching and assessment.

Yes.

But there may be quite a lot of change if we move to the advanced British standard or a different baccalaureate style system anyway

Sofabum · 03/02/2024 18:36

I think 6 weeks works in Enid Blyton land where children could run along the lane and have adventures all day with a basket full of ginger beer and be parent free. The reality is that lots of kids spend 6 weeks on screens.

Swipe left for the next trending thread