Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 4 weeks summer is ok

414 replies

comeonlabour · 03/02/2024 14:21

So as the title suggests, if the plans do go ahead to make summer hols 4 weeks I for one am not against it. I always think 6 weeks is way too long so 4 is more manageable

Also we will have longer half terms of 2 weeks in some cases instead of 1 so all good

Anyone else feel the same/agree with me

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 26/02/2024 11:38

I’ve been thinking about this-we have just had a week off for February half term. It has rained for virtually the whole week and it’s bloody freezing. Anything you want to do with the kids needs to be indoors and costs a fortune. There is no way I would want to swap a week in July in the sunshine, for another week off now!

Mackonadragos · 26/02/2024 11:27

comeonlabour · 03/02/2024 14:21

So as the title suggests, if the plans do go ahead to make summer hols 4 weeks I for one am not against it. I always think 6 weeks is way too long so 4 is more manageable

Also we will have longer half terms of 2 weeks in some cases instead of 1 so all good

Anyone else feel the same/agree with me

No, this would be a fuc*ing misery.

It already is. The entire year would be revolving around school and education without a decent break. Also the 2-weak-long autumn breaks sound wonderful in this bleak weather.

European countries and European children have way longer summer holidays.

sorestupid · 10/02/2024 12:35

I read OPs post and it simply made me wonder if people like that only have children to benefit the wider economy rather than because they actually want children.

Mind you I'm one of those weirdos who is not desperate to be rid of their children within days of school holiday starting.

@Libgera I don’t understand the above?

sorestupid · 10/02/2024 12:33

I really like the idea of 4 wks in the summer & longer half terms.

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 10/02/2024 12:30

@Iwasafool it wouldn't work. No spare teachers for covering absences now.

Iwasafool · 10/02/2024 12:22

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 10/02/2024 12:19

They mean that it was an alternative suggested, allowing teachers to chose when to be off.

Can you imagine the logistical nightmare. It would be awful

I'd have thought it would be impossible to do without massive disruption to kids. Obviously there are times teachers aren't there but usually unavoidable things like sickness.

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 10/02/2024 12:19

Iwasafool · 08/02/2024 19:36

If we are talking UK workers are entitled to 5.6 weeks holiday a year. Not sure why teachers would only get 4.

They mean that it was an alternative suggested, allowing teachers to chose when to be off.

Can you imagine the logistical nightmare. It would be awful

ConsuelaHammock · 08/02/2024 20:10

My children get 9 weeks. It’s perfect

Libgera · 08/02/2024 19:56

I read OPs post and it simply made me wonder if people like that only have children to benefit the wider economy rather than because they actually want children.

Mind you I'm one of those weirdos who is not desperate to be rid of their children within days of school holiday starting.

Iwasafool · 08/02/2024 19:36

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 07/02/2024 01:38

From whaf I hear it is haemorrhaging teachers because of appalling working conditions with no respect or discipline and chronic underfunding, crumbling facilities and class sizes double what they should be, toxic work environments with incompetent management, political interference in how qualified professionals do their job and an SEN support budget that needs quadrupling rather than the latesf genius plan to cut it. I haven't heard of any teachers quitting because they think 4 weeks of annual leave per year with some flexibility on when it is taken would be preferable to 13 weeks of leave at fixed times, despite the inconvenience that inflexibility no doubt causes.

If we are talking UK workers are entitled to 5.6 weeks holiday a year. Not sure why teachers would only get 4.

SqueakyShouts · 07/02/2024 07:40

9 weeks for my DD.

4 would be much easier from a childcare point of view but once they're older I really think they need the extended break between years.

EasternStandard · 07/02/2024 06:56

If Wales does go ahead I’m not sure why holiday time making it more attractive won’t be considered

Seems a bad oversight

menopausalmare · 07/02/2024 06:51

ThePeaAndThePrincess, because it hasn't happened yet. But if it did it would be the tipping point for a number of my colleagues.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 07/02/2024 01:38

From whaf I hear it is haemorrhaging teachers because of appalling working conditions with no respect or discipline and chronic underfunding, crumbling facilities and class sizes double what they should be, toxic work environments with incompetent management, political interference in how qualified professionals do their job and an SEN support budget that needs quadrupling rather than the latesf genius plan to cut it. I haven't heard of any teachers quitting because they think 4 weeks of annual leave per year with some flexibility on when it is taken would be preferable to 13 weeks of leave at fixed times, despite the inconvenience that inflexibility no doubt causes.

Shinyandnew1 · 06/02/2024 19:12

Teachers already have a lot of time off so do not have the issue that most parents have of not having enough quality time with their children

One of the many reasons that teachers I know have left is the inflexibility of the job in term time. There is no scope to take a day off to watch your child’s school assembly or school play or come to Sports Day or Open Days. I wasn’t able to attend a single show/play/assembly for my youngest-she doesn’t seem to remember, but I hated not being there every single time. Yes, there is more holiday than other people, but the profession is haemorrhaging teachers, so that isn’t enough to make people join/stay.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 06/02/2024 19:05

Well, teachers can only take time off when the schools are closed. Would the paid leave have to be used during the normal summer holiday? If so, it’s not really helpful for teachers in terms of being “parental leave” for things like in-service days or when their children are sick.

Nobody can use the existing (unpaid so hardly anybody can use it ever, but anyway...) parental leave for that, either. It has to be taken in blocks of one week minimum and has to be pre-agreed by the employer in advance. It therefore is not emergency leave/ covering sick days.

Teachers already have a lot of time off so do not have the issue that most parents have of not having enough quality time with their children, but I'm sure they would be grateful to have some of the school holidays as paid leave if the parental leave policy was changed in the way I suggested.

Longma · 05/02/2024 20:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

0rangeCrush · 05/02/2024 20:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

I personally would rather they invested money in public services - in my area, everything is closing. The council run gym is only open during office hours, the swimming pool only has lane swimming and it’s almost exclusively booked for lessons, youth clubs are closing due to a lack of funding, swing parks are barely maintained, and so on.
I would much rather these services be available than reducing costs of foreign travel.

Even government funding/subsidised child entry to local attractions would be far
more widely beneficial to people who are struggling financially (and wider society)than reducing costs of foreign travel: something only available to the comparatively wealthy. Plus; it would encourage people to stay in the UK and spend in the UK rather than us losing revenue to overseas destinations.

If anything;foreign travel should be more expensive.

0rangeCrush · 05/02/2024 20:23

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 11:49

Yes, all parents should have it. Teachers say their holiday time is unpaid (i.e. they are only contracted 39 weeks per year rather than 52 with paid holidays like most employees: I've not checked a teacher contract to verify this but this is my understanding) so two of their 13 weeks where they have unpaid leave would then be paid each year, at their weekly rate of pay. Not sure I see the issue?

One of the UK's big problems is an unwillingness to invest in anything that doesn't have immediate payoffs. Time and money invested into children, quality child: parent time, high standards of education pays off many times over in terms of future productivity. This mentality also pervades healthcare here (far less focus on preventative care/ early intervention and diagnosis which is cheaper and more effective) than in comparable countries. And infrastructure (let it crumble into disrepair rather than forecast what will be required in 20 years and build that as these are long-term projects). Same for energy capacity. Same for the pensions ponzi scheme. Until some long-term thinking is applied and people understand that it costs far more to firefight totally foreseeable issues once you've let them escalate into a forest fire than it would do to buy a fire extinguiser and have that next to your campfire, the UK will continue to waste enormous amounts of money on very poor outcomes per pound spent.

Well, teachers can only take time off when the schools are closed. Would the paid leave have to be used during the normal summer holiday? If so, it’s not really helpful for teachers in terms of being “parental leave” for things like in-service days or when their children are sick.

Longma · 05/02/2024 20:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Longma · 05/02/2024 20:17

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 11:49

Yes, all parents should have it. Teachers say their holiday time is unpaid (i.e. they are only contracted 39 weeks per year rather than 52 with paid holidays like most employees: I've not checked a teacher contract to verify this but this is my understanding) so two of their 13 weeks where they have unpaid leave would then be paid each year, at their weekly rate of pay. Not sure I see the issue?

One of the UK's big problems is an unwillingness to invest in anything that doesn't have immediate payoffs. Time and money invested into children, quality child: parent time, high standards of education pays off many times over in terms of future productivity. This mentality also pervades healthcare here (far less focus on preventative care/ early intervention and diagnosis which is cheaper and more effective) than in comparable countries. And infrastructure (let it crumble into disrepair rather than forecast what will be required in 20 years and build that as these are long-term projects). Same for energy capacity. Same for the pensions ponzi scheme. Until some long-term thinking is applied and people understand that it costs far more to firefight totally foreseeable issues once you've let them escalate into a forest fire than it would do to buy a fire extinguiser and have that next to your campfire, the UK will continue to waste enormous amounts of money on very poor outcomes per pound spent.

0rangeCrush · 05/02/2024 11:29

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 11:17

To be honest I think it would be better for children to have longer school days and much longer holidays, so shorter terms. Condense it basically, so that the vast majority of their life isn't focused on school. Whole days of freedom are more valuable than an extra free hour or two after school each day, where school will already have taken up the vast majority of their mental and physical energy. And in winter those after school hours are in the dark so useless for any outdoor activity. Longer school days would also be better for most working parents, and it would probably be cheaper to swap after school childcare for whole day activities in the school holidays.

I also think that the current "parental leave" policy should be scrapped because most people simply cannot afford to take this unpaid leave. It should be replaced by a more generous 2 weeks per year of extra paid leave at the rate of the person's actual salary/ earnings (so that everyone can afford to use it) for the years of primary school, funded by the Government. This would allow much more parental time with children (also important therefore to double the allowance to 4 weeks for single parents) and have huge benefits in terms of child mental health, adult mental health, raising secure and well-balanced children and children feeling rested and restored ready to go back to school and study, less stressed and more focused. And developmentally we know beyond doubt that children benefit enormously from significant time that is undirected. It's so unhealthy to put them on a treadmill of daily demands at such a young age and crushes their imaginations and creativity.

We need to focus our Government policy more on wellbeing and quality of life given that's the entire point of having an economy in the first place. Currently, because they do not have a vote, funding for anything related to children is even more woeful than everything else: education (right from early years through to university), children's services, CAMHS, means testing even of child benefit/ childcare funding which is an abomination. We need to unashamedly say "yes, children are the most vulnerable members of our society and the future of it, and it benefits us all to fund this, even those who do not have children."

Looking back to childhood many people's fondest memories will be of their summer holidays. It should be a priority and the idea it should be curtailed rather than looking at policies to extend it/ increase the quality of it as family time are bizarre to me and very short-sighted.

Would teachers also get this extra two weeks of leave? If so, how would that work?

OnTheBanks · 05/02/2024 11:20

3 months in Ireland at secondary, June, July and August

ThePeaAndThePrincess · 05/02/2024 11:17

To be honest I think it would be better for children to have longer school days and much longer holidays, so shorter terms. Condense it basically, so that the vast majority of their life isn't focused on school. Whole days of freedom are more valuable than an extra free hour or two after school each day, where school will already have taken up the vast majority of their mental and physical energy. And in winter those after school hours are in the dark so useless for any outdoor activity. Longer school days would also be better for most working parents, and it would probably be cheaper to swap after school childcare for whole day activities in the school holidays.

I also think that the current "parental leave" policy should be scrapped because most people simply cannot afford to take this unpaid leave. It should be replaced by a more generous 2 weeks per year of extra paid leave at the rate of the person's actual salary/ earnings (so that everyone can afford to use it) for the years of primary school, funded by the Government. This would allow much more parental time with children (also important therefore to double the allowance to 4 weeks for single parents) and have huge benefits in terms of child mental health, adult mental health, raising secure and well-balanced children and children feeling rested and restored ready to go back to school and study, less stressed and more focused. And developmentally we know beyond doubt that children benefit enormously from significant time that is undirected. It's so unhealthy to put them on a treadmill of daily demands at such a young age and crushes their imaginations and creativity.

We need to focus our Government policy more on wellbeing and quality of life given that's the entire point of having an economy in the first place. Currently, because they do not have a vote, funding for anything related to children is even more woeful than everything else: education (right from early years through to university), children's services, CAMHS, means testing even of child benefit/ childcare funding which is an abomination. We need to unashamedly say "yes, children are the most vulnerable members of our society and the future of it, and it benefits us all to fund this, even those who do not have children."

Looking back to childhood many people's fondest memories will be of their summer holidays. It should be a priority and the idea it should be curtailed rather than looking at policies to extend it/ increase the quality of it as family time are bizarre to me and very short-sighted.