Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 4 weeks summer is ok

414 replies

comeonlabour · 03/02/2024 14:21

So as the title suggests, if the plans do go ahead to make summer hols 4 weeks I for one am not against it. I always think 6 weeks is way too long so 4 is more manageable

Also we will have longer half terms of 2 weeks in some cases instead of 1 so all good

Anyone else feel the same/agree with me

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 28/02/2024 13:39

Bargello · 28/02/2024 13:32

Couple of points.

The "well teachers don;t get paid for holidays" is just semantics. You earn X amount a year, are contracted to Y days work, and get paid your salary in 12, monthly chunks just like everyone else. Literally nobody cares about the wording of your contract and that you are technically only paid for classroom days. By all means ask for more money if you think you are underpaid, but the whole "teachers are not paid for holidays" is such a ridiculous argument and one which loses you support.

Also - where are all these teachers working all holidays? I live next door to a primary school in Scotland and can see into school from my living room. There are never any teachers preparing classrooms and cleaning or whatever else people have claimed they do during the summer break. School finishes at lunchtime on the last day of the summer term in June, the building is locked and deserted by 2pm. You sometimes see a janitor/catetaker, or council workers doing maintenance. I've seen the Head pop in maybe 2 or 3 times over the holidays for 15 minutes to check everything's OK and presumably to pick up mail. The teachers come back for the two in-service/inset days before term starts in August.

Are you on the right thread?

I don’t see what either of your points has to do with moving 2 weeks of the school holidays to a different time of the year?

Bargello · 28/02/2024 13:32

Couple of points.

The "well teachers don;t get paid for holidays" is just semantics. You earn X amount a year, are contracted to Y days work, and get paid your salary in 12, monthly chunks just like everyone else. Literally nobody cares about the wording of your contract and that you are technically only paid for classroom days. By all means ask for more money if you think you are underpaid, but the whole "teachers are not paid for holidays" is such a ridiculous argument and one which loses you support.

Also - where are all these teachers working all holidays? I live next door to a primary school in Scotland and can see into school from my living room. There are never any teachers preparing classrooms and cleaning or whatever else people have claimed they do during the summer break. School finishes at lunchtime on the last day of the summer term in June, the building is locked and deserted by 2pm. You sometimes see a janitor/catetaker, or council workers doing maintenance. I've seen the Head pop in maybe 2 or 3 times over the holidays for 15 minutes to check everything's OK and presumably to pick up mail. The teachers come back for the two in-service/inset days before term starts in August.

shearwater2 · 28/02/2024 13:29

spriots · 28/02/2024 12:55

@shearwater2 but the countries ranked below us also have longer summer holidays too so I am not sure it's easy to conclude longer holidays are better

True, but that makes the point for me - it's not the holidays in themselves.

Shinyandnew1 · 28/02/2024 13:10

Autienotnaughtie · 28/02/2024 05:00

Definitely 4. The system is based on a archaic time when often families had one parent at home, or siblings looked after each other or friends/relatives helped out. Now most kids are stuck in childcare anyway.

I do think something should be done about holiday prices tho. It's unfair to insist we can only go away at set times but then companies charge significantly more for those times.

Nothing will be ‘done about’ holiday prices-it’s supply and demand.

If the summer is cut to 4 weeks, it will be much much worse.

You’ll be paying much more than you do now for your summer break and you’ll have the added bonus of sitting in a 12-hour tailback on the motorway either side of your holiday as well because everyone else will be on the road then as well.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 13:02

shearwater2 · 28/02/2024 12:39

It's interesting that other countries who do better than us in educational terms tend to have longer holidays not shorter and also start formal school later.

It shows that the support systems for what happens before they go to school, and what happens in school holidays (i.e. good value childcare, holiday schemes, good pre-school, support for parental leave, help for those on lower incomes) are key.

So we should be looking at other things if kids are suffering negative outcomes from a six week summer holiday, not the length of the holiday itself.

Edited

Very good point. From a quick google search very few countries have less than 6 weeks - Thailand, South Korea and potentially some African ones but these countries also have better weather all year round

Shinyandnew1 · 28/02/2024 13:02

Elephantswillnever · 28/02/2024 06:26

Six weeks is a complete pita for childcare. Two weeks off each covers four weeks so that would be better. I appreciate other people manage to do stuff as a family etc.

You’ll still have to find the same amount of childcare though. You’d just have to find it in February and October when there are probably far fewer holiday clubs running!

spriots · 28/02/2024 12:55

@shearwater2 but the countries ranked below us also have longer summer holidays too so I am not sure it's easy to conclude longer holidays are better

shearwater2 · 28/02/2024 12:39

It's interesting that other countries who do better than us in educational terms tend to have longer holidays not shorter and also start formal school later.

It shows that the support systems for what happens before they go to school, and what happens in school holidays (i.e. good value childcare, holiday schemes, good pre-school, support for parental leave, help for those on lower incomes) are key.

So we should be looking at other things if kids are suffering negative outcomes from a six week summer holiday, not the length of the holiday itself.

LoveAutumnColours · 28/02/2024 09:45

For you that may well work but for thousands it may not. Think about families that have family abroad they go visit every year. They may need that time to travel and actually visit.

talking about travel, the entirety of the UK families who take holidays, both here and abroad, would all need to travel in just that 4 week window

without people attending places of interest, they’d cease to exist and visiting only weekends or those sole 4 weeks is not enough

kids need to decompress, have fun and just be kids. Didn’t you have a relaxed and fun filled childhood? Lived mine. Seemed to last forever (certainly more than a measles 4 weeks!)

what might be better option if you’re coming from a child care perspective is some programmes that are more affordable for low income families so they can take advantage of the child care.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 09:37

Children need time to focus on less academic activities -sport / creativity etc and the summer holidays allow time for that.

the solution is probably more free activities/camps during the summer holidays. Obviously comes at a cost but will hope with both childcare issues and keeping the poorer/more vulnerable children engaged so that their learning doesn’t regress. Schools are sitting there empty so the space is available so it’s the people to run it that is going to be the main cost but there will be lots of students looking for summer work/ could introduce schemes to bring in overseas students etc.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 09:31

Elephantswillnever · 28/02/2024 06:26

Six weeks is a complete pita for childcare. Two weeks off each covers four weeks so that would be better. I appreciate other people manage to do stuff as a family etc.

There are generally more holiday club options in the summer holidays though compared to other times of year.

not everyone will be able to take the same time off work so less people may be able to get time off during the summer which could make childcare harder or ability to enjoy time as a family.

the pressure on airports/roads etc as well as holiday prices will be higher if everyone is trying to travel at the same time. If schools don’t all have the same weeks it will be hard if you have children at different schools/want to see friends or relatives with children at different schools.

higher pressure on exam marking. If teachers get less time off in the summer they may be less inclined to do marking as combined with prep for next school year they won’t be left with much holiday.

will make it harder for people who have family abroad to visit them/ spend time with them as less likely to have holiday overlap/restricted in length of time you can go etc.

the school years will all merge in each other a lot more with a shorter break.

milveycrohn · 28/02/2024 08:20

@Elephantswillnever
"Six weeks is a complete pita for childcare. Two weeks off each covers four weeks so that would be better. I appreciate other people manage to do stuff as a family etc."
But it's the same number of school days and holidays. It's just that the holidays are moved to October / February and Christmas, when the weather is not as good. Older children have exams in June, so extra holiday in May is out of the question.
Everybody will be trying to squash their summer holiday into the same 4 weeks (unless different schools have a different 4 weeks, but then you may have children with different holidays).
Unless you are fortunate to go abroad in those days out of season, then having your holiday in October is definitely not as good.
I speak as someone who worked first part time, and then full time, with my DH also working, and yes, we have been away in October, etc. and have had to juggle holidays at other times. Cornwall in October is not nearly as good.....
But during the summer there are a few summer camps. We did this 2 years running, for one week (for 2 out of 3 DC, as youngest was too young). It was expensive, yes, which is why we only did it twice.
However, it is easier to get childminders and other family members to look after DC during the summer, knowing they can take them outside for quite a bit of time.

MrsMurphyIWish · 28/02/2024 06:29

If this does happen, then the 4 weeks will have to be moved to July rather than August or primary and secondary schools may have different holidays. Our whole exam system - the exams, the marking, the results, A-levels, UCAS - is all based around the current academic year.

Elephantswillnever · 28/02/2024 06:26

Six weeks is a complete pita for childcare. Two weeks off each covers four weeks so that would be better. I appreciate other people manage to do stuff as a family etc.

YourGreatLemonShark · 28/02/2024 06:23

I wouldn’t want to shorten the holidays. I work full time, but never have an issue covering it. She loves the long holidays, I wouldn’t want it cut down.

Can you imagine the price hikes for summer holidays if they are condensed to 4 weeks? Which 4 weeks do you choose? August is always the crappest montyh weather wise. No thanks to shortening the holidays from me!

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 28/02/2024 05:20

Everyone trying to fit holidays and getting time off work into the same 4 weeks will be very difficult. Holidays other times of year are not as easy due to the weather not being as good

Autienotnaughtie · 28/02/2024 05:00

Definitely 4. The system is based on a archaic time when often families had one parent at home, or siblings looked after each other or friends/relatives helped out. Now most kids are stuck in childcare anyway.

I do think something should be done about holiday prices tho. It's unfair to insist we can only go away at set times but then companies charge significantly more for those times.

Meadowfinch · 28/02/2024 03:47

DS's independent school has just consulted on breaking up later before Christmas and adding the extra week to the summer so he would break up about the 7th July and have eight weeks off. He loves the idea.

So we seem to be going in the opposite direction.

YankSplaining · 28/02/2024 02:44

As an American, I’m used to about three months’ summer vacation, so the idea of cutting a six-week break to four weeks sounds borderline barbaric.

sashh · 28/02/2024 02:19

KvotheTheBloodless · 03/02/2024 14:39

The reasoning behind it is that the most disadvantaged children fall further behind over summer, as their parents don't read with them or do anything educational - they arrive back in school after 6 weeks of mainly screen time having forgotten how to sit and concentrate, and their reading and maths skills have dropped too.

For this reason alone I think it's a good idea. The better off majority needs to compromise for the sake of the less fortunate minority.

But surely it would be better to implement something in the holidays for these children.

shearwater2 · 27/02/2024 14:09

Just do everything Finland does with education. No exams, more holidays, no pressure, start formal schooling later, teachers teach what they want and get better educational outcomes.

shearwater2 · 27/02/2024 14:05

I don't agree with four weeks, keep six weeks but start the holidays at the end of June.

Justkeepswimmingswimming · 27/02/2024 12:05

Comedycook · 03/02/2024 14:30

Agree. 4 weeks sounds better. Six is too long and my kids start to get bored and fed up. Most mums work nowadays so it is actually just a childcare nightmare for a lot of people rather than a relaxing break

But you would still need the same amount of childcare but it would be in February and October so mostly outdoor summer sports camps which tend to be staffed partly by uni students wouldn’t be available. So there would be less childcare available and it would be more expensive.

Shinyandnew1 · 27/02/2024 11:58

I get some like the routine and some need the childcare

Thought this might make things much worse. Having two weeks off in February and October is going to make it much harder for parents to source childcare than with a 6 week block. The summer clubs are often predominantly staffed by university students who have the summer off.