Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what baby item(s) we shouldn’t waste money on?

160 replies

Mummytooobe · 03/02/2024 13:44

What did you buy but never used or thought was pointless?

We were looking at picking up a Moses on marketplace but by the time we’ve done that and bought a new mattress, we might as well have bought an entirely new one. Happy to do so but not if you didn’t use it.

What DIDN’T you use?

On our must-have list we have:

  • Brand new mattresses for all baby sleeping places
  • Ultra safe infant car seat (looking at the Avionaut or Maxi Cosi models)
  • Supportive baby carrier like the ergobaby
  • Compact buggy for after 6 months

We have also picked up a second hand Mamaroo swing for very cheap, so we’re pleased with that. Planning on breastfeeding so not getting any bottles or prep machines unless we need to.

What don’t we need? Please de-influence me!

OP posts:
PenguinLove1 · 03/02/2024 17:41

Didnt use any of these much at all -

  • swing (he hated it and was a faff to use and noise was annoying)
  • moses basket (he wouldn't sleep in it, preferred carrycot from pram
  • diaper bin thing - just put in outside bin
  • changing table - just stuck a mat on the floor most of the time
  • loads of neutral clothes bought before i knew what he was - i liked him in blue once he was born
  • baby shoes etc - dont stay on and dont look comfortable

What i loved-

  • very basic bouncy chair
  • rocking nursing chair and footstool in nursery - helped me get some rest during the long nights baby wasnt settling
  • curved nursing pillow - this is a brilliant must have, fits round your stomach and baby can test on top in your arms - saves you raking the weight.
  • millions of muslins

I would honestly buy a few bottles, steriliser and have some emergency ready made formula, and have a few dummies just in case - i didnt think i would need either but couldnt breastfeed after massive blood loss and ended up in the supermarket on the way home from hospital having to buy some which wasnt great looking back

wubwubwub · 03/02/2024 17:40

The joy of living on the modern woo is that you can get stuff delivered to you within hours and shops are open 24hrs.

Don't buy anything gimmicky.

And if you find you need something, get it.

BertieBotts · 03/02/2024 17:38

Sometimes the bundles do work out cheaper - it's worth checking if there are specific accessories that you want. A lot of the time though IME they are padded out with stuff that you don't necessarily need so that they LOOK better value.

afkonholidaynearleek · 03/02/2024 17:36

We used a Moses basket all the time with our DCs until they were about three months old

❌ White noise machine
❌ Changing table - just use a mat on a normal table, chest of drawers or keep it under the sofa
❌ Cot - until you need it
❌ Baby monitor - until you need it

OneMoreTime23 · 03/02/2024 17:31

Didn’t have:

Moses basket
baby bath
changing unit
Fussy outfits
nursing chair
Puree maker

Did have:

Second hand hammock (with new mattress)
vibrating bouncy chair
Stokke travel system (didn’t get a second pushchair)
hand pump and some bottles + steriliser
baby gros for first 6 months

DD mainly slept in bed with me. Downstairs she slept on me, in the bouncy chair or carry cot on the pram. When she got bigger she started the night sleep in the hammock then came in with me later.

I planned to breastfeed but she had some issues that meant it couldn’t happen. I expressed for her for a year, first with the hand pump then with a hospital grade one.

She came in the bath with me.

DH worked away 5.5 days a week so I had to do what worked for us.

When she hit 6 months she had bits of what/we were eating. Never pureed or mashed anything.

Mummytooobe · 03/02/2024 17:26

@BertieBotts thank you so much for taking the time to write something so detailed and informative. All parents to be should read that comment!!

OP posts:
lieselotte · 03/02/2024 17:24

Baby alarm. I bought one, and I was given one, and didn't use either of them!

BertieBotts · 03/02/2024 17:23

I honestly think stuff like a Moses Basket and nursing chair are personal - I didn't want to go to a specific chair to breastfeed, I just breastfed wherever I was and as cosleeping did night feeds in bed. Once baby is in their own room, a comfortable chair is nice to have but I would wait and see what you want once they are that age - it's hard to know what is comfy for BF until you've done it.

We used the carrycot like a moses basket in the living room with both the younger DC, with DC1 I had one of the big old fashioned bouncers and put him down in that basically from birth, or just laid him on a blanket. But I also just held him a lot.

BertieBotts · 03/02/2024 17:20

I used to work in a baby stuff shop, and I have 3 DC.

I don't think the super expensive car seats are worth it personally. You can spend £450 on a top end one with a rotating base etc or you can spend £120 on a basic one with optional £80-100 on base, and just rotate it however you like in the house which is where you actually put the baby in and out of it anyway. They are just as safe (if you buy a decent brand with good side impact protection etc). And actually, even the brands that usually do poorly for safety ratings tend to have a fairly decent safety rating on their infant seat, because the infant carrier being rear facing is extremely safe to begin with.

(There is nothing wrong with the expensive ones and they do have different features. If the feature is worth the difference in price, then fair enough - but you should know what you're paying for.)

I didn't use swaddles or scratch mitts, didn't like them.

Snow suits utterly hated these, faffy pointless things. Just use blankets.

Don't get a massive bundle with a million extras on a pram - it's usually cheaper to buy the pram unit itself separately and then you can pick and choose what accessories you actually want. Universal raincovers are generally fine, though get one from Boots, supermarket etc not Amazon, you don't need a matching changing bag (unless you want to, but again, know what you're paying for). Parasols are totally pointless, rarely stay up and don't work properly. If you are going somewhere sunny, a UV net or shade is better. In the UK, you can just angle the buggy or place it in the shade. You generally need the proper car seat adapters, if you want to use the car seat on the buggy. Maxi Cosi ones take most brands (Cybex, Britax, M-C, Nuna, Joie, Besafe, Avionaut) not just the short list that they usually say on the website, but it has to be an "infant" type - things like Joie 360 Spin can't go on any pram. You can get away without buying a carrycot, if the pram has a lie-flat (esp parent-facing) mode, but a carrycot is a bit nicer, more contained and has a proper mattress - some are even approved to use for overnight sleep. This can be helpful if you plan to do a lot of walking or you want to use the carrycot in the house, or travel when LO is younger.

Purpose-built co-sleeper cots are generally faffy, don't last very long and not that good. Get an IKEA cot, or any cotbed and convert it instead if you want a co-sleeper type cot.

Actually IKEA furniture in general is brilliant for babies and SO much less expensive than the overpriced nursery sets. It used to boggle my mind seeing people come in and spend 3k on a nursery set when you could have got the lot for a few hundred pounds down the road at IKEA!

Modern style baby bouncers with the teeny tiny round seat are not as good as the old fashioned ones which were huge. Only the Baby Bjorn one (and copycats) are like this now - these are worth having, but they are more expensive so might not be worth it. If you want a cheaper style, it's worth getting something like a rocker, or a swing with a motor. You can wait and see for these if it's something that seems useful for your baby or not. It is helpful to have a "parking space" for the baby in different areas of the house, before they can crawl. I think personally the laid back bouncers/rockers etc are better for them than seats like the Bumbo. I am not keen on the pillow things like Snuggle Nest - I think they are misleadingly marketed (and too expensive).

If you want to use a baby bath, the Shnuggle one is meant to be the best and if you need to use an in-bath bath support, the Angelcare one is the best. Before you buy any kind of baby bath insert, try kneeling down next to your bath (preferably early in pregnancy without a bump, or get your partner to!) for 10 minutes leaning your arms into the bath. It is surprisingly uncomfortable. Any kind of tub that you bring out and fill with water is also a bit of a pain. To be honest, I found the easiest way to bath babies is to stick them in the bath with an adult (I made this dad's job otherwise they just wanted to breastfeed) or bath them in a sink.

For slings I'd def recommend a sling library or sling consult rather than going in blind or buying whatever the most recommended model is (which is always Ergo - big marketing budget). Personally I'm a fan of a stretchy wrap for the first 6-8 months and then a soft structured carrier, but a more basic one, not the ones they have now with loads of different modes, but everyone has different preferences.

In general you can get SO many things second hand, doesn't need to be new. (Car seat, dummies and bottles yes). Babies use things for such a short time.

Also, think about whether there's an adult version which is cheaper (e.g. towels - you don't need a baby-specific towel, it's just a smaller version of a normal towel) or an own-brand which is fine (e.g. bottles, dummies - you can get all kinds of brands, Nuk, Mam etc or just get a bog standard Tesco/Boots' own.)

If you are going to buy things new, consider a brick and mortar store especially for expensive/complicated items. Best is an independent nursery specialist, second best is John Lewis/Mamas and Papas, everything else (Smyths, Halfords, Boots, supermarkets) are all a bit hit and miss but still generally easier to deal with than online. The recommendation for only new mattresses has been withdrawn, but it can be nice to have a new one anyway.

Think about washability of things - don't buy a pillow support thing which is sponge clean only.

On this note, get 2x waterproof mattress protectors for your bed. Babies are leaky, and so is late pregnancy/postpartum. Get the nicest one you can as we only felt confident to ditch them once the youngest was over 18m.

Think about whether you'll really need something literally from day one - if not, you can always wait and see if you want it or not. You can save a huge amount of money this way. If you have an urge to shop anyway, scratch the itch by researching and create a list, spreadsheet, amazon wishlist etc.

TheFairyCaravan · 03/02/2024 17:14

DDIL gets lots of use out of her Moses basket. She was given it for free, luckily, and DGS has most of his day time naps in it.

She got a secondhand next to me crib from Facebook marketplace.

DGS hates being properly swaddled but sleeps really well in these love to dream sleeping bags.

They’ve got a lovely high chair, it’s a Joie one I think, which reclines so DGS can sit in it while they’re having their meals.

Swaddle Up 2.5 TOG Blue

Our Swaddle Up Warm in Silly Goose Blue is ideal for cool weather. The innovative wings helps your baby to sleep longer. Shop now at Love To Dream!

https://lovetodream.com/gb-en/all-products-uk/swaddle-up-quilted-cotton?v=12541&_gl=1*lso3u4*_up*MQ..&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIicr7uNSPhAMVaKhoCR3LDwr3EAAYASAAEgKzM_D_BwE

Ihaterhymingrabbit · 03/02/2024 17:08

Mummytooobe · 03/02/2024 14:18

Interesting that everyone is saying Moses basket. I’m just not sure where we’d put baby down in the day?

We got loads of use out of our Moses basket, baby didn’t like the next to me crib as it was too big at first, Moses basket was nice and cosy and we could carry it up and down the stairs while baby was asleep as they are quite light and portable.

Nottodaty · 03/02/2024 17:02

We had a lot use out of Moses basket - we would move it between the living room and our bedroom. Especially with my second I had some where I knew she was safe quickly to deal with the older one.

We didn’t really buy clothes, just sleep suits and vests - we got present so they had a few outfits! But with a sickly baby it was just easier! Muslin squares a must for us! Large ones are good as an easier cover up while feeding.

The other random thing was a travel cot - we had it set up in our bedroom once she moved to her own room and cot. It meant again she was somewhere safe when I had a quick shower or getting ready for work (we kept it up till she was about 2 and half she was safe and cold play with her toys) also if she was restless or poorly it meant she could sleep in it, close to me and I would sleep better!

and we just had a basic baby bouncer. Once she was too old for a Moses basket she had somewhere safe and I would put one of those toys that had the toys hanging down for her to play. Meant I could do something else for five minutes!

Blanketpolicy · 03/02/2024 16:56

No need for moses basket, crib, next to me etc. A lie flat pram is ok for naps downstairs and baby can sleep in their cot next to your bed from day 1 (swaddled in a blanket). Baby sleeping bags are a must have.

Car seats are a must have too.

No need to baby furniture - it is cute but usually expensive, cheaply made and has a very short life span.

We used our gliding chair a lot - used to feed during the night in early weeks, but mainly used it to read bedtime stories for years or for a cuddle/to soothe ds if he woke during the night. It was then used in my bedroom (mostly to throw clothes on!) for 15 years until I gave it to my niece for her baby who has also used a lot.

Travel systems not needed. The pram bit is good, the car seat bit can be useful. The buggy parts, which are the longest used part of the system, are poor and there are much better buggies out there.

We didn't need a baby monitor as house was small enough to hear, the temperature bit of it was useful. My niece has one with a camera and audio which is cool to see when her dd is stirring without entering the room, and she will sometime settle if she hears her mums voice, but not necessary.

Someone bought niece a huge electric swing/rocking seat - was expensive, took up too much room, not good for baby as not lie flat, and was only used for a couple of months.

suafa · 03/02/2024 16:49

All large supermarkets sell baby items. Given their opening hours, unless you genuinely live in back of beyond, you can pick up extra "essentials" if they are actually needed!

yesminister · 03/02/2024 16:49

i had a crib downstairs (personal reasons why i didn't have a moses basket).

i adapted an ikea cot into a next to me crib (side off cable tied to my bed, all gaps dealt with and the health visitor reviewed it and was very happy). i could slide the baby over for a feed and back again.
although did co sleep as well.

slings - essential in my book. wrap when little and ergo when bigger but finding a sling library is a good idea for trying styles and also good positioning advice.

breastfed so didn't have any bottle or steriliser paraphernalia. good breast feeding tops made such a difference. two vest tops with one pulled up and the other down worked well but i invested in some properly designed ones that were a god send.

i used cloth nappies and washable wipes which developed into quite a hobby and obsession but kept me happy.

ikea high chair is the best. easy to clean, cheap and just does the job so well.

changing mat upstairs and down. changed on the floor downstairs and upstairs on the bed.

never had a nursing chair. good cushions and pillows were the way forward.

did succumb to ewan the sheep (not worth the money).

jumperoo - 1st loved it. 2nd hated it.

spent a lot on the first pushchair/pram combo. only any good if baby fell asleep in the car seat so i could clip them on the frame without disturbing for the sling. got a double when the next one came along and needn't have bothered. always had one in the pushchair and one in a sling. both a waste of money and much cheaper and less insta worthy ones do the job just fine. prams are like weddings, add 50% to the real cost just to tug on heartstrings.

muslins great for shoulder carry/winding.

did have a baby monitor as lived in 3 story house.

always have a sandwich cut into 1/4's ready made. one handed eating when breast feeding or just pinned down with a sleeping baby on your chest is a life saver. i had been known to have one during the night if the need arose.

they don't need many toys at all for a while. cuddles, chatting, singing and lots of eye contact is all a teeny needs.

old fashioned baby bouncer is just fine. all these swinging, singing chairs just set you up for a mad panic when the batteries run out and you need 4 AA's and you only have 3!

Bumbo - what was i thinking?

Baby bath - i had one but used it in the big bath. after c sec no way i could carry it.

long phone charger - night feeds with my phone on charge as i discovered mumsnet for the first time saved my sanity!

Caspianberg · 03/02/2024 16:45

We didn’t have a Moses basket, but as a a small baby Ds would never have allowed us to just put him down to sleep.
So usually fed to sleep then napped next to me on bed or on me on sofa. Or just put him on floor blanket or baby bouncer. 99% of naps were taken in pram though so he could be rocked or walked around block to sleep then park up inside. Just used that to put baby in also daytime if he did fall asleep on me.

Never used a full changing bag ( just a bag we already had), or baby play mat (just blanket folded), or play gym.

Changing Mat ontop of chest of drawers as changing station in baby room we used every single time we changed nappy at home for 2+ years (until no nappies)

Snowdropsarecoming · 03/02/2024 16:37

Mummytooobe · 03/02/2024 14:18

Interesting that everyone is saying Moses basket. I’m just not sure where we’d put baby down in the day?

You don’t or they scream.

Burpcloth · 03/02/2024 16:34

Another vote for the handiness of a downstairs moses basket (but the pram bassinet wasn't an option for us so maybe we might have stuck with that if it was). Even if it's just for the first few sleepy newborn weeks. I found it handy that the stand stood her at a nice height for me to sleep next to her on the sofa too.

Got a plastic shnuggle one with stand for £10 on marketplace, mattress was £15 from shnuggle direct.

I love these threads as everyone is so different. So many people down voting on baby baths but the one thing I go out of my way to really rate is the Shnuggle bath (or any brand if it's this sit up style with a bump for their bum). My daughter used it 0-18months and saved us ever filling a whole bath.

Peachyscream · 03/02/2024 16:32

Get the absolute essentials now, research, pick and add to your ‘save for later’ Amazon basket. Then make sure you have prime and order if you NEED them.

Thedance · 03/02/2024 16:26

I think a next to me bed is more useful than a moses basket. You can use the pram for sleeping in the day if you have a baby that will sleep away from you that is.
I would also add a sling to your list.They are invaluable if you have a baby that won't be put down.

determinedtomakethiswork · 03/02/2024 16:24

slowerprofessor · 03/02/2024 14:01

Nursing chair, no. You can use any chair. See also: changing table. Just put a changing mat on a chest of drawers. Moses basket - no need. They can sleep anywhere. If you decide once the baby has arrived that you actually do need one, you can get one then.

But where are you going to put the baby on the first day out of hospital?

Glittertwins · 03/02/2024 16:21

Mummytooobe · 03/02/2024 14:18

Interesting that everyone is saying Moses basket. I’m just not sure where we’d put baby down in the day?

On a soft mat or sheet, much easier.

I'd also get things that can grow with the baby as well. We had one (albeit twin) Jané buggy which was so easy on all surfaces, one change bag that clipped to buggy handle, one set of Stokke TrippTrapp chairs which we still use as spare chairs around the house years later.
We did not bother with baby monitor, nappy bins, nursing chair, white noise machine, cot beds.

Pacifybull · 03/02/2024 16:21

We used the Moses basket a lot with both DC. Wouldn’t have been without it.

However, we didn’t have a carrycot or any sort of pram system. We didn’t have a pram at all. We used a sling. We got an umbrella fold buggy later.

We didn’t have:
baby monitor
changing table
nursing chair
nursery
changing bag

newlaptop12 · 03/02/2024 16:20

Expensive buggy/travel system. I had a Maclaren which lasted for both kids. Cannot believe people pay well over £1000 just for the name.

FriendlyNeighbourhoodAccountant · 03/02/2024 16:19

For us a moses basket was essential. Our house is over 3 floors and I had a C-section so the fewer times I had to walk up and down the stairs to put the baby down for a nap the better to be honest. Realistically they should be sleeping in the same room as you while very young, I didn't feel comfortable being on a separate floor during the day while they were napping. We also have a dog though, I know some parents have a newborn mat/insert that they used on the sofa but I wanted the baby out of the way so the dog didn't accidentally sit on them. We also didn't have a bassinet on our pushchair, just used a pushchair suitable from birth rather than a travel system with a carrycot which is what a lot of people who don't have a moses basket use.