Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it deflating that majority of children's song/book characters are "he"?

114 replies

Radradrad · 03/02/2024 09:14

To name some examples:
Five Little Monkeys (fell off and bumped HIS head. Every monkey in that song is male).

Miss Polly Had a Dolly (male doctor, though being a female doctor myself I always sing over it with "she") 😂 actually more accurate since the majority of GP's are women.

Don't get me started on dinosaurs in books and songs, no wonder the dinosaurs went extinct as it seems there wasn't a single female dinosaur?

And then shows like Hey Duggee, which I actually do like, but there are 6 main characters and only two are female. Why?! And I downright refuse to have Octonauts on as none of the main characters are female.

Omg one more thing, the fact EVERYONE thinks Bluey is a boy when she is a girl! Just because she isnt pink/wearing a dress. Asda even have her on boys underwear!

Is it just me?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
2031MummyTBC · 06/02/2024 12:49

Fair enough, I couldn't scroll past that one, sorry! Justice for Lilo, who is a great female character!✊

MasterBeth · 06/02/2024 12:33

2031MummyTBC · 04/02/2024 21:17

I'm sorry, I have to take a stand here. @MasterBeth, Lilo and Stich does not have a male protagonist. Stitch can't even talk, Lilo is the main character.

You may well be right. It's been a long time!

We saw it at the cinema and I think my youngest was terrified by it, so I may not have been paying full attention!

Workawayxx · 05/02/2024 14:36

Needmorelego · 03/02/2024 11:22

@Workawayxx have you not read The Gruffalo's Child?
The Gruffalo is the Dad, the child is a girl.

Sorry, just saw this. Yes, Gruffalo's child is a big favourite here 😊. It's just one of few.

2031MummyTBC · 04/02/2024 21:17

I'm sorry, I have to take a stand here. @MasterBeth, Lilo and Stich does not have a male protagonist. Stitch can't even talk, Lilo is the main character.

TempestTost · 04/02/2024 21:05

Gunpowder · 04/02/2024 15:42

That’s the one I was thinking of! Female animals are only allowed to be SAHMs or nurses. Glad to hear some of the books have been updated as they are otherwise interesting and fun.

There are female characters who aren't SAHM or nurses in Richard Scarry. Officer Flossy.. Or the mouse who is a mechanic.

But at the time they were written, lots more women were SAHM than are now. So it's not like it's unrealistic.

TempestTost · 04/02/2024 20:57

Books like Dear Zoo are old enough that it was normative to use the male pronoun when the sex was unknown, especially for animals. Similarly to the way 'man" could be used to mean both human or a male person, depending on the context.

I find when younger people read books like that now the assumption tends to be that they were all meant to be male animals, whereas the reality is that the reader was meant to understand it as meaning the sex isn't known. (Or really, would pick that up intuitively, as most of us wouldn't stop to consider the sex of imaginary animals in a kid's story.)

Anyone who is bothered now can use "she" for some , or I suppose "they" if preferred.

Needmorelego · 04/02/2024 20:47

@Iwasafool ok so Gentle Ben and Littlest Hobo were both boys and played by (various) boys.
But in the TV series Woof about a human boy who turns into a dog - the dog was played by the famous Pippin the Dog who was female.
Go Pippin !

TempestTost · 04/02/2024 20:44

Cushionsandcaramel · 03/02/2024 18:26

My daughter grew up thinking that doctors were all female and nurses were male, because of a book we had.

Am also a female doctor and our family doctor was female too, so that reinforced the idea for her. She was very surprised when she found out that doctors could be male!

My son thought for a while doctors were all women, because all the GPs he'd seen were women. It was a bit funny because his grandfather is a doctor, but I suppose he never really saw him at work.

Kids often over-generalize when they are young, I don't think it makes much difference long term.

Needmorelego · 04/02/2024 20:39

@Iwasafool ok a quick Google says Skippy was female and she was played by 9 different kangaroos. Google doesn't say if they were male or female 😂
Now to Google Gentle Ben and The Littlest Hobo.....

Iwasafool · 04/02/2024 20:37

Needmorelego · 04/02/2024 20:34

@Iwasafool I think Skippy the Bush Kangaroo was a boy but played by a girl 😂🤔
I will Google......

Well these trans animal actors are everywhere. So confusing!

On a serious note it is weird isn't it, I mean there must be loads of female Collies and male kangaroos.

Needmorelego · 04/02/2024 20:34

@Iwasafool I think Skippy the Bush Kangaroo was a boy but played by a girl 😂🤔
I will Google......

Iwasafool · 04/02/2024 20:28

Gunpowder · 04/02/2024 15:42

That’s the one I was thinking of! Female animals are only allowed to be SAHMs or nurses. Glad to hear some of the books have been updated as they are otherwise interesting and fun.

Lassie was a heroic dog, maybe she doesn't count as she was trans as the "actor" portraying her was born male. Disgusting really, pushing his way in and robbing a born female of her right to be the star. In fact more than one male dog played Lassie and I don't think she was ever played by a female dog.

I still loved Lassie when I was a child, wouldn't miss an episode.

I'm wondering about Champion the Wonder Horse now.

Gunpowder · 04/02/2024 15:42

Needmorelego · 04/02/2024 11:11

@Gunpowder I think some Richard Scarry books have been slightly updated.
But the one bit in "What Do People Do All Day" where the mummy pig ends up in the bunk beds with the children while the husband snores happily away in his bed is the most realistic parenting scene in a children's book ever 😂😂

That’s the one I was thinking of! Female animals are only allowed to be SAHMs or nurses. Glad to hear some of the books have been updated as they are otherwise interesting and fun.

YankSplaining · 04/02/2024 14:44

2mummies1baby · 04/02/2024 11:14

@Needmorelego - I think you are massively missing the point. I don't think it's acceptable to have a children's book with five characters, all of whom are male. You are free to disagree. I think children do pick up on it and internalise that 'male = default'.

My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic has six main characters, and they’re all female. (A New Generation put one token male in the main five characters.) There’s nothing wrong with all-male main characters in books or TV or movies, as long as other things have all-female main characters or mixed-sex main characters to balance it out.

Quoting from a different post:

We haven’t really watched Octonaughts but I didn’t know there was no girls.

There aren’t “no girls” - there are six males and two females. My daughters like that Tweak, the female bunny character, is an engineer “just like Daddy.” 🙂

bakewellbride · 04/02/2024 14:17

My kids are 5 and nearly 2 and I used to teach little children and I don't 'get' any of this. Plenty of female characters all around. Can't get worked up about Bluey being on boys' underwear/ clothes. My son loves Bluey and obviously knows she's a girl, why shouldn't he have clothes / underwear with them on as an option? Seem to be trying hard to find something to get annoyed about op.

Needmorelego · 04/02/2024 11:56

@2mummies1baby yes we will have to agree to disagree.
Like I said - I've not done research (other than being a volunteer reader at my daughter's primary so I've read lots of children's books).
🙂

Lovingitallnow · 04/02/2024 11:35

I did caveat with recently which I would describe in the last quarter century. And also that I gave my head a wobble. I'd also argue that Anna and Elsa had more depth and character development in their pinkie fingers than that list excepting wall-e, Tarzan, Aladdin and Hercules. Also most of them are animals.

MasterBeth · 04/02/2024 11:26

Lovingitallnow · 03/02/2024 09:38

Your time will come when almost all the Disney protagonists are female. I found myself frustrated there wasn't more male ones recently before I gave my head a wobble.

Off the top of my head: male Disney/Pixar protagonists:

Mickey
Donald
Goofy
Mowgli
Baloo
Robin Hood
Wart/Arthur
Buzz Lightyear
Woody
Lightning McQueen
Mike
Sully
Nemo/Nemo's dad
Big Hero 6 robot
Pinocchio
Bambi
Peter Pan
Pooh
Remy
Simba
Wall-E
Hercules
Aladdin
Bolt
Wreck-it Ralph
Tarzan
Mr Incredible
Stitch

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 04/02/2024 11:20

If you’re looking for some lovely books with female heroes to read to your kids, I can recommend Sam Gayton. Give The Last Zoo and The Snow Merchant a try, also World Weavers. Better for somewhat older kids, with heroic, real, flaws-and-all girls taking center stage. Love them !!

2mummies1baby · 04/02/2024 11:14

@Needmorelego - I think you are massively missing the point. I don't think it's acceptable to have a children's book with five characters, all of whom are male. You are free to disagree. I think children do pick up on it and internalise that 'male = default'.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 04/02/2024 11:13

Pacifybull · 03/02/2024 09:31

No-one thinks Bluey is a boy, do they? I’ve never heard that.

Little Miss Muffet
Little Bo Peep
Cinderella
Red Riding Hood
Snow White
Goldilocks

These aren’t great role models though.

Little Miss Muffet = frightened away by a spider

Little Bo Peep = so airheaded she lost her sheep, and whatever you do don’t make it worse woman, just leave them alone

Cinderella = woman, you can’t succeed unless you’re all dolled up and get yourself a rich man

Red Riding Hood = dead unless a man with a big tool comes to your aid

Snow White = dead unless a man kisses you

Goldilocks = fussy picky women never happy unless they’re being treated like a child

Needmorelego · 04/02/2024 11:11

@Gunpowder I think some Richard Scarry books have been slightly updated.
But the one bit in "What Do People Do All Day" where the mummy pig ends up in the bunk beds with the children while the husband snores happily away in his bed is the most realistic parenting scene in a children's book ever 😂😂

Gunpowder · 04/02/2024 11:08

I have always changed pronouns as i read/sing if I think it’s at all sexist. Particularly in Richard Scarry books which are gorgeous but ridiculously old fashioned in that way.

Needmorelego · 04/02/2024 11:05

I must live in a parallel universe because I have never noticed this in books, tv or films.
There's plenty of both males and females. Maybe it depends on what you watch and read 🤔

Needmorelego · 04/02/2024 11:03

@2mummies1baby what I meant though do children really read The Gruffalo and think "oh no there's no females in this book"?
To them it's just a mouse, a fox, a snake and an owl.
(I may be wrong - I haven't done research)