Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this what social mobility looks like? Multimillionaire sister / benefit dependant sister

140 replies

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 08:48

A friend of mine in council accommodation entirely reliant on benefits has a sister who is a multimillionaire.

I have been aware of this situation for over a decade, and find it unusual. They seem to be on good terms and visit each other's houses. I know rich sister helped poor sister out once or twice with train fare to family events, but nothing more than that, I don't think.

They come from a fairly average middle class home, father a professional, mother worked part time. Parents remained in their middle class home until father died and mother moved into nursing home.

Both are graduates, both are single mums.

The only time I am aware of it causing any problems are when one cousin ( from council flat) got into trouble at school for "lying" about who her aunty is - she was telling the truth but no one believed her.

I suppose in a truly socially mobile society, this should be common, but I think it is an unusual situation. Perhaps it is more common that I think.

YABU - this is how it should be, and/or this situation is common
YANBU - this is rare.

OP posts:
notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 09:33

Multimillionaire sister set up a business while she was still at university, as a bit of a sideline, but it has taken off and is now international, You will all have heard of it, but most likely not heard of her - no man involved, she never married. Benefit dependant sister married and divorced and gets child maintenance - and every other weekend free. She has a psychology degree but it never lead to much work

OP posts:
determinedtomakethiswork · 03/02/2024 09:29

But the thing is that there's no point buying someone on benefits a house unless you also give them the money to run that house and repair it when it needs it.

Why is one of the sisters on benefits? Why is she not working?

Blanketenvy · 03/02/2024 09:28

I find it odd. I can't imagine being a multi millionaire and not buying a sibling a nice place to live (if they wanted) unless there is some complex backstory, but in my family we help each other out in different ways and are aware that our own financial success or lack of is due to health/disability/circumstance and not just eg irresponsibility.

Resilience · 03/02/2024 09:27

I find this strangely depressing.

I'm at the lower end of being a HR tax payer, which from the perspective of my background is wealthy beyond imagination. I have friends who live in social housing and are dependent on benefits and friends who live in 5-bed detached homes with large gardens and who spend thousands on entertainment. I consider that a form of social mobility - we all get on and there's no judgement on how we all ended up where we are just enjoyment of each other.

I found the point about being self made or benefitting from a connection to a man quite interesting. You could argue that social mobility includes the willingness of people to marry outside of their social-economic class. This was very rare in the past.

I think the example of the sisters illustrates how having children is the biggest barrier for many women. Then your support network (financially and practically) can make a huge difference to your earning potential post children. Being in a position to control that independently of others before you have children is the only way to secure that for definite but is beyond the reach of many.

Pigeon851 · 03/02/2024 09:24

Not unusual for siblings to end up on different salaries (my DB out earns me by some distance) although what you describe is extreme. It sounds like the less well off sister in your scenario has taken a step DOWN the social mobility ladder, though, given what you say about her parents.

6pence · 03/02/2024 09:23

I think it’s a healthy dynamic. Both are happy to enter each others worlds with no resentment or competition. Helping out when necessary but no one beholden to anyone or expecting anything. Doing things that are affordable to both means equality in the relationship, even if there isn’t financial equality.

Spendonsend · 03/02/2024 09:21

I dont think its that unusual for siblings to take very different paths and end up in different places.

i think its unusual to end up a multi-millionnaire though.

User2356542 · 03/02/2024 09:20

BeckyWithTheGoodBear · 03/02/2024 09:15

Is the multi millionaire sister a celebrity?

This was what I wanted to say as well with "an industry accessible to everyone". Becoming a celebrity or social media star is not a realistic career choice for the vast majority of people with degrees. There's more luck involved than anything else. So it's not true social mobility but a really lucky break combined with hard work and a physically attractive appearance. A socially mobile society offers most people the option to earn more based on academic studies, work experience, a business or whatever else they decided to work on. Everyone becoming celebrities is not a remotely realistic or feasible social solution to poverty.

WandaWonder · 03/02/2024 09:17

Unless you are one of the people concerned I would find it weird you know so much

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 03/02/2024 09:17

BeckyWithTheGoodBear · 03/02/2024 09:15

Is the multi millionaire sister a celebrity?

Ah good point, re the people at school 'knowing who she is'!
Is it insta-rich/fame?

BeckyWithTheGoodBear · 03/02/2024 09:15

Is the multi millionaire sister a celebrity?

JustFrustrated · 03/02/2024 09:14

User2356542 · 03/02/2024 09:13

It's obviously very rare but there are also not enough details. In a true socially mobile society, the sister needs to be a self-made multimillionaire in an industry that is related to her degree and that everyone has access to. Is this the case?

If her ex-partner (or their family) was involved in any way then she has not achieved social mobility, she was just lucky or looks attractive. Did her business receive any starting investment/capital from her former partner? Did she get any lump sum or high value asset as part of the divorce?

Sorry to be cynical, but in most cases where a relatively young woman has achieved great success, there is some personal connection to a man (or men) along the way. Whether it be as a partner, divorce settlement, inheritance etc.

If she truly earned her millions via a high-powered salaried job or a startup she created entirely herself then hats off and she deserves a lot of respect and accolade. However the in itself is a total outlier, especially also being a single mum, so it's not a situation that is replicable by other single mums in similar positions.

This is a depressing read.
Not entirely true either.

User2356542 · 03/02/2024 09:13

It's obviously very rare but there are also not enough details. In a true socially mobile society, the sister needs to be a self-made multimillionaire in an industry that is related to her degree and that everyone has access to. Is this the case?

If her ex-partner (or their family) was involved in any way then she has not achieved social mobility, she was just lucky or looks attractive. Did her business receive any starting investment/capital from her former partner? Did she get any lump sum or high value asset as part of the divorce?

Sorry to be cynical, but in most cases where a relatively young woman has achieved great success, there is some personal connection to a man (or men) along the way. Whether it be as a partner, divorce settlement, inheritance etc.

If she truly earned her millions via a high-powered salaried job or a startup she created entirely herself then hats off and she deserves a lot of respect and accolade. However the in itself is a total outlier, especially also being a single mum, so it's not a situation that is replicable by other single mums in similar positions.

AgentProvocateur · 03/02/2024 09:12

I think the question is why one of the graduates is entirely reliant on benefits. Where did their lives diverge, and why?

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 03/02/2024 09:00

What do you mean? 2 sisters ended up doing differently paid jobs? Or has the benefit dependent sister not used her graduate degree for employment or had difficult life circumstances? Why should her sister fund things for her?