Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this what social mobility looks like? Multimillionaire sister / benefit dependant sister

140 replies

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 08:48

A friend of mine in council accommodation entirely reliant on benefits has a sister who is a multimillionaire.

I have been aware of this situation for over a decade, and find it unusual. They seem to be on good terms and visit each other's houses. I know rich sister helped poor sister out once or twice with train fare to family events, but nothing more than that, I don't think.

They come from a fairly average middle class home, father a professional, mother worked part time. Parents remained in their middle class home until father died and mother moved into nursing home.

Both are graduates, both are single mums.

The only time I am aware of it causing any problems are when one cousin ( from council flat) got into trouble at school for "lying" about who her aunty is - she was telling the truth but no one believed her.

I suppose in a truly socially mobile society, this should be common, but I think it is an unusual situation. Perhaps it is more common that I think.

YABU - this is how it should be, and/or this situation is common
YANBU - this is rare.

OP posts:
Grilledsquid · 03/02/2024 10:07

padmorn · 03/02/2024 10:02

@notknowledgeable if I was close to my sibling then yes I would get them onboard. Surely there is an area they can learn or be trained in. Dont think that's too extreme really.

Working with family in business can be hard and break relationships especially when one knows nothing about it.

SportMum1982 · 03/02/2024 10:06

I agree that money doesn’t equal class mobility. I know an incredibly rich family who flaunt their wealth (originally working class and self made) we’re talking multiple high end vehicles. Kids and parents wearing very expensive clothes (I’m talking Hermes not Gucci). But I am aware of old wealth and they’re walking around in hand me downs and drive an old Volvo (no lie)!

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 10:05

Ametora · 03/02/2024 10:03

I cant see any social mobility for the more affluent sister. You said that they come from a fairly average middle class home, father a professional, mother worked part time. So solidly middle class and that is what you describe now. She has not become upper class but is a middle class professional as her father was

The other sister has experienced downward mobility

well, I am talking financially, not about class - she earns probably over 100x what her parents ever did

OP posts:
LonginesPrime · 03/02/2024 10:05

padmorn · 03/02/2024 10:02

@notknowledgeable if I was close to my sibling then yes I would get them onboard. Surely there is an area they can learn or be trained in. Dont think that's too extreme really.

OP isn't one of the siblings, so none of us actually know what conversations have or haven't occurred between these sisters.

Anything could have been discussed and we'd have no idea as we're on the outside of their relationship and personal finances, etc.

Ametora · 03/02/2024 10:03

I cant see any social mobility for the more affluent sister. You said that they come from a fairly average middle class home, father a professional, mother worked part time. So solidly middle class and that is what you describe now. She has not become upper class but is a middle class professional as her father was

The other sister has experienced downward mobility

padmorn · 03/02/2024 10:03

@notknowledgeable are you the rich sister op.

padmorn · 03/02/2024 10:02

@notknowledgeable if I was close to my sibling then yes I would get them onboard. Surely there is an area they can learn or be trained in. Dont think that's too extreme really.

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 10:02

Gallowayan · 03/02/2024 10:00

Sociologists call this "long range social mobility". It is highly unusual. It's more common to be upwardly (or downwardly) mobile over a shorter range. Making lots of money may not equal class mobility and its a credit to both of them that they get on well.

O! There is a word for it! Thank you

OP posts:
LonginesPrime · 03/02/2024 10:01

"How it should be" meaning in a society which has true free mobility, then the starting point of any pair of siblings should have no baring on the end point, and siblings from the same background should have vastly differing outcomes in life - and I am asking if this is actually happening

But you know it's actually happening - you said that it is.

When you say "should", do you really mean "could" though? I assume you're not suggesting that we as a society morally should be striving for that kind of wealth disparity?

Obviously, people end up on benefits for all sorts of reasons, regardless of education or background. Im still unclear as to what you're trying to find out.

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 10:01

padmorn · 03/02/2024 09:59

Why did rich sister not bring the other sister on board with the business perhaps their relationship isn't close.

Why would she? If your sibling started their own business as a teen at university would you want or expect to "be on board"? Anyway, it is in a sector that poorer sister knows nothing about

OP posts:
Gallowayan · 03/02/2024 10:00

Sociologists call this "long range social mobility". It is highly unusual. It's more common to be upwardly (or downwardly) mobile over a shorter range. Making lots of money may not equal class mobility and its a credit to both of them that they get on well.

padmorn · 03/02/2024 09:59

Why did rich sister not bring the other sister on board with the business perhaps their relationship isn't close.

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 09:55

SaunteringOnBy · 03/02/2024 09:47

One sister worked hard and got a bit of luck.
Other sister worked hard and didn't get a bit of luck.

They started average, one went up, one went down.

It's all bollocks anyway.
Money, houses, cars, holidays blah blah blah.

Are they happy?
Some people are happy working 70hour weeks to get a business going

Some are happy working 20 hour weeks to spend time at home.
Some are only happy surrounded by meaningless shite, some are happy having the bare minimum.

I'd be fucking miserable if I had a shit ton of money but no time to spend it. I would fucking hate to have a big house but have to spend so much time working to pay for it that I'm never in it. I'd rather have fuck all and endless time to enjoy it than have everything and no time to enjoy it.

Yes, I have no reason not to think they are both happy, although possibly the poorer one more so than the richer one

OP posts:
SilverBranchGoldenPears · 03/02/2024 09:53

My siblings and I have all done a lot ‚better‘ in terms of career and life than one of our siblings who lives in a council house and now works a minimum wage job after being at home for 20 years. It was life choices. FWIW she is quite the bitter, unpleasant woman with few social skills so it’s a self-fulfilling prophecy.

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 09:52

LonginesPrime · 03/02/2024 09:45

YABU - this is how it should be, and/or this situation is common
YANBU - this is rare.

What do you mean when you ask if this is "how it should be?"

And why are you asking if it's rare or common? How can each individual confirm this? They only know their own circle.

It sounds like these are just two people living their lives and you feel that their respective financial situations define them in some way that's more meaningful for wider society. What are you actually asking?

"How it should be" meaning in a society which has true free mobility, then the starting point of any pair of siblings should have no baring on the end point, and siblings from the same background should have vastly differing outcomes in life - and I am asking if this is actually happening

OP posts:
MesCroissants · 03/02/2024 09:52

This is fairly outing to anyone who knows them or you, which doesn't matter as long as you're ok with fishing for opinion on their situation as you see it and gossiping!

Neither of their situations is particularly unusual from their starting point, although the scale of the rich sister's success probably is. It will be more unusual for such a difference to exist between siblings, and much more unusual between siblings who get on!

There is a range of outcomes between me and my siblings, although nowhere near as wide as this. As long as we're all doing ok then it's all good, although as you are possibly fishing for, if I was very very wealthy and my sibling was struggling I would help them out if they'd accept it. But you can't know the individual situation and their private conversations.

SaunteringOnBy · 03/02/2024 09:47

One sister worked hard and got a bit of luck.
Other sister worked hard and didn't get a bit of luck.

They started average, one went up, one went down.

It's all bollocks anyway.
Money, houses, cars, holidays blah blah blah.

Are they happy?
Some people are happy working 70hour weeks to get a business going

Some are happy working 20 hour weeks to spend time at home.
Some are only happy surrounded by meaningless shite, some are happy having the bare minimum.

I'd be fucking miserable if I had a shit ton of money but no time to spend it. I would fucking hate to have a big house but have to spend so much time working to pay for it that I'm never in it. I'd rather have fuck all and endless time to enjoy it than have everything and no time to enjoy it.

LonginesPrime · 03/02/2024 09:45

YABU - this is how it should be, and/or this situation is common
YANBU - this is rare.

What do you mean when you ask if this is "how it should be?"

And why are you asking if it's rare or common? How can each individual confirm this? They only know their own circle.

It sounds like these are just two people living their lives and you feel that their respective financial situations define them in some way that's more meaningful for wider society. What are you actually asking?

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 03/02/2024 09:43

My inlaws are millionaires, after being able to take advantage of the housing market.

My husband and I have lived without working heating, and unable to afford to eat and they refused to help us (we had a baby and a toddler at the time) as we were hit badly by the financial crash in the early 00s.

So, yes, in my experience it isn't unusual for families to be split so massively in their financial status and not assist in any way.

Thankfully we clawed ourselves up and are doing okay now..

quisensoucie · 03/02/2024 09:41

@notknowledgeable I am struggling to understand why this is any of your business, nor why you choose to broadcast yourfriend's social situation all over a national forum.

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 09:38

determinedtomakethiswork · 03/02/2024 09:29

But the thing is that there's no point buying someone on benefits a house unless you also give them the money to run that house and repair it when it needs it.

Why is one of the sisters on benefits? Why is she not working?

She is working, she is a TA.

OP posts:
notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 09:38

JustFrustrated · 03/02/2024 09:14

This is a depressing read.
Not entirely true either.

No, I agree, it is not true! men are just as likely to drag women down as give them a leg up, and the reverse is true too

OP posts:
notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 09:36

Pigeon851 · 03/02/2024 09:24

Not unusual for siblings to end up on different salaries (my DB out earns me by some distance) although what you describe is extreme. It sounds like the less well off sister in your scenario has taken a step DOWN the social mobility ladder, though, given what you say about her parents.

Well yes, she has, but surely that IS social mobility - it works in both directions

OP posts:
notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 09:35

User2356542 · 03/02/2024 09:13

It's obviously very rare but there are also not enough details. In a true socially mobile society, the sister needs to be a self-made multimillionaire in an industry that is related to her degree and that everyone has access to. Is this the case?

If her ex-partner (or their family) was involved in any way then she has not achieved social mobility, she was just lucky or looks attractive. Did her business receive any starting investment/capital from her former partner? Did she get any lump sum or high value asset as part of the divorce?

Sorry to be cynical, but in most cases where a relatively young woman has achieved great success, there is some personal connection to a man (or men) along the way. Whether it be as a partner, divorce settlement, inheritance etc.

If she truly earned her millions via a high-powered salaried job or a startup she created entirely herself then hats off and she deserves a lot of respect and accolade. However the in itself is a total outlier, especially also being a single mum, so it's not a situation that is replicable by other single mums in similar positions.

Yes, her degree is accessible to anyone with the grades..surely all degrees are? And no, no leg up from anyone

OP posts:
Allfur · 03/02/2024 09:35

Rich sister sounds tight, poor sister sounds like she needs to sort her life out