Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this what social mobility looks like? Multimillionaire sister / benefit dependant sister

140 replies

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 08:48

A friend of mine in council accommodation entirely reliant on benefits has a sister who is a multimillionaire.

I have been aware of this situation for over a decade, and find it unusual. They seem to be on good terms and visit each other's houses. I know rich sister helped poor sister out once or twice with train fare to family events, but nothing more than that, I don't think.

They come from a fairly average middle class home, father a professional, mother worked part time. Parents remained in their middle class home until father died and mother moved into nursing home.

Both are graduates, both are single mums.

The only time I am aware of it causing any problems are when one cousin ( from council flat) got into trouble at school for "lying" about who her aunty is - she was telling the truth but no one believed her.

I suppose in a truly socially mobile society, this should be common, but I think it is an unusual situation. Perhaps it is more common that I think.

YABU - this is how it should be, and/or this situation is common
YANBU - this is rare.

OP posts:
Moier · 03/02/2024 12:18

@thetheduchessofspork

Thankyou for your kind words.

DreadPirateRobots · 03/02/2024 12:18

The poorer sister has a council tenancy, which potentially sounds like a better option for her than an owned property she wouldn't financially be able to maintain. She has a lifetime tenancy with manageable rent that benefits can support if necessary, and she never has to worry about paying if the boiler blows up or the roof falls off.

It's also awfully easy to talk about how much you'd help everybody out when the money in question is pure pie in the sky. Introducing financial dependence into close family relationships rarely does much for the relationship, on either side.

OriginalUsername2 · 03/02/2024 12:13

Being a millionaire doesn’t mean she has a million pounds spare in cash.

And we are not responsible for our grown siblings in any way.

Crumpleton · 03/02/2024 12:05

I honestly don't think where you end up is a product of where you start or qualifications, it's aptitude, attitude and drive.

Totally agree with this.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 03/02/2024 12:03

I don't know what my only sibling earns but I'd guess about 3x what I did in my last job. The fundamental difference is that I've been disabled since my mid-20s, with a disability that hugely affected my choice of work.

Dibbydoos · 03/02/2024 11:57

My brother's a multimillionaire, my sister and I are not.

My brother chose to get into IT/robotics, I went into sustainability and my sister has mainly been in administrative jobs, she is now PA and office manager to a self made man, ie has a great job.

I went to uni my siblings didnt.

I have had a great career, my legacy will live on but won't be assigned to me, lol! I live well as do my family. I have been involved in some amazing inventions that haven't yet taken off, maybe I'll get mega rich one day 🤣 willing I do, I will set my kids/step kids/ family up then give the rest away.

My sister, following divorce years ago, lives with a guy who owns an ex council house in a good area. She lives well.

We were all brought up on a council estate.

I honestly don't think where you end up is a product of where you start or qualifications, it's aptitude, attitude and drive.

Social mobility is open to all. You just have to want it.

Crumpleton · 03/02/2024 11:49

I'm not rich, did part time work while DC were at school, struggled when they were small money wise but so do thousands of others, DH and I bob along in life earning what we work for, mortgage but can manage as we live within my means. In our 60's.

Older sibling, worked from 16-19, had children, split with partner many years ago has been on benifits ever since.

Used to help out but then one day I needed to see the dentist due to tooth pain realised they were becoming entitled and would happily see me go without when they said I was selfish not giving the money over to them which I needed to spend getting myself pain free.

So no I personally don't find it odd that one sibling isn't giving handouts to the other.
It can be a case of the more you give the more they want.

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 11:48

MumUndone · 03/02/2024 11:43

I think the more unusual aspect of this situation is that both sisters are from the same, middle class background and both have degrees, but one has ended up in council housing reliant on benefits. I suppose it's indicative of social mobility but the wrong way round, going 'down' rather than 'up'.

But there is always going to be a down if there is an up - one person getting a university place or job means another doesn't. One person cornering the market means another company loses it. Social mobility is always both ways

OP posts:
Fionaville · 03/02/2024 11:48

If I was the rich sister, I would help the younger one out. To me, there is no pleasure in financial success, if your loved ones are left struggling.
Maybe it's just me, but when I daydream about winning the Euro lottery rollover, high on the list is how much I'd give my loved ones and my community.
I do believe that anyone who is a multi millionaire, has had a certain amount of luck. Hard work alone isn't enough. A few things have had to fall into place at the right time, for it to be achievable. Most millionaires won't acknowledge this. If they did, maybe they'd be a bit more generous.

MumUndone · 03/02/2024 11:43

I think the more unusual aspect of this situation is that both sisters are from the same, middle class background and both have degrees, but one has ended up in council housing reliant on benefits. I suppose it's indicative of social mobility but the wrong way round, going 'down' rather than 'up'.

CrappySack · 03/02/2024 11:39

theduchessofspork · 03/02/2024 11:30

There’s no should about it, but it’s normal for siblings who get on to help each other in life.

I couldn’t be successful and see my sister struggle, and I think that would be most people’s take on it.

Exactly.

Who wants to be a Scrooge McDuck with a mountain of gold coins while their siblings that they get along with struggle.

PhoenixStarbeamer · 03/02/2024 11:37

Talkamongstyourselves · 03/02/2024 11:27

From your OP

A friend of mine in council accommodation entirely reliant on benefits

So she's totally reliant on benefits yet she is working? It's 1 or the other not both. Working and receiving top-up benefits is different to being entirely reliant on benefits.

I think you have an agenda here.

Yes but for example me, I work every day but it's classed as part time, single mum to a disabled child. I pay full rent, get no housing benefit but I am totally reliant on my tax credits benefit payment every Friday to buy food and heat our home. If one week was missed I'd be screwed. So I kind of get what OP means.

PhoenixStarbeamer · 03/02/2024 11:33

I think it's getting more normal. Why should rich sister pay for poor sister to live.

thaegumathteth · 03/02/2024 11:31

My brother is a multimillionaire. My sister earns about 25k as does her husband. My husband earns £55k and I am a sahm at the moment. So we all are different. I would never expect or accept money from my brother. He has helped mum though with care costs recently which is definitely a blessing for us all.

theduchessofspork · 03/02/2024 11:30

chantelion · 03/02/2024 11:27

@theduchessofspork and why on earth should they??? All adults here, all made their choices.

There’s no should about it, but it’s normal for siblings who get on to help each other in life.

I couldn’t be successful and see my sister struggle, and I think that would be most people’s take on it.

theduchessofspork · 03/02/2024 11:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Talkamongstyourselves · 03/02/2024 11:27

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 09:38

She is working, she is a TA.

From your OP

A friend of mine in council accommodation entirely reliant on benefits

So she's totally reliant on benefits yet she is working? It's 1 or the other not both. Working and receiving top-up benefits is different to being entirely reliant on benefits.

I think you have an agenda here.

chantelion · 03/02/2024 11:27

@theduchessofspork and why on earth should they??? All adults here, all made their choices.

chantelion · 03/02/2024 11:26

Allfur · 03/02/2024 09:35

Rich sister sounds tight, poor sister sounds like she needs to sort her life out

Why tight? She made success happen for her, so why does she have to just hand it out? They were both raised the same yet took different paths.
I know siblings in exactly the same situation. One hugely successful, very wealthy but worked insanely hard to achieve that. The other two siblings also had the opportunity to study, use their degrees to pursue a career path but didn't. One chose to start a family early and didn't do anything after that, the other expected to ride on the coattails of the wealthy sibling . Suffice to say that the wealthy one won't do anything for the user sibling yet always looks like the bad one.

theduchessofspork · 03/02/2024 11:25

notknowledgeable · 03/02/2024 10:07

Well no, not really, not only is poorer sister totally ignorant of this subject, and would need years and a degree, but the area is flooded with perfectly capable knowledgeable graduates, so why would sister be an employment prospect?

It’s peculiar she doesn’t help her sister towards a better lifestyle eg with childcare so she can use her degree. If the wealthier sister is really wealthy I’d also think it was normal to provide her sibling with better housing when she was able.

No need to offer her a role in the company though, that would be odd.

Alcyoneus · 03/02/2024 11:22

Perfect example of two people with same upbringing. One making bad choices and expecting other people to pay for her bad choices.

New2024 · 03/02/2024 11:21

As regards property, it’s so expensive here that I’ve seen Victorian terraced houses at £800k.

Regarding wealthy siblings - there’s no obligation to sub the rest of your family. They may not even want you to and you may find yourself questioning their approach if they do

MorningSunshineSparkles · 03/02/2024 11:21

My DB is very wealthy, I am not. I’m a carer for a disabled child, not sure why you think the disparity in our income is abnormal? He had a different set of life circumstances to me despite the same upbringing. That is normal.

theduchessofspork · 03/02/2024 11:21

@Moier I am so sorry that happened to you.

Gottseidank · 03/02/2024 11:20

Strange & slightly unsavoury thread IMO